+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

Sending the Palestinians to bed without dinner

By withholding the PA’s tax revenues, the Israeli government is effectively stealing Palestinian money. So why won’t the international community call it that?

Palestinian policemen block protesters during a demonstration against the visit of US President Barak Obama to the West Bank, Ramallah, March 21, 2013. (photo: Keren Manor/Activestills.org)

Palestinian policemen block protesters during a demonstration against the visit of US President Barak Obama to the West Bank, Ramallah, March 21, 2013. (photo: Keren Manor/Activestills.org)

At the end of last year the Israeli government announced that it would stop transferring Palestinian tax revenue to the Palestinian Authority. The move was explained, explicitly, as a punitive measure for the Palestinian ascension to the International Criminal Court. Conveniently, it also happened to take place at the start of Israel’s fast-paced election season.

The funds in question are tariffs and customs fees that Israel collects on behalf of the Palestinians, which the Palestinian Authority cannot collect for itself, since Israel won’t allow it to control any sea or air port. The goods that are being taxed merely pass through Israel. According to the Paris Protocols, the economic section of the Oslo Accords, the tax money is Palestinian; Israel is just a middle man.

So when Israel refuses to transfer the Palestinian tax revenue, it is stealing. Except nobody calls it that, for two reasons. The first reason is that Israel is not a rogue state in the eyes of most of the world, and states don’t really steal — they have disputes, or they occupy, or nationalize or appropriate.

The second reason is that everyone involved — the Israelis, the Palestinians and the international community — knows that Israel will eventually give the money back. Every year or two, the Israeli government decides to withhold the tax funds, usually in response to some policy decision that doesn’t strike its fancy. It waits a few months until the international pressure grows — and the Palestinian Authority inches toward collapse — before giving it back.

So what does withholding the tax funds accomplish? Firstly, it means that hundreds of thousands of Palestinians lose part of their income. The first thing that the Palestinian Authority slashes when it starts to run out of money is salaries — the salaries of 180,000 civil servants, each of whom supports a family.

PHOTOS: Israel cuts off Palestinian power twice in one week

Withholding tax funds, or holding up the monthly income of hundreds of thousands of Palestinian families, is Israel’s way sending the Palestinian Authority to bed without dinner. The Israeli government is saying: your behavior is not acceptable, and although we are not going to do anything too dramatic, we want you to hurt for a little bit.

The Palestinian Authority relies on Israel for everything: its imports and exports, the very taxes it collects, the freedom of movement of everyone from a sheep herder in the south Hebron Hills to Mahmoud Abbas himself (let’s not forget the siege on Yasser Arafat in the Muqata’a), and the weapons with which it polices on Israel’s behalf. And the PA serves Israel’s interests, making its occupation easier by administering West Bank cities, arresting militants who threaten Israel, and even by levying high value added taxes on its citizens in order to avoid creating too much competition for in Israel’s very own captive market.

If the idea of two parties with such a skewed power dynamic negotiating with each other didn’t seem absurd in 1993, it certainly should 22 years later. Joining the ICC was one of a number of ways that the PA has been attempting to change that.

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article
  • LEAVE A COMMENT

    * Required

    COMMENTS

    1. Bruce Gould

      As the piece shows, Israel controls everything, everything, everything – water, money, power, imports, exports, who enters and who gets to travel, building permits, communications, taxes..and it arrests whoever it likes, whenever it likes, decides when a trial is neccessary and when it isn’t, and so on. And as dozens of human rights groups have observed, they aren’t particularly benign about it.

      “Israel sprays Gaza farms with poisonous gases”:

      https://www.middleeastmonitor.com/news/middle-east/18151-israel-sprays-gaza-farms-with-poisonous-gases-again

      Reply to Comment
      • Bryan

        The wonders of Israeli technology and science – to be able to make the sesert bloom and the oasis unbloom.

        Reply to Comment
    2. Bockke

      Amd when, at long last, will the Europeans and the Americans send their ultra-spoiled child, Israel, to bed without dinner just once in its life? Hell, when will they even once send it to bed without dessert? Why are the guilt-ridden parents (guilt-ridden on account of what their own grandparents did in a time past) so afraid of the brat’s temper tantrums? Why do they still let it be an uncontrolled bully? Well, in part because unlike real families this child controls the parents’ purse strings to a strange extent and interferes in the parents’ political married life in pathological ways. The child has a bully pal named “lobby” that intrudes on family life. And “lobby” is pals with “bibi”…. It’s quite a situation.

      Reply to Comment
      • Bryan

        Absolutely right Bockke: there are so many things that caring parents could do if the child continues to misbehave and throw tantrums – take away the pocket-money (the $3,000,000,000+ per annum contributions from the US), stop subsidizing their hobbies (deny charitable status to organisations that advance settlement activities), ground them (stop providing a veto at the UN Security Council and diplomatic support at international forums), shame them (tell their friends the truth about their persistent misbeviour e.g. USS Liberty and WMD activities), stop providing them with holiday treats (e.g. bar Netanyahu next time he demands to visit uninvited), take away their toys (refuse to give them weapons that are only going to be used to infringe human rights). Seldom does a spoiled and delinquent child fail to respond to such consistent and caring parental discipline, but if mum is too cowed by the cuckoo in the nest, and afraid that the child will respond by bullying her, then surely it is up to neighbours and friends to provide tough-love, and start seriously applying BDS. And also the teachers have a role to play: if the headmaster (the Supreme Court) changed the class-room rules (passing a Constitutional Amendment to severely limit and control political donations and bribes) then the scope for continued bullying would be much reduced. But perhaps the reason this does not happen is that parents, family, neighbours, friends and teachers alike are all terrified that the confronted brat will respond with allegations that “You are all pedophiles”.

        Reply to Comment