+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

Solidarity with Palestinians rises, as does risk to activists

It’s been two years since peace activist Seán O’Neill last visited Israel and he’s noticed some fundamental changes to the Israeli left. While solidarity with Palestinians is on the rise, activists are under tighter surveillance of the state

By Seán O’Neill

Israeli activists marching in West Jerusalem toward Sheikh Jarrah, December 2009. (photo: Flickr/lisang)

An Israeli activist friend called me Thursday night with some parting advice as I left for my hostel after getting a beer with him.  I had mentioned that Friday I would head down to the weekly protest at Sheikh Jarrah.

“Be careful,” he said, “it’s getting dangerous out there.”  Then he added a clarifying point: “For people on this side.”  He gestured with his head to the streets of West Jerusalem behind him, lined with bars and cafes.  By “this side” he meant Israelis, and while I’ve never been part of any side, his point was taken.

Two years ago I was denied entry at Ben Gurion airport, putting an abrupt end to my work with Christian Peacemaker Teams in the South Hebron Hills.  For most of 2006  to 2009 I worked on CPT’s project based in the village of At-Tuwani, supporting a nascent, grassroots Palestinian-led movement of nonviolent resistance to continued Israeli occupation and settlement expansion.  Often on Saturdays, anywhere from a handful to several dozen Israeli activists would come to the area to be in solidarity with the Palestinians.  It wasn’t always an easy relationship, but there was a sense on both sides that it was the nucleus of something important.

Back now for the first time since then, that movement seems to have taken some significant steps.  For one thing, I used to be able to recognize the majority of Israeli activists that would turn up to stand with Palestinians at actions or protests.  Friday at Sheikh Jarrah I recognized only one.  Another Israeli activist friend, who I’ll call Eli, contends that the weekly Sheikh Jarrah demonstrations have helped get more Israelis involved.  Showing up at Sheikh Jarrah, after all, is an easier first step than taking to the the hills south of Yatta.

Another change is a sense that the democratic space Israeli activists used to enjoy, in contrast to their Palestinian counterparts, is shrinking.  This is what my friend was referring to the other night when he said it was getting dangerous.

He wasn’t referring to danger from Palestinians, which one still thinking in terms of stale paradigms of a conflict between two peoples might assume, but rather to danger from other Israelis, including the institutions of the state.

His words struck me with a particular resonance because they echoed the sentiments Eli had expressed in a conversation the day before.  Eli is veteran of the anti-occupation left.  He’s no stranger to scrutiny from the Israeli government.  They’ve had a file on him for years. I know, because I saw it during interrogation at the airport when I foolishly listed him as the friend I was coming to visit.  Yet sitting on his back porch on a hilltop town in the Galilee on Wednesday, looking out over the deceptively peaceful Jezreel valley, he said he felt that something fundamental is changing.

“Soon someone’s going to get killed,” he said.  “I mean an Israeli.  Arabs getting killed is normal, people accept that.  But soon they’re going to kill an Israeli, and then we’ll see who the real activists are.”  Eli said he noticed a new level of hatred from the Israeli security forces levelled at Israeli activists.  At one recent demonstration in Beit Ummar a furious soldier called him a nerd and then proceeded to head butt him.  “You’re the guy we used to beat up on the playground in school,” the soldier told him.  This was particularly disturbing to him.  After all, this was a hostility that transcended politics.  This was about a loathing of the different or the weak, the very people a robust democracy is supposed to be able to protect.  Fascism, on the other hand, hates the weak and idolizes the strong.  Fascism is a word that the Israeli left is using more frequently these days, and they don’t mean it as hyperbole.  At the Sheikh Jarrah protest, one Israeli woman donned a shirt that said “Fascism sucks.”  A Israeli man held a sign that said “Jews and Arabs united against fascism.”

Eli’s view was that as Israeli democracy erodes, and as Israeli activists are subject to more of the violence that has traditionally been reserved for Palestinians, a new and ever more meaningful solidarity between the two groups will develop.  The Arab Spring and Israel’s awkward unease with the broader region’s growing democratic movements highlights this evolution, and may well expedite it.  But it didn’t create it.  Palestinians and Israelis having been building a shared struggle at the grassroots level for years while the talking heads of the world have remained confounded at the continued failure of the charade known as “the peace process”.

Furthermore, the sites of this struggle have spread in the last two years and the movement is pushing its way into the consciousness of the average, apolitical citizen.  No longer are demonstrations restricted to villages in the West Bank.  Now they are in Jerusalem and, as of Nakba day, on the borders with Lebanon, Syria and Gaza.  If the front lines were once several service taxis away from the bars of Jaffa street, now they are an easy 10 minute walk.  At the same time, if Israeli ultranationalist extremism and its attendant violence was previously confined to remote settlement outposts or the old city of Hebron, Jerusalem Day on Wednesday brought it to Damascus Gate, just a stone’s throw away, no pun intended, from Western tourists lounging in the Jerusalem Hotel.

There is a palpable sense that a storm is brewing.  Arguably it has been brewing for years but after two years away, it actually feels two years closer.  Perhaps it’s overly audacious to believe that on the other side of the storm lies a shared future, but I can’t help but feel optimistic.  And yet the uneasy question remains of how many lives will be destroyed in the meantime.

Sean O’Neill worked for Christian Peacemaker Teams from 2006-2009 in the South Hebron Hills supporting Palestinian-led nonviolent resistance to Israeli occupation and continued settlement expansion.  He is currently an MA candidate at New York University in Near Eastern Studies and Journalism.  He is in Israel/Palestine this summer researching for his masters’ thesis.

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article

    * Required


    1. Few Israelis nearly killed years ago. The author who was denied entry in the past allowed this time to enter. The state forces repression is inconsistent. If at all, I feel less threatened now than few years ago. Not that they despise us less – just they feel the end to their rule is approaching. Just compare the scenes in Nabi Saleh to these in Bil’in 5 years ago.

      Reply to Comment
    2. Noam

      Interesting, although slightly hysterical.
      My real fear is of a fanatic civilian rightwinger shooting down leftists, ala Baruch Goldstein. Not uniformed police/soldiers. I’ve been to Sheikh Jarrah, and the police brutality there isn’t as bad as things I’ve seen in Austria or Greece. [This is not a defence of the armed forces, just a call for less hysteria in the just struggle against fascism).

      Counting the recent infiltration events of the northern border as another aspect of the grassroots struggle between Israelis and Palestinians, however, is ridiculous.

      Reply to Comment
    3. Rann B

      The idea of shared struggle is also somewhat ridiculous in itself. I’m Israeli. I can come and go as I please in the West Bank (though, horror of horrors, I sometimes have to walk up a hill around a checkpoint). Palestinians can’t leave. Before we can be useful solidarity activists, we have to acknowledge a few things:

      1. We are not needed. We are useful, and sometimes our privilege saves lives, but we are not needed.

      2. ‘ “Soon someone’s going to get killed,” he said. “I mean an Israeli. Arabs getting killed is normal, people accept that. But soon they’re going to kill an Israeli, and then we’ll see who the real activists are.” ‘

      So what? So an Israeli gets killed. We will cry and we will mourn. Perhaps (if we’re honest with ourselves) we will cry and mourn more than we do when a Palestinian is murdered by Israeli forces. But we are not different. White people get killed too. It’s what happens when we face armies. Non-violent or not, we are soldiers and we take risks.

      3. We do not share this struggle. We are guests in it. For an Irishman even more than an Israeli, the romantic notion of joint struggle is absurd. This is a Palestinian struggle. Solidarity does not mean sharing, because very few of us have the guts to relaly really live in the West Bank or Gaza long-term. It means listening and learning.

      4. Just about everyone on the left throws around the word ‘fascist’ without thinking. It’s boring and adds nothing to the debate. Is Israel becoming more fascist? Probably, but shouting it from the rooftops is not really very useful to anyone.

      5. Lastly, Sheikh Jarrah is not dangerous. Tripoli is dangerous. Deraa is dangerous. Get some perspective.


      Reply to Comment
    4. max

      Rann, I’m afraid it may not be taken as a compliment, but yours are wise words I can identify with.
      Sheikh Jarrah: I’m in favor of demonstration as a democratic act. But refusing to accept a supreme court decision is an anti-democratic act.

      Reply to Comment
    5. Ben Israel

      I love it when people like Sean or Rachel Corrie call themselves “peacemakers”. Really Orwellian. Throwing Jews out of their homes in the Hevron hills where Jews have lived for millenia is “peace making”. Throwing Jews out of neighborhoods where they lived for decades before Arab ethnic cleansing threw them out in 1948 and to which they returned is “peacemaking”. Rachel Corrie burning an American flag with a deranged look on her face in front of a group of incited Arab kids is “peacemaking”.
      Eli the “peacemaker” is upset that a policeman called him a “nerd” and head butt him. Well, if Eli wants to see REAL Israeli police violence he should watch this film in which policemen beat boys and girls heads in with truncheons when they are passively sitting in a house slated for demolition (it is against the law for police to beat people in the head with truncheons). The police called the young religious girls “whores” for good measure. The police would never DARE do this to the Left…


      Reply to Comment
    6. Rann B

      Ben Israel: I have no issue with Jews living in Hebron if they come there (or return there) as equals to live in peace. The current settlers (read: colonizers, not due to the place they’ve chosen to live in, but rather due to their actions) are anything but. Equally, I fully support the right of return of Palestinian refugees and their descendants to Jaffa, Haifa and so on. Again, under the same conditions, which I believe are possible, though we are very far from that today.

      As for police and their treatment of leftists vs their behavior during outpost evacuations: sure, police are an institution of violence. I’ve seen border police shoot ‘rubber’ bullets into someone’s brain in Bil’in, someone who was a lawyer and can now barely read, and is about the most peaceful guy I’ve ever met. I’ve seen beatings you wouldn’t wish on your worse enemy. Police are charged with getting the state’s dirty work done, and they carry it out with brutality every time.

      Reply to Comment
    7. exhausted

      Rann B, the one thing I have really found unuseful and distasteful since I began my journey towards justice and peace is fellow travelers who feel the need to lecture the rest of us from a humbler/more radical-than-thou attitude. I find the four points in your post both not at all helpful and also reflecting a less than complete comprehension of what the author of the article was saying.

      Reply to Comment