+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

Where have Israel's leftists gone? The changing face of Labor

The Labor party is convinced that it can somehow disassociate itself with the Left, call itself the ‘center’ and sneak its way back into power with semantic tricks. It will take the entire left-wing camp down with it.

By Tom Cohen

Labor Party leader Isaac Herzog. (Photo by Yotam Ronen/Activestills.org)

Labor Party leader Isaac Herzog. (Photo by Yotam Ronen/Activestills.org)

Last year, a delegation of Knesset members went to visit PLO Chairman Mahmoud Abbas. Among the MKs who participated were Hilik Bar of Labor and Tamar Zandberg of Meretz. There had been a terror attack a few days earlier and there was some pressure to cancel the visit. But MK Bar, who was the head of the Knesset’s Two-State Caucus, wasn’t deterred. A bona fide Zionist, an IDF captain in the reserves, he thought he would be immune from the accusations that would be hurled at him.

The delegation members went to Ramallah, were photographed meeting with the PLO chairman and put out press releases. But MK Bar didn’t foresee the might of the Right’s propaganda machine. A few hours after the delegation returned to Jerusalem, the settler organizations got to work: they bought up ad space in newspapers and accused MK Bar of encouraging terrorism. His Facebook page was flooded with insults, op-eds turned him into Haneen Zoabi and even some members of his own Labor party began attack him.

MK Bar still bears the scars of that visit to Ramallah to this day. He learned his lesson. Ever since, he prefers to stand with the attackers and not those under attack. In the year since, he has joined the Right in its campaign against symbolic recognition of Palestinian statehood, and just last week led a public censure of MK Zandberg in the Knesset. A complete 180. Nobody today would dare say Bar and Meretz are part of the same political camp.

Once a year, more or less, the Labor Party undergoes a shift of this sort. Today the party is identified with past social protests, tomorrow it will be with the institution’s economic reformers. Today it wants to end the occupation, tomorrow it will join the Right in its attempts to strengthen the WZO’s Settlement Division, or in its slew of legislative attempts aimed at strengthening the occupation.

The public doesn’t buy it, of course. Does anybody actually believe that Isaac Herzog — who was ready to sacrifice his top spot to Tzipi Livni, all while chasing Meretz voters — has really become the guy who is trying to outflank Netanyahu from the right on the Iran deal? The downpour of ‘Likes’ showered upon Labor MKs whenever they attack the Left is having its effect. Their appetite has been awakened, and the Labor party is suddenly sounding a lot like Avigdor Liberman: it attacks Meretz and the Joint List at every opportunity; its members call Meretz MKs “Haneen Zoabi,” and then join right-wing efforts to have the real Haneen Zoabi kicked out of the Knesset.

Do they not understand that by joining the attacks on the Left they are calling their own legitimacy into question? Do they not understand that they are demolishing the leftist brand that people associate first and foremost with Labor?

The Labor party is convinced that it can somehow disassociate itself with the Left. Instead of believing that the Left will be victorious, it wants to call itself the “center” and sneak its way back into power with semantic tricks. As if the Israeli public is so dense, that if only Labor changed its name the mobs would throng right back into its member rolls. The party has experimented a number of times in recent years with trying to distance itself from anything that smells like diplomatic compromise or peacemaking, including under the leadership of both Ehud Barak and Shelly Yacimovich. The results would be disastrous, not only for the Labor party but also for the whole Left. Dashing into the overcrowded and undefined “center” camp would also make Herzog irrelevant.

If MK Bar and the other Labor hawks aren’t happy with being associated with the Left, then they’re in the wrong party. Labor has indeed turned its back on the Left’s values in recent years, but the public nevertheless continues to view it as a leftist party. Also now, the result of its attacks on the Left will be weakening the entire camp, and nothing else.

Labor losing its way carries an important message for my party, Meretz. The last elections were difficult for Meretz, and it is clearly time for internal reforms and change. But the right-wing delirium consuming the Labor party (which is surely related to its upcoming primaries) proves that a true left-wing party is still necessary, one with consistent ideology, and which isn’t ashamed of its label and doesn’t hide its values.

It would be disastrous if the trauma of the most recent elections leads Meretz into a process that eliminates the party altogether by merging into Labor. The Labor party is an important partner. There are good people there. But it will never constitute a viable alternative to Meretz. The current efforts to court Labor, while it questions our very legitimacy, is especially disappointing.

Tom Cohen is a political activist and a member of the Meretz central committee. This article was first published in Hebrew on Local Call. Read it here.

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article
  • LEAVE A COMMENT

    * Required

    COMMENTS

    1. Pdero X

      MK Bar – Still pushing Rabin’s and Peres’ Dream

      MK Bar has hardly moved to the right or joined his attackers. MK Bar has been pushing for a two state solution. The Jerusalem Post reports:

      “Bar presented what he called “a solid foundation for a final status agreement and end of all claims between us and the Palestinians” to some 450 participants in a conference of the Knesset Caucus to Resolve the Arab-Israeli Conflict, which Bar leads. The gathering included MKs mostly from the Zionist Union, a smattering from Meretz and MK Oren Hazan (Likud).

      In the outline Bar distributed to attendees, Bar wrote that the plan “protects Israel’s vital security interests, keeps Jerusalem united, solves the Palestinian refugee problem outside of Israel’s borders, leaves the majority of settlers in their homes, strengthens Israel’s position in the world, and gives Israel a boost in its unflinching war on terrorism.”

      Bar’s plan first calls for Israel to recognize a Palestinian state in the UN, but says that borders, the refugee issue, Jerusalem, security arrangements, etc. must be negotiated between the two sides. The recognition and approval of “Palestine” joining UN institutions will be conditioned on it not undermining the need to negotiate. In addition, the Palestinians would recognize two nation states.

      The plan also provides that, when there is a Palestinian state, Jews may securely live in it as residents or citizens, thus creating an option for Israelis not to be expelled from their homes.

      “If there can be a Jewish community in London and Berlin, then there can be a Jewish community in Palestine,” Bar wrote.

      In addition, Palestinian citizens would have “privileged access” to places of worship, tourism, academia and trade in Israel, and vice-versa.

      The MK also called for Israel to officially respond to the Arab Peace Initiative – not necessarily to agree to it, but to stop ignoring it. This would go handin- hand with conducting a regional dialogue in conjunction with bilateral relations between Israel and Arab states.

      The outline also calls to improve quality of life in Gaza, which Bar posits would return the Palestinian Authority to the Strip to replace Hamas, form a municipal body to represent residents of east Jerusalem, and maintain the status quo on the Temple Mount.

      Bar called for better integration of Israeli-Arabs into Israeli society, including teaching young Israelis peace and coexistence, opening a bilingual university, and requiring Israeli Arabs to do civilian or IDF service after a permanent peace treaty is signed.

      The outline also deals with Israel’s relations with Diaspora Jewry. It says the government should give world Jewry an “advisory status on issues of national importance and matters of foreign policy” and educate them in Hebrew, Jewish history, and Zionism.

      The goal would be to strengthen their Jewish identity, while still promoting the Zionist idea of “the negation of the Diaspora” and encouraging them to move to Israel.

      During the conference, Bar slammed those on the Right who reject a twostate solution, saying they will lead Israel to lose its Jewish majority and bring about the end of the Zionist project.”

      He is doing what a true leftist should be doing, exploring ways to end the conflict.

      When, if ever, did the Palestinian left hold a conference on how to peacefully Resolve the Arab-Israeli Conflict?

      Reply to Comment
      • Pedro X

        My, my, I wonder why my post was held up for a day.

        Reply to Comment
    2. Giora Me'ir

      Labor is another, purportedly, left of center party who’s time has passed. Like most of the so-called social democratic parties of Europe. They apparently didn’t learn the lesson of the last election, that is, when face with the real thing and an imitation, people will choose the real thing.

      Reply to Comment

The stories that matter.
The missing context.
All in one weekly email.

Subscribe to +972's newsletter