+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

Arabs in Israel want to join the government. You'll never guess who's stopping them

Joint List Chairman Ayman Odeh said he would be willing to consider joining a center-left coalition, prompting a response from Israel’s centrist party that reveals the true face of those who hope to replace Netanyahu.

Joint List head Ayman Odeh seen during a plenum session in the assembly hall of the Knesset, November 13, 2017. (Yonatan Sindel/Flash90)

Joint List head Ayman Odeh seen during a plenum session in the assembly hall of the Knesset, November 13, 2017. (Yonatan Sindel/Flash90)

I do not know whether Joint List Chairman Ayman Odeh is a diligent paramedic or a doctor preparing for the long-term treatment of a 72-year-old patient suffering from chronic illnesses such as racism and Zionism. In either case, the patient is suddenly showing signs of life.

All it took was a single interview with Odeh with a top journalist in one of Israel’s largest newspapers last week, in which the member of Knesset said he would join a center-left coalition under certain conditions, to throw his party directly into the lion’s den of Jewish Israeli electoral politics.

His first condition for joining the coalition was that the government would work toward ending the occupation and establishing a Palestinian state. This should sound familiar to both Prime Minister Netanyahu — who committed to those very ideas in his Bar Ilan speech — as well as the Labor Party.

But in today’s messianic State of Israel there is no such thing as “ending the occupation” or, God forbid, “peace.” There is annexation, settlements, closure, and managing the occupation under the guise of Trump’s so-called “deal of the century.” There is not a single Zionist party in Israel who speaks about removing settlements or even freezing settlement construction. Odeh’s condition should have taken the option off the table.

Odeh said that under a center-left coalition that would include the Arab parties, Palestinian citizens of Israel would no longer be second-class citizens. Wouldn’t this, as the Balad party has long advocated, be the state of all citizens we all want so badly? After all, the “citizens” Odeh represents also want to be able to rule the country. What’s wrong with that?

Reader survey banner

Unfortunately, Odeh’s vision is unfounded, since the Jewish state is unwilling to allow its non-Jewish citizens to take part in ruling. After all, the mechanisms of the state were built and maintained in order to preserve pure Jewish sovereignty. Balad quickly made clear that it would oppose any government run by what it called “occupying generals,” distancing itself from the leader of the Joint List they belong to.

Yet a quick glance on social media revealed a relatively small number of people who vocally opposed Odeh’s comments. The Islamic Movement and Ahmad Tibi’s Ta’al party, both part of the Joint List as well, did not reject Odeh’s comments. On the one hand, they said they would not oppose joining a center-left coalition or a political alliance that would block the establishment of a right-wing government. On the other hand, they said the conditions for doing so had not yet ripened, adding that discussing the possibility of joining the coalition is not relevant at this time.

It took the Joint List 48 hours to issue an official response to the controversy. By that time, Blue and White, the centrist party that hopes to beat Netanyahu’s Likud party in next month’s elections, had already distanced itself from Odeh and his party, while Likud warned against the possibility that the center would link up with the Arabs. According to the Joint List, Odeh’s statements exposed the way in which both Likud and Blue and White view Israel’s Arab public, saying that the competition between the two is based on the exclusion of Palestinians from the political arena. While Likud wants to disqualify the Joint List from running, Blue and White is simply unwilling to work with Palestinians.

Blue and White leader Benny Gantz seen at an opposition rally in central Tel Aviv, May 25, 2019. (Oren Ziv/Activestills.org)

Blue and White leader Benny Gantz seen at an opposition rally in central Tel Aviv, May 25, 2019. (Oren Ziv/Activestills.org)

The response further stated that the Joint List “will not hesitate to seize any parliamentary opportunity to advance the interests of our people in due course,” and that the its demands from the ruling party will be determined “together” following the results of the upcoming elections. It seems they seem to have forgiven Odeh for “acting out.” From now on, if you believe them, they’re working together.

Odeh’s second, far more realistic condition was to repeal the Jewish Nation-State Law — a demand tens of thousands of Palestinian citizens . But he didn’t stop there: Odeh then proceeded to list a number of demands that don’t actually require him to be part of the coalition, such as stopping the penalization of illegal home construction (which disproportionally affects Palestinian citizens), and putting an end to violence and crime inside the Arab community.

The probability that a center-left coalition will come into being following the elections is close to zero — and not because of the right, which has ruled Israel for nearly 20 years, but because Israel has neither a political center nor a formidable left. Blue and White head Benny Gantz, who is supposed to represent the moderate center, says he will “crush” Gaza. The former IDF chief of staff doesn’t talk about ending the occupation, which he has spent his professional life helping to maintain, and has already stated that he would not sit alongside Arab parties in the government.

The sudden turbulence in this dormant election campaign has, at the very least, revealed the true face of all those who purport to be able to replace the right. It is also an opportunity to remember that center-left politicians Isaac Herzog, Tzipi Livni, Avi Gabbay and Benny Gantz all promised a political revolution without the Arab parties — just before they found themselves on the benches of the opposition alongside those very same Arab parties.

Odeh told Local Call that he is happy with the responses to his interview, adding that a situation in which 75 percent of Arab citizens were willing to negotiate with the government and 40 were willing to join a right-wing government would be a dangerous trend for Arab society (according to a joint Local Call-+972 poll conducted before the previous elections, 47 percent of Arab citizens were ready to vote for Jewish parites, while 87 percent supported Arab parties joining the government).

Odeh says that he “wanted to show the Arab voters that we can use politics to promote our interests and we do not need to vote for Jewish parties. On the other hand, Likud went crazy in its response [to Odeh’s remarks – S.S], and Blue and White are now embarrassed. At least the burden of proof is on them… the public will judge them on election day.” Regardless of the outcome of the elections, the ball is now in Blue and White’s court.

A version of this article was first published in Hebrew on Local Call. Read it here.

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article

    * Required


    1. Rivka Koen

      It’s almost farcical, isn’t it, Israel’s twin myths: “democracy” and being “the Jewish state.” Not only are the two not possible at the same time, but also, it’s very clearly neither one, nor the other.

      Do Jews vote in Israeli elections? No. Most of the world’s Jews are not citizens of Israel and have no power to vote in Israeli elections. Yet Netanyahu speaks as if he is the leader of the Jewish people, declaring our most vicious persecutors throughout the world “great friends of the Jewish people” because they stroked his ego a bit and helped him gain more power.

      Does Israel provide Jews a safe haven? Not at all. Two of the countries with the largest Jewish populations are the United States and Hungary, but in both of those places, most Jews are not Orthodox. Hungarian Jews are Neologs, while American Jews are mostly Reform, Conservative (closely related to Neolog), and other similar streams of Judaism. What does Israel do to Neolog, Reform, and Conservative rabbis? Why, it puts them in jail, of course.

      So anyway, who does vote in Israeli elections? Israelis, but not all Israelis. If you’re a non-Jewish citizen of Israel, you might as well not be voting, because your representatives will never be allowed to share in power. And if you’re a non-Orthodox Jew, the same is true, because at no point will the existence of your religion ever be officially acknowledged.

      So it’s not a Jewish state, certainly not “the nation-state of the Jewish people,” and it’s not a democracy for Israeli citizens, so what is it exactly? A thuggish colonial regime masquerading as a refuge for Jews and as a democratic state when it is neither of those things.

      Reply to Comment
      • itshak Gordine

        You are in delirium. Any Israeli can vote, regardless of their opinions or religion. There are parties of extreme left, left, center, right, Arab, religious or not. And all those who exceed the eligibility threshold are represented in the Knesset. Party alliances are commonplace. Israel is a very democratic state, do not dislike it. You seem not to live in Israel. Why so much hatred and lies?

        Reply to Comment
      • Tommy Goldberg

        Very true, Rivka. Perhaps the only way out of this mess is the realization that the current regime is ultimately harmful to Jews (Israeli or otherwise) as well.

        Being forced into an army service so traumatic that people have to hike through Nepal or some such place for half a year afterwards to get over it isn’t healthy.

        Being constantly told that you’re part of an embattled minority surrounded by 100 million (Arab) savages who want you dead (or at least exiled) isn’t healthy.

        Living in a country that refuses to show its schoolchildren the actual borders of their country isn’t healthy. (Neither is the irony of accusing the Palestinian Authority of the very same.)

        No wonder Israelis have been escaping in droves to places like Berlin, where they feel much safer than in the country of their birth. Berlin!!!

        Reply to Comment
        • Rachel

          My partner was forced into army service by poverty, and wasn’t able to hike through Nepal after being discharged. She still had to work, to go to college, etc.

          This is the “volunteer army” Israel hopes to soon be able to have. The poor being traumatized at the behest of a ruling class that debates whether to sacrifice the poor’s health and future in order to kill brown people, and always decides, like the villain of Shrek, that it’s a risk they’re willing to take.

          Reply to Comment
    2. Firentis

      If Odeh was serious about sitting in the government he would put forward realistic demands. Instead he put together a wishlist. His condition for joining the government is the end of the occupation and the creation of a Palestinian state. As if negotiations to that effect haven’t taken place and failed miserably due to a Palestinian refusal to ever recognize or accept the existence of a Jewish state in the Middle East in any borders. Which brings us to an additional condition that Odeh put forward – cancelling the nation state law – which once again demonstrates that the underlying demand of the Palestinians is the elimination of the Jewish state. With these kinds of conditions it is no wonder that it would be suicidal for any Israeli party to even consider sitting in a government with him. It will smell like exactly what it is — a surrender to Arab rejectionism.

      He might as well put forward his real conditions – renaming Israel to Palestine and deporting the Jews unless they are extremely well behaved like the useful idiots one finds writing in certain online publications. Those can stick around and grovel like the sniveling cowards that they are.

      Any Israeli Arab that wants to integrate into Israel is welcome to vote for a party that isn’t openly rejecting Israel’s existence while pretending that it is the one being rejected.

      Reply to Comment
      • Ben

        It never fails.

        Whenever a Palestinians offers serious, sincere overtures towards peace coexistence, true democratic participation, and a viable two state solution, the Israeli right wing then develops a case of the vapors, starts swooning and fainting and waxing hysterical. Out comes first the usual gaseous existential threat exhalations:

        “…due to a Palestinian refusal to ever recognize or accept the existence of a Jewish state…the underlying demand of the Palestinians is the elimination of the Jewish state…”

        –then it descends into what I can only call pure hysteria:

        “suicidal for any Israeli party to even consider sitting in a government with him…a surrender to Arab rejectionism… deporting the Jews unless they are extremely well behaved…openly rejecting Israel’s existence”

        You get that? If you sit in a government with Ayman Odeh then deportation of the Jews is next!!!! Suicidal!!!!! Suicidal to sit in a government with Ayman Odeh!!!

        Pure, vaporous hysteria.

        Ayman Odeh, the MK who was shot point blank in the face with a rubber bullet by Israeli police for being Arab while protesting, protesting the ethnic cleansing of Umm al-Hiran.

        So now you see what the Israel right wing regards as a “threat.”

        Reply to Comment