+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

Israel's national scapegoat

Since members of Israel’s parliament can’t take out their anger about the Turkey reconciliation deal on Netanyahu, they go for the easiest target around — Haneen Zoabi.

Balad MK Haneen Zoabi, Febuary 8, 2016. (Yonatan Sindel/Flash90)

Balad MK Haneen Zoabi, Febuary 8, 2016. (Yonatan Sindel/Flash90)

For all nine years of my childhood in Iran, I never personally encountered anti-Semitism. We lived in a mixed neighborhood, I studied at a Jewish high school along with non-Jews, and I cannot remember even a single instance where I was insulted or attacked for being Jewish.

From time to time I would hear stories from older family members about quarrels with the neighborhood hooligans who would harass them for being Jewish. The motif almost always repeated itself: the thugs would always demand the Jews apologize. “Ask for forgiveness, Jude,” they demanded, blocking the path until the Jew apologized for his or her existence. Only then would they be able to pass. Or not. Either way, it could have easily resulted in blows.

I recalled these stories as I watched a group of Knesset members attacking Haneen Zoabi as she spoke in Israel’s parliament about the Turkey reconciliation agreement on Thursday, demanding she apologize. The leader of the pack was MK Hamad Amar, the deputy speaker of the Knesset and a member of Defense Minister Avigdor Liberman‘s Yisrael Beiteinu party.

Amar repeatedly demanded that Zoabi apologize for calling the IDF soldiers who killed nine unarmed civilians on the Mavi Marmara “murderers.” When she refused, the deputy speaker had Zoabi removed from the plenum. Dozens of soldiers and officers who were visiting the Knesset as guests looked on from the gallery. Amar was particularly worried about upholding their honor. Let the Arab apologize.

It is clear that Netanyahu’s reconciliation agreement with Turkey put members of Knesset, particularly those on the right, in an embarrassing position: on the one hand, it is clear that by apologizing for killing Turkish citizens aboard the Mavi Marmara and agreeing to compensate the families, Israel is admitting that their deaths were unwarranted. And what does one call the unwarranted killing of unarmed people if not murder? On the other hand, they cannot take out their anger on Netanyahu. So they take it out on Haneen Zoabi, of course.

What was really terrifying wasn’t the violence directed at Zoabi, although as I watched the live broadcast of her speech there were moments when I truly feared for her physical safety. What was really terrifying came after Zoabi’s removal: MK after MK got up and competed with one another over who could spew the most poisonous, violent invective.

“Terrorist” and “neo-fascist” were only some of the terms they used. Minister of Science, Technology and Space Ofir Akunis, who spoke on behalf of the coalition, said that the Knesset should pass a law to expel her from the legislature as soon as possible, “so that we no longer have to see this terrorist’s disgusting face.” Erel Margalit, the Zionist Union’s new big-man, published a photo of Zoabi on his Facebook page with the caption “Go to Gaza, dammit.”

MK Avi Dichter, who heads the Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee, said: “Haneen Zoabi is not a circus, she isn’t even worthy of being used as lion food.” And all this less than a day after the Knesset passed the first reading of a bill that would raise the fine for desecrating state symbols to NIS 58,400 ($15,000), instead of the 300 liras (the old, defunct Israeli currency).

Every time we see our elected officials at their worse, which happens quite often, we need to remember they people are not just a product of the public atmosphere — they create it. This kind of violence does not grow in a vacuum; it is the product of continuous demonizing and delegitimization of the Palestinian public in Israel’s elected representatives, specifically against the Balad party and Haneen Zoabi — with a mix of nationalism, fascism, chauvinism, and racism.

When it is publicly acceptable for Yair Lapid to use her last name to denigrate an entire public (“Zoabis”), Ofir Akunis’ comments are only a matter of time. When a primetime news anchor says on-air that Balad MKs simply hate the fact that there are Jews in Israel and nobody speaks out, Erel Margalit’s remarks are only a matter of time. When Balad MKs are suspended from parliamentary activity for weeks because they tried to bring about an end to the policy of holding onto dead Palestinians as bargaining chips, legislating Zoabi’s expulsion from the Knesset is only a matter of time.

At the annual Balad party conference earlier this month, I spoke in the name of group of Jewish activists who recently submitted an official request to become full members of the party. Among other things I tried to explain why it is in the interest of Israeli Jews to let go of their privilege and join the oppressed group in its demand for equality and justice. When I saw the insanity at the Knesset on Wednesday, it became ever clearer to me: belonging to the oppressor group, which is represented by these members of Knesset, disgraces me as a human being. Because the Akunises and Lapids are rapidly spreading. Because if we do not stand firmly alongside Haneen Zoabi today, one day we will look in the mirror and discover we have become Ofir Akunis himself.

This article was first published in Hebrew on Local Call. Read it here.

Newsletter banner

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article

    * Required


    1. i_like_ike52

      (1) I know, I know, the Jews had it so good in Iran and all the other Muslim countries. That’s why 95% of the Jews left, because they had it so good there.

      (2) Regarding Zoabi, I don’t understand why it is so hard for you to understand that average Israelis like myself despise her, not because she opposes Israeli policies, which even many Jewish Israeli MK’s do, but because she curses the country and demands it be eradicated and then sticks out her hands and takes all the generous benefits the accursed Israeli taxpayer gives to her. Is that so hard to understand?

      Reply to Comment
      • Ben

        What I don’t understand is how you don’t understand that a hothead like Zoabi will always say stuff like she does (and the MKs in the Knesset will always think it is acceptable to call any Arab a terrorist all day long but god forbid anyone ever call a holy army commando a murderer) but until you respond even halfway honestly and decently to someone like the totally un-Zoabiish and thoroughly decent Ayman Odeh, instead of treating him with disdain and hostility, you will always promote the Zoabis, and you know what?, people like Lieberman and Netanyahu, and yourself I do suspect, love Zoabi, she is your perfect foil and scapegoat, it is Ayman Odeh you truly fear and loathe. Cry me a river. Lieberman loves Zoabi. For Lieberman a good Arab is a militant Arab and a bad Arab is one who seeks reconciliation between peoples.

        Reply to Comment
      • Carmen

        “(1) I know, I know, the Jews had it so good in Iran and all the other Muslim countries. That’s why 95% of the Jews left, because they had it so good there.

        2) Regarding Zoabi, I don’t understand why it is so hard for you to understand that average Israelis like myself despise her, not because she opposes Israeli policies, which even many Jewish Israeli MK’s do, but because she curses the country and demands it be eradicated and then sticks out her hands and takes all the generous benefits the accursed Israeli taxpayer gives to her. Is that so hard to understand?”

        Regarding #1 – what does this claim that have to do with this piece? Nothing.

        When you speak for ‘average Israelis’ you’re just talking about men though, aren’t you?

        The demonization of Haneen Zoavi wouldn’t be half as strenuous if she were a he. This patriarchal society which doesn’t tolerate fearlessness in females, especially the non-Jewish ones. Unless you’re settler Anat Cohen, who isn’t fearless but sociopathic, not the same thing.

        I watched this and looked at the other female MKs and thought to myself, you’re cheerleaders to the madness that is the ‘zionist experiment’, not players. If they throw out Ms Zoavi again, because they’re terrified of her, you’ll be next unless you remember your job is to be attractive (as much as is possible), stroke our egos, have babies, support everything we say and do and occasionally screech epithets at the opposition.

        What ‘generous benefits’ are you talking about? Explain please. Does she receive compensation over and above the other MKs? If she requires more security than other MKs, that’s hardly a generous benefit but the ‘state’ responsibility for inciting so much hatred against her; they damn well better keep her safe. Please provide evidence for your claim wrt ‘generous benefits’. As a member of knesset, whether you hate her or love her, she’s entitled to the same ‘benefits’ as the rest of them.

        What I find disturbing is the uncouth fool screaming at her. I know there were many, but MK Oren Hazan was clamoring for the most attention. He has a real Liberman-gangster vibe about him – loud, abrasive, partial to strip clubs and prostitutes – just what every good average israeli (male) loves in their politicians, shouting her down endlessly, calling her a terrorist, etc. What a guy.

        Reply to Comment
        • tajrid

          Excuse me, but she obviously volunteered to be the ‘firebrand’ of sacrifice. She spouts on over and over the same BS and it really gets boring.

          Reply to Comment
    2. Ben

      Well having watched that circus masquerading as a legislative body I can see Israelis are real, real close to a spirit of reconciliation and thoughtful and intelligent consideration of a fair and just final peace accord, and that egos and political grandstanding and clownishness are kept to a civilized minimum in your western country that is a light unto the nations. Hallelujah and glory be. The future of Zionism is swell.

      Outside intervention, people. The inmates are running the asylum.

      Reply to Comment
    3. Mikets

      Zoabi, like but more so than her fellow Israeli Arab MKs, is betraying her constituents. She represents the Arabs of Palestine and ignores those of Israel – who elected her.

      Reply to Comment
    4. Ben

      By the way, she said “you murdered,” which was later doctored to “Israeli soldiers are murderers,” and she was never really allowed to even speak, as you had the proven liar and resident frat boy jackass, oh, and MK, Oren Hazan simply shutting her up by yelling insults at her the minute she took the podium. And other MKs physically threatened her. All the while security sat around smirking and the Deputy Speaker twiddled his thumbs. Banana republic.

      Reply to Comment
    5. Yannick

      Hey, the world isnt black and white. Go to sleep.

      Reply to Comment
    6. Avi

      I think that the IDF attack on the ship was stupid but the so called peace activists weren’t unarmed at all. They used metal pipes which they dismenteled from the deck to bit the solders!

      Reply to Comment
    7. Qassem Suleimani

      Orly, Iran has changed a lot since you left. As an Iranian, I would welcome you back to Iran. This would also seriously embarass the zionists. Come back home for the sake of world peace

      Reply to Comment