Appreciate this article? +972 depends on your support.

Click here to help us keep going

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

Surviving the ups and downs: Israel's first Arab-Jewish school turns 30

For three decades the school at Neve Shalom/Wahat al-Salam has taught our children how to grow and become adults with a cohesive national and human identity, without fear of the other. Today, however, the future looks as uncertain as ever.

(Translated from Hebrew by Rivka Einy)

Edi Edlund (left) and Abed Islam, founders of the Neve Shalom/Wahat Al Salam school. (Courtesy of Neve Shalom/Wahat Al Salam)

Edi Edlund (left) and Abed Islam, founders of the Neve Shalom/Wahat al-Salam school. (Courtesy of Neve Shalom/Wahat Al Salam)

Atop a small mountain in the Latrun area lies the village we chose to establish a small family. Located between Tel Aviv and Jerusalem, the Arab-Jewish village goes by the name Neve Shalom/Wahat al-Salam.

A few weeks ago, the village hosted an emotional and beautiful event to mark 30 years since the opening of the village school. All of us, parents and children, celebrated in the schoolyard to honor the tremendous effort, and the first of its kind: a school that is both binational and bilingual. With us were also members of the school’s founding generation, the ones who were the first to put Arabs and Jews in the same classroom. Those first classrooms had two teachers, Abed and Eti—one Arab and one Jew.

Back then there wasn’t a set plan—no schedule, curriculum or pedagogical approach. There were no permits that needed to be granted nor any extra supervision, just two brave teachers and the village residents, made up of several families who decided to start the journey together. They believed in their inherent goodness, being good neighbors, speaking two languages, equality, and not being afraid to talk about anything. As for the rest of it, they had no clue what would happen, they simply knew they would figure it out. Every problem has a solution, and those who intend to teach about how to achieve peace there are no shortcuts—they simply need to live together.

Thirty years ago, the HaMishmar newspaper reported that the first ever Arab-Jewish school in the world would open in Neve Shalom, on land donated to its founders by the nearby Latrun monastery. This land did not belong to an expropriated, destroyed Arab village, nor was it state land rife with a painful history. Rather, it was a piece of land free of injustice and guilt, and so atop it we built hope, room by room.

At the whim of the Education Ministry

Today, the school houses approximately 180 students, from kindergarten to sixth grade, in a building located in the heart of the village. During school hours, the main road to the village is closed off in both directions for the sake of the children and their freedom of movement. Until a friend expressed to me how strange it was to close off a main road for eight hours a day, I hadn’t quite grasped just how much the school is prioritized above all else in the village.

Most of the students come from outside the village, from nearby towns such as Abu Gosh, Ein Rafa, Beit Nekofa, Jerusalem, Carmei Yosef, Tzur Hadassa, Kibbutz Gezer, Kfar Oriah, Modi’in, Ramla, Lod, among other places. Thus transportation presents a complicated budgeting and logistical challenge. Sometimes these costs can break the family’s bank, preventing them from continuing to send their children to the school. Unfortunately Israeli citizens lack the right to choose where and how their children will be educated. If as parents you desire different schooling for your children than what you are given, you must pay out of pocket.

The school in its first years. (Courtesy of Neve Shalom/Wahat al-Salam)

The school in its first years. (Courtesy of Neve Shalom/Wahat al-Salam)

Three decades of tireless pedagogical practice sum up the history of the Arab-Jewish conflict rather well. It is enough to walk around the photography exhibition of the school in order to understand that what is happening outside always seeps in—even if we are atop a mountain, somewhat disconnected—the political situation does not bypass us. The schoolchildren hear the army planes on their way to Gaza. Even “price tag” criminals signed our guestbook once. The past 30 years have seen two intifadas, the Oslo accords, a visit by President Clinton, a performance by Pink Floyd’s Roger Waters, attacks, and plenty of ups and downs.

There have been times that the government has recognized and subsidized us, and times when we ran from the Education Ministry, like when former Minister Limor Livnat forced upon us a director who wasn’t really interested in peace, leaving us with no money.

There were good days and dark ones too. Sometimes we spoke of Rabin’s assassination, sometimes we spoke of other ideologically- and politically-motivated murders, such as those of Arafat, Martin Luther King Jr., Mahatma Gandhi, Naji Al-Ali (the famous Palestinian cartoonist), and others.

What do we do on Remembrance Day?

In a country where Israelis and Palestinians live together, work and meet in the supermarket, to be educated together was once considered bordering on the forbidden. Even today relations remain unstable.

When everybody on the outside is talking about peace, we are considered “popular” and “cute,” and the Ministry of Education sends smiley people to take photos of us under our peace arch. When peace goes out of fashion, the very same model of education that emphasizes peace, equality, social justice and democracy is kicked aside in favor of Jewish heritage and Zionism.

Sometimes we are up and sometimes down, but the journey has continued for 30 years based on the belief that there is no other way—and thanks to the donations and volunteer efforts of the sane world abroad. Developing this model comes with many errors and many successes. Debates surrounding what we should discuss and do not were not simple: how do we mark the national holidays of Independence Day and Nakba Day, Land Day and Remembrance Day? You’d be surprised that even in this field there are various fashionable trends, such as the difference between a “narrative” approach and the approach of “managing the conflict,” or whether to separate into various groups during difficult days, or to combine forces, even during times of crisis.

I have learned over the years that we were once more daring. There was a time when our children went to demonstrations and openly opposed the war along with their parents. We used to shout for an end to the occupation and for a peace agreement. We used to see the road more clearly and would go the limit with our young students.

Schoolchildren demonstrate at an anti-occupation rally. (Courtesy of Neve Shalom/Wahat al-Salam)

Schoolchildren demonstrate at an anti-occupation rally. (Courtesy of Neve Shalom/Wahat al-Salam)

The task now is to survive the military operations, wars and manifestations of hatred and racism. It has become a difficult task in the shadow of governments who do all they can to dispossess, colonize and separate—to govern and embitter the lives of millions of Palestinians and to control them in the name of the Jewish state and its security. We no longer even speak of the peace process, which is miserable and wretched. It seems that soon the message of peace, justice and equality among humans will be denounced as an anti-Semitic, not to mention incitement against the state itself.

‘Have mercy on our children’

Eti Edlund, our founding teacher, now a grandmother to children in the school, was left alone after her co-founder, Abed Islam, passed away a few years ago. “We have met many people on our journey,” she says, “academics who have seen beams of light emanate from our institution, and those who view us as a generation of sinners, who would, heaven forbid, have their children intermarry. We have met senior officials from the Ministry of Education who dismissed the idea with a wave of the hand, only to embrace us after nine years of work. We met so called ‘experts’ who believed that teaching two languages simultaneously would harm the development of our children, as well as good friends who took pity on our own children because we would be their teachers.

“We have heard, learned, changed, and continued forward resolutely, eyes wide open and with a willingness to adopt any idea or piece of advice, any bit of help along the way. The goals we set for ourselves were clear and concrete: to bring together two cultures, teach both languages, and create a school where students enjoy learning.”

Photography exhibit to mark 30 years since the founding of bi-national school. (photo: Samah Salaime)

Photography exhibit to mark 30 years since the founding of bi-national school. (photo: Samah Salaime)

During the ceremony I met a mother from Abu Gosh, a graduate of the school whose son is currently in third grade. With tears in her eyes she walked around the exhibit, telling her son how much love, warmth and joy she experienced in the school, and how much she wanted it to continue through high school, rather than end at seventh grade.

Students of a bi-national and bi-lingual school grow to become adults with a cohesive national and human identity, an awareness of their history and that of their neighbors, who are not threatened by the Jewish student on the nearby bench or afraid of a game of hide-and-seek led by an Arab student during recess. They value meaningful learning and know how one can be happy while learning at the same time. And yes—they may even be world’s most naïve people and believe that peace is on its way.

Samah Salaime is a social worker, a director of AWC (Arab Women in the Center) in Lod/Lyd and a graduate of the Mandel Leadership Institute in Jerusalem. This article was first published in Hebrew on Local Call, where she is a blogger. Read it here.

Newsletter banner

For additional original analysis and breaking news, visit +972 Magazine's Facebook page or follow us on Twitter. Our newsletter features a comprehensive round-up of the week's events. Sign up here.

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article
  • LEAVE A COMMENT

    * Required

    COMMENTS

    1. Pedro X

      When we talk about Jewish-Arab schools we should remember that Israeli Universities are open to both Israeli Arabs and Jews, to Christian, Jews and Muslims and seculars. In the West Bank Palestinian Universities do not offer places to Jews. Amira Haas was banned from attending a conference at a leading Palestinian University because she was Jewish.

      One of the most impressive examples of co-existence between Jewish and Arab students is at Ariel University. More than 3 times the total number of the combined Jewish and Arab students at Neve Shalom are Arab at Ariel University. The Jewish and Arab students have a history of co-existence. You will also find Ethiopians of Jewish descent going to school here in a warm educative environment. 70% of the students come from central Israel and the Tel Aviv area. This is not a settlers only university.

      The University offers many courses in the sciences, health and engineering. It has a school of architecture. It has a particle accelerator which is used in cutting edge cancer research. You can study electrical engineering, psychology or public communications and market management. Of course one can study computer sciences and math here.

      Despite its cross cultural existence, in a safe environment, research programs and practical programs for those looking for education leading to employment, Ariel is boycotted by Europeans and leftists for where the campus is located not for what the university provides in terms of education to both Israeli Arabs and Jews.

      Why is not Samah singing praises of a mixed Jewish-Arab University which provides so many Arabs with a quality eduction year after year?

      Reply to Comment
      • Bruce Gould

        I hear there are blacks at Harvard, but that doesn’t mean there isn’t segregation in American schools, it doesn’t mean that schools in black neighborhoods aren’t underfunded compared to their white counterparts. Here’s an article from Haaretz about educational segregation in Israel:

        http://www.haaretz.com/business/.premium-1.578944

        Reply to Comment
        • Luc Longley

          Bruce, boring post. You are conflating socko-economic class for race. And public schools are not segregated by race.
          Instead of reading garbage from Blumenthal that only confirms your racist believes, educate yourself by reading Dr. Thomas Sowell.

          And I am embarrassed for you that you said “I hear that there are blacks at Harard”. You sound like bigot from the 1960s.

          Reply to Comment
          • marnie

            Sarcasm and humor are wasted on many at +972, guess you are another one. And the underfunding of schools for African Americans and special programming for African Americans compared to whites is as stark and obvious as black and white. Other than being a distraction, you offer nothing to the conversation. Yet another one.

            Reply to Comment
          • Wedding Singer

            Yes! That joke by Bruce Gould is a real “knee-slapper”! In fact, I could not get through his paragraph without spitting my sides over his masterful ownership of sarcasm.

            Now that is out of the way….

            Your simplicitic view of race and unwillingness to learn is startling for the 21st century.

            Reply to Comment
    2. It’s important to listen to the teacher

      Reply to Comment
    3. Ben

      @ Pedro X:

      “In the West Bank Palestinian Universities do not offer places to Jews”

      Normally you would have written this sentence as

      “In Judea and Samaria Palestinian Universities do not offer places to Jews”

      But you looked at that and realized that that would give the game away and you couldn’t maintain the fiction that your construction relies upon, the fiction that the Palestinians are not thoroughly occupied and oppressed in their own land. And so in this case, unusually, you used the term “West Bank” to peddle the hasbara idea that those nasty Palestinians are just implacably stingy and Jew-hating in their own land because, um, that’s just the way those people are, even though those nice Jews offer them spots in their own university…and rouse them randomly out of bed at 2AM to conduct “mapping” then throw away the photos they take of the terrified family at 2AM; and randomly invade people’s houses at 3AM and arrest the father, verified totally innocent ahead of time, drag him out, throw him in a jeep blindfolded, drive him out of the village somewhere and then let him go–all for practice. Why don’t the Israelis save those handy 2AM photos for the Ariel University application photos and save those lucky Palestinians the chore of making another photo? Yes, those lucky Palestinians, go figure why they’re so ungrateful. Why I hear tell they don’t offer military strategy and financing courses, olive tree pruning courses and courses on the basics of hydrological theft 101 to those nice Israeli settler neighbors of theirs, how small minded and ungrateful of them. It just goes to show you.

      Reply to Comment