+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

Israel cannot evade responsibility for the catastrophe in Gaza

A top Israeli news correspondent argues that Israel must form an international coalition to take over Gaza and overthrow Hamas. This concept leaves out decades of Israel’s conduct, which has had very little to do with security and a whole lot to do with punishing Gaza’s residents.

By Amir Rotem

Palestinian protesters chant as they surround a donkey cart loaded with tires during clashes with Israeli troops on the Israeli border with Gaza. December 22, 2017. (Wissam Nassar/Flash90)

Palestinian protesters chant as they surround a donkey cart loaded with tires during clashes with Israeli troops on the Israeli border with Gaza. December 22, 2017. (Wissam Nassar/Flash90)

In his recent column in Yedioth Ahronoth, Channel 10’s chief international correspondent Nadav Eyal suggests a solution to the challenge presented by Gaza. He calls for international mobilization to seize control of the Gaza Strip in order to overthrow Hamas (“in one way or another”), all under the laundered definition of a “humanitarian intervention.” By doing so, Eyal reinforces a highly destructive narrative, which is flawed and incomplete at best. The move he proposes not only absolves Israel of any and all responsibility for the situation in the Strip, it rewards Israel with further avowal of its own victimhood — a card to be pulled out at any time.

Under the ominous headline, “Before Gaza turns into Somalia,” the Palestinian enclave is presented, in keeping with the prevalent Israeli narrative, as some sort of untamed growth that sprang up inconveniently; a spontaneous occurrence that took us by surprise and with which we are sadly compelled to contend because no one else can.

But, wait a minute, why us? It would be far more elegant to have an international force put an end to this inconvenience, one which Eyal joins in framing as a purely military issue. This conceptualization of the situation leaves out decades of Israel’s conduct, which has had very little to do with security and a whole lot to do with punishing Gaza’s residents, policing every aspect of their lives, while reducing their needs to “humanitarian” alone.

The text needs to be unpacked. Eyal opens by ostensibly summarizing the current situation: a “drizzle” of projectiles from the Gaza Strip and the ongoing torture of Israel’s southern communities; Palestinian residents of Gaza killed in protests near the fence (a reminder that these events were sparked by Trump’s declaration on Jerusalem); and the ever-present threat of another round of hostilities.


What is missing so far? Everything that led us to where we were before the U.S. president flicked his match at our flammable region: 50 years of Israeli control, whether by way of physical presence on the ground and military administration of all aspects of civilian life, or by remote control. The contemporary form of Israel’s control over Gaza includes hermetic closure on movement of people and goods, and taking liberties to permit or deny, constrict or release the hold on every last detail involved in leading a normal life.

Israel isn’t a distinguished resident of a respectable neighborhood dealing with an ill-mannered next-door neighbor. Israel is the general contractor and the neighborhood cop. The state of Gaza’s infrastructure, economy, its residents’ health and well-being, are all results of the actions and conduct of Hamas, the Palestinian Authority, Egypt and the international community. But first and foremost, they are the result of Israel’s deliberate, explicit policy, which has always been directed at keeping Gaza residents in a state of survival. Nothing more, nothing less.

Eyal grants Israel and the Arab countries a pass on this “humanitarian intervention,” given the century-long Arab-Jewish conflict. Eyal says that Israel should support the idea because if Gaza plunges into humanitarian disaster, Israel will be held accountable. “Whether it’s right or wrong, that’s what will happen,” he writes. The obvious response is that whether it happens or not, the blame placed on Israel would not be misdirected.

Israel plays a key role in the devastating state of Gaza today, and even now, when there is so much that can be done long before any military invasion, all that Israel’s highest ranking official in charge of Palestinian civilian affairs, the Coordinator of Government Activities in the Territories (COGAT), has done is to write a letter to the UN, alerting it to the deteriorating humanitarian conditions in the Strip. Eyal references this as a way of showing that Israel also understands that there are those who would consider it the responsible party.

Palestinian boys study by candlelight during a power outage in Rafah, southern Gaza Strip on March 14, 2015. (Abed Rahim Khatib /Flash90)

Palestinian boys study by candlelight during a power outage in Rafah, southern Gaza Strip on March 14, 2015. (Abed Rahim Khatib /Flash90)

The text in its entirety is extremely disconcerting, not only because of the “humanitarian” war proposed by Eyal, but also because of its revision of power relations, letting Israel off the hook for its actions that severely violate the human rights of millions of people. Eyal isn’t the first herald of dark prophecies regarding Gaza’s future, while invoking the names of failed states. He has chosen Somalia and South Sudan, whose stories he knows well.

Gaza is neither of these. The majority of its population is made up of young, educated people with a thirst for life; keenly aware of everything that life in the 21st century has to offer, but suffocated by conditions that bear resemblance to the Middle Ages. What they need is a chance to live life the way they want and know how to. What they require are the conditions to do so. Presenting them as a dangerous, homogenous mass is both dehumanizing, and a great disservice to the truth.

Amir Rotem is the director of Gisha’s public department. This article was first published in Hebrew on Local Call. Read it here.

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article

    * Required


    1. Bruce Gould

      Facts on Gaza from IMEU: https://imeu.org/article/the-crisis-in-gaza

      The immediate cause of the current crisis in Gaza is the West Bank-based Palestinian Authority’s efforts to pressure its rival Hamas and to curry favor with the Trump administration. However, the appalling conditions that the nearly 2 million Palestinians in Gaza are forced to endure are ultimately the result of 50 years of Israeli military rule over the tiny coastal enclave and a cruel and illegal siege and naval blockade that Israel has imposed since 2007, an act of collective punishment that amounts to a war crime. (Although Israel withdrew some 8,000 illegal settlers in 2005, it continues to militarily occupy Gaza according to international law because it maintains control over virtually all entry and exit from Gaza as well as its coastline and airspace.)

      Reply to Comment
    2. Ben

      “aware of everything that life in the 21st century has to offer, but suffocated by conditions that bear resemblance to the Middle Ages”

      Leave it to Israel to lay siege to a place, besiege it, in classic medieval fashion, but pose as the victim and the humanitarian, and as the one who “gave them back their land and this is the thanks we get.” (While also omitting the fact that it teamed up with the U.S. to stage a coup, to overthrow a democratically elected government.) I tell you, nothing about the occupation is honest.

      Reply to Comment
      • Ben

        Here’s another medieval siege in progress, in the West Bank, courtesy of the Israeli occupation authorities:

        Israeli military digs deep trenches to prevent access to communities of Masafer Yatta

        “These communities are not connected to running water and depend on water delivered in trucks by aid organizations every day. Because of the access restrictions, the organizations have not been able to deliver water since 15 November, and the residents have been suffering a water shortage. On Thursday, 9 November, at 9:00 A.M., military forces equipped with a digger arrived in the area. They blocked off the roads leading from Khirbet Jenbah, Khirbet al-Fakhit and Khirbet al-Halawah to the main road, Route 317, with dirt piles and rocks. This prevented residents from accessing the main road, but did not prevent travel between the communities. After the military left, residents partially opened the roadblocks, allowing cars to get through. On 15 November, the military returned and blocked the roads again. The military also gradually blocked off the roads linking between the communities….”

        Reply to Comment
    3. Catena Santoro

      This article makes a good point, but it is too kind towards Israel.
      It states exactly what Palestine should do…not Israel…Palestine should Create an international coalition and take back the occupied territories from Israel without force but with a strong sweep… Israel knows the world does not approve of its bullying and war crimes…so it might try to pull some fast move.

      Reply to Comment

The stories that matter.
The missing context.
All in one weekly email.

Subscribe to +972's newsletter