+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

'Open up or we'll tase you': Police arrest activists protesting Gaza violence

In the northern city of Haifa, Israeli police are arresting activists who are organizing demonstrations against the violence in Gaza.

Protest in support of hunger-striking Palestinian prisoners, Haifa, May 22, 2017. (Maria Zreik/Activestills.org)

Illustrative photo of Palestinian protest in Haifa. (Maria Zreik/Activestills.org)

Israeli police arrested and interrogated a number of Palestinian and Jewish political activists from the northern city of Haifa over the past several days, due to their participation in demonstrations following the killing of over 60 protesters in Gaza this past week. Among those arrested were General Secretary of Hadash’s Haifa chapter, Raja Zaatry, and Yoav Bar, an activist with the Abnaa al-Balad movement, who was arrested twice.

Iris Bar, a political activist and Yoav’s partner, describes what happened:

“On Monday evening, we held a protest. The harassment began the following day. I believe it has to do with the upcoming local elections. There is a Facebook group for Haifa’s residents, which has both Arab and Jewish members, and which is run by a right winger. Often you will see absurd conversations taking place there — Jews sending Arabs to Gaza, Arabs sending Jews to Europe. But it may be the only space in the country that is shared by Jews and Arabs of all political stripes. After Monday’s demonstration, some group members began putting pressure on the mayor. Someone wrote: ‘Why are you letting them protest?’ They probably felt that they had to do something.”

On Tuesday morning, the police began arriving at people’s homes. Most people were at work, so they caught only Yoav, who has more flexible work hours. I know of five activists who were paid a visit, both Jews and Arabs. The police came to their homes, some family members received frightening phone calls. I assume that there were others whom I don’t know about.”



On Tuesday we had another protest, and the police jumped on anyone who did not stand on the sidewalk, specifically on photographers who were documenting the demonstration. The police yelled ‘get on the sidewalk!’ hysterically at them, even though they were neither on the road nor blocking traffic.”

Majd Kayyal, a journalist and political activist who was also at the protest says that in the eyes of the police, the fact that an Arab stepped onto the road for five minutes is “the most catastrophic thing that can happen.”

“I think it is legitimate and legal, and shouldn’t worry the police,” Kayyal adds, “but they cannot understand and accept that there are people who protest without their permission, without taking orders of where to stand or not stand.”

Majd Kayyal at his home in Haifa days after he was released from Shin Bet custody. (Photo by Shiraz Grinbaum/Activestills.org)

Palestinian activist Majd Kayyal at his home in Haifa. (Shiraz Grinbaum/Activestills.org)

“The fact that the protests took place in downtown Haifa is no coincidence. This is the same place where Arab residents were kicked out of so it could be turned into a recreational area with bars. Since 2013, there has been an increase in the mistreatment of political activists – in terms of numbers arrested, release conditions, preventative arrests, etc.”

“Ultimately, this is foolish behavior. They do not have the tools to influence us. They still believe that arresting three or four organizers will stop people from going into the streets, as if they are puppets. They are unable to understand that we have a political demand. They won’t be able to stop that.”

‘Open up or we’ll tase you’

Yoav Bar himself described both his arrests on his blog [Hebrew]:

I was harassed twice this week, both times with false arrests – and all in violation of the law. The reason: the police’s efforts to prevent the protests that took place in Haifa against the massacre of protesters in Gaza.

How does one make an arrest without a warrant?

On Monday morning I heard loud knocks on the iron gate outside my house, along with yelling: ‘Yoav! Yoav!’

I was still in my pajamas, reading in bed. For a second I thought someone was drowning at the entrance of my home and calling for my help. I weighed getting dressed before helping him? On second thought, I remembered that I live in the Halisa neighborhood, and that the road is covered in asphalt, and that it rained not too long ago. And anyway, anyone who is drowning right now wouldn’t be able to strike the iron gate. I relaxed and continued reading.

The iron gate, two meters high, was locked. The yelling and knocking were suddenly at my front door, and from there the doors to the rooms inside the house, as well as the windows. The person yelling did not suffice calling out my name, he created some kind of background music with an improvised instrument that he put together from things he found in the yard.

After the commotion died down and the guests left, I calmly got up and began going about my day. However, immediately after I opened the gate and walked out into the street, I saw four figures running toward me. I was able to go back into the yard and lock the gate before they stood before the gate and yelled at me to open up. Now, face to face, I could see that they were police officers, two men and two women, with uniforms and name tags.

‘What’s the issue?’ I asked. ‘Why should I open? Do you have a warrant?’

“Yes!” they responded. I asked to see the warrant, but they did not show me a thing. Instead they yelled: “Open immediately or we will tase you.”

Because they had already pointed the taser at me, I did not want to test their patience. I opened the gate and went with them.

At the station, I was told that I am not under arrest but detained for the purposes of investigation. When I complained that they lied to me and detained me without a warrant, they continued lying: ‘We did not say you were under arrest, nor did we say we had a warrant.’

After the long wait, the interrogation itself was short, and ended when they told me that I would be released as long as I agree to three days in house arrest. I tried to refuse, but then was told I would be sent to Jalma prison and then would be brought before a judge who would determine the conditions of my release. I agreed to house arrest.

On Wednesday evening, while under house arrest, a police officer in uniform appeared at the iron gate and announced that I was under arrest. I went with him.

When I exited the police car outside the station, the officer told me that since I was under arrest, he would have to handcuff me, including my legs. I slowly walked through the station’s long hallways, the cuffs hurting my legs with every movement. The officer tried to convince me to walk faster – yet I refused.

I was led to a room where the officer began filling out arrest forms. There was a problem. He called a number of other officers and explained that he needs to fill out the forms, but he does not know the reason for the arrest. He explains to one of his superiors that he arrested me because he was alone on shift, and that his partner was keeping an eye on another person under arrest. Eventually, one of the officers came up with a cause for arrest: ‘Write that he behaved in a way that could disrupt the public order.’

When that was complete, we set out for another long journey in the hallways, toward the intelligence branch. Now, in order to speed up the process, it turned out that I could march without the cuffs.

The officer at police intelligence read me a short text that he prepared ahead of time, according to which Israel Police received a tip about an illegal protest that is being planned for Friday. He warned me that if I would be interrogated again should I take part.

It turns out that between Thursday night and Friday, the police prepared a long list of political activists who may protest on Friday, and arrested or summoned many of them for similar conversations.

One of those activists, Raja Zaatry, described how the police officers came to his home after midnight, arrested him, took him to the police station, and claimed that he was organizing an “illegal demonstration on Sunday. If he goes to the protest, they said, he would be arrested immediately. Zaatry says that the response to the scaremongering is to make sure that the protest on Sunday is as big as possible. We cannot let fascism pass, the protest must be against what is happening in Gaza, as well as against the attempts to frighten and silence us.”

Israeli policemen arrest protesters as Palestnians living in Israel and left wing activists protest against the Israeli attack on Gaza in down town Haifa, July 18, 2014. Israeli police arrested 28 activists, as protesters took the streets and blocked roads calling to put an end to the attack. (Faiz Abu Rmeleh/Activestills.org)

Israeli policemen arrest protesters as Palestnians living in Israel and left wing activists protest against the Israeli attack on Gaza in down town Haifa, July 18, 2014. (Faiz Abu Rmeleh/Activestills.org)

The police issued the following response:

Israel Police acts in accordance with the law in order to protect public safety and security, and whenever there is a suspicion that extremist elements intend to organize illegal and violent protests, the police acts accordingly to prevent it, including by locating the organizers who are hiding from the law.

The police will continue to allow the public to exercise the right to protest and freedom of expression, but will prevent any attempt to disrupt public order and endanger public peace and security.

Furthermore, we do not disclose details from ongoing investigations and emphasize that the stated arrest is unknown and did not take place in our district.

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article

    * Required


    1. Brian McDonough

      The terribly stupid and unsuccessful Gaza invasion of Israel by Hamas was not a “protest,” let alone a “peaceful protest.” It was not even a riot; it was a terribly stupid and unsuccessful invasion of Israel by Hamas. Here below is Hamas Co-Founder Mahmoud Al-Zahar proudly admitting that the Hamas protests in Gaza are not “peaceful”: “when we talk about ‘peaceful resistance’ we are deceiving the public.” Here below also is a video of a captured Gazan who also revealed the “protest” tactics of Hamas which true created, organized, directed, orchestrated and choreographed the “protests.” Here below also are numerous videos of Hamas and Gazans admitting the truth of the Gaza “protests” of Hamas:






      What is the intent of the alleged “peaceful” Hamas protests? Their intent is the longstanding intent of Hamas. Here is Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh stating: “we must behead ALL Jews, and to crush INFANT skulls all day. To be heroic is to target the babies of the Jews. . . a greater friend to us Palestinians is Hitler.” These are the “peaceful” Gazan protests and the “peaceful protesters”:


      Here is Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar encouraging the “peaceful” protesters what to do at the protests: “TEAR OUT THEIR (JEWS’) HEARTS FROM THEIR BODIES.” These are the “peaceful” Gazan protests and the “peaceful protesters.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=klFbf6VG7uA&feature=youtu.be

      Hamas Leader Ismail Haniyeh states in this video, lest anyone deny that Hamas organizes, directs, orchestrates and choreographs the alleged protests and deny the true intent of the Gazan protests: “Hamas is the canon, and we are the ammunition.” These are “peaceful” Gazan protests and “peaceful protesters.” https://youtu.be/y2m_gy-rD_s

      Here is the Hamas leader Khaled Mash’al declaring the murder of Americans: “Oh Americans, Allah will punish you. The time has come for Allah to declare war on you. . . Death to America.” The video goes on to show Hamas leader Fathi Hammad stating: “killing a single Jew is the same as killing 30 million Jews.” The video goes on to show Hamas-Gaza cleric Mushen Abu ‘Ita stating: “The annihilation of Jews here in Palestine is one of the most splendid blessings for Palestine” These are the “peaceful” Gazan protests and the “peaceful protesters.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nW4RMCO5hQk

      Because of its murderous Anti-Semitism, YouTube was forced to remove this Hamas-Gaza cleric video to his supportive Gazan audience in which he encourages the Gazan Protests: “the best way to describe the record of the Prophet’s treatment of the Jews is one of violence and force toward the Jews. . . I call upon every Muslim: Do not stand idly by and let those Jews spread corruption upon the land. [You must] carry out glorious deeds against them. One of the greatest duties, and one of the best forms of worship in our day, is to fight those Jews.” These are the “peaceful” Gazan protests and the “peaceful protesters.” https://www.memri.org/reports/youtube-censors-memri-removes-%E2%80%93-harmful-or-dangerous-content-%E2%80%93-memri-tv-translated-clip

      This Hamas-Gaza cleric states to his supportive Gazan audience the true intent of the protests: “we must return to [our land] – above ground, underground, by means of demonstrations, bombs, weapons, explosives, explosive belts.” These are the “peaceful” Gazan protests and the “peaceful protesters.” https://www.memri.org/tv/hamas-cleric-abu-funun-we-must-return-to-our-land-using-bombs-explosive-belts

      This Hamas-Gaza cleric states to his supportive Gazan audience the true intent of the protests: “the Great Return March. . . is a form of Jihad. It does not eliminate the need for Jihad by the sword, by missiles, and by rockets. They go hand in hand.” These are “peaceful” Gazan protests and “peaceful protesters.” https://www.memri.org/tv/gaza-friday-sermon-abu-jleidan-return-march-form-of-jihad-jews-philosophers-of-terrorism-and-crime

      Reply to Comment
    2. Bruce Gould

      @Brian: It’s interesting, but the people commenting on these videos seem to think the translation is fake. I don’t speak Arabic, so perhaps we can have some input from those who do?

      I prefer this from Haaretz: https://www.haaretz.com/1.5056537

      The Hamas leader in Gaza, Ismail Haniyeh, said on Saturday his government was willing to accept a Palestinian state within the 1967 borders

      Reply to Comment
      • Bruce Gould

        (the comment was made in 2008)

        Reply to Comment