+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

Lifelong refugees: Palestinian boat people search for a new home

After escaping the horrors of the Syrian Civil War by boat, a group of Palestinian refugees washed up on the shores of Greece. Now they are wandering the streets of Athens without food or shelter.

Palestinian refugees from Syria fleeing the horrors of war on a boat originally headed to Italy.

Palestinian refugees from Syria fleeing the horrors of war on a boat originally headed to Italy.

After four days at sea, with no food or fuel, 175 Palestinian refugees were rescued by the Greek navy. After fleeing the horrors of war in Syria for neighboring Turkey and paying huge sums to their smugglers, who promised to bring them to Italy (not to mention ensure they had entry permits, as well as food and drink), the refugees found themselves living in the streets of Athens. Dreaming of reaching Europe on one hand, while facing the possibility of deportation on the other.

Some of those same refugees are members of the Salaime family, from the Palestinian village Sajara, which was destroyed in 1948. My family’s village.

As it made its way to the beaches of Greece, the same boat carrying the Palestinian refugees washed up on the shores of my consciousness. That’s it, I can no longer pretend that that the war in Syria is far removed from me or my children. Now that members of my village, along with other refugees, have escaped from Yarmouk and Al-A’idan refugee camps, there are people who will tell the story. There are photographs of the boat and there are children begging for a piece of bread, after they lost all their food at sea. There are the tears of a helpless mother as she faces her children.

And there is the human trafficking between Syria, Turkey, Egypt and Italy. “War traffickers,” said Abu Ahmad Salaime, a 54-year-old engineer who was chosen to head the group of refugees who left Turkey in an old, rusty boat carrying 175 people.

There was no single whole family on the boat. Everyone has been separated between Syria and Turkey. “They don’t put the entire family on one small boat in the middle of a huge sea,” said one of the survivors. And anyway “who has the money to pay the smugglers, who take between $5,000 and $10,000 per person? This is the equivalent of an entire house in a Syrian camp. So imagine, Samah, binti, what we had to do to get here. We’ll make it where we make it, and then we’ll demand family reunification. This is how everyone does it.”

The photos and horrific stories that have been coming out of Yarmouk would shock anyone. But this is not happening here, not at our door, we’ll be okay. This mantra keeps us Palestinians in Israel calm.

Lifelong refugees

Two years ago, the Arabs in Israel took part in the humanitarian mission for the Syrian Za’atri refugee camp in Jordan, and then came the stories that the Jordanian authorities refused to allow Palestinians from Syria into the camps. I was overcome with rage by Jordan’s decision, which did not allow a Syrian-born Palestinian into the country despite being married to a Syrian woman, after claiming that according to the United Nations, a person can only be a refugee once in their life.

Syria receives world support for absorbing Palestinian refugees from 1948 — this is a status that stays with you your entire life until a solution is found and the Palestinians return to their land, said the Jordanians. Now, when the Syrians have themselves become refugees, it has been decided that there is no “double sale.” Syrians were welcomed with open arms, while the gates slammed shut on the Palestinians.

In this war, half of the Syrian people became refugees. The war, which engulfed the entire country, did not pass over the Palestinian refugees. The smart and lucky ones, who left before ISIS captured Yarmouk, found safety across the world — especially in Sweden, Germany and the Netherlands — with friends and relatives. The joke about the new Palestinian capital established in southern Sweden no longer makes me laugh.

The boat that carried several of my family members did not reach Italy, its original destination. After several days, the dates, raisins and drinking water disappeared. There was no bread left, which was meant solely for the children. The fuel ran out in the middle of the journey, and the person who was supposed to come from Benghazi to help them refuel never came.

Palestinian refugees seen in Yarmouk refugee camp, Damascus, Syria. (photo: Walla Masoud/UNRWA)

Palestinian refugees seen in Yarmouk refugee camp, Damascus, Syria. (photo: Walla Masoud/UNRWA)

The Egyptian captain reached a point of desperation and could not make contact with the smugglers. Under pressure from the frightened passengers, he agreed to call for help from the Greek navy. After several hours, a large ship arrived with a helicopter, and pulled the boat toward the nearest Greek island. The entire ordeal lasted 10 hours.

Trampling our dignity

On the beaches of Greece, volunteers from the Red Cross waited for the refugees with a tent encampment. “Finally, food and a mattress to sleep on,” one woman told me. “Thank God, the people in this camp are really very nice. There is food, drink and medical treatment. Everything. We even had access to the internet to call our family members and tell them we were saved.”

And we, Palestinians in Israel and across the world, breathed easy. The photos from the boat were published in the Facebook group dedicated to the villagers of Sajara, and we knew that the group made it to shore safely. Hundreds of family members rushed to “like” the photos and bless the survivors. However, it turned out that they could remain in the camp for no longer than four days. The Greeks kicked them out, since there were more boats on the way, and the group was asked to leave Greece as soon as possible.

The refugees were thrown into the streets of Athens with some clothing, 50 euros per person and a temporary freedom of movement pass. They began to wander, in the streets and public parks or in dilapidated apartments and packed hotels, with nine people to a room for an exorbitant price. “Here is another industry of exploitation in a city suffering from a difficult financial crises,” says Abu Ahmad Salaime, “Everyone wants to make money off us. That’s how it is: those who have money live, and who do not get stepped on.”

The churches and orphanages of Athens are full of refugees. The story of two young children whose parents drowned on one of the boats, hasn’t left me for the past few days. A Palestinian activist in the city, who today is a Greek citizen, said that the Palestinians in the city are collapsing under the load and the requests for help. There is no one to talk to at the Palestinian embassy in Athens, and people across the city have lost all hope.

Sometimes people find food in the street, other times they don’t — everything depends on the kind heartedness of passersby.

“A few days ago a truck came to the park and provided us with food bags,” says Abu Ahmad. “Many people ran over to the truck, but I stood to the side and watched. It pained me greatly. Of course I also wanted to eat, but I felt like my pride was being trampled on. I am an engineer and my daughters are brilliant students who are also studying engineering and computer science. Why should I be in this position? What have I done in my life?

“I was very angry at my parents, who turned us into refugees in Syria, but somehow I managed. I told myself that the most important thing is to remain quiet. The most important thing is a roof, a job, a family and a livelihood.

“And here I am, waiting for a strange man to hand me a bag of food. All of a sudden I think that my parents, who were uprooted from their land, were lucky. Despite their difficult conditions and the war, they remained with the members of their village, all of them from Palestine. They remained together, and their journey ended in an Arab country. The Syrians are just as miserable as us, but could speak Arabic. You know, all of a sudden I miss being surrounded by the Syrian accent. In Turkey they didn’t speak to us in Arabic, and here we’ll have to learn another language in order to receive a single can of food.”

“I chose to flee with my father,” tells me one of his daughters. “Perhaps I will continue to study in Europe. My mother remained in the camp with three brothers and she is waiting for us to call and save her so that we will go back to being together. My sister and I had to leave because we were afraid of being kidnapped by the fighters. Many young women have been raped and kidnapped, and on the way from Homs we passed areas controlled by different armed groups — Nusra Front, ISIS, Al-Ahrar. Every area is controlled by a different group. We paid the rebels to allow us to pass peacefully.”

Jaffa flotilla

Several days ago I participated in the “return flotilla” to Jaffa, organized by the Israeli NGO Zochrot. We boarded the “Sababa” ship in Jaffa port, where we listened to an elderly man (also named Abu Ahmad) describe how he was pushed into a boat with hundreds of people without parents and food during the 1948 war. His boat was meant to sail to Egypt, but he found himself on the beach of Gaza, 11 years old, alone. It took him a few more years until he went back to Jaffa.

I thought to myself: “What am I doing on this fake flotilla, on a boat used to sell ice cream and cold drinks, with a group of enlightened Jews who are shocked by what happened to us 67 years ago? The same thing is happening today to the descendants of those same refugees. Today and every day.

This time around, the irony of life took its toll. I couldn’t sit in the restaurant after the tour like everyone else. I came home with pain all over my body, and spoke for hours with the survivors from the boat, only to hear their story, cry and feel their pain.

There is only one question on my mind since then: why didn’t these damn boats, with the new-old asylum seekers, reach Acre?

Samah Salaime is a social worker, a director of AWC (Arab Women in the Center) in Lod/Lyd and a graduate of the Mandel Leadership Institute in Jerusalem. This article was first published in Hebrew on Local Call, where he/she is a blogger. Read it here.

Newsletter banner

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article

    * Required


    1. Bar

      Truly a painful essay to read.

      The author, however, should understand that the reason this is happening is that for decades the Arab states, in collusion with Palestinian leaders (whose views, according to most surveys, are supported by most Palestinians), and with a wink and a nod from Europe, have rejected integration into their new (as noted, ARAB) countries in favor of remaining “refugees” in order to apply pressure on Israel. Over the same period, Israel has absorbed a large number of Jewish refugees from Arab and Muslim states, as well as refugees from Europe. Later, Israel absorbed Ethiopian refugees and troubled Jewry from Russia. The key word is absorption. And don’t kid yourself, those North African Jews who moved to Paris or Montreal instead of Israel, also became absorbed into those new countries.

      That’s what happens to refugees who aren’t pawns in a decades-long game of “destroy the Jews.” Perhaps instead of continuing to dream that somehow you would gain a country that has been built with the sweat and blood of Jewish refugees seeking a small corner of land in a vast Middle East, it is time to understand that being perpetual refugees is not in your interest. And going back to a country you did not build, even if you feel it is yours, is only keeping you and your family away from a normal life. Is it fair? No. It also isn’t fair that any Jews had to die in this conflict and that Jewish communities older than the Arab invasion by a thousand years were destroyed.

      Reply to Comment
      • Ben

        It doesn’t add up. Israel already has way MORE than the “small corner of land” Jewish refugees sought in the 1940s. So then why the endless cadging over a tiny percentage of land that itself is outside anything those refugees sought? It does not add up. The settlements were not built by the sweat and blood of refugees. They were built illegally in occupied territory by people who already had a secure place to live west of the green line. Your appeal to the plight of Jewish refugees is hollow.

        Reply to Comment
        • BigCat

          Talking about “it doesn’t add up”, its seems you can’t even do basic math, Brain Ben David T. Dekkers! Here are the facts:

          Israel occupies (a) one-tenth of (b) 1% of the total landmass known as the Middle East.

          The Arabs occupy 99.9% of the total landmass known as the Middle East.

          “Keep in mind that the Arabs control 99.9 percent of the Middle East lands. Israel represents one-tenth of one percent of the landmass. But that’s too much for the Arabs. They want it all. And that is ultimately what the fighting in Israel is about today . . . No matter how many land concessions the Israelis make, it will never be enough. — from “Myths of the Middle East”, Joseph Farah, Arab-American editor and journalist, WorldNetDaily, 11 October 2000.

          Did you understand the math, moron? Or should I ‘splain it more? Have you ever wondered why Arabs cannot absorb their own Arab brothers as Isreal absorbed and integrated in tiny Israel over a million Jews who expelled by the Arabs or is your psychotic fixation on Jews preventing you from thinking clearly? Go find a job, moron.

          Reply to Comment
      • David T.

        Bar: “The author, however, should understand that the reason this is happening is that for decades …”

        they are not allowd by Israel to return to their homeland, because they are not Jews.

        “Over the same period, Israel has absorbed a large number of Jewish refugees …”

        because they are Jews and not Palestinians who were expelled by Israel.

        “The key word is absorption.”

        The key words is repatriation.

        “And going back to a country you did not build, even if you feel it is yours, is only keeping you and your family away from a normal life.”

        Your best antizionist argument so far!

        “It also isn’t fair that any Jews had to die in this conflict and that Jewish communities older than the Arab invasion by a thousand years were destroyed.”

        It also isn’t fair that any Arabs had to die in this conflict and that Arab communities older than the Jewish invasion by a thousand years were destroyed.

        Reply to Comment
    2. Pedro X

      Nebi Netanyahu

      Netanyahu offered to lead the Palestinian refugees out of war torn Syria into the promised land of the West Bank on condition the refugees sign a document stating that they would not settle in Israel. The UN and Israel were going to cover the cost. Yet, the esteemed leader of the Palestinian people said no way, it was better for the Palestinians to die, which they have been doing in bunches. Abbas and his fellow Palestinians were too busy scratching their armpits to care about doing anything significant about helping out Palestinians of Syria.

      It is ironic that the neither Israeli Arabs nor Palestinian Arabs in the West or Gaza took to protesting Abbas’ decision and demanding for Palestinians in Syria, Iraq, Lebanon or Jordan be saved. More Palestinians have been killed and displaced in Syria than during the Gaza war. Yet Arabs do not care enough to take the Palestinian governments to task for blocking the return of the Palestinian diaspora to the Palestinian territories.

      It is also truly pathetic that the Palestinian community in Greece along with the Palestinian Embassy there cannot help out 175 Palestinian boat people. Israel took in over 600,000 Jews who were expelled from Arab countries, 1,000,000 Jews from Russia and tens of thousands of other Jews. Yet Palestinians cannot pass the cup to collect enough money to keep their brothers and sisters off the streets in Athens.

      Reply to Comment
      • Ben

        Well that’s a pack of lies Pedro X. What went down is much more accurately termed one f—ing sick form of blackmail by the Israeli occupier. Netanyahu “offered” nothing, he blocked the return that Abbas requested by cynically and rather sadistically using the plight of both these refugees and Abbas as a leader to set a condition that itself violated international law on refugees. Very very sick. This is the truth no matter how much the Hasbara organs work overtime to twist this episode to their liking. As Ami Kaufman makes quite clear:

        Reply to Comment
        • Pedro X

          Netanyahu offered life, Abbas offered death to the Syrian Palestinians. The Syrian Palestinians have no right of return. Never have and never will. Israel was never and never will be their country. If Palestinians prefer death and homelessness than acknowledging they have no right of return to Israel, it is their choice. But Abbas should have allowed Syrian Palestinians to have made the choice between life and death.

          Reply to Comment
        • BigCat

          “Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas rejected an Israeli offer to allow Palestinian refugees fleeing Syria to enter the Palestinian territories on condition that they forgo their “right of return” to Israel proper, Abbas told the Egyptian press on Wednesday evening.”


          What a hogwash you are, Brian Ben David T. Dekkers. Haaretz, your ultimate source for “real education”, also documented that offer from PM Netanyahu. This obsession with Jews has made you totally and completely irrational. You don’t really care about “Palestinians” do you? Your problem is anti-Semitism, moron.

          Reply to Comment