+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

Israel Hayom's new target: Conscientious objector's mother

‘Israel Hayom’ put a high school principal in its crosshairs after she expressed support for her daughter’s refusal to serve in the IDF. This is what a witch hunt looks like.

By Yael Marom

Iris Gur, mother of conscientious objector Noa Gur Golan, protests in support of her daughter, who sat in prison for 98 over her refusal to serve in the IDF. (Courtesy of Mesarvot)

Iris Gur, mother of conscientious objector Noa Gur Golan, protests in support of her daughter, who served 98 days in prison for her refusal to serve in the IDF. (Courtesy of Mesarvot)

Israel Hayom, the newspaper funded by Netanyahu patron Sheldon Adelson, and the country’s most circulated daily, has found yet another target. After an unsuccessful attempt last week to bring about the firing of Palestinian-Israeli journalist Makbula Nassar a week earlier, this week  Israel Hayom put Iris Gur, the mother of conscientious objector Noa Gur Golan, in its crosshairs.

Gur, an elementary school principal, has expressed support and pride for her daughter, who served 98 days in military prison after refusing to be conscripted into the IDF. According to Israel Hayom, this makes Iris an “Israel hater” who is unfit for her job as a teacher. Or as Matan Peleg, from the far-right group Im Tirzu, put it: “It is inconceivable that schools will be led by principals that do not believe in the right of the state to protect itself.”

The article, published last Tuesday by Yair Altman, opens with the following: “Educating toward conscientious objection? Iris Gur, the principal of a state elementary school and an employee of the Ministry of Education, published a post on her Facebook page that praises and encourages her daughter and others to refuse to enlist in the IDF.” Altman writes that Iris accompanied her daughter to military prison and even participated in a protest to support her daughter. Altman adds that Gur’s personal Facebook page is full of “extreme and controversial political statements, including articles from Palestinian websites about the army arresting children, as well posts about ‘terror against children’ and posts by Women Wage Peace.”

On Thursday morning, Israel Hayom reported that the campaign had succeeded. The Education Ministry will reportedly summon Iris Gur to clarify that the contents of her Facebook page “do not constitute part of the school’s educational environment.”

Crowdfunding campaign banner

Not Zionist enough?

Noa Gur Golan refused to serve in the army because of her commitment to pacifism and nonviolence, and says she believes that she must personally work to bring about peace. She requested that the IDF recognize her as a conscientious objector and permit her to perform civil service instead. Two weeks ago, the army discharged her after 98 days in prison, labeling her behavior “serious misconduct.”

Israeli conscientious objector Noa Gur Golan. (Courtesy of Mesarvot)

Israeli conscientious objector Noa Gur Golan. (Courtesy of Mesarvot)

In an interview with Yedioth Ahronoth earlier this year, Iris said:

If my daughter is willing to pay the price and go to prison, then I too am willing to pay. If someone thinks I am doing the wrong thing, then I am willing to pay any price to support my daughter. I am, first and foremost, her mother. They say that I am putting my job at risk, but I have been in the education system for 30 years, and I find it hard to believe that I will be fired for saying I support my daughter. At worst I will be given a warning or summoned for a meeting. The teachers at my school know about Noa’s decision not to enlist… I really have nothing to hide.

Noa is 19 and made her choice and I support her, because she deserves to live according to her worldview. We had many conversations during which I asked her repeatedly if she was sure of what she was doing… after these conversations, I understood that this is her truth and that she can’t do otherwise.

Gur Golan is part of the Mesarvot network, which supports conscientious objectors. Following the attacks on her mother, Mesarvot issued the following statement:

Every year, many young people choose to refrain from IDF service in one way or another, some of them do so while declaring their opposition to the occupation and Israeli policies, and often pay the price of lengthy prison sentences. These are brave young people who, despite all the norms of Israeli society, choose to take a stand and take responsibility.

This is certainly not the first time Israel Hayom has targeted people, and government employees in particular, for being insufficiently Zionist, for being too left-wing, or for being Palestinian. Netanyahu’s confidants as well as his supporters are busy the cleansing civil service of those whose views do not match the prime minister’s. This is especially true for teachers who dare to express opinions seen as left wing, and that do not conform to the idea that militaristic education and violence are morally justifiable. Employees in the Education Ministry are legally allowed to express political opinions. However, as the list of persecuted teachers grows longer, the message is clear: some opinions are legitimate, others aren’t — and you better think twice before writing words like “peace” on your Facebook page.

Yael Marom is Just Vision’s public engagement manager in Israel and a co-editor of Local Call, where a version of this article was originally published in Hebrew.

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article
  • LEAVE A COMMENT

    * Required

    COMMENTS

    1. Itshak Gordin Halevy

      Israel Hayom is totally right.

      Reply to Comment
      • Ben

        Israel Hayom is basically a propaganda-distributing NGO funded with massive amounts of foreign money, amounts that swamp the usual funding typical NGOs get. So some ludicrous gambling magnate sits in Las Vegas, Nevada and uses his casino-gotten gains to funds attacks on brave Israelis like Noa Gur Golan and her mother and that’s OK with you guys? OK. I don’t want then to hear another peep out of you about how NGOs should not be getting foreign money.

        Reply to Comment
        • Itshak Gordin Halevy

          Ben: Do you live in Israel? Probably not and you post on this forum a lot of comments. Here in Israel we do not like Jewish traitors. This Noa Gour and her mother should be ashamed. Most of Israelis quite agree with me. For years we underwent the diktats of the champagne left. Now it is over.

          Reply to Comment
          • Ben

            Halevy, Noa Gur Golan ain’t no “champagne leftist” and she ain’t no traitor and she ain’t no “Jewish traitor.” I have news for you, I am not counting on “we in Israel” to change anything. Outside pressure will be needed. Fanatics and cults can’t be reasoned with. And your pose as poor victim of “diktats” rings exceedingly hollow. You underwent no “diktats” of any left, “champagne” or otherwise, because there never was any real left, so there can’t be any “it” that “is over.” Edo Konrad explains:

            “…This view of Israeli politics, which at its core purports that Israeli democracy has been “hijacked” by a group of extremist right-wingers, has gained currency …. If the Right has in fact been hijacking Israeli democracy, it has enlisted some fairly furtive partners in crime — namely, the Israeli electorate and the broad range of politicians it has elected over the past six years. So, no, not all Israelis are represented by the right-wing policies of Benjamin Netanyahu and his government. But the alternative doesn’t look all that different.”
            read more: https://972mag.com/why-the-hijacking-of-israeli-democracy-is-a-myth/113746/

            Reply to Comment
          • Ben

            Halevy, Noa Gur Golan is no “champagne leftist” and she is no traitor. And not a “Jewish traitor” either. One does not count on “we in Israel” to change anything. Outside pressure will be needed. Fanatics and cults can’t be reasoned with. Your pose as victim of “diktats” rings exceedingly hollow. You underwent no “diktats” of any left, “champagne” or otherwise, because there never was any real left, so there can’t be any “it” that “is over.” The right, disguised or out in the open, has always been in power in Israel.

            What has changed is that the spores of outright fascism, always latent in the soil, have been activated, now that push has come to shove and the occupation can’t be “managed” and deferred politely anymore. This latent fascism, now that the hour is late and increasingly open apartheid can’t be politely covered over and managed for outside consumption much longer, has been awakened to come fully to the surface and declare itself frankly and overwhelm the political ecology. It’s a moment of truth. What it says is that Israeli Zionism was never truly interested in compromise and peace, and when push came to shove, the pretending stopped. Edo Konrad explains:

            “…This view of Israeli politics, which at its core purports that Israeli democracy has been “hijacked” by a group of extremist right-wingers, has gained currency …. If the Right has in fact been hijacking Israeli democracy, it has enlisted some fairly furtive partners in crime — namely, the Israeli electorate and the broad range of politicians it has elected over the past six years. So, no, not all Israelis are represented by the right-wing policies of Benjamin Netanyahu and his government. But the alternative doesn’t look all that different.”
            read more: https://972mag.com/why-the-hijacking-of-israeli-democracy-is-a-myth/113746/

            Reply to Comment