+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

WATCH: Bulldozers demolish Palestinian homes outside J'lem

By Moriel Rothman

Al-Khalayleh, Palestinian village near the settlement of Giva’at Ze’ev, outside of Jerusalem – A group of young men are swinging shovels and hammers at the walls of a house – their own house.

They had watched as the bulldozers tore down their neighbors’ homes and buildings early the same morning, and decided to destroy part of their house themselves. They were doing this, on one hand, to “not let the Israelis have the pleasure of doing it,” they told me.

But more than that, they were doing so with the hope that the authorities would decide that enough of the house was gone, and allow them to keep one room. Also, this way they perhaps could avoid the fine Palestinians are commonly forced to pay– for the cost of the demolition of their house.

Their desperate efforts were in vain: after the bulldozer finished across the street, border police swarmed over to the house where the boys were swinging their tools.

Everyone was cleared out of the area and the bulldozer went to work flattening the entire structure.

This specific demolition, along with four others, took place Tuesday morning (December 6, 2011) in the village of Al-Khalayleh, but the story could describe hundreds of similar demolitions that have taken place in recent years throughout the occupied territories. The story is as follows:

A Palestinian family builds a new house or building. Sometimes they try to get a building permit, other times they do not bother. Either way the result is the same: permission is not granted and the building is constructed “illegally.”

According to the Israeli planning group Bimkom, in 1972, 97 percent of the building permits submitted by Palestinians were approved. By 2000, the rate was down to 2.7 percent. Since 2000, the acceptance rate has averaged somewhere around 5 percent.

The building is then declared illegal by Israeli authorities – whether it be the Civil Aministration in Area C, as was the case in Al-Khalayleh, or the municipality in East Jerusalem, as was the case in two demolitions that took place the day before (December 5) in Wadi Asoul and Beit Hanina (where, as the homeowner explained, “They dug into the concrete around the home also, so that it will be impossible to rebuild.”)

Sometimes the families are warned in advance that there will be a demolition, sometimes the bureaucracy takes place over their heads or behind their backs. Either way, they rarely know exactly when the demolition will happen.

And there was indeed a current of surprised panic in Al-Khalayleh, humming around the sea of dark blue uniforms and bright yellow bulldozers, dotted with Palestinian villagers holding up cell phones to film.

Everyone was yelling, making phone calls and demanding to see papers. Then the engine of the bulldozer clicked on, the black traction started to move, and the crowd grew silent – unless maybe it had been silenced by the sound of cracking concrete.

Within five minutes, the demolition was finished and the police escorted the bulldozers 100 meters up the street, to destroy the next structure.

And then the next. All in all five structures – two of them residential houses – were destroyed in the span of a few hours.

As the final structure was being demolished, the owner of one of the houses came up to me and asked:

“What can I do now?”

“I… don’t know.”

But in fact I did know. Nothing. The answer is nothing. The demolition was, in essence, a punishment for being Palestinian. He has no option to go to court, because the only courts he has access to are the occupation courts. If he rebuilds, his house will likely be destroyed again. And in all likelihood, the bulldozers will return soon to destroy some of his neighbors’ houses as well.

If trends can tell us anything, these demolitions over the past few days are just the beginning of a renewed wave of destruction. Is this governmental decision bolstered by the realization that most of the Israeli population will never hear about the demolitions, and that many of those who do hear about them will choose to ignore these stories of destruction? That the issue will be written off as “too distant” or “too complicated” or even “too depressing?”

It is not too distant – these demolitions are taking place inside and around Jerusalem, a matter of minutes in a taxi for an Israeli living in West Jerusalem.

It is not too complicated – these demolitions do not involve “terrorism” and “deterrence” and “death.” Even the argument that “Palestinians are illegally taking over land” cannot be applied here, as all of these structures were within the municipal borders of the Palestinian village itself.

These demolitions are simply instances of government offices wielding bureaucratic force to demolish homes built by Palestinians without a permit, which they would not have received even had they requested one. Why? Perhaps to exert control. Perhaps to remind the Palestinians that this land is not their land, not even the villages they live in. Perhaps to sow helplessness, despair, depression.

And these demolitions are certainly depressing. But they are not “too depressing,” especially for those of us with the privilege to go home at night – to a home that is not and will not be in danger of demolition. It is our obligation as Israelis, as wielders of such privilege, to see to it that these demolitions do not continue as planned, whether that be through lobbying, writing, witnessing, posting, filming, discussing, protesting or some other way. We cannot sit silently.

Moriel Rothman is an American-Israeli writer and activist. He lives in Jerusalem, and is active with Rabbis for Human Rights, who recently submitted a petition asking the Israeli Civil Administration to allow Palestinians in Area C to plan for themselves, rather than depend on permission from the Israeli system.

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article

    * Required


    1. AYLA

      Thank you, Moriel, for your witness, your heart, your “I don’t know” and your knowing. Thank you, too, for asking, and allowing, us to bear witness.

      Reply to Comment
    2. Danny

      What a despicable state Israel has become. And the world sits silent and lets this happen. The way it did during the holocaust. Shame on world leaders for being Israel’s enablers. Shame on Obama who unashamedly goes to AIPAC and reasserts America’s blind support for Israel. And most of all – shame on Israelis who chirp about the holocaust day and night, yet have no sympathy for fellow human beings living twenty minutes away.

      Reply to Comment
    3. Moriel Rothman

      @Danny, while I understand your frustration and anger, I think that it is important to remember that the situation is much more complicated than “Israelis who have no sympathy for fellow human beings.” There is, on the Israeli side, a lot of fear and a lot of misunderstanding and, most of all, a lot of ignorance. I truly believe that most Israelis- like most people- are basically good, and that were most of them to witness these demonstrations, as I did, I think that most of them would feel sympathy. The question is how we convince the average Israeli that they should overcome their fear, make the extra effort and start to truly see people on the other side. I don’t think that saying “shame on them” is exactly the way, and I think that it is important to try to empathize with Israelis as well, as tempting as it is to paint a picture of a ‘good people’ and a ‘bad people.’ Any collective application of guilt is dangerous and wrongheaded.

      Reply to Comment
    4. Rabbi Arik Ascherman

      It used to be that the average Israeli assumed that anybody who had their house demolished was a terrorist. Today, many know that isn’t the case, but buy the line that the house was “illegal.” And, you really don’t feel it until you experience it up close. Wherever and whenever I hear a pneumatic drill I shudder runs up and down my spine.

      Reply to Comment
    5. Danny

      @Moriel: I am an ex-Israeli who has lived many years in Israel. While I agree that Israelis by and large are an ignorant people (I submit as evidence the creatures who inhabit the knesset today), one thing most Israelis are not ignorant about is the treatment of the Palestinians in the occupied territories. Why? Simply because most Israelis have, in some capacity, seen it with their own eyes during their military service. I myself became “enlightened” after spending 6 weeks in the occupied territories while guarding settlements. Israelis choose to turn a blind eye to Palestinian suffering mainly because of their extreme dislike (if not outright hatred) of Arabs. I have personally spoken with Israelis who told of their desire to cleanse Israel of all Arabs. Most damning of all is the fact that it is regular Israelis who are responsible for the existence of this abomination of a government. I daresay that, just like Gazans are punished for having the gall to vote for a Hamas government, so too Israelis should be punished. Sorry, but I think the time for “empathy” and “understanding” of Israel’s actions is over, and it is now time to help the Palestinians against Israel’s brutality before all of them become homeless in their own land.

      Reply to Comment
    6. Moriel Rothman

      @Danny- A few comments.
      1. You say that most Israelis have seen the treatment of Palestinians in the OT directly- I just don’t think that’s true. Perhaps if you narrow that down to “most Israeli men who do active combat duty.” But that is not most Israelis.
      2. God forbid that the sort of collective punishment that was used against the Gazans should ever been seen as legitimate. If we are ever going to make things better for anyone here, we need to break out of collectivization and the mentality that allows us to trick ourselves into thinking that collective punishment can ever be just.
      3. I agree, of course, that it is time to stop Israeli brutality towards Palestinians, my challenge to your first comment was focused on the question of how, and of how we face/address the Israeli side as we do that. I do not think that telling Israelis that they have no sympathy for fellow human beings is a good way to get them to listen.

      Reply to Comment
    7. Edithann

      comment was deleted.

      Reply to Comment
    8. Moriel Rothman

      @Edithann. Your comments do not deserve a response. Please direct your hatred elsewhere. You are not helping anyone, and certainly not the Palestinians, with your nonsense.

      Reply to Comment
    9. Edithann

      @Moriel Rothman..I beg to differ but I noticed you read my comment before it was deleted.
      It’s obvious my comment caused a disturbance within the ‘hive’.
      Anyway, it’s also obvious you only want to preach to the converted and regurgitate the same nonsense ad nauseum.
      Does justification of barbarism and revenge become more palatable over time? I guess it must as you’ve been selling that same old line for centuries.


      Reply to Comment