+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

Eritrean asylum seekers: Caught between jail and death

Immigration police arresting an Eritrean refugee, Tel Aviv, Israel, 2/3/2008 (Oren Ziv/Activestills.org)

This is the story of Philmon Razena, a 25-year-old Eritrean asylum seeker. Like the other tens of thousands of others, Philmon lives under constant threat of being jailed or deported by the Israeli authorities, while also being closely monitored by the Eritrean government, which terrifies Eritreans whether they are in Israel or elsewhere. Over the past month, asylum seekers from different countries take matters into their own hands, from civil disobedience to silent demonstrations on the streets of Tel Aviv, and culminating in an indefinite general strike to protest Israel’s asylum policies. This is their story, too.

By Philmon Razena

On Saturday December 20, the Israeli media reported on a “violent altercation between Eritreans” in Kibbutz Kinneret, as well as claims that the Eritrean government is attempting to launder money out of Israel. These reports left many Israelis confused, so it is time to clarify things. The Eritrean Ambassador, Tesfamariam Tekeste, had arranged a conference in Israel and organized for the transportation of 600 members of the Eritrean community to Kinneret. Approximately 60 other people attended, including myself.

For us, this was to be a rare opportunity to ask the ambassador directly about the human rights situation in Eritrea and to ask about our families there. I went because my father has been in jail for several months. He was imprisoned because my public opposition to the regime. I haven’t heard from him since he was jailed.

The ambassador knew exactly who we were. The Eritrean government follows Eritrean dissidents in Israel who call for democracy. It also occasionally publishes leaflets threatening to kidnap or kill us.

When we entered the hall, the ambassador told the audience that we were working for the Ethiopian government, an enemy state of Eritrea. He ordered them to attack us and left the room. Eleven of us were injured, including one woman. When we called the police, they initially came to our defense. But the ambassador told them that we were armed criminals and we were arrested.

Why did the ambassador choose to hold a conference at Kibbutz Kinneret? Why did he not hold it in the center of the country, close to the Eritrean community? The ambassador wanted to bring people away from the watchful eye of the broader Eritrean public in Israel as well as the regime’s opposition leaders.

During the conference, the ambassador explained to the audience how they could get around the law which bans asylum seekers in Israel from sending money overseas. He explained a series of measures whereby they can send money to their families through the Eritrean government bank accounts in Germany. This would involve paying very high commission to the government. He promised everyone that they would be able to buy homes. These were false promises. Most of the Eritrean public does not have this kind of money. Thus, nobody can buy a home, but the government will earn commission regardless. But false promises and corruption are nothing new in the Eritrean government, nor are human trafficking, forced labor, trafficking of illegal weapons or cultivating ties with terrorists.

The government terrifies Eritreans whether they are in Israel or elsewhere. Many communities in Israel are afraid to openly oppose the Eritrean regime because they fear it would put their families’ lives at risk, since they may be imprisoned like my father, or killed. Opposition to the regime comes at a very high price. I was once put in jail because I was politically active in college. So I fled Eritrea. Now my father is paying the price.

Some people are scared so they corporate with the government.There are few who believe its lies, but most do because they know that they are not protected in Israel. Every day, asylum seekers in Israel live in fear of being deported back to Eritrea because their asylum requests are not checked, nor are they recognized as refugees. There are people who believe that they might escape death or prison in Eritrea by cooperating with the government. Most of those who traveled to Kibbutz Kinneret didn’t do so because they dreamed of buying a house; they came out of desperation and fear.

It is desperation and fear that brought 30,000 people to Tel Aviv’s Rabin Square two days ago. This is why there have been demonstrations over the last few weeks, and why we are on strike. We are striking because 54,000 asylum seekers are living in Israel without basic security, under constant threat of jail or deportation and still trapped in the vicious circle of fear that we tried to escape from in the first place.

Philmon Razena is a 25-year-old asylum seeker from Eritrea. This article first appeared in Hebrew on Haokets.

‘Strike for Freedom’: What do the asylum seekers want?
Thousands of asylum seekers hold ‘silent march’ on streets of Tel Aviv

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article

    * Required


    1. Lloyd

      From all media reports out there, these dissidents went to the meeting with metal pipes, hammers and rocks looking to incite violence. Let’s stop with the victim card. These individuals are hooligans and I see why the Eritrean government wouldn’t want them around. The Israeli government should do the same and expel them to the ends of the earth for all I care.

      Reply to Comment
      • 30 people do not 30,000 make. I wouldn’t be surprised to find some people brought weapons; that does not taint a class. Consider that one police attending the 30,000 protest itself said he had never seen such a well ordered event.

        Razena has made a rather detailed asylum plea. His plea should be heard and adjudicated.

        There was a time when Jews made asylum plea. Israel has signed the 51 Convention. For the sake of Israel and these claimants–let the law play out.

        Courts exist to this end.

        Reply to Comment
      • okbit tsige

        I wonder why the Israel government is denneying the dictatorial extinct Eritrean leadership.Eritrea is at the bottom of the human rights order followed by North Korea .So the UNHCR must give shade to Eritrean escapee .most of them have been in a jail while they were home land ,it is inhuman to state them as illegal job immigrants ,I hope that Israel government should reconsider their asylum case in order !!!!!!

        Reply to Comment
        • The Trespasser

          Dictatorship in a certain country is not a reason to give political asylum to entire population of said country.

          Why won’t you go back to your country and not overthrow the dictator? Scared? Over 1 000 000 of people can’t arrange a revolution? What a pathetic bunch.

          I’m ashamed to have same DNA as you.

          Reply to Comment
    2. seltie

      why the isreali gov signed 51 convention then? be human have respect to human if you guys really believe with gOD BUT IF YOU ANNOUNCE U GUYS R EVIL GO AHEAD

      Reply to Comment
      • The issue of the 51 Convention is under legal contention now. I would like to tell you it will all work out, but, realistically, that would be a very big move for the High Court to make.

        It is up to the Justices. There are times in most nations where judges must stand against public anger and misunderstanding. This is one such time.

        Reply to Comment
    3. The Trespasser

      One of most nonsensical pieces ever published.

      >When we entered the hall, the ambassador told the audience that we were working for the Ethiopian government, an enemy state of Eritrea. He ordered them to attack us and left the room. Eleven of us were injured, including one woman. When we called the police, they initially came to our defense. But the ambassador told them that we were armed criminals and we were arrested.

      Police came and arrested those who were wounded? Bullshit.

      >Every day, asylum seekers in Israel live in fear of being deported back to Eritrea

      Liar. Israel can not deport Eritreans due to the “temporary humanitarian protection group” status granted by UNHCR.

      Truly, each people has the government they deserve.

      Reply to Comment