+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

What happens to a cop who beats up a handcuffed 15 year old

Just as nobody seriously believes that Israel upholds Palestinians’ basic human rights, it should come as no surprise when it fails to bring to justice those who violate those rights — even if the victim is an American citizen.

I had to rub my eyes and reread the headline in Haaretz this morning: “Cop Who Beat Up Palestinian Teen Gets Six Weeks Community Service.” I must have misread. Not six weeks jail time? Or at least six months community service? No. Just six weeks (45 days) of community service for a policeman who repeatedly and brutally punched and kicked 15-year-old Tariq Abu Khdeir in the stomach and head after he was already in custody — and unconscious.

Abu Khdeir, a Palestinian-American from Florida who was on a family trip to Jerusalem during the summer of 2014, was arrested near a protest in the East Jerusalem neighborhood of Shuafat. The arrest came just days after his cousin, Mohammed Abu Khdeir, was kidnapped and burned alive by three Israeli Jews. Tariq maintains he was not involved in any protest.

In handing down the lenient sentence, the judge took into account the fact that the police officer had no criminal record and had positive character references. Police officers — the people tasked with upholding the law — should not have criminal records in the first place. And if for some reason they do, they should not be rewarded for that when committing a crime. And positive character references? The guy beat up a kid in handcuffs. This very act overrides any positive character references, presumably from fellow Israeli security personnel.

This is just perverse. A police officer who is supposed to serve as a role model of respect and civility, beats up a minor while after he is already restrained and in custody.

What kind of message does such a lenient sentence send to other officers? That they can beat up arrested Palestinians, even minors, and get away with it. Apparently that’s no big deal. Apparently that’s not considered a flagrant violation of their most basic duties.

And what does that say about Israeli society? That Palestinian lives are not as valued as Jewish ones. That it is not an aberration from the norm, but rather part and parcel of Israel’s policy of crushing the enemy — another example of the double standard inherent in Israel’s legal system when it comes to apprehending and trying Jewish assailants.

A week ago Israel sent over a dozen elite, undercover officers to raid a hospital in Hebron and arrest a Palestinian man accused of stabbing and seriously wounding an Israeli. And yet no one has been arrested or charged in the murder of three members of the Dawabshe family in July of this year. Another example of the double standard was attack on Rabbis for Human Rights head Arik Ascherman by a masked settler last month. The culprit has already been caught and indicted, yet countless other incidents of settler violence against lesser known Israeli Jewish activists and — not to mention those against Palestinians — rarely even result in arrests. According to statistics compiled by Israeli human rights organization Yesh Din, only 7 percent of Palestinian complaints of settler violence result in indictments.

Just as nobody seriously believes that Israel upholds Palestinians’ basic human rights, it should come as no surprise when it fails to bring to justice those who violate those rights. For anyone still under this delusion, today’s news should be another nail in the coffin. The notion of justice and the rule of law — in any way that benefits Palestinians living under Israeli rule — has lost all meaning. Israel’s judicial system, like all of its institutions, serves the agenda of the Jewish hegemony.

Newsletter banner

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article

    * Required


    1. been there

      The disturbing part of this story is not that the IDF get away with extreme violence,that’s no surprise to anyone but that the American officials do not defend their own citizens. Which country do they really serve?
      I hope American Embassy staff read this letter.

      Reply to Comment
    2. Eliza

      I would think that the only reason the police officer concerned even got a minimal community service sentence for beating a handcuffed minor is that Tariq Abu Khdeir was actually an American citizen. If he had not been American, then I doubt that the officer involved would have even been charged or faced any internal disciplinary measures.

      Of course the Israeli authorities treat Palestinians with contempt. The murder of Tariq’s cousin has not resulted in any Israeli Jew being held to account.

      What stands out for me is the absolute incompetence of Israeli forces. The raid on the Hebron Hospital is almost keystone cops stuff. An Israeli special unit enters a hospital like a bunch of clowns to arrest an injured person and immediately shoots a visitor who comes out of the toilet. I know that the Israeli police/IDF operate under the protection of impunity so they can pretty much do what they want. But is it possible for them to execute a relatively simple action like arresting an injured man in hospital without killing someone else. Apparently not.

      The author is spot on. Israel’s judicial system operates to protect and enhance Jewish hegemony.

      The day will come when individual Israelis will be held to account for their criminal acts against Palestinians – not necessarily in a collective sense but each individual will be held to account.

      Reply to Comment
      • Merkava

        My good friend BEN says:

        “An Israeli special unit enters a hospital like a bunch of clowns to arrest an injured person and immediately shoots a visitor who comes out of the toilet”.
        But my good friend BEN forgot that:

        1. “injured person” is in fact a terrorist who identified an innocent civilian as a Jew and attacked him with machete with the intent to murder him, but succeed only in critically injuring him.

        2. injured person” was injured during the commission of the crime of murder of an innocent civilian!

        3. Israel prosecutes cops who misbehave while carrying out their duties under dangerous and life-threatening circumstances, while Palestinians name their streets after terrorist who murder innocent men, women and children and pay salaries to their families.

        Btw, my good friend BEN, why are you posing as a chic [Eva/Eliza/Lauren]? I am still literarily rolling on the ground laughing my a$$ off! I still can’t wrap my mind around the idea that BEN, who in his own words is a retired old man, likes to be a chic and poses as a chic! Does the old man BEN also put on lipstick and other women’s stuff? Gee! This is good stuff and I am loving every part of it. thank you +972 for the gift of BEN! He indeed is a very funny character.


        Reply to Comment