Appreciate this article? +972 depends on your support.

Click here to help us keep going

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

Jewish pundits can't decide if they're happy about Bernie Sanders' win in NH

Can an American politician who was born to Jewish parents just be an American politician who happens to be Jewish? Is Israel becoming less important in American politics?

File photo of Democratic presidential candidate, Senator Bernie Sanders (A Katz / Shutterstock.com)

File photo of Democratic presidential candidate, Senator Bernie Sanders (A Katz / Shutterstock.com)

NEW YORK — Bernie Sanders, the senator from Vermont, won the Democratic primary in the state of New Hampshire on Tuesday night. Sanders, who identifies as a social democrat, is Jewish.

But when he spoke about his background in his victory speech he mentioned only that he was the son of Polish immigrants who were poor and little-educated, making it sound as though they might have been eating kielbasa and pierogi for Sunday lunch instead of challah and tsimmes for Friday night dinner.

He highlighted his own success as an illustration of the national narrative that Sanders called “the promise of America” — the idea that one should be able to achieve one’s goals based on hard work and merit.

“My friends,” said Sanders,

I am the son of a Polish immigrant who came to this country speaking no English and having no money. My father worked every day of his life and he never made a whole lot.

My mom and dad and brother and I lived in a three and a half room rent controlled apartment in Brooklyn, New York. My mother, who died at a young age always dreamed of moving out of that apartment, getting a home of her own, but she never realized that dream. The truth is that neither one of my parents could ever have dreamed that I would be here tonight standing before you as a candidate for president of the United States.

This is the promise of America and this is the promise we must keep alive for future generations.

Several Jewish observers on social media were unhappy at Sanders’ failure to emphasize that his parents were Jews, and that he is now the first Jewish American to win a Democratic primary. (Barry Goldwater, the Republican nominee in the 1964 election, had a Jewish father but was raised Episcopalian, although he acknowledged his Jewish heritage.)

kampeas tweet

 

cohen tweet

 

 

shalev tweet

miller tweet

Sanders has never denied that he is Jewish. Nor could he, even if he wanted to, given that he bears an uncanny resemblance to practically every other 70-something Jewish man who lives on Manhattan’s Upper West Side.

He has spoken about spending a few months volunteering on a kibbutz during the mid 1960s, although since entering the presidential race he has tantalized journalists  by refusing to name the kibbutz. The information became a bit of a holy grail for Jewish journalists, until a Haaretz reporter finally discovered it last week in a 26 year-old interview Sanders gave to the paper.

Sanders married the Jewish American woman who traveled with him to the kibbutz, but they did not have children and divorced in 1966, less than two years into the marriage. He has been with his second wife since 1988;  she is not Jewish.

Sanders is also not the kind of Jewish legislator who advocates for tribal causes. He does not, for example, give speeches or make appearances at events on behalf of Jewish federations or Israel advocacy NGOs like AIPAC. Vermont, the state he represents in the senate, does not have a significant Jewish population — although my friend Allison Kaplan Sommer, the Haaretz columnist, discovered that one of his closest friends and advisors is an Orthodox Jew who teaches at the University of Vermont.

Most recently, Sanders made self-deprecating Jewish jokes in a Saturday Night Live skit with Larry David, whose parody of Sanders is so accurate that many claim it has become a contemporary comedic trope (Sanders comes in at 2:15 in the video embedded below).

American Jews vote overwhelmingly for the Democratic party, and plenty of them support Bernie Sanders. But their affinity for the candidate is based on his political views, which are primarily about social justice and and social welfare. His single mention of the Middle East in his New Hampshire speech was a reference to the group that calls itself Islamic State, or ISIS, and the need to destroy them without sending American soldiers to fight another war there. He did not mention Israel at all. So Jews who are on the fence about Bernie are wondering if they should be proud that one of their own could be president, or irritated that he’s not rushing to embrace the tribe.

Can an American politician who was born to Jewish parents just be an American politician who happens to be Jewish? In the country that considers the right to re-invent oneself a defining value, surely that is Sanders’ right. It’s not as though he’s pretending to be something he’s not. He simply doesn’t seem to feel that his Jewishness is an important factor in his political views.

On the other hand, a Jewish American who is deeply committed to the values of social justice,  especially one with a distinctive Brooklyn accent, is in very much a “type” that most Jewish Americans identify with deeply. Often called “red diaper babies” for the social-democratic values they were raised on, they played prominent roles in the major social justice causes of the 1960s, most notably in the civil rights movement. The collective memory of their involvement in social justice causes is a powerful chapter in the Jewish American narrative, often portrayed in Hollywood films. The liberal branches of Judaism in the United States even identify social justice as a Jewish value called “tikkun olam,” or healing the world. Which is why so many American Jews are convinced they remember an Uncle Sheldon who looked and sounded just like Bernie, and who dominated political conversations at their Passover seders or their Friday night dinner tables. You can see the female equivalent portrayed by “Aunt May,” the secular socialist schoolteacher in the seder scene of Woody Allen’s Crimes and Misdemeanors.

File photo of Democratic presidential candidate, Senator Bernie Sanders (Crush Rush / Shutterstock.com)

File photo of Democratic presidential candidate, Senator Bernie Sanders (Crush Rush / Shutterstock.com)

Perhaps the most significant aspect of Sanders’ candidacy is, as he has said on several occasions, that he has shown it’s possible to raise money for a presidential campaign without taking money from the big financial institutions or the oligarchs. But he has also shown that a candidate need not curry favor either with donors or with the electorate by visiting or mentioning Israel. Do voters not care about Israel anymore? We’ve hardly heard about it in this campaign.

Compare this year’s primaries to the 2008 campaign, when then-Senator Obama felt compelled to visit Israel and be photographed placing a note in a crevice of the Western Wall, even before he was nominated as his party’s candidate for the presidency. And remember the unseemly one-upmanship between Biden and Republican candidates over who was really a BFF of Bibi’s? This time ’round, no candidate is mentioning her or his friendship with the Israeli prime minister. In fact, they’re not talking about Israel much at all. Donald Trump even managed to get away with making borderline anti Semitic jokes during his speech at the Republican  Jewish Coalition — and he still won his party’s primary in New Hampshire on Tuesday night.

And while it’s very common to encounter Jewish Americans who espouse deeply liberal social views but swing disconcertingly to the right on Israel, the interesting thing about these “Progressive Except for Palestine” (PEP) Jews  is that they do not vote for  candidates based on their views on Israel — which is why Bernie Sanders can appeal to Jewish voters without mentioning his affection for Israel or rushing off to Jerusalem to give Bibi a hug.

Is it important that the Democratic party’s candidate for president in 2016 might be a Jew for the first time? In historical terms, of course it is. But I don’t think its significance is that the age of discrimination against Jews has passed, any more than the age of discrimination against African Americans passed with the election of Barack Obama.

Bernie hasn’t tested his secular social democratic views in the Bible belt states yet. But in terms of the impact Israel policy has on the U.S. electorate, what is significant is the fact that Sanders managed to trounce Hillary Clinton in New Hampshire without once mentioning the only democratic state in the Middle East ™, Golda or the right to self defense against terrorists. Perhaps what we are seeing is the decline of Israel as a major factor in U.S. domestic politics.

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article
  • LEAVE A COMMENT

    * Required

    COMMENTS

    1. Leffe

      “Can an American politician who was born to Jewish parents just be an American politician who happens to be Jewish”

      The answer is, yes.

      Reply to Comment
    2. robb Wexler

      as an american jew who does not care about my “roots” I am very happy to see this change in our political system. I hope it stays. its time we foucs on cleaning our own house. Israel occupied palestine without us aid in 1948 and again in 1967 our 3-5 billion is not yoru entire defense budget and yes personally I am tired of having a bunch of genocidal maniacs 5,000 miles away from me have so muchinfluence over my government. especially since all you do is whine about criticism against your insane occuaption of palestinians. Take your 3 billion and leave us the hell alone. SOme of us just want to be humans not identify with religions. races etc etc get over it israel

      Reply to Comment
    3. Ben

      Feel the Bern!

      How a 74-year-old Jewish grandpa will change the American order
      Poor people have iPhones too? Sanders was ignored, then mocked, but if anybody can change the trajectory of increasingly mucky American politics, maybe it’s him.

      Guy Rolnik
      09.02.2016 | 23:37
      http://www.haaretz.com/opinion/.premium-1.702350

      Reply to Comment
    4. Ben

      Sanders is right on target on economic and domestic policy but, as Peter Beinart explains, he’s blowing it in on foreign policy. Bernie’s got to get up to speed and develop the same confidence in this arena he has on economics. The subjects are connected obviously (the corrupt depredations of the military industrial complex–which Eisenhower was so right about and ever since Kennedy the US has lost its way on–and excessive interventionism). On all these issues, domestic and foreign, Hillary Clinton is both deeply corrupted and trying too much to prove she’s one of the boys:

      On foreign policy, Bernie is blowing it
      The leftist Vermont Senator is forfeiting his chance to influence the foreign policy agenda and to make Hillary Clinton less hawkish.

      Peter Beinart
      http://www.haaretz.com/opinion/.premium-1.702478

      Reply to Comment
    5. Dave

      At what point do you come to the conclusion that any further examination of your own belly button will only produce ever diminishing returns? Newsflash. Sanders’ isn’t running to be the Mayor of Chelm. He’s running to be President of the United States. He doesn’t care if your happy about it or not, and you know what? Neither do the rest of us.

      Reply to Comment
    6. Eliza

      Is Israel ceasing to be a major factor in US domestic politics?

      Israel is as probably as important to most of the American voting public as it ever was; that is not very important at all. Politicians being publicly pro-Israel has always been about pleasing their Jewish donor base – and voters didn’t think much about Israel and the Palestinians so there was no down side for candidates to wax lyrical about their support of Israel. Basically just a motherhood statement which didn’t offend anyone.

      What has changed is that Israel is now not so neutral a topic. There is a price to pay for some candidates amongst portions of their voter base to mindlessly praise Israel. Clinton is still fielding off some disdain at her recent comment announcing that one of her first calls if elected as President will be to Netanyahu. Still pleasing to the donor base but now portions of the voter base are non plussed to say the least.

      That is what is happening.

      What irks me is the notion the election of Sanders would be equivalent to the election of Obama in terms of breaking new ground. Sanders appears to me to someone whose identity is not primarily based on his Jewish background, in fact, his Jewishness is irrelevant. No-one really cares except for other Jews who want to place him firmly in the tribe.

      And what is this about equating the discrimination against Afro-Americans with that against Jewish Americans! You have gotta be kidding.

      Is it always necessary for Jews to be the victim; do you really have to shoulder your way in and claim an equal victimhood with people many of whom are behind eight ball simply because of their African ancestry.

      Reply to Comment
    7. Wendy

      I have given a lot to Bernie Sanders. As a writer and philanthropist who leaves no stone unturned working for Palestinian rights, I never deny that I am Jewish, not religious, but definitely Jewish.

      Since I have a lot in common with Bernie, I do not get his Polish meme. It’s not good for him and as is, he has an uphill battle. To come out as Jewish would be great for him and us.

      Reply to Comment