+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

Settler violence on the rise as olive harvest begins in West Bank

Since the beginning of the olive harvest two weeks ago, Israeli human rights organizations have documented 10 cases of settler violence and theft against Palestinians and their property. For now, it seems like the police are doing their job.

Palestinian farmers from the West Bank village of Qaryut assess the damage done to their olive trees the day before by Israeli settlers, October 20, 2013. Officials from the Palestinian Ministry of Agriculture on the scene counted 60 trees damaged belonging to 12 different farmers. (photo: Ryan Rodrick Beiler/Activestills.org)

Palestinian farmers from the West Bank village of Qaryut assess the damage done to their olive trees the day before by Israeli settlers, October 20, 2013. Officials from the Palestinian Ministry of Agriculture on the scene counted 60 trees damaged belonging to 12 different farmers. (photo: Ryan Rodrick Beiler/Activestills.org)

The olive harvest season, which began two weeks ago across Israel-Palestine, is one of the most heated seasons in the year for Palestinians in the occupied territories, especially for those living in Area C, under complete Israeli military control.

Nearly every plot of Palestinian land designated for farming in the West Bank is located in this area, yet 60 percent of that very land now belongs to settlement local and regional councils. Israel’s multifarious practices of dispossession, from land expropriations to declaring whole swaths of private property closed military zones, have restricted Palestinian access to their agricultural land. In many places, they are allowed access only during seasons when they plow the land, or during the olive harvest. The success of the harvest has a direct effect on their livelihood. Often times, land that has been abandoned by Palestinians due to settler violence is later taken over by those very same settlers.

Every year at this time, like clockwork, Israeli settlers head out to Palestinian olive groves to sow destruction and violence. Since 2005, Israeli anti-occupation NGO Yesh Din has documented around 280 police cases relating to attacks on olive trees. According to the organization, only six of those cases ended in indictments. Over 93 percent of them were closed due to police failure to find the criminals or to gather the proper evidence to put the suspects on trial. Often times, the army simply “takes care” of conflagrations between settlers and Palestinians by preventing the Palestinians from accessing their agricultural land, a practice that has been roundly criticized by Israel’s High Court of Justice.

Thus, reports over the past few weeks of cases in which Israeli security forces actually caught settlers as they were harassing Palestinian farmers are surprising in just how out of the ordinary they are. Under normal circumstances, a news report on police catching criminals in the act as they attack innocent people would be a case of dog bites man. In the reality of occupation, this is clearly a case of man bites dog.

Last Sunday, for instance, settlers were caught stealing olives from a Palestinian grove adjacent the village of Al-Jinya, not far from the settlement outpost of Zait Ra’anan. Zacharia Sada, who coordinates Israeli NGO Rabbis for Human Rights’ field workers, witnessed the incident and directed the security forces to the area where they caught the suspects.

That same day, Palestinians from the village of Qaryut near the outpost of Habayit Haadom, were also attacked. In this case, too, security forces arrived on the scene apprehended the attackers. On Monday, security forces detained a resident of the settlement Eli — who Palestinians claim has repeatedly harassed them — after he was reportedly caught stealing olives from Qaryut’s olive trees. Later in the week, police detained two Israelis who were harvesting Palestinian olives in the village of Burin.

Israelis harvest olive trees belonging to Palestinian famers from the village of Al-Janiya, adjacent to the settler outpost of Zait Ra'anan, West Bank. (Yesh Din)

Israelis harvest olive trees belonging to Palestinian famers from the village of Al-Janiya, adjacent to the settler outpost of Zait Ra’anan, West Bank. (Yesh Din)

Violent settlers are seldom caught by law enforcement or the army. Since the beginning of the olive harvest season two weeks ago, Yesh Din has documented 10 cases of violence against Palestinians or their property — including the theft of olives and the destruction of trees — across the West Bank.

On October 16, a resident of the village A-Sawaya, near the settlement of Rechalim, reported that anonymous persons harvested and vandalized 14 of his olive trees. The area in question is next to an IDF security corridor, which forces the owner of the property to coordinate with the army every time he wants to access the land.

According to Yesh Din, Israeli citizens attacked a group of Palestinian harvesters last Saturday in Beit Furik. Palestinians say police arrived on the scene and apprehended one of the attackers. In another case that same day, Israelis tried to prevent Palestinian famers in the village Huwarra from harvesting their trees. They fled when they noticed security forces approaching.

On October 13th, farmers from the village of Jalud complained that anonymous persons had stolen olives from approximately 300 trees on land that can only be accessed by coordinating with the IDF. On that same day, Israelis were seen harvesting olive trees on land belonging to the village of Awarta.

According to Rabbis for Human Rights, the fact that the security forces were able to detain Israelis as they attacked and stole from Palestinians in the West Bank is remarkable. “This behavior teaches us that when there is a will, here is a way for security forces to do their job. Unfortunately, it is especially rare, and many crimes against Palestinian farmers do not receive the proper attention from security forces or law enforcement.”

Yesh Din issued the following response to the events of the past two weeks:

The livelihood of many Palestinians depends on the olive harvest, and thus law enforcement must ensure the ability of Palestinian farmers to reach their land and harvest their trees. As in every year, before the beginning of the olive harvest, we warned the authorities about the growing concern over violence against Palestinians across the West Bank, especially in more dangerous areas. We expect the police and the army to take decisive action against criminals who harm the Palestinian harvesters and their livelihood, to prevent as much dispossession and violence as possible, and to put the criminals on trial. This is the only way to send a message that the Palestinian wellbeing of Palestinians and their property are not being abandoned by the state.”

This post was first published in Hebrew on Local Call. Read it here.

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article

    * Required


    1. Itshak Gordin Halevy

      I condemn violence. But a Jew cannot be a settler in Eretz Israel. Does 972 mag condemn the Arab terrorism against Jews? Of course no. Double standard.

      Reply to Comment
      • Bruce Gould

        @Itshak: 972 isn’t a human rights organziation, it’s a news source about human rights. Btselem, on the other hand, IS a human rights group, and it DOES condemn violence against Israelis by Palestinians:


        “Over the years, mainly during the second intifada, Palestinian organizations killed hundreds of Israeli civilians and wounded thousands in attacks that deliberately targeted civilians in Israel and in the occupied territories. B’Tselem strongly objects to attempts to justify these attacks through distorted interpretations of international law. Civilians must be shielded from all hostilities. Attacks against civilians undermine every moral, legal and human standard. The intentional targeting of civilians, under any circumstances whatsoever, is defined as a war crime.”


        Reply to Comment
        • Itshak Gordin Halevy

          Not really: Do you have some links redirecting to articles published on 972 mag about Arab attacks against Jews?

          Reply to Comment
      • Ben

        You don’t condemn violence for one second, Halevy. You applaud it. The occupation, its land theft, its dispossession, its daily brutality against civilians by its occupying army and its settlers is violence. State sponsored violence on a massive scale. And a form of terrorism. You are trying to normalize this. The double standard is yours. +972 Magazine does condemn terror on both sides. It is you who don’t. “But a Jew cannot be a settler in Eretz Israel.” This is pure blood and soil nationalism. Extremism. Jews have a special right to it? Why?

        Reply to Comment
        • Itshak Gordin Halevy

          I never saw any condemnation by 972, never. They have adopted the position of the enemies of the Jewish State. The Judea and Samaria are parts of Eretz Israel. Some parts of them are occupied by Arabs till now. A Jew who lives there is a proud citizen of Israel and not a settler. Foreigners can live in peace in Eretz Israel if they respect the laws and our sovereignty. I do not know whether you are a Jew, Ben. If you are you really have self hatred. Do you live in Israel?

          Reply to Comment
          • Ben

            This is like having a conversation with a Scientologist true believer about whether L. Ron Hubbard was a crackpot or not and whether his inheritor David Miscavage is a sociopath or not, and whether Scientology helps or hurts people and whether Scientology preys on the mentally ill or not, and whether Scientology is a form of organized crime masquerading as a religion or not. And whether Tom Cruise is right when with that zealot’s narcissistic glaze in his eyes he tells Scientologists that “it’s a privilege…our time is now…only we can help humanity….”* In that conversation no headway will be made persuading the other side by either person. And please note, I am not comparing the detestable Scientology to Judaism. Not at all, not even a little bit. I am comparing the mindset of these people to the mindset of certain persons on this planet who engage in certain forms of what I think are the *misuse* of Judaism.
            *Tom Cruise Scientology Video – ( Original UNCUT )

            Reply to Comment
    2. Timothy Porter

      “Settler violence…” Sounds scary, right? What’s the death toll? Hmmm… About… none? Articles like this are a systematic attempt to dehumanize an entire group of people. This is politics at its worst!

      Reply to Comment
      • Ben

        An interesting new twist on excusing the occupation. With an extra dollop of contempt. The death toll from slavery, in the Southern United States once upon a time, at the hands of the inhabitants of those antebellum plantation mansions was about none too–but the death toll from the overseers and bounty hunters and enforcers who worked for them was significantly higher than that. The equivalent of those overseers and bounty hunters and enforcers today is the Israeli army and the Israeli border police, and the Palestinian death toll at their hands is way higher than none. Of course, using “the death toll” as a measure of violence is by itself a sign that you are treating people like animals–such a measure is how cattle ranchers and game wardens and fisheries experts assess their practices. A telling example of the underlying attitudes of the Israeli overseers.

        Reply to Comment
        • Timothy Porter

          Your comparison of Israelis to southern slave holders borders on insanity. If you look at things objectively (not that I would expect you to), the Arabs benefited from Israel’s existence despite their belligerence. And… there is no occupation! https://972mag.com/how-netanyahu-rewrote-israeli-history-with-one-viral-video/122378/#comment_form_wrap

          I suggest you stop using the “occupation” as an explanation for anything given what’s going on in the region and the rest of the world.

          Reply to Comment
          • Ben

            Not a serious response.

            Reply to Comment
          • Timothy Porter

            What a cop-out.

            Reply to Comment