+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

Why the Arabs are coming to Tel Aviv

It used to be that when Israel demolished Arab homes there would be a spontaneous strike and reactionary protest in some of the Arab cities. But there is a new political force leading Palestinian citizens of Israel, and this time, the protest is coming to Tel Aviv.

Joint List leader, Ayman Odeh, speaks during the party's Hebrew-language launch event, Tel Aviv, February 11, 2015. (Photo: Activestills.org)

Joint List leader, Ayman Odeh, speaks during the party’s Hebrew-language launch event, Tel Aviv, February 11, 2015. (Photo: Activestills.org)

The average Israeli does not understand the dramatic changes taking place in their own back yard — in Arab society. Snippets of  information about Arab society’s agenda — house demolitions, a march here, a protest there — appear in the Hebrew media every once in a while, sparingly.

The way that the Arabs relate to the government is fairly predictable, it seems. For Jewish Israelis, the script probably seems to be the same. If something is going on with “the neighbors” — like land expropriation, the Prawer plan, a murder by the police, or even abhorrent statements by the prime minister on election day — the automatic Arab reaction will come on the streets, often spontaneous and angry. But most importantly, nobody will care — neither the government nor the media.

Lately, however, with the election of the Joint List and tremendous efforts to restructure the Higher Arab Monitoring Committee, there is a sense that Arab citizens are riding on a different wave. That change was evident in the message broadcast on the eve of elections, that Palestinian citizens of the state want to integrate on all levels and in all areas of life in the country — a revolutionary message in itself — and are determined to protect the weaker segments of society. That message is becoming a real plan of action on the ground today.

Let’s look at two of the small steps taken so far by the elected leadership of the Arab public: they rejected an offer to meet with the Arab League, a meeting that was its wet dream for decades, the dream of being given recognition and respect. Secondly they decided to allow MKs to respond in a number of ways when the national anthem is sung in the Knesset (to either stand quietly or to leave).

Those steps may seem small and symbolic, but they are far more. The establishment of a Knesset coexistence caucus, the rejection of immediate reactionary protests in response to home demolitions and setting an agreed-upon date for a general strike, in the middle of the week — these are all signs of a new direction in a new struggle by Palestinian Israelis.

Residents walk through the remains of their homes in the unrecognized village Dahmash, Israel, April 15, 2015. (Oren Ziv/Activestills.org)

Residents walk through the remains of their homes in the unrecognized village Dahmash, central Israel, April 15, 2015. (Oren Ziv/Activestills.org)

Tuesday is expected to be a significant escalation of the message that Arab society is trying to send to the Jewish state. In the heart of the most Israeli city, Tel Aviv, and in the city square most symbolic for social struggles, Rabin Square, thousands of Arab citizens (I hope) will demonstrate at 5 p.m. The Arabs will come from Umm a-Fahm, Nazareth, Sakhnin, Rahat, Ramleh and Lod, from Taibe and Haifa and Beer Sheva, with signs in Arabic and in Hebrew, so that nobody can ignore them anymore. Their voice must be heard. The government’s policies of oppressing its Arab citizens must end, for everyone’s sake.

If you think about the slogans behind the rally, you will find that there is a clear declaration: we Arab citizens live here, we will not give up our rights, and we will never stop pursuing justice and equality.

But not only that: We are seeking partners for our struggle inside Israeli society. We are not ashamed, we are not complaining, we are not begging; we are here to protect those citizens who believe in democracy, which is in mortal danger, and we must cooperate with each other.

No apologies

Palestinian society has undergone an evolution of sorts since the establishment of the State of Israel. It began with the generation that went through the trauma that followed the Nakba, the Palestinians who survived here (and who became Israelis against their will). The next generation is the defeated and frustrated generation, which grew up with those same parents who survived 1948, those who quietly took the citizenship, some of whom said thank you and kept their heads down. Then sprouted an angry generation. When you dig into the history, you discover that they are the victims of a split personality: Palestinian consciousness, Israeli on paper. This is the rebellious generation, those who don’t accept Israel and its actions, and what it has done and continues to do to the Palestinian people.

Today we see a generation of Palestinians creating a discourse in which Palestinian identity is cohesive, the sense of national belonging is unwavering, and which has a civic awareness that is super Israeli. The new Palestinian does not need to prove his loyalty to Palestine, because it is clear that the essence of the struggle for survival here is part of the struggle for defining ones own identity, and the right to the land on which we were born. On the other hand, he also doesn’t feel the need to test his relationship with Israel — he is a law-abiding citizen and knows how to work effectively from within the Israeli civil framework.

In this generation you will not find the same “good Arab” with whom you could eat hummus, who wouldn’t dare to say what he thinks, about whom Jews boast: “I have an Arab friend.” He is also not the same distant Arab who stays away from the Jews in order to maintain his identity. Full of confidence, this generation shows up on the Israeli doorstep and asks to come in, with no apologies and with no hesitation.

After 70 years you can no longer suspect the Palestinian citizen of Israel of being a traitor, even if the right wing wants to paint him as such, and to incite against him and to hate him. It is impossible to not see the new Palestinian in him — a Hebrew speaker, a hard worker. The educated Palestinian, the modern activist who talks about the right to proper education, to public transportation, to housing and the right to make a living — like any other citizen. And likewise, about the right of return and justice for his people. The most dangerous type of Arab is the one who looks like Ayman Odeh, because you can relate to him.

Herein lies one of the biggest problems facing the new Palestinian: what will be the reaction of Jewish Israelis? Will they be ready to tear down labels? Is Israeli society ready for an Arab with the scent of authentic Israeli chutzpah? What do you do with him? Do you oppress him? Do you clip his wings? Or do you push him into the corner and apply “moderate physical pressure” until he gives up on his desire to be a part of society?

If so, Israel will have an even bigger problem, and it will look like a fool in front of the whole world. On the other hand, the Arabs could despair at some point and simply stop trying, and that would be a dangerous development. As President Rivlin said a few weeks ago, “he who is scared of votes in the ballot box will get stones on the streets.”

Tuesday is a test for both sides. The Arabs are coming to Tel Aviv. We’ll see how many come and what message they bring with them. I will be there, of course.

On the other hand, it will be interesting to see how the Jews feel when they see us and how they respond. Will the evening dog-walkers stop for a moment to read a sign? Will we succeed at making them relate to our struggle for democracy and humanity, or at least to spark their interest into what’s taking place in their back yard? I want to believe the answer is yes.

What is certain is that we Arabs don’t have much to lose; worst comes to worst we can handle a little more alienation and racism. We will wrap up the protest, stop in Jaffa to eat something, and return home. And you will be able to say is this: The Arabs were in Tel Aviv; and now the Arabs are gone.

Samah Salaime is a social worker, a director of AWC (Arab Women in the Center) in Lod/Lyd and a graduate of the Mandel Leadership Institute in Jerusalem. She is a blogger for our Hebrew-language sister-site, Local Call, where this article was first published. Read it in Hebrew here.

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article

    * Required


    1. Jello

      I think that what is happening with Ayman Odeh is a very positive and constructive process. At the same time, if they show up in Tel Aviv with Palestinian flags to demand their ‘rights’ then we will simply ignore them because they will make their loyalties explicit with that gesture.

      Reply to Comment
        • Jello

          If the Irish were at war with the United States and the Irish flag was used to bury the remains of bombers that blew up civilians in the United States I would imagine that the reaction to that march would be different.

          A better analogy would be a march by Arab Americans where they would demand their ‘rights’ under an Islamic State flag, or a march during WW2 by German Americans demanding their ‘rights’ under a Nazi flag.

          Reply to Comment
          • Ben

            All these analogies fall through. None of these juxtapositions involve a venal post-war occupation in which the USA occupied territories illegally and while illegally occupying these territories flagrantly violated international laws governing the behavior of occupiers. One gets tired of pointing this out every time Jello hallucinates 48-year American settlements in Baden-Wurttemberg and Nagano Prefecture.

            Reply to Comment
          • Dutch Oven

            Brian, you did not even read the post before you responded you lazy hack. This is about Israeli Arabs, not settlements. You really have issues.

            Reply to Comment
          • Jello

            And what does that have to do with Israeli Arabs and them marching for their “rights” under the flag of a movement dedicated to Israel’s destruction?

            Reply to Comment
        • Dutch Oven

          What an idiotic response.

          Reply to Comment
      • rana

        you can ignore them all you like, but you can’t ignore the truth – in the end it will rise to the surface. Reality always wins.

        Reply to Comment
        • Jello

          The reality is that we can and will continue to ignore them. That is also the truth.

          Reply to Comment
    2. Ben

      “The most dangerous type of Arab is the one who looks like Ayman Odeh, because you can relate to him. Herein lies one of the biggest problems facing the new Palestinian: what will be the reaction of Jewish Israelis?”

      Odeh is great. Here is what worries me a bit. Feel free to call me paranoid, but I hope the Shin Bet has stepped up protection for Odeh, with all the devotion they would give a Jewish politician, because there is most definitely more than one person out there who will want to do to him what they did to Rabin. It was done to Rabin. It was done to Martin Luther King Jr.. As I said in another context, Arab non-violent protest makes the hair stand up on the back of the collective neck of the hard right settlement movement. And the last thing Lieberman wants is an Arab who wants to belong, as he proved in that snarling TV show encounter. And I’m not casting aspersions on the vast, vast majority, the almost 100% of Jewish Israelis. It just takes one nutcase. And lastly, that murderous person could well be Arab not Jewish. There are hateful extremists on both sides.

      Reply to Comment
      • BigCat

        Another gibberish from Brian….eh…”Ben”. Here is what must “worry you”, Brian: your own country. Currently Baltimore is burning! How come you care not that your own country burns, but instead get all emotional, sentimental and all riled-up whenever you hear the words ‘Jews’ and/or Israel? Go seek professional help, Brian. This obsession with Jews and Israel has screwed-up your mind big time.

        Reply to Comment
    3. New Relic

      Odeh does not miss too many meals!
      His publicist should advise him not to pose,with his arms up like in the cover photo. Not his best look! He almost pantsed himself!

      Reply to Comment
    4. Pedro X

      In the 1980s the Misgav Regional Council told the Arab town of Sakhnin to start building up to meet the needs of its residents. The people of Sakhnin said it takes too long to prepare master plans, get planning authority approval and building permits for them to go that route. That was 30 years ago and Arabs still believe it is better to buck the system than conform to planning rules.

      In 2012 the Northern Planning Authority shut down building in Arab locales in Northern Israel because they did not properly plan for increased sewage to be treated. They simply failed to plan for the ability to meet this requirement.

      If Arabs want to develop, it would be preferable that they start conforming to building plans and modern requirements instead of building illegally. It takes time, but it is well worth it.

      Reply to Comment
      • Ben

        More chaff. The fact is that getting the permit granted is made almost impossible. Everyone knows that. All your layers of obfuscation don’t hide that. The planning rules are made deliberately onerous and opaque for Arabs and streamlined for Jews. Then you twist it to make it sound like they are too stupid and lazy to plan sewer pipes! You’ve left out major parts of these stories. This kind of racist, dishonest, condescending arrogance to those they are oppressing is SO Israeli!

        Reply to Comment
        • BigCat

          Here ya go again, Brian…eh….”Ben” with your usual racist nonsense. None of your idiotic claim “is SO Israeli”. In Israel the same law applies to all Israelis: Christians, Jews, Druze, Muslim-Arabs, Atheists, Gays, Lesbos., etc. They all have to meet the same conditions and requirements in order to obtain a building permit. All that Pedro said are factual and you have not refuted any of them with any fact, on the contrary, you always feel the need to rant against any- and everything. How about finding a paid job, Brian? How about standing on your own feet and paying your own bills with the money you earned with your own sweat, Brian, instead of depending on food-stamps the United States’ Government provides you with my tax dollars? How about using the time you have to find a job instead of using it joggling from one Jewish website to another doing research on Jews and ranting on every comment section about Jews and Israel. How about seeking professional help for your obsession with Jews, Brian? I can help you with a job, you know, Brian? Come now, what say you, Brian, you want a job or not?

          Reply to Comment
    5. Bluegrass Picker of Afula

      When you “integrate” yourselves into sayeret Golani, ==then== you will be truly accepted.

      Reply to Comment