+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

The strange catharsis of hopelessness in Israel

There are no negotiations on the horizon, no deals on the table and no calls to end the violence. This moment in Israeli politics is dismal, yet sobering. 

Thousands of Israeli Left wing activists particiapted a rally in Rabin Square, Tel-Aviv, calling for talks with Palestinians and in support of the two states solution on May 27'th, 2017. (Gili Yaari/Flash90)

Members of the Israeli peace camp rally in Rabin Square, Tel-Aviv, calling for talks with Palestinians and in support of the two states solution. May 27, 2017. (Gili Yaari/Flash90)

It was hard not to feel just a bit giddy in recent weeks about the possibility that corruption investigations against Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu may eventually bear fruit. It was also hard not to feel some excitement about the prospect of early elections due to a coalition breakdown, which would mean the possibility, however minute, of ending Netanyahu’s nearly decade-long reign. Even though Netanyahu’s conviction is still out of reach, and general elections, whenever they happen, are no reason to rejoice —Netanyahu’s Likud Party continues to dominate the polls, and the alternatives are all variations on the same theme — it was tempting to feel there might be a minuscule ray of light in the endlessly dark tunnel. A sudden bit of oxygen in the room.

For those of us who have been living, following and writing about Israeli politics for many years, the current moment is significant. Not because there is anything new, but precisely because nothing is new. For those of us who internalized some time ago that Israel’s occupation is not an unavoidable situation or a temporary condition, but, in fact, the country’s largest national project; for those of us who have for years scoffed at the notion of an American-mediated “peace process” — this moment is significant.

For the first time since I can remember in my brief lifetime, we are squarely in a period where there is not only no peace process, but no facade of one, no developments to look forward to except for further violence. There are no negotiations on the horizon, no deal on the table, no set of parameters, no scheduled summits, no backdoor meetings, no time-frames, no guiding principles, and no calls to end the violence. The Trump Administration’s entrance a year ago, and its subsequent policy decisions, has made this all the more evident. While it is refreshing that there are no longer any smokescreens, it is also utterly depressing.

Growing up in the 1990’s, I remember there was always some benchmark in Israeli politics and its conflict with Palestinians to look forward to, always some ball in motion, some hurdle to cross, something to somehow feel hopeful about. When I was 12, Rabin and Arafat shook hands on the White House Lawn, and I remember hearing the excerpt from Rabin’s speech over and over again for months afterward: “enough of blood and tears, enough.” I remember feeling hopeful. Then Rabin was murdered, Netanyahu was elected, and of course, years later, I became politically conscious. I realized what a farce the Oslo agreement was, providing cover for Israel’s continued settlement enterprise and creating the basis for a Palestinian puppet regime that remains in power in the West Bank. But there was nonetheless a general consensus in Israel about the need to end the violence. Or at least a semblance of it. There was an atmosphere of sadness and regret for the continued violence.

Can you imagine anyone in Israeli politics turning to the Palestinians today and saying, “enough of blood and tears enough?”

Israelis rally in support of Elor Azaria, the Israeli soldier who shot and killed incapacitated Palestinian attacker in Hebron. Rabin Square, Tel Aviv, April 19, 2016. (Tomer Neuberg/Flash90)

Israelis rally in support of Elor Azaria, the Israeli soldier who shot and killed an incapacitated Palestinian attacker in Hebron. Rabin Square, Tel Aviv, April 19, 2016. (Tomer Neuberg/Flash90)

In today’s Israel, violence against Palestinians is rewarded and bereavement is revered. On Monday, Israel’s military announced that Elor Azaria, the soldier convicted of manslaughter after killing a wounded and incapacitated Palestinian assailant in Hebron, will be released in May, reducing his already short 18-month sentence. He will have served a total of nine months in prison, less than many Israelis who refuse to serve in the army because they oppose occupation and less than most Palestinian “security” prisoners who are held in Israeli jails without charge or trial. Also this week, an Israeli educator Miriam Peretz received the Israel Prize for lifetime achievement  — the country’s most prestigious prize for a civilian — for “strengthening the Jewish-Israeli spirit.” Peretz, a bereaved mother of two IDF soldiers, lost both her sons twelve years apart, in operations in Lebanon and Gaza, respectively.

Since the start of 2018, 19 Palestinians have been killed, six of them minors, by Israeli soldiers, with the exception of one killed by an Israeli civilian from a settlement. In January and February alone, the Israel Defense Forces arrested 1,319 Palestinians, 274 of them minors, 23 women, and four journalists. Israel recently shot a child in the head with a rubber bullet and then arrested him (while still recovering and awaiting surgery) in the middle of the night in his bed and pressured him to admit that his head injury was from falling off a bike. Israeli soldiers were recently caught on film violently preventing Palestinian medics from treating a Palestinian who they had shot. Another recent video shows IDF soldiers beating a Palestinian man, who later died of his wounds.

In the meantime, Israeli life goes on as usual. In fact it prospers. In 2017, Israel’s economy grew three percent, and it is projected to continue to stay strong.

Today, Israeli state violence and disregard for human life is evident and no longer downplayed or denied. Earlier this month at the Economic Club in Washington, Netanyahu said that Israel intends to continue military control over the West Bank indefinitely. Justice Minister Ayelet Shaked admitted that Israel seeks to maintain Jewish dominance at the expense of Palestinian human rights. Israel’s Foreign and Culture Ministries are busy boycotting a fictional film made by an Israeli war veteran that doesn’t make the IDF look like the most moral army in the world.

In May, Israel will mark 70 years of existence by inaugurating the U.S. embassy move to Jerusalem, possibly attended by President Trump, a move which is no less than a declaration of war on Palestinian self-determination and any kind of viable resolution.

As an Israeli and as a journalist, I have been horrified and angry and indignant and cynical and jaded over and over again for years. This moment in time makes obvious even to the naked eye the devastation and disillusionment that me and many of my peers have felt for a long time. In a way, it is bittersweet catharsis.

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article

    * Required


    1. Bruce Gould

      @Sally Parker: “I’m hoping that Mondoweiss, 972, and JVP can take a hard look at Israel’s foreign policy, and decide whether it’s closer to a plan or a suicide pill.”

      Suicide pill. Ronald Lauder, president of the World Jewish Congress, just wrote an editorial in the New York Times titled “Israels Self Inflicted Wounds”


      “But the Jewish democratic state faces two grave threats that I believe could endanger its very existence….”

      Reply to Comment
    2. Tony Riley

      I might take you seriously if you didn’t support the racist BDS movement

      Reply to Comment
    3. Lewis from Afula

      I have seen the “hope” that Zonszhein advocates, together with her heroes – Rabin, Peres and all the other “Great Leaders”. That regime turned Israel into a valley of death, with buses, pizza parlours, shops, malls, discos and everything blowing up by Arab homicide bombers.
      1500 Israelis were murdered by the “Religion of Peace” and 5000 were blinded, deafened, burned, had amputations, seriously physically maimed etc.

      No, life is much better under Bibi.
      Do not let the Zonsheins spoil it !

      Reply to Comment
      • Esther minsky

        The Palestinian issue was not created by Israel. Palestine was never a sole Arab state. Even in the 1930’s the Arab revolt against the British mandate , was responsible for the massacre of hundreds of Jewish Palestinians. In 1948 Jordan occupied Jewish Judea and Samaria. Jews were killed or forcibly exiled. The Arab population were mistreated by the hashamite kingdom. How come there were no protests from 1948-1967? Israel liberated these territories in 1967 Jordan didn’t want them back in return for a peace treaty. Israel assumed responsibility for the Arab population giving them electricity,running water health care employment and prosperity. For this they received hostility terrorism world criticism . The Jewish people have only one small state the Arabs have 32 Muslim states all of whom call for the destruction of Israel. Any Palestinian state should rightfully be in Jordan whose population is mostly Palestinian . During the pre 1948 struggle to establish a Jewish state the Labour left politicians were willing to accept a Jewish autonomy under British rule sharing the land with the existing Arab population even though the British openly favoured the Arabs and did nothing to stop the constant attacks by Arab terror groups on Jewish populations who were unarmed and unprotected. This same left Labour movement betrayed the brave fighters of Lechi giving them away to the British who executed them. We have always had traitors , kapos ,Jews prepared to capitulate to the enemy today they are the left wing media and academics who encourage our enemies to continue attacking and murdering our people . You are to blame for the rise of antisemitism and attacks on Jews globaly.

        Reply to Comment