+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

Israelis should listen to the message of the Jewish flotilla

The Israel naval unit warned the “Irene” twice not to break Israeli law. The “Jewish flotilla” – actually just a single boat with symbolic amounts of provisions, continued sailing toward Gaza. The navy took over, and the boat ultimately anchored in Ashdod. The activists have been detained for questioning, the Israeli news reported. Yawn.

For the most part, Israelis will probably dismiss the Jewish flotilla as radicals, weirdos and eccentrics at best, self-haters, at worst. The quiet conclusion and low-key coverage will be easy to ignore.

It was left to the handful of relatives and supporters to create something quote-worthy. The mother of a leading activist, Yonatan Shapira, expressed fear about the IDF, as her son is reportedly being held for questioning (NRG reports that Israelis are being held at the Ashdod police station). “I don’t trust the IDF”  – that’s a headline in Israel. This was in Hebrew – the English version is decidedly more neutral: “Navy stops Gaza-bound “Jewish vessel

NRG too, the website of the Maariv daily newspaper, put her fears into the sub-headline – noting that she’s afraid something will happen to him. Turns out there was some reason for worry, according to Shapira’s account in Ynet. He claimed that, the reportedly quiet takeover and questioning involved violence and electrical prods.

But many Israelis will stop reading right at the top of those stories. The moment someone expresses subversive thoughts doubting IDF integrity, most Israeli minds will shut down. The IDF, recall, is consistently the most trusted institution in the country, by a longshot and this has always been the case.

By contrast, “Leftists” is one of the dirtiest words here these days, synonymous in many people’s minds with Israel-hating, possibly anti-semitism and treason. It is associated with other nasty terms like human rights and democracy, which are increasingly scorned as a result.

But I wonder, if people could divorce the messages from the trappings they despise – how awful are the things the protesters are saying? They sought to symbolically protest a destructive policy, without hurting anyone, through civil disobedience. Their signs said “Jews and Arabs Refuse to be Enemies,”  “Are prosthetics dangerous” – as the ship tried to bring medical equipment for the sick. They called to “End the occupation” – something most Israelis either want, or at least accept that. Ariel Sharon said it seven years ago already.

Further, the organizers say they protest the policy because it feeds hostility against Israel; they explicitly critique the siege as government policy, distinguished from anti-Israel messages –  and they seek to end Israel’s feelings of “isolation and persecution.” That sounds like concern for Israel, not hate.

Still, the Israeli Foreign Ministry spokesperson called it “a completely unnecessary media gimmick which should never have been born…a trick of hatred and publicity for people who don’t care about the love of Israel and don’t deserve more than a footnote.”

So how do Israeli authorities suggest improving Israel’s relations with the world? Ironically, the advertising banner above the nrg story about the Jewish flotilla proposes a different solution: Join israel’s propaganda efforts, run by the Ministry of Propaganda and Diaspora (the term Hasbara is also sometimes translated as public diplomacy in – well – diplomatic language). The ad shows a would-be female foreign reporter with demonic eyes demonstrating how Israelis cook their chicken skewers on primitive cooking fires.  The idea is that these evil reporters are the real sources of anger against Israel.

Blaming foreign reporters seems beyond desperate. Maybe it’s time to start listening to the Jewish flotilla.

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article
  • LEAVE A COMMENT

    * Required

    COMMENTS

    1. But the people that read to the end of this article are the choir – we understand the importance. How do you bang this message over the head of the general Israeli public? Where are the billboards down Highway 2? Why can’t the left rise above its vilification?

      There’s a disconnect – reason is not making it to the general public as it continues to drift to the right. How do you reach the people with the enlightened message of the so-called left?

      Reply to Comment
    2. Extremist Zionist

      Adam, I will explain to you why the Israeli public does not respond to stunts like these flotillas. It is called “experience”. You see, the vast majority of Israelis remember the thousands of Israelis killed or wounded in the wake of the Oslo Agreements. They also remember the thousands of rockets fired at Israel AFTER the unilateral withdrawals from the south Lebanon security zone and Gaza Strip.
      When Israel made steps in the direction of “peace” as you “progressives” define it, Israel was not reciprocated with good will on the side of the Arabs, but rather more strident demands and increased attacks. Now, you will say “what Israel offered was inadequate”. Well, how are Israeli supposed to know that an “adequate” offer is supposed to look like. After all, the Palestinians are clearly saying they will never agree to give up the Palestinian “right of return”, something no Israeli gov’t will ever agree to. This is even if Israel agreed to a complete withdrawal to the pre-67 lines. This is why most Israeli are indifferent to the message of groups like those of the flotilla organizers.

      Reply to Comment
    3. […] UPDATE THREE: Just to put this in local [Israeli] perspective, Dahlia Scheindlin has written in the new Israeli group publication +972 [Israel's international calling code] magazine sardonically that “The Israel naval unit warned the Irene twice not to break Israeli law. The ‘Jewish flotilla – actually just a single boat with symbolic amounts of provisions, continued sailing toward Gaza. The navy took over, and the boat ultimately anchored in Ashdod. The activists have been detained for questioning, the Israeli news reported. Yawn. For the most part, Israelis will probably dismiss the Jewish flotilla as radicals, weirdos and eccentrics at best, self-haters, at worst. The quiet conclusion and low-key coverage will be easy to ignore. It was left to the handful of relatives and supporters to create something quote-worthy. The mother of a leading activist, Yonatan Shapira, expressed fear about the IDF, as her son is reportedly being held for questioning (NRG reports that Israelis are being held at the Ashdod police station). “I don’t trust the IDF” – that’s a headline in Israel. This was in Hebrew – the English version is decidedly more neutral … But many Israelis will stop reading right at the top of those stories. The moment someone expresses subversive thoughts doubting IDF integrity, most Israeli minds will shut down. The IDF, recall, is consistently the most trusted institution in the country, by a longshot and this has always been the case. By contrast, ‘Leftists’ is one of the dirtiest words here these days, synonymous in many people’s minds with Israel-hating, possibly anti-semitism and treason. It is associated with other nasty terms like human rights and democracy, which are increasingly scorned as a result. But I wonder, if people could divorce the messages from the trappings they despise – how awful are the things the protesters are saying? They sought to symbolically protest a destructive policy, without hurting anyone, through civil disobedience. Their signs said ‘Jews and Arabs Refuse to be Enemies’, ‘Are prosthetics dangerous?’ – as the ship tried to bring medical equipment for the sick. They called to ‘End the occupation’ – something most Israelis either want, or at least accept … Ariel Sharon said it seven years ago already. Further, the organizers say they protest the policy because it feeds hostility against Israel; they explicitly critique the siege as government policy, distinguished from anti-Israel messages – and they seek to end Israel’s feelings of ‘isolation and persecution’. That sounds like concern for Israel, not hate. Still, the Israeli Foreign Ministry spokesperson called it ‘a completely unnecessary media gimmick which should never have been born…a trick of hatred and publicity for people who don’t care about the love of Israel and don’t deserve more than a footnote’. So how do Israeli authorities suggest improving Israel’s relations with the world? Ironically, the advertising banner above the nrg story about the Jewish flotilla proposes a different solution: Join Israel’s propaganda efforts, run by the Ministry of Propaganda and Diaspora (the term Hasbara is also sometimes translated as public diplomacy in – well – diplomatic language). The ad shows a would-be female foreign reporter with demonic eyes demonstrating how Israelis cook their chicken skewers on primitive cooking fires. The idea is that these evil reporters are the real sources of anger against Israel” … This is posted here. […]

      Reply to Comment
    4. Dan

      Some context, if I may. The person that lead this so called flotilla vandalized the walls of the Warsaw ghetto (I believe he wrote there ‘may all ghetos be released’). His partners and himself are not doing it for truth or for anything else. They are doing it because they believe that external pressure on Israel might make its politicians bend down. The fact of the matter is that these people, who like to call themselves pro-democracy and pro-human rights (not for Jews, of course), are unelectable (surely the author of this piece is aware of that, considering she was their campaign adviser for a few time now), and since they can’t win the hearts of Israelis, they are resorting to twisting their arms. This will not work.

      Reply to Comment