+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

When the canons roar, the Israeli Left remains silent

It appears not much has changed since Operation Cast Lead, when opposition leader Haim Oron tragically decided to support the military offensive. Rather than apologizing and giving evasive answers to the media, the Left, led by the failed opposition leader, should be standing up to yell ‘enough!’

By Elinor Davidov

It took seven days of “Operation Brother’s Keeper” for the leaders of the Israeli Left in the opposition to say, sofly, that there is a problem with the current military operation, with its goals and with its implementation.

For the first time, a week of collective punishment, a closure on the southern West Bank, assassinations in Gaza, violent house searches and the killing of five Palestinians, we read the words of Meretz leader Zehava Galon and Meretz MK Nitzan Horowitz. Their statements were not delivered forcefully at rallies organized by leftist parties, nor were they made clearly and unequivocally in numerous media outlets. Instead, they were written on Facebook, as if it was about just another message to their constituents aimed at winning another vote or two come election time.

Their criticism followed an obligatory disclaimer, in which they stated they do not intend to justify the kidnapping or side with the Palestinians. After all, any statement critical of the state and the army necessitates an apologetic introduction, as if the Knesset members feel they are “traitors” themselves – the same way their friends on the right see them.

Meretz Chairwoman Zehava Galon and opposition leader Yitzhak Herzog of Labor (Photo: Yotam Ronen/Activestills.org)

Meretz Chairwoman Zehava Galon and opposition leader Yitzhak Herzog of Labor (Photo: Yotam Ronen/Activestills.org)

The weak Left has lost its ability to express an unequivocal and clear position – one that opposes military operations whose goals are fabricated and whose results are disastrous, not only for the civilian population in the West Bank and Gaza, but also for the possibility (which was destroyed long ago by Israel) to negotiate with the government that represents the Palestinian public. Even Meretz and Hadash, openly left-wing parties, did not release proper statements, did not clearly call to refrain from going forward with the operation, did not bother to do a thing aside from write a few hollow sentences on their personal Facebook profiles.

From ‘Cast Lead’ until today

As if we haven’t learned the lesson, and as if ingratiating ourselves with the Right will bring the Left to power, the left-wing MKs bury their heads in the sand, roll their eyes at the evil terrorism coming from Hebron, and refuse to point at the real problem: the Israeli occupation of the Palestinian territories.

It seems water hasn’t passed under the bridge of the most prominent leftist party in the Knesset, Meretz. As if we don’t remember the disgraceful decision by then-chairman Haim Oron to support the disastrous Operation Cast Lead, which claimed the lives of over 1,000 Palestinians, many of them civilians. Needless to say that Hamas recovered, and residents of Israel’s south are still suffering from rocket fire from Gaza.

Like its predecessors, the current Israeli government is acting all the more forcefully against those with whom it must sit and negotiate the end of the conflict. It has become pointless to repeat the ways in which successive Israeli governments acted against the PLO for many years, singlehandedly destroying the moderate, secular Palestinian Left, all while aiding and abetting the religious radicalization of Palestinian society. Now, when Israel is trying to dismantle the new Palestinian government, to sabotage the agreement ending internal Palestinian rifts and to destroy Hamas, do not be surprised when more radical organizations set the tone in the coming years.

Read +972’s full coverage of the kidnappings

Rather than apologizing and giving evasive answers to the media, rather than visiting the families in order to be seen as an integral part of the Israeli people and rather than spending all day condemning MK Haneen Zoabi’s comments in order to draw a thick, red line between us and her, the Left, lead by the failed opposition leader, should have stood up to yell “enough!” What’s the point of torturing millions? What is the point of depriving hundreds of thousands of Palestinians of work? Which military goals were achieved by searching 1,000 homes in one night while harassing a civilian population? What will we achieve by shooting live bullets at stone throwers? What is Israel’s interest in arresting hundreds of past or present Hamas members with no trial?

The government ministers approved an additional NIS 5 million for local settlement councils in the West Bank on Sunday. The reason given for the special supplement was the “the security situation that has been created against the background of the abduction of the three youths.” Next week they will decide on an additional budget increase. Now children, guess who already openly announced that he would support any supplement whose goal is to protect Israelis in the West Bank? That’s right! The honorable opposition leader, Isaac Herzog (Labor).

When military analysts are the ones writing the most critical articles against the operation, something is deeply wrong with the Israeli Left. And perhaps this is nothing new, but we are evermore insulted as time goes on. Just like we marched together during Cast Lead (another failed, cruel attempt at destroying Hamas), now we must raise our voices at every possible chance: in the media, in the Knesset and in the streets. We must say no to unnecessary violence, no the political cynicism of right-wing politicians, no to settlement growth and no to the occupation.

But it seems to me that left-wing members of Knesset are not interested in their voters, and that the winds of war still blow among and between them. When the cannons roar, leftists bow their heads in silence.

Elinor Davidov is a journalist and editor for London at Kirschenbaum. Read this article in Hebrew on Local Call.

More on the kidnappings:
What happens when the IDF embeds Israeli reporters
Rights groups say IDF response to kidnapping is collective punishment
Photos: After kidnapping, West Bank cities under lockdown

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article

    * Required


    1. Kolumn9

      Her proposal is to respond to the actions of terrorists by doing nothing. Yet she wonders why no one listens to people like her.

      Why is Israel acting against Hamas? Because it is an explicitly terrorist organiztion that wishes to kill Israeli civilians and has done so repeatedly. There should really be no particular additional reason needed to act against it.

      What is the point of the other actions? To increase pressure on the kidnappers and to limit their mobility while collecting information and searching for the kidnapped teenagers.

      Why search 1000 houses? Because they are looking for three kidnapped Israeli teens who our government has a solemn duty to protect.

      What line does she want to draw? She wants to side with Zoabi in considering the kidnapping of Israeli teenagers legitimate? And when Zoabi starts justifying their murders, which she will, what then? How much support is there for that position even if we ignore for a moment that it is plainly despicable? It is both wrong and bad politics to be on the ‘other side’ when your constituens are being attacked by terrorists.

      Reply to Comment
    2. עיניים לראותEYES2C

      The ZIONIST LEFT is not opposed to the occupation. The Zionist Left is silent when the canons are silent, and certainly so when the canons roar.

      Meretz and Labour chose not to cooperate with the Democratic Front for Peace and Equality to bring down the extreme right which rules Israel.

      Reply to Comment
      • The Trespasser

        DFPE’s agenda is plain stupid and there is no chance that they’d gain any wide support from anyone who has no brain damage.

        Reply to Comment
        • Kolumn9

          You are clearing talking to the wrong person since he doesn’t even know that 15+6+4 is not enough to form a governing coalition in a 120 member parliament and certainly not enough to bring down a sitting government. Unless he expects them all to cooperate in launching a revolution? Isn’t that what communists are always waiting for?

          Reply to Comment
          • The Trespasser

            I’m not talking to idiots. Merely pointing out their idiocy for sheer fun.

            Reply to Comment
          • RICK

            Counting votes for taking over the gov’t is so completely beside the point. What Israel needs is a social movement that sees the stupidity of a racist form of government. Movements start with the truth, not counting votes. The truth is that oppressing a people and thinking you’re better than Palestinians, that you can continue shameful behavior against millions of innocent people is more stupid than not winning an election.

            Reply to Comment
    3. JG

      As if you clown know people with no brain damage., sitting in your hasbara office bunker…..

      Reply to Comment
      • The Trespasser

        Implying that you know who I am or where I am sitting at is a symptom of schizophrenia.

        Reply to Comment
    4. sh

      Ouch! Cannons roar. Canon is several things including a camera brand, but none of them roar.

      Reply to Comment
      • directrob

        Either these comments are ignored or your comment is too subtle, just a test …

        It is CANNONS not CANONS, please correct the header.

        Reply to Comment