+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

Photo essay: Refugees uprooted again in bid to expel foreigners

Text by: Rami Gudovitch
All photos by: Activestills.org

South Sudanese refugees board a bus taking them to Ben Gurion airport, where they will be deported to South Sudan. Arad, Israel, June 17, 2012. (Photo: Yotam Ronen/Activestills.org)

“Do you know, Rami, that I was in ‘Mustafa Mahmoud?’” Regina, a 12-year-old South Sudanese girl, asked me after she and her family were released from 27 days in an Israeli prison. Her father, a tall man with noticeable facial scars from the torture he underwent in Khartoum, affirms her words, handing me an old newspaper clipping from Egypt, dated 2005. I cannot read Arabic, but I can see her mother, laying on the ground, surrounded by police officers in one photo, and the little body of a child covered by a white sheet in another. “This was my cousin. He was killed by the police there,” adds Regina.

“Mustafa Mahmoud” refers to a massacre committed by the Cairo police during a peaceful demonstration by South Sudanese refugees near the UNHCR offices. The massacre sparked the first wave of African refugees fleeing to Israel, crossing the Sinai desert and reaching the promised land.

For many of the members of the community, the years in Israel were the only calm years in their lives. For many of the children, these years were happy childhood years, spent living in multicultural neighborhoods, going to schools, learning a new language, meeting school teachers and staff who care for the well-being of any child regardless of gender, color, or nationality.

A representative of the Authority of Population and Immigration checks South Sudanese people boarding a bus for Ben-Gurion Airport. The refugees were gathered in a raid conducted by Oz Unit. Arad, Israel, June 17, 2012. (Photo: Yotam Ronen/Activestills.org)

South Sudanese children board a bus taking them to Ben-Gurion Airport for deportation. Tel-Aviv, Israel, June 17, 2012. (Photo: Oren Ziv/Activestills.org)

In recent years, I found myself lucky enough to be part of a small multicultural community in south Tel Aviv, and some of my closest friends were members of the small South Sudanese community. I heard so many life stories that reminded me of tales often told to me as a child by old family members, who escaped Europe in the 30s—now told by children who fled to gain peaceful years in a country where they were beginning to feel at home in. Now, this little universe has been destroyed.

The government’s deportation order, following the referendum in South Sudan that led to the independence of the country, caught us all unprepared. It is not that the South Sudanese did not wish to return to their country. In fact, at the peak in 2009, there were around 1,900 members of community residing in Israel. By in July 2011, when the county’s independence was declared, only some 900 members remained in Israel. Most of the single young men returned to South Sudan, wishing to help build the new country.

The ones who remained in Israel were mostly families with children. News from South Sudan portrayed a harsh picture of a land unprepared to offer a future for children or for other weak groups in society. It has the highest mortality rate for newborn babies and nursing mothers in the world. A girl of 14 has a higher probability of dying while giving birth than of attending school. One million people suffer from food shortages, and the World Food Organization has warned that the country will continue to suffer major disasters in coming years.

A South Sudanese child in his home fills a bottle of water on the morning of his deportation. Tel Aviv, Israel, June 17, 2012. (Photo: Oren Ziv/Activestills.org)


South Sudanese refugees receive travel documents at Ben-Gurion Airport, Israel, June 17, 2012. (Photo: Oren Ziv/Activestills.org)

With this dreadful reality in mind, we—a small group of representatives from different human rights organizations—opened a public campaign against the deportation to South Sudan. We were successful in getting the facts to the media, and for awhile we were convinced that we could stop it. But after attorney Anat Ben-Dor’s appeal to the district court against the deportation order was rejected, nothing could stop it besides the good will of the government. And that was the last thing we could expect.

Indeed, the deportation order went into effect. On the very next day, after a public statement by Interior Minister Eli Yishai requiring all South Sudanese to register for a “voluntary return” within a week, the Oz Unit of immigration officers began arresting South Sudanese in the streets of major cities in Israel.

For us, the Israeli friends, teachers, and neighbors of the community, these days are beyond comprehension. The streets are being emptied out, racist Israelis commit daily attacks against refugees, more and more of our beloved friends are sent to a country with very low chances of survival.

Walking down the streets of the neighborhood these days I can see only voids—circles of missing people, people who were sent like animals, hunted by immigration police, forced to sign that they “want to leave” or else, then detained and pushed out.

South Sudanese refugees board a bus in Tel Aviv’s Central Bus Station taking them to Ben-Gurion Airport, Israel, June 25, 2012. (Photo: Oren Ziv/Activestills.org)

South Sudanese refugees at Ben-Gurion Airport, Israel, June 25, 2012. (Photo: Yotam Ronen/Activestills.org)

Israeli activists support South Sudanese during the second deportation, Tel Aviv, Israel, June 25, 2012. (Photo: Oren Ziv/Activestills.org)

South Sudanese children board a bus for Ben Gurion Airport, Tel Aviv, Israel, July 2, 2012. (Photo: Oren Ziv/Activestills.Org)

South Sudanese women board a bus for Ben Gurion Airport, Tel Aviv, Israel, July 11, 2012. (Photo: Oren Ziv/Activestills.org)

In recent few weeks, I have experienced some of the most horrifying moments of my life. Among the refugees arrested was Regina’s family. Upon their release, while waiting for their deportation, Regina’s 7-year-old sister Mer described to me how “the guards were at first good, at least some of them. But as we asked more questions and they lacked answers, they become more and more evil.”

Local activists protest against the deportation and attempt to disrupt the departure of the bus, arguing that conditions in South Sudan are not safe enough for the refugees to be returned there. Tel Aviv, Israel, July 25, 2012. (Photo: JC/Activestills.org)

After failing at all fronts to stop the deportation, what we are left with are the voices of the recent deportees in South Sudan. Presently, dozens of children and adults from among the deportees suffer from malaria. Dozens of others suffer from typhoid. Many have been robbed—the property they gathered in Israel did not arrive. Many children are hungry, and every week we send, with the new deportees, pita bread, chocolate, and cereal to the families and children, at their request. The returnees have no water or electricity in their huts. The money they collected or received when they were deported is running out. There are no jobs, and schools are extremely expensive. In general, many just don’t see any future opportunities ahead of them.

The question many of us are left with is why did they—or rather we—have to do it? I witness the brutal pressure Israel is presently putting on the few families that still remain, mostly for serious humanitarian, medical or social needs involving many life threatening conditions. To me it seems like the State of Israel decided to carry out an ethnic cleansing campaign. Like a Passover house-cleaning, they decided not to allow a single South Sudanese to remain. The associations that this act brings to mind are dreadful. But that is the only explanation I can find for the systematic and obsessive persecution—carried out in seven well-planned deportations—of the South Sudanese community.

A woman holds a solidarity sign in Hebrew that reads: “The people demand to stop the deportations,” at the seventh deportation to South Sudan. Tel-Aviv, Israel, August 8, 2012. (Photo: Shiraz Grinbaum/Activestills.org)

A representative of the Authority of Population and Immigration checks the names of South Sudanese people that are being deported. Tel-Aviv, Israel, August 8, 2012. (Photo: Shiraz Grinbaum/Activestills.org)

woman trys to calm her child during the seventh deportation to South Sudan at Tel Aviv’s Central Bus Station, Israel, August 8, 2012. (Photo: Shiraz Grinbaum/Activestills.org)

A South Sudanese girl holds a sign she wrote in Hebrew to her classmates, who came to say goodbye. The note reads: “Axsosa you are my best friend in school.” Tel-Aviv, Israel, August 8, 2012. (Photo: Shiraz Grinbaum/Activestills.org)

And if this is accurate, then I deeply feel that the people involved, actively, or by simply closing their eyes, will be punished. In fact, they are already being punished by not being able to look in the mirror and see a human figure. I cannot imagine a worse punishment than that.

Rami Gudovitch, an Israeli activist, says goodbye to a child who was under his care in recent years. Tel-Aviv, Israel, August 8, 2012. (Photo: Shiraz Grinbaum/Activestills.org)


Dr. Rami Gudovitch is a social activist working with migrant communities in southern Tel Aviv and a philosophy instructor at the Interdisciplinary Center, Herzliya.

Activestills is a collective of Israeli, international and Palestinian photographers, united by a conviction that photography is a vehicle for political and social change. To stay updated on our latest images, like Activestills on Facebook  or follow @activestills on Twitter. You can also visit our flickr photostream.

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article

    * Required


    1. Bluegrass Picker of Afula

      Is it acceptable to you, Rami, that there would be a one-for-one package deal: one undocumented Sudanese family will be given papers to stay in Israel, for each undocumented settler-family on the other side of the Green Line being allowed to document THEIR legal status in THEIR new home? PS: Juba is not a war zone. I plan to visit there and establish Hebrew Charter schools just like the ones in San Diego & Brooklyn. If there can be several English-speaking countries, and several Francophone countries…. the same with Hebrew. I believe that middle-class African parents WOULD pay the tuition fees, just as Karachi & Islamabad parents gladly pay big time to send their kids into convent-operated schools.

      Reply to Comment
    2. Philos

      Their legal status in their new home is: settler, illegal settler, colonialist, land thief, you know the usual legal status’ appropriated to people either settled in a land that is not their own by their government or who stole land from an indigenous people while their government turned a blind eye. You can ask the South Sudanese what it’s like to live under military occupation when you go visit Juba.

      Reply to Comment
    3. Kolumn9

      Bon Voyage! Some of your friends are travelling back to their home country. This is certainly sad for you, but on the bright side your friends are going to be back in a society where they feel at home, speaking their own language and working to improve their own country. When you go to visit them make sure to take some pictures to post here.

      The answer to your question as to why they had to do it was that the country was being overrun by illegal migrants from 3rd world countries. They couldn’t deport the Eritreans or Sudanese, so they had to deport the South Sudanese. The purpose of this was political populism and the more harsh the expulsion looked the better it played for the politicians. It is sad that they deported the South Sudanese who are or were real refugees from a friendly country and who have been in Israel the longest periods of time. You can blame obtuse NGOs that use completely unreasonable interpretations of international humanitarian law for preventing the Israeli government to expel the Eritrean economic migrants who make up 60% of the illegals. Are you going to? Probably not. You’d rather live in a fantasy world where there is space in Israel for any and all third world illegal migrants to come in and live.

      Reply to Comment
      • David

        SPACE?!!! There is hardly 2 square millimetres to rub together, and the want to half it by 2 to give to murderers and 9/11 planners!

        Reply to Comment
    4. Laman

      We have our own homeland and the Africans have their own. We do not need any more primitive savages in Eretz Israel.

      Reply to Comment
    5. Carl

      I can’t work out if the article or the comments are more depressing.
      Laman, you’re dead right. But not in the way you intended.

      Reply to Comment
    6. Glenn

      Certainly few people care about these people, least of all the Israeli government and it’s people. Silence on an issue is tantamount to loud support, and the Israelis have shown themselves to be a typical Eurocentric colonialist nation using religion as a motive for unspeakable crimes against humanity. Crimes once reserved for people with names like Hitler, and countries like the US and South Africa.

      Reply to Comment
    7. Y-Man

      @ Bluegrass Picker of Afula: You just compared Juba in motherfucking SOUTH SUDAN with San Diego and Brooklyn!?!?!? You seem like a really well-grounded, totally sincere individual. Well, good luck with establishing a Hebrew charter school there. Watch out for land mines! And it will be ironic when you duck and cover from al-Bashir’s bombs– usually you Israelis are the ones making the other schmucks do that!

      Reply to Comment
    8. Popov

      Comment deleted and user banned

      Reply to Comment
    9. I wont blame israel for their actions; i’ll rather blame african leaders for their inhuman and egocentric ways of leadership that has rendered their subjects to abject poverty and constant fighting every now and then. Now the bitter truth is that even the south sudanese people also got a place to call home. So, LETS BE CONTENTED WITH WHAT WE HAVE, LIVE IN PEACE AND BUILD OUR HOMES. God bless africa

      Reply to Comment
    10. s maloney

      Dr Gudovitch

      “And if this is accurate, then I deeply feel that the people involved, actively, or by simply closing their eyes, will be punished. In fact, they are already being punished by not being able to look in the mirror and see a human figure. I cannot imagine a worse punishment than that.”

      You seem to imagine the “people involved” see what you imagine they ought to see because you believe them to be, at least in the policies they initiate and support, “inhuman”.
      In fact “history shows”… or rather, could you supply your readers with a list of such policy intiators, criminals, and enemies of humanity, who have ever shown “pangs” of conscience or hopefully more serious discomfort? Or taken the consequent remedial action?

      I doubt if you can…(cf Napoleon – pshaw.. Paris makes that many soldiers in a single night!) etc.

      In reality I would suggest such moral vacuums on legs do not experience discomfort of any kind but rather, over their miserable careers on this unfortunate planet, just seek larger and larger canvasses for their ever greater displays of inhumanity – to impress their co-inhmanitarians who make up a completely unsecret, brazen, and boastful international and competitive “community” since the … late renaissance or or late 19th century (say).

      It sounds nice to say “I cannot imagine a worse punishment than that”, so they end castigated with their own petards, as it were… but no the question is not their punishment, but disempowerment is needed before they become more ambitious… for example one method – albeit an extreme on for our enlightened and luxurious days – was practiced in Russia during the German occupation, the honey trap which involve smuggling a land mine into a “lover’s” bed – instead of hot water bottle.

      In short, moral self-censure – is not enough, and there are are good reasons not to get locked into such new-agey tripey and sobby peace/love “remedies”. Unless, that is, you can provide your readers with a list of such self-punishing “corrupt on earthers”to show the efficacy of moral self censure in history.

      Reply to Comment

The stories that matter.
The missing context.
All in one weekly email.

Subscribe to +972's newsletter