+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

Why isn’t the West Bank rioting, too?

And why doesn’t anyone in Israel seem to notice this? Answer: for the same reason that the Palestinian riots started in the first place.

With Palestinians protesting violently in East Jerusalem and the Israeli north, and with Palestinians in Gaza, or some of them anyway, firing rockets into Israel’s south, who are the only Palestinians in this land who are not raising hell these days?

The Palestinians of the West Bank. They threw a lot of rocks when the Israeli army invaded the Hebron area gunning for Hamas and looking for Eyal Yifrah, Naftali Fraenkel, Gil-Ad Shaar and their kidnappers, but since the boys were found murdered a week ago and the army left, the West Bank has been remarkably quiet. Even in the last few days, following the discovery of Mohammed Abu Khdeir’s burnt body, when Palestinian violence has spread through East Jerusalem and Israel’s “Arab Triangle,” when we’re on the verge of war with Gaza again, there’s little news from the West Bank.

Yet nobody notices.

Why is the West Bank, the heart of the Palestinian nation, the most populous part of it, and the part that comes most harshly under Israel’s malign power, davka the one part of the Palestinian nation that isn’t rebelling against Israel today? Why is the West Bank, which is most closely associated with the first and second intifadas, now largely absent from the action that threatens to turn into a third one?

Because of Mahmoud Abbas and the Palestinian Authority. It’s not that the people of the West Bank don’t want to attack Israeli soldiers and settlers, it’s that the PA security forces are doing their best not to let them. PA troops, not Israeli troops, keep order in the cities, villages and refugee camps where the West Bank’s Palestinians live, and it is those PA troops – unlike Israeli police in East Jerusalem and the Triangle these days – who are keeping a lid on the tension. It is thanks to Abbas and the PA that the 2.5 million Palestinians of the West Bank are not rioting en masse against Israeli soldiers and settlers.Newsletter banner 6 -540
And nobody in Israel notices. Just like nobody in Israel noticed it for the past several years when PA troops, at Abbas’ orders, were working alongside the IDF and Shin Bet hour-by-hour to shut down terror to a remarkable degree. Two and a half weeks ago, on June 19, Haaretz’s Ari Shavit, the voice of the so-called Israeli center, wrote a column titled “Seven Good Years.”

The suicide bombers’ offensive abated already in 2005, but from 2007 onward Mahmoud Abbas, Salam Fayyad, the IDF, the Shin Bet security service, Palestinian security forces and the separation fence managed to silence the next violence from the east. The number of Israeli casualties from terror attacks – and the number of Palestinian casualties from Israeli fire – dwindled in the last half-decade to levels the likes of which we hadn’t known in previous decades. The second intifada dissipated and even the street pressure of the first intifada wasn’t resumed.

Until the abduction of the three youths in Alon Shvut a week ago, no strategic attack had been launched. The bloody attacks on Israeli cities and even the attacks on the settlements and settlers dramatically diminished. The economic prosperity, cultural boom and good life … since 2007 were possible only because the violent reality we had lived in was replaced with a reality of quiet borders, a quiet West Bank and astonishing stability.

We didn’t notice then, like we don’t notice the relative quiet in the West Bank today. And it’s because we didn’t notice what Abbas was doing for us – not because he loves us, but because his interests coincided with ours – that we pissed away the best chance we ever had or ever will have to make peace with the Palestinians. Not only didn’t we make peace, but the Israeli government and public grew steadily more contemptuous of the Palestinians, beginning with Abbas. And it’s because we’re so contemptuous of the Palestinians that we’re incapable of acknowledging that they’re doing anything good, that they’re helping us instead of hurting us, that we should appreciate what they’re doing instead of trashing them. And, in turn, it’s because of that callous indifference of ours, years and years of it while we enjoyed “a reality of quiet borders, a quiet West Bank and astonishing stability,” that we’re seeing the Palestinians finally erupt.

Except in the West Bank, where Abbas’ men are still holding the fort, still protecting us. We’ll notice them when they’re gone, not before.

Why this isn’t a ‘new’ intifada
A premier failure: Where is Israel’s leadership?

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article

    * Required


    1. ish yehudi

      yes, and Palestinians in the West Bank remembers the retribution of the IDF and is tired of intifada, no? They have too much to lose from inviting the army back into their towns and destroying again what has been built/ in the last few years. lets throw all the 16-19 year olds together for a while, and learn some lessons.

      Reply to Comment
    2. shachalnur

      You’re wrong Larry,suffering from “pigeon superstition”.

      The only reason for things getting out of hand is the internal fight over who rules Israel.

      Palestinians can’t do a thing except manoeuvre their way through this mess,and help Israel to commit suicide.

      Current events in and around Israel now are not being controlled by the Israeli government,and Bibi is forced to play Rapid Chess with limited time on the clock and no control over the rules.

      Israel is turning out out be a lousy chessplayer under time pressure,and are losing position and quality.

      Assymetric warfare by US and Europe perpetrated on the Middle East has found Israel unprepared,at that’s not surprising at all.

      This usually happens when your sponsors,protectors and enablers pull the plug on you.

      Reply to Comment
    3. Brian P., Seattle, WA

      Larry thanks once again for a beautifully clarifying piece. The story of the shabby, intentionally belittling, humiliating, begrudging treatment of Abu Mazen by the Netanyahu government contains in compressed form the story of the whole conflict, at least since Netanyahu took office. It reveals so much for those with eyes to see. You see. Ari Shavit wrote a whole piece about the wonderful quiet and astonishing stability he is enjoying so much without quite actually seeing what it means, without placing the credit where it belongs. That says a whole lot about Ari Shavit and the kind of Israeli attitude he epitomizes, and about how different you and your attitude are. Keep up your outstanding work, Larry!

      Reply to Comment
    4. Thanks a lot, Brian my man!

      Reply to Comment
    5. been there

      The PA is a quisling regime

      Abbas is neither elected nor representative but he is Israel’s darling.. “keep order” in this case means violent suppression

      Reply to Comment
    6. Eliza

      What else did you ever think would happen? Of course Israelis have contempt for Palestinians; whether they belong to Fatah, Hamas or are non political non aligned people simply trying to live their lives under occupation as best as they can.

      Israel may need to talk endlessly about wanting to make ‘peace’ with the Palestinians but it also needs to create the conditions that enable the transfer of as many non-Jews from the W/B as possible (whether by the Jordon option or killing them). Full scale violence cannot be ruled out if Israel thinks it can get away with it. The other alternative is the squeezing of non-Jews into small disconnected bantustans. Pretty much its only possible to do this to other human beings if you can view them with contempt as less worthy.

      Abbas ‘doing good’ or helping Israel cannot be expected to result in a reduction of the amount of contempt in which Israelis hold Palestinians. I rather think that a few little pats on the Abbas/PA collective head for being so downright obliging won’t really make much difference in the larger scheme of things (apart from that warm cozy feeling so called liberal Zionists may get).

      Man up – colonization of other peoples’ land is not a zero sum game and certainly not for the faint-hearted.

      Reply to Comment
    7. Rab

      Judea and Samaria Palestinians aren’t rioting because, 1. many of the leaders who would lead these riots were arrested by the IDF in the weeks after the Israeli teens’ kidnapping and murder; 2. Abbas is grateful that this threat from Hamas was neutralized.

      This has nothing to do with peacefulness, goodwill or anything of the sort. This demonstrates that the IDF operation, and operations in general, have been effective.

      Reply to Comment