+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

Why is the Egyptian Army in Sinai?

And why is the Chief of Military Intelligence still in office? Two comments on recent events

Egyptian Forces in Sinai: Several reports indicate that Egyptian military forces have entered Sharm el-Sheikh, in Sinai. Rumors also say this is where Mubarak is at the moment.

The entrance of Egyptian military forces into Sinai is prohibited by the Egyptian-Israeli peace treaty, to which the US is a guarantor. Lisa Goldman and myself tried to get a reply from the IDF Spokesman, to no avail. The spokesman of the Foreign Ministry, Yigal Palmor, gave Goldman the following response: “We will have to analyze the situation. We are under clear instructions not to make any comment on the Egyptian situation, no matter what. So it’s not as though we’ll have an answer later on. You’ll just have to wait and see, okay?”

It’s hard to believe the IDF is not aware of Egyptian army movements into Sinai, which is technically an invasion and a breach of the peace accords. If the Egyptians acted without coordinating their movements with Israel, this is very troubling news; such a move, after all, led to the Six Days War. If the act was coordinated, then someone in the government has to explain under what authority he acts. The peace accords were approved by the Knesset, and changing them would conceivably require its approval. Furthermore, the issue raises the question of whether Israel supports the Mubarak regime against is own citizens.

Update: Israel “defense officials” now admit that Egyptian troops entered Sinai in coordination with Israel’s Ministry of Defense.

LOL! On January 25th, the Egyptians flooded the streets, a date which granted the uprising its hashtag, #Jan25. On that very day, the cruel Lord opened the mouth of the ass, Chief of Military Intelligence Maj. General Aviv Kochavi, and he told (Hebrew) the Knesset’s Foreign Affairs and Security Committee that “at the moment, the stability of the Egyptian regime is not at risk”.

You know how that turned out. Now, Military Intelligence (AMAN) and Israeli intelligence in general have a long series of screw-up regarding foreseeing the future, which admittedly is not all that simple. In 1967, AMAN estimated there will be no war. Its failures before the Yom Kippur War need no mentioning. When the Iraqi-Iranian war broke out, it estimated it will last three weeks. Eight years later, it estimated the war will end in two or three years; it ended within a few weeks. The Mossad brought us into Lebanon in 1982, woefully overestimating the Phalanges. AMAN failed to foresee the Sabra and Shatila massacre, even though concluding that sending the Phalanges to deal with their mortal enemies two days after their leader was assassinated may not be a good idea is not precisely rocket science. The GSS failed to foresee the First Intifada – or, when you think about it, the Second one as well. Prior to the First Gulf War, AMAN estimated Saddam Hussein won’t lob missiles at Israel; he did. On the eve of the Second Gulf War, AMAN warned Hussein may fire in desperation the rest of his WMD arsenal at Israel, not realizing no such arsenal existed. Faulty intelligence delivered to the American intelligence community by AMAN was one of the factors contributing to the invasion of Iraq in 2003. And of course, we have the yearly prognosis of the Chief of Intelligence, telling us Iran will have the bomb by the next autumn.

The Agranat investigative committee decided, back in 1974 – following the fiasco of the Yom Kippur War – that AMAN must be stripped of its position of national evaluator, and the IDF managed to work its way around that recommendation for 37 years. After the failure of intelligence during the Second Gulf War, the Steinitz committee decreed that Unit 8200, AMAN’s sigint unit, ought to become an independent agency, not reporting to the Chief of Intelligence. Nothing of the sort happened.

Now that we’ve seen AMAN at its best once more, perhaps its time to retire Aviv Kochavi, dismantle AMAN, and create a new national evaluation unit, one which is not under the command of generals and can bring civil society, too, into its estimates. The Intelligence Command, for its part, may keep doing what it’s good at: following enemy unit movements.

Unlikely, though. It didn’t happen after the shock of the Yom Kippur War, so why would it happen now?

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article

    * Required


    1. So I came to this via twitter where the +972 twitter feed asked the question “Did Israel approve this violation of peace treaty?” Whilst the potential implications for Israel are significant, I find this an odd question to pose. Both the Egyptian public and political body are engaged in an uprising of epic proportion and frankly I shouldn’t think anyone cares less about Israel at the minute.

      If the State of Israel is a partner of peace to the other countries in the Middle East then they should have no problem with accepting that that Mubarak and the military acted in an emergency (if he stays in power, which I hope he doesn’t), and if a new regime rises in Egypt then the relationship between the two countries will, more than likely, have to be carefully rebuilt.

      Although AMAN has made many mistakes in Israel’s past, the whole world seems to be watching Egypt, at the minute, and although the government is remaining tight lipped over what is happening, I would be amazed if they weren’t closely watching everything that happens. It would be illogical to not monitor they’re neighbor and, in Mubarak, closest Middle Eastern ally.

      One concern I do have, although I find the idea extremely unlikely at the minute, is that if regime change does occur, and Israel isn’t happy with Mubarak’s successor, whether they would consider manipulating the military presence to amp up feelings of distrust towards Egypt within the Israeli public as a pretext for war. As I said, though, I think this scenario is unlikely, but I can’t help but consider it.

      Reply to Comment
    2. Brian Nahodil

      I for one am shocked that Israel has not expressed outrage thus leading me to believe it was an act that was done in cooperation or that Israel is assisting the Egypt revolt.

      Reply to Comment