+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

Marginalized groups that Qatari PR would rather you not see

The American network CBS – via its flagship news magazine show, “60 Minutes” – gave the tiny peninsula Kingdom of Qatar a free ride in its report earlier this year exploring the small gulf nation. Correspondent Bob Simon, dubbed by the network itself as “the most honored journalist in international reporting,” delivered a public relations coup to the Emir and his government (i.e. family) by failing to properly investigate life in the country of less than two million people (the majority of whom are foreign laborers).

Simon was partially right.  Yes, for many – namely, the wealthy portion of the one-quarter of population that is actually Qataris – life is content thanks to an absurd amount of amenities and luxuries courtesy of global oil prices. But those who do not fall into that category do exist, and for the most part their stories are untold.

Salim (not his real name) is a Lebanese man I met through friends over dinner at the souk one night in 2009. He is gay and has been with his partner – a married Qatari man – for a number of years. (Such extramarital affairs are said to be quite common.)  Salim has lived in Qatar for more than a decade.  And when we met, he revealed that a few years prior to the dinner, he was arrested upon arrival at the airport in Doha just as he was returning from a large party in Western Europe. Salim claims he was held and beaten for three days and repeatedly called names considered derogatory terms for homosexual men. Perhaps by coincidence, though likely not, he said that just days earlier, a male member of the extended Qatari royal family made advances towards him at the party. Salim rejected him, which he claims angered the Qatari man.

Michel (not his real name) is also Lebanese. When I met him in 2008, he was working for Qatar Airways, the national carrier, based in Doha but flying around the world.  He and other airline crew live in dormitories, which include a curfew and constant monitoring of their comings and goings. He told me that his first dorm-mate was evicted from the country when authorities discovered he was HIV-positive. According to Michel, the individual was taken from the government office – where he was told of his deportation – directly to the airport, not even permitted to go “home” and collect his things, which Michel says he ended up shipping to him.

Their stories go unheard.  As will Lucy’s (not her real name), a young Filipina woman working (then, not sure about now) in the canteen of the Al Jazeera English compound. Lucy, at the time, was employed via a subcontractor.  She worked at the Al Jazeera facility six days a week. On the seventh day, she told me, the subcontractor employed her elsewhere.  When I mentioned to the person standing in the canteen queue behind me – one of the highest ranking directors of the channel – that Lucy works non-stop seven days a week, he seemed unbothered. He heard me, but was unresponsive. (Disclaimer: I worked at Al Jazeera English for five years and found the majority of people there to be actively dedicated to the rights of global laborers.)

The less-glitzy streets of Doha, June 2008 (photo: open cage/flickrcc)

The less-glitzy streets of Doha, June 2008 (photo: open cage/flickrcc)

Lucy is not alone.  Foreign laborers working in Qatar, more than three-quarters of the people physically residing there, have few-to-no rights. Most (unlike Lucy) have Fridays off, when they are seen congregating in public places. A sign posted at the front entrance of the glitzy shopping center, which  Simon refers to as a sort of “Rodeo Drive,” indicates they are not welcome inside.  Technically, the sign notes that Friday is for “Families-only,” a clear reference excluding the South Asian workers who are in Qatar earning money – remittances – to send back home to their spouses and children.  I, a single caucasian male, was not prevented from entering the center, nor was I harassed while inside.  The foreign laborers are not wealthy, of course, nor are they considered in assessments of national wealth. Hence, the figures referred to by many, including CBS, in which Qataris are the world’s richest people, bear a hint of deception, as the majority of the people in Qatar are not actually counted. It would be like saying that Californians are the richest in America based solely on the incomes of people in Bel Air.

An alley in Souq Waqif, where many Filipino, South Indian and Bangladeshi workers (photo: kate.gardiner/flckr/cc) live, Doha, Qatar, May 2011 (photo:

An alley in Souq Waqif, where many Filipino, South Indian and Bangladeshi workers (photo: kate.gardiner/flckr/cc) live, Doha, Qatar, May 2011 (photo:

Then there are those who are not counted by any measures. Hassan (not his real name) and his family (a mother and nine siblings, the father died in a car crash) are “Bidun.” Translating from the Arabic word “without,” Bidun are technically stateless “leftovers” in the Gulf. In neighboring Kuwait, they number more than 100,000. In Qatar, their numbers are much smaller, but their problems and daily struggles in coping with statelessness are just as real. According to Human Rights Watch, “Bidun cannot register for education or health benefits, or legally hold employment.  The government does not register the birth of Bidun children.” For Hassan, this means constantly operating beneath the radar, using roads that do not have checkpoints, ensuring he is home during specific hours of the evening, and avoiding all risks that might result in his arrest or, worse, expulsion. According to Hassan, a Qatari man claiming that he would help the family obtain citizenship documents for a North African country took their money and disappeared, wiping the family of most of their savings and leaving them with no official channels for recourse.

Perhaps most upsetting was the site of a particular roundabout (of which there are many) in Doha where, I was told, Pashtun men are sexually solicited by local Qatari men. An adjacent lot on the corner which overnight serves as a parking facility for large transport trucks reportedly provides the cloak of nighttime darkness and discretion for such activities. I myself did not witness any active solicitation or engagement, but I did see dozens of young, Pashtun men loitering at this particular roundabout, and one told us he had often gone with Arab men who offered him money.

Stories like these are just the tip of the iceberg.  A deeper investigation into life in Qatar, particularly in a report that claims to examine from the inside the country and its growing role, should have explored these and similar narratives. In addition, CBS should have been more educated in its questions – as in, aware of the sectarian, religious, ethnic, tribal tensions and rivalries that exist among the Arab world, of which Qatar is a player with specific interests.  It should have also been more honest about some facts – like Qatar’s preference for promoting advanced education in the physical sciences and not in the liberal arts (presumably because chemists don’t lead revolutions).  And it should now be more apologetic about some obvious omissions – like any reference to the ongoing unrest in Qatar’s neighbor, Bahrain.  After all, Qatar is part of the Saudi-led GCC (Gulf Cooperation Council) that sent its troops to quell the Shia Bahraini demonstrators. However, mentioning these things would have likely angered all of the people Simon interviews: the King, the Prime Minister and an adviser to the army (who drives him around).

Which brings me to the my last question.  Where was the voice of criticism?

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article
  • LEAVE A COMMENT

    * Required

    COMMENTS

    1. There are large-scale political issues al Jazeera is equally silent about. Qatar is hardly more than a front window for the Sauds, who are methodically taking over the Sunni world, using local or imported paramilitaries and Saudi-trained Muslim Brotherhood politicians. You can see it everywhere, from Tunisia, to Libya, to Egypt, to Syria. It isn’t just al-Jazeera; most Arab media are too scared to talk about it. Al Qaeda death squads can pop up just about anywhere. There’s a lot of money behind it, and despite complicated prevarications from western politicians, it’s broadly NATO-supported. Stable anti-left regimes are what the west desires, and the Sauds have the machinery to deliver them. As a rule of thumb, you can say that complaints from western human rights organisations regarding Qatar, or Bahrain, for instance, are about as irrelevant as they would be regarding Saudi Arabia itself.

      Reply to Comment
      • @Florence, you are always welcome to send opinion columns to the 972 editors. They are welcome. But I’m pretty sure if people wanted to read JPost’s stories, they would go to JPost.

        Reply to Comment
    2. Palestinian

      Nobody can deny the list of human rights violations in the Arab world from East to West ,discrimination ,prejudice….you name it but this magazine supposedly covers our conflict not Qatar nor Saudi Arabia.That Lebanese gay man (Saleem)and his unfaithful Qatari “partner” I wish them the worst of luck,I wonder how much he pays him.

      Reply to Comment
      • @Palestinian, ten percent of men are said to be gay … even in the Arab world, where due to culture impositions many gay men are still married while maintaining extra-marital, discrete same-sex relations on the side. Your assumption that the Qatari man pays Salim is presumptuous at best and offensively ignorant at worst. (And, for the record, it’s incorrect.) Additionally, your comment “I wish them the worst of luck” reveals an unsympathetic nature. I imagine you’ll find it very hard to get people to support your plight against injustice if you aren’t willing to do the same for others. I encourage you to think about that.

        Reply to Comment
    3. There’s only one english-language arabic web news source I visit every morning, and that’s al-Akhbar. I assume its english-language site omits quite a lot of interesting things that appear on its arabic-language site, but that can’t be helped. Al-Akhbar has a great deal that’s of pretty immediate relevance to Palestinians, and Arabs generally, I would say. Sometimes I can see its journalists subtly making fun of the government censorship that does exist in Lebanon (for instance, they cannot criticise the security establishment directly, so they have to say sarcastically, “our excellent national security has hardly been marred by the more than twenty bombings in the last two months” or whatever; but really, they do very well. They maintain a sort of balance which is distinctively Lebanese; you couldn’t do that anywhere else. Not in Egypt, for instance. Jadaliyya is run by young left-wing US Arab academics, and it shows.

      Reply to Comment
    4. Palestinian

      @ Roee , I wasnt even discussing the percentage of gay men(which may be wrong)You ignored my first comment and you jumped to the second one “to defend gay rights” although I wasnt even talking about it .That Qatari is cheating on his wife and his Lebanese boy is part of it .I cant sympathize with such a lovely couple ,and fyi classy prostitution is well known there (so instead of a one-night stand let it be one year )Culture impositions dont tell you to cheat on your spouse.Divorce is an option.I think you had to bring up this story to provoke people to comment on your article ,its a taboo and a very “hot” one,and you know it.Millions of people support our cause although they know very well homosexuality isnt accepted by the vast majority of Palestinians esp people who live among the Palestinians.How silly to connect between defending the Palestinian cause (in case you do)and denying the mentality of the people you support.Its like if you dont adopt my values I wont support you ,really !Then dont …

      Reply to Comment
    5. max

      Roee, thanks for the post.
      From Palestinian I understand that the homosexuality topic is a deep cultural (Muslim? Arab?) one (taboo). What about the other part? Is it – in your opinion – rather one related to the huge social gap specific in that area or is it also wider spread?
      .
      But I also have to reinforce Palestinian’s comment: it’s not only as he says “this magazine supposedly covers our conflict”, it in fact covers almost exclusively supposedly Israeli crimes against Palestinians. So bringing up such stories risks diluting the message and bring up unhealthy thoughts such as the quality of Bob Simon’s report on Christians in Palestine or explain the reluctance of most secular Israelis to the one-state idea.
      We can’t afford such perspectives, they’re simply counter productive.

      Reply to Comment
    6. From a serious anti-imperialist point of view, gay interests, like women’s interests, are extremely problematic because they cut diagonally across both national and class interests, creating fifth columns of sympathisers in unpredictable places, and acting as liberal stalking horses. Almost invariably, these sympathisers are sacrificed in the long run, having served their purpose of destabilising the targeted regimes and weakening their defense against liberal imperialist penetration. Minority ethnic and religious groups can be used in the same way; for instance, never in history have the Kurds, as a national group, won any of their substantial goals, least of all national self-determination. Over and over again, they have been used and cast aside afterwards like the proverbial used condoms. And it’s the same with gays and feminists, or as the current jargon has it, “LGBT people”. One is not doing them a favour when one adopts them as mascots.

      Reply to Comment
    7. Mareli

      Palestinian is correct when he says most Palestinians are intolerant of homosexuality, which is why so many gay Palestinians have been hurt by the difficulties encountered by Arabs trying to enter Israel. Ironically, gay Palestinians need Israel in order to survive more than many Jews.

      Reply to Comment
    8. Rafael

      I don’t think Israeli white phosphorus protects Palestinian gays.

      Reply to Comment