+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

How one of Palestine's preeminent journalists lost hope for peace

Nasser Laham, the editor-in-chief of Palestine’s biggest independent media outlet, used to be an ardent supporter Abbas and the peace process. But after decades of failed attempts, something inside him changed. Today he believes Palestinians must stop talking about peace. ‘We’ll wait a thousand years, the Israelis will be defeated. What’s the hurry?’

By Meron Rapoport

Nasser Laham (right) speaks to Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas. (Courtesy of Ma'an News Agency)

Nasser Laham (right) speaks to Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas. (Courtesy of Ma’an News Agency)

You won’t find a Palestinian journalist who understands Israel and the Israelis like Nasser Laham. He took advantage of the Hebrew he learned while serving time in prison to become the most prominent commentator on Israeli affairs in the Palestinian media, hosting a popular daily television show that analyzes and translates the Israeli media for the Palestinian public. For years he served as a daily source for many Israeli journalists, hosting them in his Bethlehem office, even in his home, and speaking to them on the phone. Many are daily readers of Ma’an News Agency, the popular Palestinian news site where he serves as editor in chief.

I have known Laham for over 15 years. Despite the bloody days of the Second Intifada, the international community still believed that if only Palestinian and Israeli journalists met, they would reach an understanding that would help usher in peace. In many cases, the meetings that did take place — in countries such as Cyprus, Turkey, and Jordan — only served to deepen the divide between the two sides. But Laham and I connected, and we have remained in touch all these years.

The phrase “man of peace” is a bit contrived, but throughout the years Laham continued to support negotiations between Israel and the Palestinians, believing that a peace agreement was possible. He was close to Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, justifying the latter’s decision to establish a Palestinian state within the 1967 borders — through a negotiated settlement, rather than armed struggle — the moment Abbas replaced Yasser Arafat as the head of the PLO and the PA. Laham says Abbas even used to refer to him as “my son.”

A Palestinian man hangs posters of Mahmoud Abbas and Yasser Arafat in the West Bank city of Nablus, March 14, 2017. (Nasser Ishtayeh/Flash90)

A Palestinian man hangs posters of Mahmoud Abbas and Yasser Arafat in the West Bank city of Nablus, March 14, 2017. (Nasser Ishtayeh/Flash90)

Over the past few years, Laham has taken a different approach. Like many Palestinians, he has lost faith in Abbas’ path. The last straw was Trump’s decision to move the U.S. Embassy to Jerusalem. A short while after the declaration, Nasser wrote an article titled “The Jews’ Journey has Ended.” In another piece, Nasser wrote that at this point, we can only discuss Jews leaving the country.

When his father passed away two weeks ago, I went to visit the family in a small hall in Dheisheh refugee camp, where Laham was born and raised. After shaking the hands of the men, Laham came and sat next to me. “My father was 90, he was older than the State of Israel by 20 years,” he told me. “He was 20 years old during the Nakba, and all his life he waited to return to his village in Beit Itab (not far from present-day Beit Shemesh, M.R.). He waited in 1949, he waited in 1956, he waited in 1967, he waited during Oslo. They told him he would return. When I moved from Dheisheh to Bethlehem in 2006, he told me: ‘why are you hurrying? We’ll wait.’”

My father was right, Arafat was wrong

In addition to paying my respects, I had traveled to Bethlehem to try to understand Laham’s transformation, especially since clearly he is not the only Palestinian to undergo it. I can’t say I left feeling encouraged. Although it often seems as if he is trying to be provocative, it is clear that his beliefs reflect something deeper: the growing sense among Palestinians that there is no chance for peace with Israel; that Israel is uninterested in peace. That Israel wants to continue to occupy and kill, and therefore the only solution is for Zionism to disappear and for Zionists to leave Palestine. Not by force, he says. But the solution is clear.

When we met 15 years ago, you had hope that the conflict could be solved. Why did you think that then?

“Because Yasser Arafat convinced us, the Palestinian people, that there was a solution, and that Israel had its own DeGaulle. Now we have discovered that we were wrong. We do not need to apologize to anyone. Israel needs to apologize. The occupation needs to apologize. The occupation needs to apologize to every Jew and Arab that has been killed. The occupation needs to apologize to the Jews and the Arabs. There was plenty of blood 15 years ago, but far less hatred.”

Right wing Israelis burn the Palestinian flag and shout racist slogans, during an anti-Palestinian protest at the Gush Etzion junction, next to the Palestinian town of Bethlehem, following the kidnapping of three Israeli teenagers four days ago, West Bank, June 16, 2014. By: Oren Ziv/Activestills.org

Right wing Israelis burn the Palestinian flag and shout racist slogans, during an anti-Palestinian protest at the Gush Etzion junction, next to the Palestinian town of Bethlehem, following the kidnapping of three Israeli teenagers in June 2014. (Oren Ziv/Activestills.org)

“Today there is hatred in every home. Hatred has turned into a wild beast that roams the streets. This hatred needs 100 years until it disappears. Never in my entire life have I seen such hatred. The laws in the Knesset, the racism, the fascism, the Nazism, the barbarism. The Zionist movement is the worst in history when it comes to sowing hatred between nations. There is no hope for peace with it. No possibility for peace.”

But there was no return of refugees during Oslo. What did you tell your father back then?

“My father wanted to return to his village near Ramla. When he heard that Arafat had agreed to reconciliation with Israel, he said: Arafat is wretched, and I thought that my father was wretched and that Arafat was a great leader. In the meantime both passed away, and now it has become clear that my father was a great leader and Arafat was wretched because the Israelis killed him. My father’s fears were justified. You cannot make peace with Zionists unless you force them. We cannot fight them, we do not want to kill them. We have no armies, no weapons, no means, and no possibilities. That is why we need to respond to hatred with silence, with apathy. We will liberate Palestine quietly.”

What does that mean?

“All the politicians, from the days of Gamal Abdel Nasser, have said that we must find a solution to the conflict. Then came Kissinger and the rest of the leaders of the world and asked the Arabs: “What is your solution?” Until this very day the Israelis think that the Palestinians must come up with a solution. I am telling you that there is no solution. I am from Ramla and I want to return to Ramla. There is no other solution. There is no solution in Ramallah, there is no solution in any other city, and no Arab country can provide another solution. If the Jews and Israelis have a problem, they must solve it themselves. Trump and Nicki Haley are responsible for the devastation of the next 100 years. Let them solve your problems.”

Palmach troops overseeing the displacement of Palestinians from the central city of Ramlah in July, 1948. (Photo: Palmach Archive)

Troops belonging to the Palmach, a pre-state Zionist group, oversee the expulsion of Palestinians from the central city of Ramla, July, 1948. Tens of thousands of Palestinians were kicked out of the city during the Nakba. (Photo: Palmach Archive)

“So how do we find a solution? We wait a thousand years. The Israelis will be defeated and flee. What’s the hurry? Why are the Arabs hurrying? You remember what Hafez al-Assad told Ehud Barak and Bill Clinton at Geneva? They said: if you don’t do this and that, there won’t be a solution. He responded: we’ll wait another 100 years. And I’m also telling you, we’ll wait another 100 years. What’s the problem? There is no solution apart from taking all of Palestine and living in all of Palestine. From Metulla and Naqura until Eilat. The solution is waiting. No initiating any talks. The Palestinian leadership is wrong. Abbas is wrong to look for a solution. In France, in Italy, in Germany, in America. Why is he searching for a solution? Let the Israelis search for a solution.”

The Israelis must search for a solution?

“This is the Zionists’ problem, let them find a solution.”

The Palestinians do not have problems?

“No. I don’t have a problem. I am a fighter, I have patience, I hold steadfast to my occupied country. It is my honor to be here, it is my honor to be a prisoner, it is my honor to be a shaheed, respect to the people of Gaza for living under siege. Israelis should be ashamed of being Israeli. Abbas is old and I wish him health, but after he goes, I don’t think you’ll find a single Palestinian who will talk to you about solutions. Not Saeb Erekat, not Majd Farj, and not Jibril Rajoub. No one will dare say “I have a solution.” The solution is for the occupation to end.”

Israeli security forces arrest a protester in the Bedouin village of Khan al-Ahmar in the West Bank, July 4, 2018. (Oren Ziv)

Israeli security forces arrest a protester in the Bedouin village of Khan al-Ahmar in the West Bank, July 4, 2018. (Oren Ziv)

You’re not giving your people any hope.

“The people will wait.”

You say the Jewish journey has ended. Does that mean there is no room here for any Jews?

“This place isn’t convenient for you. You can go live in America. The Americans love the Jews. If the Zionist movement decides to move to America, the Palestinian leadership will travel to the airport in Lod and wave them goodbye. The Jews can return as tourists without visas. Why should they stay, fight, and die?”

There are six million Jews here. That’s the reality.

“Nations have moved throughout history. The Tatars, the Kurds. It happened. Zionism expelled six million Palestinians (referring to the current number of Palestinian refugees – M.R.). It happens. I think that the best place for Jews is America. What are you looking for in the backwards and Islamic Middle East?”

SUBSCRIBE TO +972 MAGAZINE'S WEEKLY NEWSLETTER

SUBMIT

Is living together impossible?

“There is no possibility of that.”

And if Israel ends the occupation?

“Too late, too late.”

In South Africa they found a solution.

“You don’t have a de Klerk and we don’t have a Nelson Mandela.”

Frederik de Klerk and Nelson Mandela shake hands at the Annual Meeting of the World Economic Forum held in Davos in January 1992. (World Economic Forum/CC BY-SA 2.0)

Frederik de Klerk and Nelson Mandela shake hands at the Annual Meeting of the World Economic Forum held in Davos in January 1992. (World Economic Forum/CC BY-SA 2.0)

And if we do find our own de Klerk and Mandela?

“There is a one in a hundred chance. If Marwan Barghouti is freed and I sit with him in Ramallah and he tells me that there is a possibility, I’ll listen and believe it. If this doesn’t happen, I won’t believe anyone. Neither to the leadership in Ramallah nor the leadership in Gaza. I don’t want to hear them.”

Abbas is more extreme than me

Despite his criticisms of Abbas, is it possible that Laham is actually expressing what the Palestinian president wants to say but cannot? “Abbas is more extreme than me,” he says. That’s how Laham interprets Abbas’ comments directed at Trump (May your house be destroyed”), his remarks about U.S. Ambassador to Israel David Friedman (“son of a dog”) or his most recent speech to the PLO Executive Committee, in which he called Zionism a European colonial project, and said the persecution of Jews in Europe was a result of their charging interest. “When Abbas says we were here before Abraham, this is exactly what he means,” says Laham.

U.S. President Donald Trump with Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas during a welcome ceremony in the West Bank city of Bethlehem, on May 23, 2017. (Flash90)

U.S. President Donald Trump with Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas during a welcome ceremony in the West Bank city of Bethlehem, on May 23, 2017. (Flash90)

You have many Israeli friends. What do you say to them?

“I lost three-fourths of them. Anyone who supports the occupation is not my friend. My friend is the person who opposes the occupation. Who fights for justice and for children, for humanity. Most of those who were my friends support the occupation. I see what they write, what they say. Anyone who justifies shooting dozens of bullets at a 12-year-old boy is no friend of mine, and I don’t want him as my friend, even if he is Arab or Muslim.”

The Palestinian people are very political. You are effectively suggesting to give up on political thinking.

“The Palestinians are a smart, educated people who have paid a high price in lives lost, in prisons. It is not a violent nation. Angry, but not violent. I am angry, but I am not violent. The occupation is violent and not angry. The Zionist is violent and not angry. When Salam Fayyad established the government in 2007, he asked Israel for a list of wanted Palestinians. They gave him a list of 480 people — 280 in the West Bank, 200 in Gaza. That means that 500 people were behind the Second Intifada. These are statistics provided by the Shin Bet. This is a tiny percentage of the Palestinian people. Less than a hundredth.”

“That is why I say that the Palestinian people are angry — not violent. They are smart. They understand that there is no military solution, no political solution, no economic solution, and no historic solution. What kind of understanding can I bring to Itamar Ben-Gvir (a far-right activist and lawyer associated with the anti-Arab Kahanist movement – M.R.), or Uri Ariel? What kind of common thinking do we have about the meaning of life, the meaning of history, the meaning of religion and politics?”

Not all Israelis are Itamar Ben-Gvir.

“I don’t see them.”

What responsibility do Palestinians have?

“We have no responsibility. Is your family in Europe responsible for the rise of the Nazis?”

The question is what responsibility the Palestinians have for managing their own affairs and politics.

“I will make an effort in the media so that no Palestinian makes a proposal. Had we a direct Palestinian leadership, it would have apologized to the Palestinian people for Oslo and its fake peace and illusions, which caused us to lose 30 years of our lives. But I do not think that there is a Palestinian leader — in Fatah, Hamas, the left or in any party — that has the courage to apologize to the Palestinian people.”

Hamas Chief Ismail Haniyeh speaks to the press upon his arrival at the Rafah border crossing, after reconciliation talks in Egypt with the Fatah movement mediated by Egyptian intelligence, in the southern Gaza Strip, September 19, 2017. (Abed Rahim Khatib/ Flash90)

Hamas Chief Ismail Haniyeh speaks to the press at the Rafah border crossing following reconciliation talks with the rival Fatah faction, in the southern Gaza Strip, September 19, 2017. (Abed Rahim Khatib/ Flash90)

“The Palestinian leadership needs to apologize for peace with Israel, it must feel remorse, because the new generations are now growing up. Every year, 43,800 Palestinian students graduate from Palestinian universities. The government employs 1,200 of them. The rest are unemployed and sit on the streets. Seventy percent of Palestinians are under 45, but there is not a single person in the Palestinian leadership under the age of 45. This is a young, educated, and oppressed society.”

Before I leave Laham’s office, I meet a member of that generation at the reception table. The young woman, her hair covered by a hijab, says she has never met a Jew in her life. She was born in Kuwait, came to the West Bank after the First Gulf War in 1991, and has never spoken spoke to a Jewish person who was not a soldier. Both of us are clearly a bit embarrassed by the situation. “You see what the wall does,” Laham says. “We don’t know each other. That’s the greatest disaster. You drive straight to Tel Aviv, I stay here.”

Meron Rapoport is an editor at Local Call, where a version of this article first appeared in Hebrew. Read it here.

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article
  • LEAVE A COMMENT

    * Required

    COMMENTS

    1. ish yehudi

      best article i’ve seen here in a long time. thanks Meron

      Reply to Comment
    2. itshak Gordin Halevy

      This is the swan song of the pseudo “Palestinian” cause

      Reply to Comment
    3. Frieda Gold

      It’s a shame. Palestinians have Gaza to live in and want to leave. Palestinians have never wanted to live side by side with a Jewish state in peace and harmony. This article proves it. When they do, there will be a willing partner to settle this conflict.

      Reply to Comment
    4. Bruce Gould

      @Jennifer Newman: “..because you not only asked for this, you literally got down on your knees and begged for it.”

      Asked for what, exactly? And what are you suggesting, because of Laham Israel should imprison all the Palestinians? I have this feeling there’s an unfinished sentence.

      Reply to Comment
    5. Ben

      Newman is just letting off steam by letting her sadism and contempt show. Any one who uses the condescending, demeaning name “pals” shows what cheap company they keep.
      There’s no talking to fanatics. As if Newman needed some new excuse to pretend to begin to love Bibi in the first place. How phony is that?
      This article talks about the bed Israel made and the far rightists express shock, shock!, at having to lie in it.

      Reply to Comment
      • Ido

        “This article talks about the bed Israel made” – the article talks about the Palestinian goal of ending Israel and cleansing it from Jews. Very specifically so. It illustrates the Palestinian refusal to make any compromises. He repeats the unrealistic delusion of Arabs returning to what is now Israel en masse, it ignores the role and responsibility of the Palestinian leadership in the current situation, refusing to accept any peace offer while lying to their people. It literally repeats what I have been telling you for some time now about the Palestinian leadership goals and intentions that you were in deep denial about. He shows how the Palestinians idea of ‘peace with Israel’ is literally ending Israel and turning it into another Arab state. And he sprinkles in some hilarious lies (“Zionism expelled six million Palestinians”, “Israel killed Arafat”, “I don’t see it”, “Palestinians are not a violent nation”, etc).

        Reply to Comment
      • Ido

        Kerry also didn’t understand why Israel was having a problem with the Palestinians refusal to accept Israel’s legitimate existence and their view that all of Israel is theirs and their goal of turning Israel into an Arab state using the Right of Return, basically Arafat’s old plan.
        And apparently to Kerry the funding and high praise and rabid incitement the PLO gave to terrorists during the ‘knife Intifadah’ is “commitment to nonviolence”.
        He ignores how Netanyahu approved the framework suggested by Kerry himself, that would have resulted in a Palestinian state based on the 1967 lines with land swaps. When it was presented to Abbas he rejected it. When
        Kerry returned with another offer to Aabbas, without the Israelis knowledge, Abbas didn’t bother to respond.

        https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/.premium.MAGAZINE-exclusive-obamas-plans-for-mideast-peace-revealed-1.5481322

        Reply to Comment
    6. itshak Gordin Halevy

      The Arabs are to be pitied. They often live in ridiculous fantasies, and they take their dreams for realities. The Jewish people are millennia old and of absolute resistance thanks to their Torah. All our enemies have disappeared one after the other and we are still here, alive and very dynamic, with a prosperous economy, a very high birth rate, an avant-garde technology and Talmudic schools everywhere. The delusions of this “journalist” and of others prove that the so-called “Palestinian cause” invented in the 1960s is coming to an end. Even leftists new historians like Benny Morris say it openly.

      Reply to Comment
      • Ben

        @Halevy: Amusing. So says the guy deeply embedded inside a neo-fascist national religious fantasy cult and who has an allied fantasy that six million Palestinians are going to disappear like magic and everything will be fine. A comedian. I’m afraid Rapoport and Laham are far more sober and realistic.

        Reply to Comment
        • itshak Gordin Halevy

          What are you talking about? The vast majority of Arabs in Judea and Samaria are under the Ramallah Authority which manages their affairs (education, garbage, security, etc.). They carry Jordanian or “Palestinian” passports. Israel provides tens of thousands of them with work. Ramallah has become a prosperous city with luxury shops and so on. What is the problem?

          Reply to Comment
          • Ben

            A message from inside the cult.
            Haley sustains his world record unbroken streak in making my point or a +972 author’s point for him. It’s really quite amazing how he does this.
            If you didn’t exist, Halevy, I’d have to invent you.

            Reply to Comment
          • itshak Gordin Halevy

            Not at all. The Arabs of Judea and Samaria are co-signatories of the Oslo Accords. The interview with this “journalist” once again shows the real motivations of the Arabs of Erets Israel. Chasing the Jews from their land with the help of a group of left-wing extremists We are waiting for them..

            Reply to Comment
          • Ben

            Not at all. The title of this article is “How one of Palestine’s preeminent journalists lost hope for peace.” And it shows the real motivations of the Israelis and the consequences of 50 years of Israeli behavior.

            As for Oslo, the Israelis of course have used it as a trick to further the occupation and do the opposite of what was intended and guys like you try to pretend Oslo is some final status legal accord and current justification for settlements. Which of course is the opposite of what it was intended for.
            The right wing used to passionately hate Oslo but now, having corrupted it and twisted it they deviously cluck about it as if it were some kind of marvelous title deed to the West Bank.
            The Israelis have never operated in good faith. You are no exception. You epitomize bad faith. Noam Sheizaf explains. ==>

            By Noam Sheizaf | September 13, 2012
            An agreement on indefinite occupation: Oslo celebrates 19 years
            https://972mag.com/an-agreement-on-indefinite-occupation-oslo-celebrates-19-years/55788/

            Reply to Comment
    7. Tommy Goldberg

      “Israel is uninterested in peace.”

      True enough, at this point.

      “There is no chance for peace with Israel.”

      Here’s where he is wrong, though. Interests change when conditions change.

      Apartheid South Africa was uninterested in peace (with its majority population.) 1944’s Germany was uninterested in peace. Until conditions changed.

      Right now, keeping Palestinians unfree is beneficial to Israel. That can change.

      Reply to Comment
    8. Bruce Gould

      https://www.timesofisrael.com/netanyahu-no-palestinian-state-under-my-watch/

      Netanyahu: No Palestinian state on my watch; PM pledges thousands of apartments in East Jerusalem, says construction will curb Bethlehem’s encroachment on capital” (2015)

      Meanwhile, as we play history Ping-Pong, the settlements increase, we have probably gone past the point where two states are possible, and around 500 Palestinians sit in jail without even being formally charged.

      Reply to Comment
    9. Lewis from Afula

      The “fakestinyans” are a fabricated nonsense people that were only invented in the 1970s. Essentially, a bunch of evil greedy Jordanians who rebranded themselves by using a new name. This was all done in a pathetic attemot to deflect their own guilt of starting the 6 day war of June 1967.

      972 magazine supports this classic “fakestinyan” ruse of name-shifting.

      The only logical solution is mass population transfer of these JORDANIANS. Their relatives in Amman are waiting for them.

      Reply to Comment
    10. Lewis from Afula

      The so-called “fakestinyans” need to dismantle themselves.
      Reversion to their original JORDANIAN identity is the only sane solution.
      When Israel repatriates the lot of them, thier JORDANIAN future will be forced upon them. Better to embrace it NOW rather than Later.

      Reply to Comment
    11. Click here to load previous comments

The stories that matter.
The missing context.
All in one weekly email.

Subscribe to +972's newsletter