+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

Asylum seekers to stay in prison while Israelis hit the polls

Human rights organizations pledge to challenge the latest iteration of the Prevention of Infiltration Law; new poll gives Livni and Labor a chance; Arab parties agree in principle to a joint list; High Court to hear Zoabi’s challenge to Knesset suspension.

African asylum seekers jailed in Holot detention center protest behind the prison's fence, as other asylum seekers take part in a protest outside the facility, in Israel's southern Negev desert, February 17, 2014.

African asylum seekers jailed in Holot detention center protest behind the prison’s fence, as other asylum seekers take part in a protest outside the facility, in Israel’s southern Negev desert, February 17, 2014.

Before disbanding itself ahead of elections, the Knesset on Monday passed its third try at a law that would keep open Israel’s detention center for African asylum seekers. The High Court of Justice struck down two previous versions of the law as unconstitutional and ordered the Holot open prison closed nearly three months ago.

The law’s fate fell into the hands of recently fired Finance Minister Yair Lapid and his ‘Yesh Atid’ party, who despite no longer being bound by coalition agreements, voted to support the law.

While the new law eases some of the more draconian measures its predecessors embodied, it nevertheless translates into the imprisonment of thousands of asylum seekers who have not been convicted, let alone accused of any crime.

Instead of subjecting African asylum seekers to one year in traditional prison followed by indefinite detention at an “open prison,” as the previous version prescribed, the new law authorizes three months in a closed prison followed by 20 months in the Holot detention facility. (Read the full text of the new law in Hebrew.)

In addition, the new law includes a clause under which the state will confiscate 20 percent of asylum seekers’ salaries, which will be released to them only if and when they leave Israel. The clause, like most of the law, is intended to encourage African asylum seekers to return to the countries from which they fled.

A consortium of Israeli human rights organizations that challenged the two previous versions of the law pledged on Monday night to fight the latest iteration as well, describing the current policy as “incitement and populism.”

“Today, the Knesset approved continuing to debase the High Court, to mislead the residents of southern Tel Aviv and to waste taxpayers’ money on wrong solutions. Incarceration for almost two years in the Holot facility and placing restrictions on employers of asylum-seekers will ensure that the rights of asylum-seekers will continue to be violated, and that the hardships of south Tel Aviv’s residents will only be exacerbated,” the organizations wrote in a statement.

Election season is on

The Knesset floor. (Photo: Itzik Edri/CC)

The Knesset floor. (Photo: Itzik Edri/CC)

Shortly after passing the law, the Knesset unanimously voted to disperse itself, which was the last technical hurdle before general elections could be called.

A new poll on Monday suggested that if Tzipi Livni ran on a joint list with the left-leaning Labor party, they could win more seats than the Likud. Previous polls projected Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s Likud and settler party Jewish Home as the biggest potential winners of new elections.

Polls this early are not very reliable in predicting actual results in the elections, which are still more than three months away. That is especially true considering that party primaries have yet to take place, which means that most parties don’t even have a list of the candidates they are fielding. What has become clear, however, is that Netanyahu is vulnerable and a fourth premiership is not a done deal.

Also on Monday, the Arab parties in the Knesset reached an agreement in principle to run on a joint list, Balad MK Basel Ghattas said. “All those who didn’t want Haneen Zoabi in the Knesset will get us on a list that polls puts us at 14-15 [seats], and it will likely be the fourth-largest list in the Knesset,” he said according to Globes.

At the initiative of Foreign Minister Avigdor Liberman, the Knesset raised the election threshold earlier this year in an attempt to force out smaller parties, primarily MK Zoabi’s Balad. The consolidation of the parties onto one joint list is a direct response to the new threshold.

On Tuesday morning, the High Court of Justice will hear an appeal filed by MK Zoabi against her six-month suspension from Knesset debates. The punishment is the harshest ever handed down by the Knesset Ethics Committee. The suspension came in response to a radio interview in which after condemning the kidnapping of three Israeli teenagers, Zoabi objected to the use of the word “terrorist.”

Pundits’ consensus: Netanyahu is vulnerable
‘Anyone but Bibi’ isn’t the point: Pre-election postulations
Moshe Kahlon for prime minister of Israel

Newsletter banner 6 -540

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article

    * Required


    1. Bruce Goud

      This may be a good time to insert a random thought (feel free to ignore): someone in this discussion seemed to have, er, feelings for Naftali Bennett. This person may be interested in Bennett’s latest adventure – it would be comical if it weren’t tragic.


      Reply to Comment
      • Lo

        You know your train has left the tracks when Haim Saban, Martin Indyk, and Dennis Ross of all people think your views toward the Palestinians are extreme.

        Reply to Comment
      • Brian

        On the subject of feelings and “waxing erotic” and all that, Uri Migav in Haaretz:

        “…If Netanyahu remains the head of Likud, it is possible that Habayit Hayehudi will become the largest right-wing party. Its chairman, Naftali Bennett, is very popular in Israel’s Tea Party, especially among first-time, hormone-driven voters.

        This is regrettable in itself, but in practical terms it’s great news for the center-left. Bennett will in any case take most of his new Knesset seats from Likud, and is still viewed as more extreme than that party. Contrary to initial fears, he’ll never be able to form a coalition. Habayit Hayehudi dreams of annexing the West Bank’s Area C (territory under exclusive Israeli control according to the Oslo Accords), controlling the Justice Ministry and putting Rabbi Avichai Rontzki, the Lord of Hosts’ anointed one, high up on its Knesset slate. These aren’t yet the dreams of mainstream Israelis…”

        Reply to Comment
    2. Ben Zakkai

      The State will confiscate 20% of the already-pathetically-low earnings of asylum seekers as a way of pressuring them into returning to the persecutory hell-holes from which they fled? The parable of the poor man’s sheep has nothing on today’s Israel.

      Reply to Comment
      • Ben – I apologize for going way off topic. Your point is so well made and I jumped at a chance to knock Bennett, which I don’t regret at all, but it wasn’t appropriate for this thread.

        Reply to Comment
        • Ben Zakkai

          No worries, no biggie, have a good day.

          Reply to Comment
    3. Thanks for the link Bruce. Cannot believe the balls on Humpty Dumpty Bennett. “Things take time. I’m not suggesting overnight… We have to change the direction. It’s already working in Israel, now we have only a little thing called the rest of the world. But you have to start somewhere.” Spoken like a true dick-tater.

      Where did he ever get the idea that the only technology in the world comes from Israel. Or the “little thing called the rest of the world” is incapable of producing excellent fruit and veg? That the “little thing called the rest of the world” has no idea to manufacture cardiac stents (guess he isn’t familiar with Medtronic, Mayo Clinic) or microchips (“Silicon Valley”). The world does not rely on the GoI. What a silly buck-toothed, balding, fat jackass. He reminds me of Humpty-Dumpty. This should be on the front page of the New York Times and mainstream media but, oh right, Rupert Murdoch and Sheldon Adelson have the monopoly on news in the US.

      Reply to Comment
    4. Average American

      Great photo of the Knesset Building, paid for by the Rothschild inter-generational banking dynasty, the real power behind Israel. Maybe that’s the real reason America is so careful with Israel, or else we might get our credit cut off.

      Reply to Comment