+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

Black labor: How a white elite uses black soldiers to enforce its will

A new photo project focuses on the soldiers of Israel’s Border Police, the main military unit used to enforce the occupation of the Palestinians. Shot in various locations across Israel and the occupied Palestinian territories, ‘Black Labor’ looks at the points of impact where Israel’s elite pits black Jews against Palestinians.

Photos by Mati Milstein, text by Tom Mehager

An Ethiopian Border Police officer fires tear gas canisters in the village of Nabi Saleh, 2010. (photo: Mati Milstein)

Nabi Saleh, 2010. (photo: Mati Milstein)

Mati Milstein’s “Black Labor” project reveals the face of the “Second Israel,” the antithesis of those Israelis who have always been viewed as the “salt of the earth.” When the parents of those photographed arrived to this country, the establishment viewed them as both morally and intellectually inferior — people who need to be re-socialized in order to become a part of the State of Israel’s moral regime.

Take, for instance, the first leaders of the Education Ministry. Back in 1945 Eliezer Riger, one of the foremost proponents of vocational education — and who would eventually come to head the Education Ministry — spoke of the need to separate Mizrahim (Jews from Arab and Muslim countries) and Ashkenazim (Jews of European origin): “Pre-vocational [education] leadership could bring a special blessing to the Oriental population, after all… the Oriental children, at least most of them, do not know how to appreciate simplified learning and cannot derive actual uselessness from non-practical education.”

Sheikh Jarrah, Jerusalem, 2011. (photo: Mati Milstein)

Sheikh Jarrah, Jerusalem, 2011. (photo: Mati Milstein)

At the end the 1950s, the head of the ministry, Yaakov Sarid, said that the government must erect a “dam to prevent the storming of academic high schools by all elementary school graduates.” The State of Israel effectively prevented parents from sending their children to academic high schools. It continues to do so today.

Then education minister Zalman Aren praised the new collective that the state was helping establish: “During my visits to the pre-vocational classes, I saw a process of merging the Diaspora communities. And the purpose is not necessarily merging children from the East with those of the West. I am speaking about merging children from the different Muslim countries.”

Hebron, 2011. (photo: Mati Milstein)

Hebron, 2011. (photo: Mati Milstein)

Meanwhile Ashkenazim spent their time in both separate educational frameworks and different military tracks. One does not need a photo series featuring the graduates of Israel’s Army Radio, as they appear on our television screens at nearly every hour of the day. The members of the”First Israel” — whether they are from the right, left, or center — speak proper Hebrew, do not sweat in the sun, are featured in gossip columns, and most importantly, are white. Very white.

Thus we are not speaking of an “invisible hand” that pushes all Mizrahi teenagers to enlist in the Border Police, while Ashkenazi teens are enlisted into Army Radio or any other unit that offers them a promising future after their service. This is the very same policy enacted by the Ashkenazi establishment that earmarks all the black labor jobs to Mizrahim and Ethiopian Israelis.

Hebron, 2011. (photo: Mati Milstein)

Hebron, 2011. (photo: Mati Milstein)

Milstein’s photos are a response to all those who claim they are “colorblind,” as well as those who carry the red flag of socialism. The correlation between class and ethnicity in Israel can be found everywhere — denying that correlation subverts any opportunity for real change. Thus in one of the photos we can see anarchist activists holding signs condemning the Border Police as “terrorists.” On the face of it, they look like a group of political activists taking part in a just protest.

Tel Aviv, 2006. (photo: Mati Milstein)

Tel Aviv, 2006. (photo: Mati Milstein)

In reality, however, they are realizing the dream of David Ben-Gurion, calling the Border Police “terrorists” just as Israel’s first prime minister viewed Mizrahi soldiers as capable of rape and murder simply due to their ethnic origin. In 1950 he went so far as saying: “The ingathering of the exiles has brought us a rabble… we must educate the young man who has come here from these countries to sit properly on a chair in his home, take a shower, not steal, not capture an Arab teenager and rape her and murder her.”

Abu Dis, Jerusalem, 2004. (photo: Mati Milstein)

Abu Dis, Jerusalem, 2004. (photo: Mati Milstein)

In a sense there are two main aspects to this kind of educational tracking. The path that was paved for Mizrahi teenagers to become the Zionist regime’s black laborers not only launched them into an inferior economic reality, it also housed them in Israel’s periphery and degraded their culture. Moreover, it cemented them as morally inferior. During the Eichmann trial, famed Jewish philosopher Hannah Arendt wrote the following: “My first impression. On the top, the judges, the best of German Jewry. Below them the prosecuting attorneys, Galicians, but still Europeans. Everything is organized by a police force that gives me the creeps. Speaks only Hebrew and looks Arabic. Some downright brutal types among them. They would obey any order.”

The irony is especially bitter when considering the context in which these words were written. The whitest man in room is being put on trial for obeying any order, but the framing of these events has yet to change.* Not only does Zionism necessitate a working class that will shoulder the burden of policing and maintaining order, it necessitates an underclass of moral inferiority. It necessitates a stable group that can be easily identified, and can be condemned and blamed for the ills of society. It is desirable to feel disgusted by a group of “brutish and uneducated Border Police officers,” who are diametrically opposed to “the beautiful ones.” This is how the disgusted can maintain his superiority.

Nabi Saleh, 2010. (photo: Mati Milstein)

Nabi Saleh, 2010. (photo: Mati Milstein)

How comfortable it is to forget or turn a blind eye. But in the end, ignoring reality is impossible: one of the photos shows two Palestinian women confronting armed Israeli soldiers during just another day of military control in the West Bank. It looks as if they are saying to the soldiers, to the photographer, and to me: “These problems between you Jews, they are yours. What the hell do you want from us?”

*Thanks to Lihi Yona for providing her thoughts on Arendt

Stop blaming Mizrahim for everything wrong in Israel
Why Mizrahim don’t vote for the Left
The struggle for Mizrahi recognition isn’t limited to Israel

Mati Milstein is a photojournalist who has been documenting Israeli society and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict since 1998. Visit his website here. Tom Mehager works for Adalah – The Legal Center for Arab Minority Rights in Israel. This article was first published in Hebrew on Haokets.

Newsletter banner

For additional original analysis and breaking news, visit +972 Magazine's Facebook page or follow us on Twitter. Our newsletter features a comprehensive round-up of the week's events. Sign up here.


    * Required


    1. Jason Kidd

      More pathetic divide and conquer attempts by the I hate Israel crowd
      You know when the race card is puiled, there are no completing arguments

      Reply to Comment
      • Ben

        This by Kidd is a simplistic forcing of an American right-wing Republican mindset about “the race card” upon a complex Israeli reality. The Israeli reality is a far more complicated and deep seated one, involving a complicated mix of nationalism, religion and culture.

        This piece by Haokets is one of at least three in an excellent series on “the white tribe.” See the recent articles by Seth Frantzman and Elad Wolf. These are penetrating analyses that get to the deeper issues of race in Israel. A complicated subject. This “white tribe” series follows on the excellent “License to Kill”series.

        +972 deserves recognition at the Sokolow or Pulitzer Prize level. In a just world it would be nominated and receive it.

        Reply to Comment
        • Gustav

          The words of Sawsan Khalife, Ben’s heroine, the one who is taking over from his other hero, Sheizaf…

          “SK: I think we can’t as Palestinians bid for statehood unless all Palestine is reunited. Maybe Palestinians can benefit from the bid. But the West Bank is not Palestine. I see the Galilee, al-Quds [Jerusalem], Haifa and Acre also as part of Palestine. We can ask for independence when we have reunited our land. After we have gained control over the air, the sea, the borders, we can be independent. I see the statehood bid as a bit of an illusion. Abu Mazen’s [Mahmoud Abbas’s] approach is not at the right time.”

          Yet Ben, doggedly maintains that his saintPalestinians are not out to try to destroy the Jewish majority state.

          Ben is a propagandist and a liar. He thinks that other people don’t notice his lies.

          Reply to Comment
        • Jason Kidd

          “+972 deserves recognition at the Sokolow or Pulitzer Prize level. In a just world it would be nominated and receive it.”

          Oh Ben, queen of drama

          First, 972 does not meet the qualIfictions for such a prize

          Secondly. Please tell us. How is the unjust world keeping 972 from such prizes? I can’t wait to hear this conspiracy theory.

          Reply to Comment
    2. Isaac

      Ashkenazi Jews are not Khazars, every genetic study has shown they are racially the same as sefaradim. Mostly middle eastern, with some italian, greek, and other mediterranean genes.

      That is why so many ashkenazim are brown, not white.

      Reply to Comment
    3. Mikhael

      All respect to MAGAV Border Police, whatever their background — whether they are of Ethiopian, Russian-Ashkenaxzi, Moroccan or Druze.
      We love you all!

      Reply to Comment