+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

Israel is turning Palestinian students into criminals

Israeli authorities have arrested at least 64 Palestinian university students since the start of 2019. That number is only growing.

By Jaclynn Ashly

Illustrative photo of Israeli soldiers arresting a Palestinian man in the West Bank, on December 8, 2015. (Nati Shohat/Flash90)

Illustrative photo of Israeli soldiers arresting a Palestinian man in the West Bank, on December 8, 2015. (Nati Shohat/Flash90)

Earlier this month, Mais Abu Ghosh, a student at Birzeit University in the West Bank, sent a letter to her family from Damon Prison in northern Israel.

“I love you so much,” Abu Ghosh wrote. “I am fine as long as you and those whom I love are fine […] You are in my mind and my spirit.” She asked her family to send greetings to her university friends and to her professors, “with no exceptions.” She added: “I am with another family now. All difficulties will pass.”

Israeli forces arrested Abu Ghosh in late August. She is one of dozens of Palestinian students who have been detained over the past three months, in a heightened crackdown on students across the occupied West Bank.

According to data collected by Right to Education, a grassroots campaign aimed at defending education in Palestine, Israeli forces have detained at least 64 university students since the start of this year. Eighteen of the detainees are students at Birzeit — the second-largest university in the occupied West Bank.

Israeli authorities routinely arrest politically active Palestinian students, but rights groups say the numbers have increased with the current crackdown.

Escalation in arrests

A spokesperson at Addameer, a Palestinian prisoners’ rights organization, told +972 that Israel has been targeting an increasing number of Palestinian students since the start of 2019. There are currently 260 Palestinian high school and university students in Israeli prisons.

Of the 18 Birzeit students who were arrested in August, Israel has released only three. All of them were taken from their homes during overnight army raids, with Israeli soldiers using “excessive force” in the course of making the arrests, according to Addameer.

Most of the detained Birzeit students are still under interrogation, which could last up to 75 days or be extended to another 90 days. Three of the students have been placed under administrative detention – a policy inherited from the British Mandate, by which Israel holds detainees indefinitely, without charge. It is used almost exclusively against Palestinians.

Addameer has expressed “serious concern for the well-being and health” of the student detainees, noting that many have been prohibited from seeing lawyers and have been subjected to “torture and ill-treatment.”

According to Right to Education, 80 Birzeit students are currently imprisoned by Israel, including 17 who are under administrative detention.

Palestinian students raise their diploma during their graduation ceremony at the end of the academic year on May 20, 2016 at Birzeit University in the West Bank town of Birzeit, near Ramallah. (Flash90)

Palestinian students raise their diploma during their graduation ceremony at the end of the academic year on May 20, 2016 at Birzeit University in the West Bank town of Birzeit, near Ramallah. (Flash90)

Last month, an Israeli military court imposed a gag order on the cases of several Palestinian student detainees who are undergoing interrogations. The gag order is expected to be lifted on Nov. 10.

Addameer said the gag order was a violation of the “basic rights of the prisoner, their family and their lawyer” and an “attempt to cover up grave human rights violations” inflicted on Palestinian prisoners during interrogations.

An Israeli army spokesperson told +972 that the students recently arrested at Birzeit are “suspected of involvement in terror attacks that occurred over the last few months in which Israeli citizens were murdered.” The spokesperson added that they could not provide further information while the cases were being investigated by the Shin Bet — Israel’s internal security agency.

The army spokesperson is most likely referring to an attack that occurred in August, when a 17 year-old Israeli girl named Rina Shnerb was killed by an improvised explosive near Dolev, a settlement located northeast of Ramallah.

Samer Arbeed, 44, has been accused of heading a Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP) cell that allegedly carried out the attack. He was hospitalized in critical condition last month, with broken ribs and kidney failure after torture and severe beatings before and during interrogations carried out by the Shin Bet at the Russian Compound in Jerusalem.

At Hadassah Hospital, Arbeed slipped into a coma and was put on a respirator. Israeli media reported that the Shin Bet had been given legal permission to use “extraordinary measures” during Arbeed’s interrogation.

In a report released last year, Addameer documented Israeli authorities’ systematic use of torture at the Russian Compound, which Palestinians refer to as al-Mascobiyya. Among the types of torture: placing the detainee in solitary confinement and exposing them to sounds of torture from neighboring cells. The cells, according to the report, do not “meet the minimum standards of adequate human living.”

‘Continuous and systematic attacks’

“Palestinian students have faced continuous and systematic attacks” by the Israeli army – particularly at Birzeit, said Yara Hawari, a fellow at the Palestinian think tank Al-Shabaka. A student who is politically active will, she said, “inevitably” have “some kind of encounter with Israeli occupation forces.”

Birzeit has served as a center for Palestinian political, cultural and academic life in the West Bank for decades. Its graduates include prominent Palestinian figures such as Marwan Barghouti, now serving a life sentence in an Israeli jail.

Israeli soldiers patrol Birzeit University, on the outskirts of the city of Ramallah in the West Bank during an operation on June 19, 2014. (Issam Rimawi/Flash90)

Israeli soldiers patrol Birzeit University, on the outskirts of the city of Ramallah in the West Bank during an operation on June 19, 2014. (Issam Rimawi/Flash90)

Since the 1970s, the university has been subject to numerous Israeli army closures, the longest of which lasted for nearly five years, from 1988-92, during the first Palestinian intifada. Students and teachers resisted the closures, holding classes in their homes or outside the closed gates of the university.

“That legacy means that Birzeit has remained a very politically active space,” Hawari said. “It’s a hub of student organizing.”

According to Tahseen Elayyan, who heads the monitoring and documentation department at the Palestinian human rights NGO al-Haq, Birzeit students represent the entire Palestinian political spectrum – both within and outside the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO).

The Palestinian Authority has not held a general election since 2005, which means that residents of the West Bank and Gaza have been prevented from expressing their political views through the democratic process. Student elections at Birzeit have served as an important barometer for the political zeitgeist.

“Birzeit represents a vibrant political Palestinian space that represents the society,” Elayyan said. “This is one of the reasons that make the university the subject of frequent Israeli attacks.”

According to Right to Education, Israeli forces have killed 26 Birzeit University students since 1984, while around 1,000 Birzeit students have been arrested since 2004. Almost invariably, the charge is involvement in terror activities.

Israeli forces have also sent in mista’revim – undercover special forces – onto the Birzeit campus to detain individual students.

In March 2018 Omar Kiswani, the head of Birzeit’s student council and a member of the Islamic Bloc on campus, was detained by mista’revim who gained access to the university campus by posing as journalists. The arrest made international news because students recorded videos of the violent incident on their phones, and these were broadcast by various media outlets. Two students and a university employee were wounded by the arresting forces.

Israeli authorities later said Kiswani was arrested over “suspected involvement in terror activity,” most likely owing to the Islamic Bloc’s association with Hamas, which Israel considers a terrorist organization.

Yara Hawari of Al-Shabaka explained that Israel targets politically active students regardless of any specific affiliation. Arrest campaigns usually come in waves, she said. An arrest of one student is followed by arrests of all the students in their network and their political circle. The recent wave seems to be targeting students suspected of affiliation with the left-wing PFLP. Arrests campaigns are an effective technique to break Palestinian youth, she added.

Targeting the agents of change

Israel’s occupying forces target Palestinian students because they are the voice of change in Palestinian society, said Hawari. At Birzeit, students are active for both political and civil rights, which the occupation tries to criminalize. The purpose of the arrest campaigns, explained Hawari, is to weaken the academic life of Palestinian students. The Shin Bet and the army know that by targeting Palestinian educational institutions they are undermining Palestinian society as a whole, she added.

Palestinian academia suffers greatly from the occupation, said Hawari. Israel has terminated or turned down visas for foreign and Palestinian academics who teach at the universities. None of the international faculty at Birzeit was issued a visa for the 2018-19 academic year; the only exceptions are those who teach or do research under the auspices of programs sponsored by foreign governments.

Israel frequently denies visas to students who wish to study abroad, or attend academic conferences. The intended result of these policies is to isolate Palestinian academia from the outside world.

SUBSCRIBE TO +972 MAGAZINE'S WEEKLY NEWSLETTER

SUBMIT

Nor can Palestinian prisoners complete their education inside Israel’s prisons. Students arrested by Israeli forces typically miss a minimum of one academic semester, while others can wait years in detention. Post-release, trying to pick up where they left off can present immense challenges. Their peers have moved on, or graduated, while they are forced to re-take classes with students who are much younger and who have not had the same life experiences.

The Palestinian Authority uses the same tactic as Israel, arresting politically engaged students to crack down on dissent — especially in cases where it challenges Fatah domination of the political landscape in Palestine. Since the beginning of this academic year the PA arrested 12 students; all of them have since been released. The Voice of Palestinian Students, a student-run Facebook group , has documented five additional arrests by PA forces in October.

Fatah, said al-Haq’s Elayyan, wants “to create an atmosphere in which Fatah always win the elections.”

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article
  • LEAVE A COMMENT

    * Required

    COMMENTS

    1. Lewis from Afula

      You cannot turn a “fakestinyan” student into a criminal.
      The fact that he calls himself / herself “fakestinyan” proves he / she is already a criminal.

      Reply to Comment
    2. Firentis

      So there are terrorists taking studying at Palestinian universities? Not much of a surprise for a society that treats terrorists as heroes and teaches children that the highest virtue is to kill a Jew.

      Reply to Comment
      • Ben

        So there are junior-totalitarian pre-Shin Bet bastards taking studying at Israeli universities? Not much of a surprise for a society that treats East German Stasi-emulating occupation stormtroopers and secret police as heroes and teaches children that the highest virtue is to round up and torture Palestinians, ethnically cleanse them and grab their land. And profess shock when they politically organize and resist. And call it all “terror.”

        Reply to Comment
        • Itshak Gordine

          You are in delirium, Ben. When I was a teenager in Switzerland, some members of the Revolutionary Marxist League used the same terms as you. Are you a teenager?
          You are in delirium, Ben. When I was a teenager in Switzerland, some members of the Revolutionary Marxist League used the same terms as you. Are you a teenager?
          Your outrageous remarks cover you with ridicule. Are you radicalizing yourself?

          Reply to Comment
          • Ben

            Last time I checked Switzerland did not storm into sleeping French villages at 3AM and drag fathers out and haul them away in front of their terrified children, and do this often “just for practice.” Or indefinitely detain children without charge, in order to maintain an illegal occupation of French territory. Nor does Switzerland have a scandalous soldiers’ organization called Breaking the Silence. Nor does Switzerland as far as I know use its intelligence services to torture in basements students who protest the government and those who “have meetings with” “affiliates we don’t like.” Nor capriciously arrest French lawmakers without charge to break their will. Nor does Switzerland coldly blackmail gay people while shouting “look at us, look at us, we are so gay friendly!!!”

            One again Itshak G. Halevy appears to think that people are fools who cannot glean basic information, make basic distinctions, or tell which side is up. Or else this Hardali settler is so tightly sealed inside a hermetic far right messianic echo chamber of “news” that he actually does not know what is going on. Oh wait, he is here most days on +972 for many months now and we will presume he actually reads the articles. So scratch the second hypothesis. Scratch that excuse. Which leads to the conclusion that Dr. Halevy’s misdiagnosing of “teenager delirium” is itself diagnosable as a condition called Querulous Ad Hominemitis.

            Reply to Comment
          • Itshak Gordine

            You live in a dream: Many complaints concern the police of some Swiss cities. Africans were shot dead and teenagers or young adults beaten up. This happened to the son of one of our friends and any complaint is impossible. Searches in France or Switzerland take place in the night or early morning. In the US, in some cities, the police would have the easy trigger with dozens of deaths a year.

            Reply to Comment
          • Ben

            You’re kidding me, right? You’re going to try to tell us that what French and Swiss police do equals what the Israeli army and border police do to the Palestinians? Night in night out, day in day out? What this tells me is that you have a willfully fairy-tale version of the occupation, a fairy-tale version of what the army does in the territories, because you yourself are an army-coddled-and-stroked settler-denizen of those territories.
            You do not rise to the level of a serious interlocutor about this.

            There are parallels to the way the police treat African Americans in America but the parallels go only so far, and the parallels are mainly about racist attitudes and relative carelessness with black lives, but the American police are not hauling in black people and their children for indefinite detention without due process or torturing them in basements to extract information. Or raiding their houses at 3AM and dragging people out just for practice, and dumping the dragged person on the side of the road a mile from their village when “the exercise” is concluded. Get real.

            Reply to Comment