+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

Gaza becomes Syria: Middle East geopolitics 2.0

The bickering between countries over who has the right to negotiate over the Palestinians is nothing new. We’ve been here before.

By Aziz Abu Sarah and Dr. Marc Gopin

There are two main camps involved in negotiating a ceasefire agreement between Hamas and Israel. However, the players are not within the camp that most would have expected. What started as Israel vs. Hamas is quickly becoming a geopolitical issue involving many new actors. While this might seem good for some, it should be seen as terrible news for Palestinians and Israelis alike.

Israel, Egypt and the PLO seem to be in one camp supporting the Egyptian ceasefire proposal, and Saudi Arabia might be there as well. That camp calls for an immediate ceasefire and for all issues to be negotiated in Egypt after the ceasefire is achieved. In the other camp stands Hamas, Qatar and Turkey. They oppose the Egyptian ceasefire because it does not address the blockade on Gaza.

UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon meets with U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry in Jerusalem on Wednesday, July 23, 2014. (photo: U.S. Embassy)

UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon meets with U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry in Jerusalem on Wednesday, July 23, 2014. (photo: U.S. Embassy)

There is a third camp that includes U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry and some other international figures, who are trying to figure out how to bring these two camps to agree on one formula for a ceasefire, but are managing to get everyone angry instead. Complicating things is a reported $11 billion defense deal between the United States and Qatar, which prompts some to question what’s going on in terms of everyone’s interests.

The problem with these new alignments is that Hamas vs. Israel is now becoming a geopolitical conflict that includes countries that have become bitter enemies. Qatar and Turkey’s support for the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt, and the opposition to Sisi, the current Egyptian president, is positioning them on the rejectionist side of any proposal that Egypt would propose. Egypt, on the other hand, does not want Qatar or Turkey to have any regional influence on its borders – certainly not in Gaza. Sisi’s strategy has been to pressure Hamas to accept his proposal by limiting aid coming from other Arab countries, such as the Tunisian aid  that was not allowed into Gaza last week. However, Egypt marginalized Hamas to a point of complete mistrust when it did not speak to its leaders directly about the first ceasefire proposal.

Secretary Kerry’s efforts have not lead to any concrete agreements yet. According to Haaretz writer Barak Ravid, the Israeli government was shocked by his ceasefire proposal. According to Ma’an News Agency, the PLO was furious that Kerry would undermine the Egyptian proposal and side with the Turkish-Qatari proposal.

The bickering between the Arab and Muslim states over who has the right to negotiate over the Palestinians is nothing new. Palestinians have paid the price for the Arab and Muslim geopolitical infighting for decades. Unfortunately, some Palestinian leaders are allowing the Palestinian case to be used in this geopolitical fight.

We have seen this movie before. Some of the same players involved in “helping” Gaza are also involved in Syria. Different proposals, never-ending talks and negotiations. The end of the matter is that regional interests trump the Syrian interest for most of these countries. Three years on Syria is divided, broken in small “states,” with over 160,000 killed and millions  displaced or made refugees. All the promises for support faded away. Syrian civilians are the ones who paid the price.

           Click here for +972′s full coverage of the war in Gaza

Today this same is happening in Gaza. ISIL, the Islamic State of Iraq and Levant, is already reported to have a presence in Gaza and is likely to try to take power from Hamas. While all the other regional powers are arguing about which “proposal” for a ceasefire should be accepted, more than 1,040 Palestinians have been killed and 6,000 injured, with 44 Israelis killed as well. If this conflict continues with the same intensity for 12 months, there will be 24,000 Palestinian killed with 72,000 injured. Gaza today lies in ruins, and more than 170,000 have been made homeless. It will take years to rebuild what was destroyed in two weeks.

Hopefully, a ceasefire will be finalized soon and the regional powers will stop playing with Palestinian lives for their own political self-interests. But let’s remember that the ceasefire will not end the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Perhaps the main problem with the ceasefire negotiations is that they ignore the underlying issues. While a ceasefire will allow Israelis to slip back into normal lives, it will keep Palestinians under occupation both in Gaza and the West Bank.

It also ignores that the next generation is comprised of children who have seen three wars in six years. Kids in Gaza only know Israelis from the destruction of their cities, and the deaths of their family members. Kids in Israel only know Palestinians from the sound of sirens. So, unless we change course, we can expect a similarly ugly confrontations very soon.

Marc Gopin is the James Laue Professor of World Religions, Diplomacy and Conflict Resolution at George Mason University in Washington D.C. He is also the co-founder of MEJDI Tours.

Obama calls on Netanyahu to accept unconditional humanitarian ceasefire; 15 killed in Gaza
PHOTOS: Gazans use ‘ceasefire’ to pick up the pieces

Newsletter banner 6 -540

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article

    * Required


    1. Craig Vale

      Syria 2.0 , An apt description to say the least. The images of ongoing sheer butchery is appalling and seemingly falls on deaf ears of many an Israeli. 3 Israeli civilian death and 40 or so IDF members as opposed to an astounding civilian death toll well over 840 Gazan’s targeted by airstrikes meant to harvest the most copious amounts of blood to instill fear amongst the populous in hopes of having them turn against Hamas.
      This is a most cynical political calculation by Netanyahu who finds himself in political peril at home. He either goes all in with a massive invasion or he backs down. The latter will spell his political demise for sure as Israeli lust for Gazan blood and Gazan land is insatiable.
      The bigger picture being the policy of a greater Israel as evidenced by settlement activity that goes on unabated. Palestinians are being slaughtered in disproportionate numbers to satisfy the desire for more and more land in which to claim for the rouge nation of Israel. It has now become a frenzy of violence even worse than what is witnessed in Syria as Bashir drops bombs in the hopes of killing rebels whereas Bibi is consciously bombing and killing civilians with the sole purpose of attempting to get them to turn on Hamas. An historical miscalculation on Netanyahu’s part that will forever place him among the worst that mankind enshrines as butchers. Sadly, he wears that badge proudly.

      Reply to Comment
    2. Whiplash

      During the so-called Humanitarian ceasefire, Hamas has rocketed and mortared Southern Israel. It is now being reported that 4 Israelis in the Eshkol region have been killed and others injured in a direct strike by mortars on a house.

      Let there be no mistake, the IDF is in Gaza to take away Hamas’ ability to target Israel’s population and to kill them as happened today.

      President Obama and John Kerry can share in the blame for today’s tragedy. By their negotiations with Qatar, who funds Hamas terror, and Turkey which morally supports Hamas, they encouraged Hamas to fight on. Many more will no die because they meddled in middle east politics.

      Israel needs to finish the job no matter what pressure is brought to bear from hypocrites like President Obama and John Kerry.

      Reply to Comment
      • CigarButNoNice

        “It is now being reported that 4 Israelis in the Eshkol region have been killed”

        According to our moral betters here: Too few dead Jews. Isn’t the spreadsheet approach to morality great? /heavy sarc

        Don’t try winning sympathy by pointing out Jewish victims to the anti-Zionists, Whiplash. The fact is they think every Israeli Jew deserves it for “being in the wrong place,” “stealing land” &c. It’s not about the moral hardware, it’s about the operating system.

        “No matter what pressure is brought to bear from hypocrites like President Obama and John Kerry.”

        Or Western Leftist useful idiot shills of Arab imperialism like the denizens of this site.

        Reply to Comment
        • Whiplash

          Not even the fact that Hamas/Islamic Jihad killed 10 Palestinian children on a playground next to the al-Shifa hospital today with one of their rockets will shake the beliefs of the Arab shills or western extreme leftists. These very same people ignored the fact by the end of 2011 Hamas had killed 160 Palestinian children working in its tunnels. Western leftists will not question what Hamas was doing in using child labor in digging its tunnels or why children were playing next to Hamas’ military compound that also doubles as Gaza’s major hospital.

          Reply to Comment
    3. JG

      Funny watch this Hasbara clown doing his work by pretending to be 2 persons…pathetic

      Reply to Comment