+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

Jewish education’s sin of omission

Despite years of Jewish education, much of which focused on Israel, this young American Zionist was still ignorant of Israel’s occupation of the West Bank.

By David Sarna Galdi

Illustrative photo by Shutterstock.com

Illustrative photo by Shutterstock.com

The Israeli occupation of the West Bank will mark its 50-year anniversary next year. For five decades, since 1967, that occupation has been a central theme in any discussion of Israel’s politics, history, current events and obviously, conflict with the Palestinians — except, apparently, if you’re young and Jewish in America.

While recently reading a critique of the absence of any discussion of the occupation (or any criticism of Israel, for that matter) in the 2016 American presidential elections, I made a disturbing realization: I myself had only become aware of the occupation and all of its ramifications relatively recently, only after moving to Israel and actively trying to codify, for myself, the country’s political genome.

Despite being the product of an active Jewish diaspora community and intense Jewish education (I was the target audience for a thorough understanding of Israel’s political physiognomy) I had been utterly in the dark when it came to Israel’s greatest blemish.

I attended Jewish schools near New York City. I went to Jewish camps. I spent countless Saturday mornings in synagogue with my grandparents. I traveled to Israel with my family a dozen times. As a 17 year old I spent the summer hiking the length and width of Israel. Later, I spent a hot, sweaty summer volunteering in an economically depressed city in the Negev desert. One could argue that I had the quintessential Zionist Jewish-American upbringing.

Yet somehow, in all of those years of exposure to Jewish and Israeli reality, history and culture, I never heard one word about the occupation, or even the actual word, “occupation.”

I came of age during the giddy, hope-filled days of the Oslo Accords. In fact, I distinctly remember the 13th of September, 1993, when my modern-Orthodox Jewish high school cancelled classes and gathered all of the students in the auditorium to watch the live broadcast of the signing ceremony on the White House lawn.

Yet, for all of my school’s engagement with Israeli current events, they left out one huge detail of modern Israeli history: the fact that in 1967, after the Six Day War, Israel seized the West Bank and Gaza but didn’t absorb them, setting the stage for today’s reality in which the territories’ non-Jewish residents live in a state of limbo without citizenship, equal rights and countless freedoms. How did that elephant in the room get lost in between the lines of the syllabus?

An Israeli soldier checks a Palestinian man’s documents at a checkpoint outside the West Bank city of Hebron on June 17, 2014, as the hunt for three Israeli teenagers believed kidnapped by militants entered its fifth day. (Photo: Tess Scheflan/Activestills.org)

An Israeli soldier checks a Palestinian man’s documents at a checkpoint outside the West Bank city of Hebron on June 17, 2014. (Photo: Tess Scheflan/Activestills.org)

To be fair, Jewish schools are expected to place an emphasis on subjects, ideas and opinions that fit their agendas and please parents who pay hefty tuitions. Therefore, it’s not surprising that by graduation, I could read the obscure script of Rash”i but didn’t know much at all about the recently felled Berlin Wall. Even so, opposition to the occupation is not outside the realm of Jewish learning; there are explicitly Jewish intellectuals who voice real and important protest to the occupation. Yeshayahu Leibowitz, one of Israel’s greatest contemporary philosophers, an Orthodox Jew and professor of biochemistry and neurophysiology at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, was one of the first, in 1967, to decry Israel’s unethical choke-hold on the West Bank and Gaza.

Actually, if I think back, my high school class spent what seemed like countless boring hours studying the Conquest of Lombardy, Beneventan War and all the rest of Charlemagne’s conquests in Europe. Was there no time to devote just one lesson to Israel’s most controversial political fact?

I finished my education and moved to Israel years ago, but the problem persists. Jewish heritage programs like Birthright Israel, a multi-million dollar initiative that brings Jewish youth to Israel from around the world, have been criticized for portraying a version of reality that ignores the occupation along with other constructive, reality based criticisms of Israel. This is a mistake, and a shame. A well-rounded education encompassing Israeli history and politics should include the contentious issue of the occupation as well as other blemishes on Israel’s short but turbulent past: the massacres in Sabra and Shatila or Deir Yassin, for example. Ignoring these less-than-convenient facts, not theories, in the framework of a Jewish or Zionist education is about as irresponsible as teaching American history without mentioning slavery.

These days, for better or worse, the cat is out of the bag. Unlike when I was growing up, American Jewish teenagers and college students today can’t ignore the occupation; it’s in their faces, discussed on campuses across the country by groups like Jewish Voice for Peace, BDS groups, and many more.

Yet while college campuses have been forced to deal with subject of the occupation, and politicians like Bernie Sanders communicate the concerns of progressive, globally aware millennials, has anything changed in the bubble-like institutions of American Jewish education?

Participants in the Open Hillel Conference, Harvard University. (photo: Gili Getz)

Participants in an Open Hillel Conference, Harvard University. (photo: Gili Getz)

Ira Miller, dean of the Upper School of Ramaz, a prestigious Manhattan Orthodox high school, told me: “We treat Jewish history and Israel from multiple perspectives. We require all seniors to take a course to prepare them for their arrival at different college campuses. Our approach in this course, as it is in other classes, is to confront points of view that are critical of Israel, and to encourage open discussion. Our love for Israel is unconditional; and from that foundation, we feel a responsibility to educate our students to understand the complexities of the political realities of sovereignty.”

Another veteran educator at a New York metropolitan area school, who asked to remain anonymous, told me something surprising: “Over the last five years my approach to teaching the conflict has evolved. The school has a Zionist mission statement, and course content must reflect this; however the vast majority of our graduates go to secular colleges. It is therefore necessary, as an intellectually honest program and to prepare them for the views which they hear in the schools they will attend, to expose them to the fact that there is another side to the conflict. I use the works of Benny Morris, refer to [Edward] Said and [Ilan] Pappe and explain the accusations of expulsions. I refute those accusations that are false and explain the context of those that occurred and how they are used for propaganda. We discuss the need to understand the Palestinian claims if there is going to be at least the possibility of peace and for our students to be informed advocates for Israel.”

The dilemma of Jewish educators is real: how does one reconcile Jewish ethics and Zionism to critical, ideological young minds when the Jewish state within its 1967 borders and the West Bank are as ethically congruent as a monastery and a wild west saloon? The hat trick of trying to engender love and support for the Jewish state while simultaneously telling the truth about its presence and policies in the West Bank is so difficult that, instead of mastering it, many pro-Israeli politicians increasingly prefer to equate any criticism of Israel with anti-Semitism.

In order to take back the debate about Israel’s ethics and legitimacy from groups with anti-Zionist agendas, and also because it is simply the right thing to do, Jewish institutions and programs should include, not hide, the appalling reality of occupation in their curriculums. Young diaspora Jews have the right to develop their opinions on Israel, and hopefully, deep connections with Israel, with a full deck of cards. The greatest achievement of modern, 21st century Zionism would be to rectify the situation that threatens its true historical nature and legitimacy. Teaching about, and indeed, ending Israel’s bear hug of the West Bank will, to paraphrase one presumptive American politician, “make Israel great again.”

David Sarna Galdi, a former editor at Haaretz newspaper, works for an nonprofit organization in Tel Aviv.

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article
  • LEAVE A COMMENT

    * Required

    COMMENTS

    1. Nancy Wein

      The fact of the matter is this: once you or I as a Jewish person studies the true history of Israel – including its founding and all the countless wars, if you are truly honest to yourself, you must conclude that the founding of the State of Israel was a big catastrophe both to the Palestinians and to the once ethical foundation of the Jewish religion. This is not an easy realization for a Jewish person but is the truth. If we are to reclaim our religion with its ethics and morality intact, we must work towards a democratic state of Israel for all its citizens and give up the idea of a “Jewish” state. Let the Jews and non-Jews live together in peace and with equal rights for all.

      Reply to Comment
      • Tess

        Well said Nancy.

        Reply to Comment
    2. Lewis from Afula

      Nancy Wein – I’ve never heard such a load of rubbish in my life. So, according to you, we should together with the PLO fascists who seek our destruction. Yeh, right… that’s gonna work right !

      Is if we are living in the Mid West rather than the Middle East. As if the sounds of Islamic barbarism with its in depth antisemitism and inbred Islamic fanaticism is not real. As if the Hezbolla warlords and Isis crazies are not killing each other just a few miles away.

      Reply to Comment
      • Ben

        “Isis.” This is just the latest excuse. Israel lovingly nurtured its occupation for years and years before Isis ever materialized. Before Isis it was Syria. Now that “the Syrian threat” does not even exist and Hezbollah is preoccupied there, its “Isis.” Tomorrow it will be something else. No one halfway objective buys this, Lewis. Nancy is correct. What?, those swimming pools, suburban lawns, daycare centers and schools in Ariel are the front line against Isis? The long haired “youths” in the shacks on the hills are the forward guard against Isis? If so, the strategic planners in the army need to be fired for abject incompetence. The state of Israel saw fit to release Meir Ettinger today. Terror is terror? Apparently not. Welcome to the Israeli rule of law–one set of laws and one code of treatment for Arabs, another vastly different one for Jews.

        http://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/.premium-1.720047
        Suspected mastermind of Jewish terrorism to be released from Israeli jail
        Shin Bet won’t extend Meir Ettinger’s administrative detention when it expires, state prosecutor says; Ettinger is thought to be the leader of terrorist activities against Palestinians

        Reply to Comment
    3. Average American

      It’s not taught as “occupation” because Zionists believe it’s already theirs. And so is everything from “the River of Egypt to the Euphrates”. And they’ll take it by force if The Others don’t make way for The Masters. Nice clothes, expensive school, all getting educated like megalomaniacs. You know what, that’s fine, it’s a free world, many different cultures. But in their pursuit of this takeover, let them use the lives of their own sons and daughters, own tanks and planes, own treasury, let them be seen as the aggressors not as everyone is trying to destroy them, and see how they stand up in the region on their own.

      Reply to Comment
      • Lewis from Afula

        Average american – we DO send our sons and daughters and use mostly our funding ($25 Billion for defense, internal security & other military associated-costs of which your G’ment provides $3 Billion). Actually, your terminally bankrupt country will soon have to drop out not just funding us but also NATO & SE Asia.
        Very soon, your Dollar will be toilet paper.

        Have a nice day!

        Reply to Comment
        • Average American

          Oh good, then you can do all the fighting to achieve your Eretz Israel just like Irgun, and Americans can go home and save money! You’ll be revealed as the aggressor as you should be, instead of under a disguise of USA, and you can have the consequences from your neighbors. Then we won’t have to borrow so much from the Jewish controlled Federal Reserve Bank, which prints true toilet paper and charges us interest on it like some kind of mafia loan shark.

          Reply to Comment

The stories that matter.
The missing context.
All in one weekly email.

Subscribe to +972's newsletter