+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

Israel cracks down on dissent

More than 1,000 Palestinian citizens of Israel were arrested by Israeli police during Operation Protective Edge, according to a lawyer representing a number of the detainees. While some were arrested for protesting the Israeli military incursion into Gaza, dozens were held without charge.

Maisa Arshid, an attorney for dozens of the detainees, says that 20 to 30 Palestinians were picked up by Israeli police every week in the Nazareth area alone. “All of them are accused of participating in illegal demonstrations,” she says. But, she adds, “Part of these demos were permitted by the police themselves.”

In many cases, there is no evidence that the accused has participated in a protest other than a policeman’s word.

Arshid adds that police frequently held people for short periods without registering the detention, likely putting the number of those who were picked up by the police even higher than 1,000.

Israeli policemen arrest protesters as Palestinians living in Israel and left wing activists protest against the Israeli attack on Gaza in down town Haifa, July 18, 2014. Israeli police arrested 28 activists, as protesters took the streets and blocked roads calling to put an end to the attack. (Fiaz abu-Ramele/Activestills.org)

Israeli policemen arrest protesters as Palestinians living in Israel and left-wing activists protest against the Israeli attack on Gaza in downtown Haifa, July 18, 2014. Israeli police arrested 28 activists, as protesters took to the streets and blocked roads calling for an end to the attack. (Fiaz abu-Ramele/Activestills.org)

When the wave of arrests began earlier in July, Palestinian citizens were detained and quickly released. Some were put on house arrest, some were ordered to do community service. But as the month and Israel’s assault on Gaza has worn on, Palestinian citizens were subject to longer and longer detainments. Last week, Arshid visited a group of detainees who had been held without charge for nine days. “Each day the court is delaying their hearing,” she says, adding that hearings initially scheduled for last Sunday were pushed back to Tuesday.

It’s a way of prolonging their detentions and it has a chilling effect on demonstrations against Operation Protective Edge, Arshid argues. “If people in the street know that people have been arrested for nine days, it will prevent protest.” She says that the detentions are a way to “terrorize the population” into silence.

While Jewish Israeli leftists who object to the war are protected by the police when they protest, they are facing increasingly violent attacks from their countrymen. Moriel Rothman-Zecher attended Tel Aviv’s most recent demonstration against Operation Protective Edge, which drew approximately 5,000 protesters. There were only a couple hundred counter-demonstrators, Rothman-Zecher tells Al Jazeera English, “but they were really, really energetic.”

Israeli police stood between the two groups, preventing clashes. But when the protest ended and the leftists began to leave, right wingers confronted them on the street. They shouted at the demonstrators, calling them “smelly traitors.” A rightest who was carrying an Israeli flag began to beat a leftist with the flag-stick; another starting hitting a leftist’s head with a crutch.

Police stand between the anti-war demonstration and rightist counter-protesters, Tel Aviv, July 26, 2014. (photo: Activestills.org)

Police stand between the anti-war demonstration and rightist counter-protesters, Tel Aviv, July 26, 2014. (photo: Activestills.org)

Rothman-Zecher feels that the rightists’ “desire for violence” isn’t new. “But there’s a new level of acceptability,” he says.

He offers Jerusalem Day protests, when right wingers march to mark “reunification” of the city, as an example. In the past, it “was nationalistic and aggressive” but leftists would be shocked to hear right wingers openly chant “Death to the Arabs,” Rothman-Zecher reflects. “It was under the surface but it was still surprising. Now it’s become the baseline.”

Although no one is organizing the counter-demonstrators – and Rothman-Zecher correctly points out that they tend to come from poor, marginalized communities –Rothman-Zecher argues that Israel’s leaders are responsible for the right wingers’ violence.

“When the leaders of the country call openly for revenge and violence, of course it becomes kosher,” he says, adding. “You have members of Knesset calling for population transfer, [a former] member of Knesset [boasting] that [he] killed Arabs…I believe very strongly that discourse shapes reality.”


Palestinian citizens have also been arrested for “incitement” for calling for demonstrations against Operation Protective Edge. Adalah Legal Center for Arab Minority Rights in Israel points out that these citizens “were arrested even before any demonstrations began.”

Among them is Rafaat Awaishi who Israeli police put on house arrest, without a hearing, after he posted a call on Facebook for people to join protests against Israel’s assault on Gaza.

Noting that Awaishi’s hearing was scheduled for July 13, “the same day that the police-imposed house arrest is to end,” Adalah called the police-imposed detention a “denial of due process.”

Palestnians living in Israel take part in a protest against the attack on Gaza in the city of Lod, Israel, August 3, 2014 (photo: Activestills)

Palestnians living in Israel take part in a protest against the attack on Gaza in the city of Lod, Israel, August 3, 2014 (Activestills)

The conditions detainees face also seem intended to deter protests. Several of Arshid’s clients have been beaten while in custody, she says, and have needed medical treatment for their injuries. During an interrogation, police allegedly removed a detainee’s kuffiyeh, urinated on it, and then put it back on the man’s neck.

Police attempts to intimidate the country’s Palestinian population are not limited to detentions. Last week, Arshid saw police harass a Palestinian teenager in Nazareth. The boy was walking down the street when an unmarked car stopped and three heavily armed men, one wearing a kippah, got out. The men, who turned out to be plainclothes policemen, “terrified the boy,” Arshid reports, adding that he was a minor. “They took pictures of him and screamed at him.”

“I thought it was another Shuafat,” Arshid says, referring to the kidnapping and murder of 16-year-old Mohammed Abu Khdeir.

When she attempted to intervene, the policemen showed Arshid their identification. She informed them that their actions were illegal, explaining that according to Israeli law, police can only stop someone if they “have the suspicion that something criminal is going on. In this case, it was [a boy] walking with a kuffiyeh.”

The police then detained Arshid for several hours before releasing her.

The arrests and detentions seem to be part of a broader crackdown on dissent and freedom of expression. Last Wednesday, the Israeli Knesset heard a bill that proposes to outlaw “discrimination against soldiers in uniform” the Jerusalem Post reported.

Pnina Tamnu-Shata, the Knesset Member who presented the bill, pointed to protests against Operation Protective Edge as proof that “We must set limits for words of incitement against soldiers. Not everything is allowed in the name of democracy.”

Police arrest a Palestinian-Israeli protester during a demonstration against Operation Protective Edge in Haifa.

Police arrest a Palestinian-Israeli protester during a demonstration against Operation Protective Edge in Haifa (photo: ActiveStills)

Palestinian citizens who attend Israeli universities have already been subject to disciplinary hearings and expulsion due to remarks made on Facebook against Israeli soldiers. In a letter to the Council of Higher Education in Israel, the Association of Civil Rights in Israel (ACRI) likened the universities’ monitoring of Palestinian students’ social media accounts to a “witch hunt.”

In a press release, ACRI stated that:

…only Arab students have been punished, even though the social forums are simmering with racist comments by Jewish students, which raises a concern that the heads of the institutions are acting according to patriotic and emotional motives that do not align with their professional obligations.

Arshid levels similar criticism at the Israeli police and the state: “They misunderstand their job – their first job is to protect their civilians and their freedom of speech.”

However, according to Arshid, “The state’s first claim is that the political situation is more important than the freedom of speech.”

Saher Jeries is a 22-year-old marketing and advertising student who lives in Haifa. He says he was at a protest there, standing towards the back, when police officers began to beat him. He and other protesters were taken to a bus where they were held for six hours before they were driven to the police station for interrogation.

During questioning, Jeries found that the Israeli police are not only trying to control the discourse about Gaza, but they also seemed intent on reshaping his identity.

“They said to me, ‘You’re Christian, why are you doing things like this?’ As though I’m not part of the [Palestinian] people.”

A shorter version of this article was first published on Al Jazeera English

Following wave of protests, Israel arrests scores of Arab activists, minors
Unprecedented violence stalks anti-war demos across Israel
The night it became dangerous to demonstrate in Tel Aviv

Newsletter Banner 2 - 540

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article

    * Required


    1. Whiplash

      Freedom of speech does not mean freedom to riot. The writer might have mentioned along with the illegal protests that many protests have been violent. Police have an obligation to maintain law and order, even in Israeli Arab areas. For instance, i24 news reported on the protests as riots on July 8, 2014:

      “Protesters also lobbed stones and firebombs at police in several east Jerusalem neighborhoods.

      Riots were also reported in Nazareth and a few other towns and villages in the north, as well in Israel’s south, near the Bedouin village of Ar’ara. Outside the southern city of Beersheba, masked men threw firebombs at cars. Dozens have been arrested in the clashes.

      Since the riots erupted on Friday, 220 suspects have been arrested and 36 policemen have been slightly wounded.”

      On June 19, 2014 some Arab Israelis clashed violently with the police and 29 arrests were made.

      Similarly the Times of Israel reported on hundreds of Arab Israelis rioting in Nazareth on July 21, 2014.

      If Arab Israelis engage in illegal and/or violent protests, they should not be surprised to be arrested. If they rally for Hamas and incite violence or hatred they might find themselves arrested. Of course, if they had gone out in Gaza to protest for Israel they would have been killed as collaborators.

      Reply to Comment
      • Goldmarx

        Are Palestinians killed as collaborators by Hamas because they participate in an anti-government rally, or for other reasons?

        Did most such collaborators ever attend such rallies, or did they in fact help the IDF?

        In the struggle against South African apartheid, it was common for black collaborators with the Boers to be killed, usually by tires put around their necks and then being set afire. The practice was called ‘necklacing’.

        Reply to Comment
      • Reza Lustig

        What exactly has this got to do with the subject of this article?

        Reply to Comment
    2. J P

      How do you in the name of journalism write an article and not even include the spectrum of information…. Such as Hamas executing “collaborators” or threatening to kill journalists in Gaza that report their “activities”. You HAVE the freedom to write what you wish but at least be intellectually honest and title the article appropriately : “Propaganda”

      Reply to Comment
      • The Trespasser

        Honest? Please. A honest person would not refer to Israeli Arabs as “Palestinian citizens of Israel”.

        Reply to Comment
    3. Joel


      @Hamas cracks down on dissent too.

      Reply to Comment
      • Scootalol

        I’m so glad to know that Israel, “the light unto nations,” is setting its standards by the actions of the likes of hamas. What next, seeking legitimization through hte actions of ISIS? “Oh, it’s only a LITTLE cannibalism!”

        Reply to Comment
        • Joel


          And what nation do you belong to?

          Reply to Comment
          • Reza Lustig

            Obviously one that does not play the “they do it too!” card when it acts like a fascist country.

            Reply to Comment
          • Joel


            Hey. I went to American U. too!

            Reply to Comment
          • Reza Lustig

            What class (year of graduation)?

            Reply to Comment
    4. Craig Vale

      The risible claim is often made as a defense to heavy criticism when Israel begins to run amok, is for supporters of Israel’s brutality, to come forth in chorus and declare Israel to be a ” Democracy” modified frequently with the words ” The Only democracy in all of the Middle East.” It seems that old adage of if you say it loud and long enough the protestation somehow becomes true. Nothing could be further from the truth . Oligarchy is more apropos and one could argue that the Likud’s right wingers run the government more in line with that of a monarchy. One only needs to Google ” Is Israel a true Democracy?) to see a plethora of entries that cite examples of the State of Israel being anything but a democracy.
      The claim is a Hasbaran underpinning that is a building block for the propaganda machine that would make Leni Riefenstahl proud and have Joseph Goebells standing to applaud the efforts of the Hasbaran minions the world over.Not since Otto Preminger’s ” Exodus” and Montavanni’s orchestra playing ” This land is my land” has the propagandist BS hit such a high crescendo. For those who may be interested in the answer to the question of ” Democracy” link below.


      Reply to Comment