How a Galilee Palestinian beat the odds to become an Arab Idol finalist | +972 Magazine How a Galilee Palestinian beat the odds to become an Arab Idol finalist

+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

How a Galilee Palestinian beat the odds to become an Arab Idol finalist

On his way to the finale of one of the most important shows in the Arab world, Haitham Khalailah had to deal with the Shin Bet, restrictions on the movement of Palestinian citizens and the fraught connection between Palestinians in Israel and the rest of the Middle East. Will he be the second Palestinian in a row to be crowned winner?

By Yael Marom and Henriette Chacar

Haitham Khalailah, a 24-year-old Palestinian singer from Majd al-Krum, competed Friday night in the finale of Arab Idol – the most popular singing competition in the entire Arab world. Hundreds of millions of viewers will have to decide by Saturday night whether Khalailah — who was able to unite Palestinians in the occupied territories, Israel and around the world — should win. The other two finalists are Hazem al-Sharif of Syria and Majd al-Madani from Saudi Arabia.

Haitham sang two songs in the semifinals, the first of which was Saber Ruba’i’s “Ahla Nisaa al-Dunia” (“The most beautiful women in the world”), followed by “‘Ala Dal’ona,” one of the most important and well-known Palestinian folk songs, which had the entire studio audience on their feet.

Khalailah performs “‘Ala Dal’ona” during the Arab Idol semifinals:

Khalailah began his Arab Idol journey alongside Manal Moussa, another contestant from the north who caused quite a bit of controversy and was subsequently voted off in the quarterfinals. Moussa took a different approach than Khalailah, and succeeded in angering just about everyone.

Moussa started off strong, and seemed like she had a very good chance of reaching the finals. But something happened along the way, likely due to her political, pro-Palestinian rhetoric – which may have been used to get more votes – and the rhetoric of her family members, which contradicted her stance.

Two months ago we wrote about the complexities of Manal and Haitham’s appearance on the show, which included dealing with the Shin Bet, restrictions on the movement of Palestinian citizens of Israel and the fraught connection between Palestinian in Israel and the Arab world.

Read more: Representing Palestine, not Israel: Arab Idol’s contestants from Israel

While the songs and performances are the most central element of the show, Arab Idol also serves as the political focal point of the Arab world. And Khalailah is the shining hope of the Palestinians, who have experienced unrelenting attacks in the past months — from a full-scale operation in the West Bank, to the brutal assault on Gaza to full-blown hate speech and racism against Palestinians in Israel. Khalailah’s presence on the show emphasizes the connection between Palestinians that exists across the world.

’48 Palestinian Arab Idol contestants Manal Moussa and Haitham Khalailah. (Screenshots from Arab Idol, MBC)

’48 Palestinian Arab Idol contestants Manal Moussa and Haitham Khalailah. (Screenshots from Arab Idol, MBC)

But Haitham’s support should not be taken for granted. Until several years ago, Palestinians with Israeli citizenship were seen as near-traitors among other Palestinians and much of the Arab world. This time, even during the initial stages of the show, Gaza’s Mohammad Assaf, who was crowned last season’s Arab Idol (and the first Palestinian to win the competition), openly supported the Palestinians contestants. He did not question their identity and did not hesitate from treating them as his natural successors.

Haitham Khalailah and Mohammad Assaf:

The fact that Haitham made it to Arab Idol is in itself a clear-cut political declaration on the part of the Arab world, as well as by Palestinian contestants who insist on maintaining their connection to the Arab world. Haitham, like Majd Kayyal before him, is part of a group of young Palestinians in Israel who are crossing borders and refusing to give up their identities, as well as their cultural and national connection to Arabs across the globe.

Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas was the first to grant legitimacy to Manal and Haitham. The leader of the Palestinian Authority took an unusual step by giving each of them official Palestinian travel documents, which allowed them to reach Beirut. It is well-known that Abbas does not generally insist on maintaining a connection with Palestinian citizens of Israel, and that he doesn’t see them as an integral part of his political decisions. His decision to support Manal and Haitham shows that the connection between Palestinians is stronger than any peace process or border. Abbas is also contemplating opening free Palestinian phone lines for open voting, just as he did when Mohammad Assaf competed in the finals.

Palestinians within Israel have been campaigning for Haitham over the past week, and have even launched an online campaign that brings together artists, media personalities, lecturers, soccer players and business people in support of their representative on the show.

Chances are that Haitham will compete head-to-head with the talented Syrian contestant, who has also received a great deal of support. The Saudi contestant, who some say reached the finale due to his strong financial backing, will most likely not win. Despite the tragedies that have befallen the region, Arab Idol and its finalists prove that life goes on, and that people must find ways to keep struggling. The Arab world will have to make both an artistic and political decision. Perhaps this will be the second year in a row that a Palestinian is crowned winner.

Yael Marom is Just Vision’s public engagement manager and a co-editor of Local Call, where this article was first published in Hebrew.

Born and raised in Jaffa, Henriette Chacar is an aspiring journalist. She is fascinated by Palestinian identity on local, regional and global levels. Aside from writing, she is active in various regional cooperation and community development initiatives. Follow her on Twitter: @HenrietteChacar.

Related:
Representing Palestine, not Israel: Arab Idol’s contestants from Israel
After ‘Arab Idol’ win, Gaza goes to sleep with hope
‘The Shin Bet was very nice, and therein lies their racism’

Newsletter banner 6 -540

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article
  • LEAVE A COMMENT

    * Required

    COMMENTS

      • Beautiful voice and music – do you have a link to a translation in English? Thanks –

        Reply to Comment
    1. sh

      I puzzled about this already last year, and supposed, perhaps wrongly, that Palestinians with Israeli citizenship were excluded from voting. But the fact that this year’s finalist is my compatriot reminded me of my question again. The TV audience all over the Arab world will choose a winner tonight. How does that work for Israelis? Can Haitham’s local fans, friends and family from Majdal Kurum vote for him?

      Reply to Comment
    2. suzan

      Haith
      aaaaaaaaam all palastein with you

      Reply to Comment
    3. Ida

      “Moussa started off strong, and seemed like she had a very good chance of reaching the finals. But something happened along the way, likely due to her political, pro-Palestinian rhetoric – which may have been used to get more votes –”
      What a spectacularly condescending and insinuating article. If this is how liberal Jews in Israel talk about Palestinians then Israel is truly a lost cause.

      Reply to Comment
      • Baladi Akka 1948

        Yep, I was astonished by that too. Particularly that one of the authors is a Palestinian from Yaffa.
        I’ve seen almost all of Manal Moussa’s performances, also when she sang nationalistic Palestinian songs and was dressed in the thawb and did the victory-sign. All four judges were totally supportive of her, and Ahlam declared that she’s ‘bint filasteen’ herself. She went on stage, and they hugged, Manal was crying…. and so was I.
        http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rIrzlHfWHu8

        Reply to Comment
      • Sluggo

        It seems like Manal Moussa made cynical use of politics during her time in the show. Research a little bit, the facts are available. What is wrong with the authors mentioning this?

        Reply to Comment
        • Baladi Akka 1948

          “It seems like ….”
          You apparently didn’t follow the show, do you even understand Arabic ?
          Manal Mousa represented Palestine ! Her rhetoric was no more ‘pro-Palestinian’ than Mohammed Assaf last year who sang many patriotic songs too, who spoke/sang about the plight of the Palestinians, the political prisoners etc.
          back.
          The fact is that many don’t appeciate Palestinian citizens of Israel claiming their Palestinian identity ‘too loudly’.

          Reply to Comment
          • Sluggo

            I am trying to follow your argument. Are you suggesting that she was voted off because she lacked talent?

            Reply to Comment
          • Baladi Akka 1948

            And I’m trying to figure out whether you’re a troll or just a troll.

            Reply to Comment