+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

Izzie in HolyLand - part 21: Hell freezes over in Israel

Izzie: Ruthie! Get me the minister of interior security in here!

Ruthie: Yes Mam!

Yitzhak Aharonovitz: Mam, you called for me?

Izzie: Yeah. Sit down, Yitzhak.

Aharonovitz: What can I do for you?

Izzie: I just read about this brutal murder in Jaffa.

Aharonovitz: Oh yeah, that. Five members of the XXX family. Terrible, terrible.

Izzie: And there’s no suspect?

Aharonovitz: Nope. But I can promise you we’ll do everything we can.

Izzie: I want you to do more.

Aharonovitz: Such as?

Izzie: Well, I saw what happened in Awarta after the murder of the Fogel family from Itamar.

Aharonovitz: Well, Ms. HolyLand, those are tactics we use only in the West Bank.

Izzie: Are you saying there’s a different law for Palestinians?

Aharonovitz: Well….

Izzie: What is this, some kind of apartheid state?!?!

Aharonovitz: Well, I wouldn’t go so far as —

Izzie: Yitzhak! Shut up and use the Awarta technique! Now!

The next morning, Izzie picks up the paper and reads the Haaretz lead story:

16,000 citizens of Bat Yam arrested, city under siege
BAT YAM – The Israeli police literally took over the town of Bat Yam yesterday in an effort to search for the murderers of the XXX family last week. Just under 10% of the city, 16,000 people, have been taken into custody and been held without due process.

Five members of the XXX family from Jaffa were brutally murdered on Friday, and the police have yet to find any clue as to who the perpetrator or perpetrators may be. The belief is they came from the nearby town of Bat Yam.

Israeli Police Chief Dudi Cohen told Haaretz: “In this case, we decided to adopt the tactics used recently in the village of Awarta to find the murderers of the Fogel family from Itamar”. Cohen said that at the moment thousands of Israeli police were randomly rounding up men, women and children and taken to the nearest police station. He added that they are not allowed to meet with lawyers and refused to specify how long the thousands of people would be held.

Citizens of Bat Yam told of midnight raids where houses and property were damaged. One resident told Haaretz of the events that took place in his home. “The police treated us like Arabs. Worse – like Palestinians! They broke my fridge, emptied my rice and sugar bags on the floor. My kids practically wet themselves with fear.”

Justice Minister Yaakov Ne’eman said the trigger for the change in tactics was an interview by former IDF Chief Rabbi Brig. Gen. Avichai Ronski after the murder of the Fogel family. Speaking last month in an interview with the Walla news website, Ronski said:

“A village like this, like Awarta, from which the murderers of the Fogel family and of the Shebo family emerged, must suffer as a village. A situation must be created whereby the inhabitants prevent anyone in this village from harming Jews. Yes, it is collective punishment. They must not be allowed to sleep at night, they must not be allowed to go to work, they must not be allowed to drive their cars. There are many ways.”

Ne’eman added that Bat Yam residents, just like those of Awarta, will also not be allowed to sleep until the murderers of the XXX family are found. “Israel is not an apartheid state. If the Palestinians have no legal rights, we’re determined Israelis will suffer the same.”

Another resident told how his 11-year-old son was taken from his home by police at midnight by gunpoint. “They broke down the door, asked me where Yossi was, went into my boy’s bedroom and dragged him out. We have no idea where they took him.”

Cohen said the raids will continue until progress in the investigation is reached. He also promised residents of Bat Yam truckloads of basic supplies, if they cooperate, until the siege ends. When asked about the police activity planned for today, Cohen refused to elaborate, but said that the city’s women will most likely be rounded up by noon.


Izzie: Ruthie!

Ruthie: Ms. HolyLand? Is that you?

Izzie: Who else would it be?

Ruthie: Well, Mam… it’s 3 am. Is something wrong?

Izzie: Yes, Ruthie, of course there is. I just had the worst nightmare. We were denying Israelis their basic civil rights. It was horrible! 16,000 people in Bat Yam were arrested! Tell me it’s not true. We’re not like that, right? We only do that to Palestinians… right? Right, Ruthie?

Ruthie: Yes, Mam. Don’t worry. Hell hasn’t frozen over yet.


For more Izzie in HolyLand, press here

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article

    * Required


    1. Great. Brilliant.
      BTW, this is what I tried to explain to my last and happily regained ex-compatriots, with little or no success. They still cannot forgive to the lefty traitors their “March of solidarity with Awarta murderers”, as they put it.

      Reply to Comment
    2. max

      I deplore the state’s behavior as described by the media, but humor alone is no substitute for a coherent direction.
      In a comment to Noam Sheizaf I wrote “I think that the hard question is what’s best in the interest of society: leniency as in the case of the settlers, leading to no results, or hard play as with the Palestinians leading to results?”
      Was Giuliani right in New York? Do you think that Western Democracies are right when curbing civil rights while fighting terrorism?
      Make no mistake: I applaud your stand, but think that what’s needed is an articulated alternative, not just criticism. I doubt that you think that sending a couple of policemen to solve the case in Awarta would have been such a plausible alternative.

      Reply to Comment
    3. @Max – I’m not so sure what i would like, a tougher stance or more leniency. But I can say these two things:
      1) I would want all people to receive the SAME treatment. Since all of us are equal, right?
      2) Whatever route taken – more lenient or less, I would want it all to be LEGAL. You just don’t go arresting people without warrants and without letting them see their lawyers.
      And yes – I would support sending “a few policemen” to solve a case. Just as a “few policemen” were sent to solve the following case of the murder of the Oshrenko family:
      As far as I know, after the Oshrenko family was murdered the police did not do any midnight raids all over Rishon Letzion and arrest 10% of the population in Rishon Letzion.

      Reply to Comment