+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

Photo essay: The symmetry of an asymmetrical conflict

2011 is drawing to a close and it has been a year full of expectation and suspense regarding the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. I admit that I thought it was a year in which significant things might change. But after a weekend trip to some of the hottest spots in the hot spot, I reflected that a few things may always remain stable. Both sides have dreams that will probably not be fulfilled. Both sides have elements – people – who seek a maximalist position. The dreams of those extremes are ultimately likely to be foiled by reality.

Despite the asymmetry of power in this conflict, those basic dynamics of maximal demands and the limitations of reality are common to both sides. Here is a short visual rendition from early December, 2011.

Maps

This map appears as part of a small glossy booklet called “Israel’s Story in Maps,” prepared by the Council of Judea and Samaria (Yesha Council).

Yesha map 122011 (Provided by Council of Judea and Samaria - Yesha)

Walking through Al Manara Square in Ramallah, this pretty, framed piece of embroidery was displayed for sale in a shop window:

Map in Ramallah 3 December 2011 (Photo: Dahlia Scheindlin)

In the idyllic version of both sides, the land between the Jordan River and the sea belongs to one sovereign: theirs.

Two States

I actually thought that 2011 was the year that might lay the foundation for the final acceptance of the Palestinian state, a relatively key factor in a two-state solution. When it became obvious over the course of the last two years that negotiations were a profound failure, the Palestinian Authority undertook a unilateral strategy of requesting that the United Nations grant statehood. After all, there are UN Resolutions recognizing the Palestinian right to self-determination, Israel itself has of course already accepted the notion of a Palestinian state, and of late, it’s hard to find anyone who denies that failure to reach a two-state solution will lead to one state – or already has. Even Jeffrey Goldberg and Peter Beinart say so.

And yet after all the anticipation of September,all that seemed to remain of the excitement in the center of Ramallah was an empty chair.

Palestine chair, Ramallah, 3 December, 2011 (Photo: Dahlia Scheindlin)

As a result, I wasn’t sure whether to be sad or amused by finding the one place, perhaps, where Palestinian sovereignty reigns undisputed:

Flag food, Ramallah 3 December, 2011 (Photo: Dahlia Scheindlin)

Jerusalem

The vision held by Palestinians that Jerusalem is integral to – indeed, the capital of – their state remains clear:

Downtown Ramallah, 3 December 2011 (Photo: Dahlia Scheindlin)

But this, of course, is Palestinian reality in Jerusalem today:

Separation wall, Abu Dis, Jerusalem, 3 December, 2011 (Photo: Dahlia Scheindlin)

Abu Dis graffiti on separation wall, 3 December, 2011 (Photo: Dahlia Scheindlin)


Maximalist Dreams

There’s no denying that both sides have them. Full right of return is a dream for many Palestinians, evidenced by the prominent placement of this sign right outside the Muqata (the seat of the Palestinian Authority government and the burial place of Yassir Arafat).

Refugee letter sign, Ramallah 3 December 2011 (Photo: Dahlia Scheindlin)

Some Israelis, of course, have dreams too. A tip for early 2012 – keep your eyes on Migron, an illegal West Bank outpost on the wrong end of an Israeli Supreme Court ruling that is slated for evacuation in March. Avigdor Lieberman’s Israel Beitenu party has already threatened to topple the government if Migron, and nearby Givat Assaf, are dismantled.

Migron, 4 December 2011. Sign reads: "We have not taken the land of the gentiles, nor do we rule over gentile property, rather, this is the path of our forefathers" (Photo: Dahlia Scheindlin)

Itai Harel, one of the founders of Migron, comes from aristocratic settler lineage – his father is Israel Harel, a former head of Yesha (the Council of Judea and Samaria) and a major voice of the settler community. His son Itai is passionate and undeterred.

Itai Harel, 4 Decmeber, 2011 (Photo: Dahlia Scheindlin)

Itai Harel, 4 Decmeber, 2011 (Photo: Dahlia Scheindlin)

With such powerful political backing, it doesn’t look like Migron will go gentle at all.

**********

All this makes 2012 a hard year to predict. But it doesn’t seem likely that mutually exclusive demands among certain groups in these conflicting parties are likely to go away.  The only question left is what kind of reality will emerge to keep them in check.

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article
  • LEAVE A COMMENT

    * Required

    COMMENTS

    1. directrob

      “the Palestinian Authority undertook a unilateral strategy of requesting that the United Nations grant statehood”
      .
      I think the words “undertook a unilateral strategy” are misplaced here. You would never write “Israel undertook the unilateral strategy of requesting the security council …” If you are asking the UN (=all countries) how can it be unilateral.

      Reply to Comment
    2. Sinjim

      Who knew a piece of artwork by a private citizen is “symmetrical” to a published propaganda booklet by an official organization of the Israeli occupation apparatus? Who knew that to create an embroidery showing historic Palestine without any imposed borders is claiming exclusive right to it?
      .
      Who knew that a short note expressing the Palestinian people’s hope to rectify our greatest sorrow is “symmetrical” to the ongoing theft and dispossession at the hands of the state of Israel? Who knew that there was symmetry between your country’s settlements and a sign?
      .
      Symmetry, Dahlia. You keep using that word. I don’t think it means what you think it means.

      Reply to Comment
    3. directrob

      @Sinjim,
      To be fair, the article is called “The symmetry of an asymmetrical” conflict, but the word symmetry does not occur in the article.

      Reply to Comment
    4. gill

      West Bank, as far as I know – is “No Man’s Land” and until the 2 parties – Israel and West Bank leaders – sit down and sort out a peace plan – it remains disputed land. Correct me if I am wrong. Thank you

      Reply to Comment