+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

Palestinians in Gaza are reminding us that they exist

Reality is stronger than any propaganda campaign. It will ultimately break through and penetrate public awareness.

By Hagai El-Ad

Palestinian protesters gather near the border fence during the second week of the Great Return March, east of Jabaliya, April 6, 2018. (Mohammed Zaanoun/Activestills.org)

Palestinian protesters gather near the border fence during the second week of the Great Return March, east of Jabaliya, April 6, 2018. (Mohammed Zaanoun/Activestills.org)

Two million people live in the Gaza Strip. That’s a statement of fact, not opinion. Two million people live like prisoners in a prison built by Israel, and it seems that Israel’s sole vision for their future is to keep them jailed there forever.

What happens when the prisoners stage a protest? We’ll just shoot them from the other side of the fence. And if the gunfire looks bad on TV? We’ll send in the prime minister’s advisers in fancy suits to give interviews near the fence.

And if the inmates burn tires? We’ll look into prohibiting tires from being brought into the prison. And if the prisoners come to the protests by the busload? We’ll threaten the bus company owners, and so on, and so forth.

And so it goes, from one year to the next, one Friday to the next. In the meantime, the death toll rises and Gaza’s beleaguered hospitals are pushed ever nearer to collapse.

What’ll happen next Friday? Never mind reality. Have some more propaganda instead. It’s all their fault, says the man in the suit.

Here’s a question for Israelis: What would you do after living for more than a decade under blockade, on a small strip of land roughly half the size of New York City, in conditions of severe overcrowding with no seaport, airport or any other avenue by which leave? With no jobs, no hope, no future for you or your children, dependent on humanitarian aid that may well stop coming, with only a few hours a day of electricity, and water that’s polluted?

The Israeli propaganda machine dupes Israelis into thinking that the two million people living in the besieged Gaza Strip are not human beings. Instead, we are told, each and every one of them is actually a murderous terrorist. Here they come, hell-bent on destroying us. They are armed with stones and equipped with onions as shields. They’re a deadly, primeval swarm. Nothing but live gunfire every Friday and bombing and shelling every few years can keep them in check and ensure they toe the line in the prison we’ve confined them to.



But what happens after the propaganda? How many more Fridays (scores of dead, hundreds of wounded), or rounds of air strikes (thousands of dead) will keep Gaza contained? Is this Israel’s vision? Is this a strategy? Is this the future?

As far as Israels are concerned, the residents of Gaza simply woke up one Friday and decided to swarm the fence. And even if they do have any grievances, they shouldn’t address them to us. It’s all the handiwork of Hamas. After all, we left. They’ve been managing their own affairs for years; it has nothing to do with us.

But it turns out you can’t just walk out and shut the gate behind you on a small, crowded piece of land you ruled for 40 years, especially not when you’re still calling the shots on how many trucks can come in and out, or how much water and electricity is supplied to the people living in the enclosure you wanted to erase from your mind. Gaza and its two million residents cannot be made to disappear, not literally and not figuratively.

Palestinians demonstrate near Khan Yunis by the border fence between Israel and the southern Gaza Strip on March 09, 2018. Photo by Abed Rahim Khatib/ Flash90

Palestinians demonstrate near Khan Yunis by the border fence between Israel and the southern Gaza Strip on March 09, 2018. (Abed Rahim Khatib/ Flash90)

Reality is stronger than any propaganda campaign. It will ultimately break through and penetrate public awareness. Even the inmates in the Gaza prison managed to remind us they exist – and on the first night of Passover at that. Even after 50 days of bombing them in the summer of 2014, we had forgotten they exist. Even though we killed 547 children back then, lo and behold, they’re still there. The great March of Return hasn’t gotten one Gazan past the fence, but it has returned Gaza to the public eye.

How do Israelis envision the future? The sea won’t swallow up Gaza, nor will Egypt. Donald Trump won’t save the day, nor will Rwandan President Paul Kagame. How do we build a reality where Gazans have a future? How do we ensure our two million neighbors have electricity, clean water, and jobs? Thirteen million people live between the Mediterranean and the Jordan River; nearly one out of six lives in Gaza. What framework will secure political rights, freedom and a future for this vast public?

All of that is a world away from the mind of the man in the suit talking to reporters near the fence. He’s busy with propaganda now. To hell with reality. There are dead and wounded in the background, but the suit remains spotless, not a speck of dust, not a drop of blood. That same suit is pressed and ready for next Friday, and for the one after that.

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article

    * Required


    1. Lewis from Afula

      The Gazans’ clean water, electricity, gas and food is Hamas’s problem.
      It is not up to Israel to provide them with goodies. Their own government is responsible.

      Reply to Comment
      • Nizar

        How can it be their problem when you besiege them and stop anything or anyone from entering or leaving? Two million people are living in the biggest open air prison in the world. you control the sea and air and borders and you say it is their problem? Give me a break

        Reply to Comment
        • Lewis from Afula

          They need to STOP their war of extermination. Then, the siege will stop too.

          Reply to Comment
      • Bruce Gould

        @Lewis: Gisha, an Israeli human rights group, has a publication called “50 Shades of Control”. Here’s the info on Israel’s control of Gaza’s economy:


        “Israel takes the liberty of deciding what products are worth manufacturing in Gaza and selling outside of it, impacting the profitability and feasibility of different branches of industry….”

        Reply to Comment
    2. Firentis

      There is a fence and a border. If the people on the other side of the border want something from us they can ask nicely through their government. If they insist that their goal is to destroy us then we will ensure that they fail. If they choose to try to cross the border we will ensure that they fail. Whatever happens in Gaza is the responsibility of the people in charge of Gaza. Take your complaints to them because the well-being of the people of Gaza is not our problem.

      Reply to Comment
      • Ben

        “the people in charge of Gaza”

        Um, that would be the Israelis. I know, you disagree. But we were not born yesterday.

        Reply to Comment
        • Lewis from Afula

          This is Ben’s problem – his total lack of objectivity and common sense.

          The only Israeli who has been “occupying Gaza” is one suffering from schizophrenia. This guy purposely broke into Gaza a few years ago because of mental issues that affect his day to day thoughts and judgement. The devious Gazans have kept him hostage since then.

          Wake up Ben !
          Israel left Gaza in 2005.
          The only langauge the Hamas dogs is undertand is FORCE.

          Reply to Comment
          • Ben

            Thanks. I knew you would disagree. But as I said, we were not born yesterday. Save it for the aging aipac aunts and uncles in Philadelphia who weren’t born yesterday but might as well have been for all their easy dupableness.

            Reply to Comment
          • Ben

            And in other news today:

            Genesis Prize Cancels Ceremony After 2018 Winner Natalie Portman Says Won’t Visit Israel
            Portman said ‘recent events in Israel’ have been ‘extremely distressing,’ making it uncomfortable for her to participate in any public events in Israel

            Sigh. Natalie Portman, another Israeli whose “problem” is that she lacks “objectivity and common sense.” Or, in the words of I. G. Halevy, is “the shame of the Jewish people.” “Inaudible”!

            Reply to Comment
          • Lewis from Afula

            So no comment about the Israeli Schizophrenic who is being held hostage by Gazan dogs.
            I guess that raising that tends to upset your entire narrative.

            Reply to Comment
          • Ben

            On the contrary, I think your casting of all this strongly reinforces my narrative.

            First of all, you should refer to persons as having schizophrenia or suffering from schizophrenia (as you did earlier) not contemptuously to “Schizophrenics.” Your inveterate lack of respect for human beings permeates your language or slips through. So, likewise, unlike Lewis the Dehumanizer, we shall call persons, whether Arab or Jew, humans, not dogs.

            Listen to Lewis: “the Israeli Schizophrenic, the Gazan dogs, blah blah blah.” Attractive, huh?

            And per the argument about force, unlike Lewis, we pray that the force applied is nonviolent. Lewis secretly, actually not so secretly, prays for, fantasizes about violence, all the better to facilitate his frankly stated 21st century ethnic cleansing and mass population transfer schemes “for dogs.” Because the very last thing Lewis wants is a peaceful two state or one state solution.

            Yeshayahu Leibowitz, were he alive today, would call Lewis from Afula a Judeo-N*zi, and I think Yeshayahu Leibowitz would be right, as he was right when he was alive.

            Reply to Comment
    3. Lewis from Afula

      I am still awaiting your analysis about the Israeli Schizophrenic who is being held hostage by Gazans.

      Reply to Comment
      • Ben

        Yup. You are. With the same attitude.

        And here is the blindness of Lewis from Afula:

        He is very keen to impress upon us how Hamas is reportedly holding an Israeli hostage. It’s so inhuman! Those beasts!

        Yet at the very same time he seems blithely unaware that the Israel leadership holds THOUSANDS of Palestinian political prisoners hostage in indefinite detention without trial. Not to mention the millions of Gazan held hostage on calorie counts.

        In this routine obtuseness Lewis from Afula seems to me a rather typical Israeli, aside from his own particularly brutal fascist agenda.

        Poor sensitive Lewis! The forced mass transfer enthusiast frets about hostages! Somebody help this poor sensitive soul soothe himself!

        Reply to Comment
      • Ben

        Since you care so deeply, deeply about defenseless hostages, Lewis, I hope Bezalel Smotrich didn’t upset you too much:

        Israeli Lawmaker: Palestinian Teen Tamimi ‘Should Have Gotten a Bullet, at Least in the Knee’
        Ahed Tamimi, the Palestinian teenager famed for slapping an Israeli soldier on camera, should have been shot, at least in the knee, Deputy Knesset Speaker Bezalel Smotrich (Habayit Hayehudi) wrote on Twitter Saturday.
        “In my opinion, she should have gotten a bullet, at least in the kneecap,” he wrote. “That would have put her under house arrest for the rest of her life.”


        How many times have I said that the occupation is run by gangsters? That it is organized crime? Then along comes the esteemed Deputy Knesset Speaker Smotrich to prove my point all over again.

        Reply to Comment
        • Lewis from Afula

          Still no answer to my question about the Israeli Schizophrenia Sufferer who is being held hostage in Gaza.

          Firstly, Ben waffles on about my incorrect grammar and spelling of the word Schizophrenia.

          Then, Ben says “Israel is doing worse….etc etc”. Ben is unaware that before June 1967, not a single JORDANIAN or Gazan was under any Israeli political control. It was the attempt to exterminate Israel that brought about the occupation.

          Once we repatriate the Jordanians, these arguments with the Bens of the World will become obsolete.

          Reply to Comment
          • Ben

            There there, it’s ok, actually I did answer you, you poor, misunderstood, sweet, sensitive soul. I really don’t need or want an answer from you, however, on the 17-year-old Palestinian girl being held hostage in an Israeli prison along with thousands of other political prisoners. Thousands!

            Reply to Comment