Appreciate this article? +972 depends on your support.

Click here to help us keep going

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

Arab-Jewish industrial parks: The last chance for economic equality?

Shared industrial parks have the potential to create local and regional growth engines that would allow Arab towns and Israel’s Arab citizens to achieve economic stability and provide a better future for the younger generation. Israel’s leadership must realize that this is not something to be taken for granted.

By Khalil Mari and Ronen Sabag

The annual State Comptroller’s report has once again exposed the severe lack of equality between Arab and Jewish towns in income generated in industrial zones. Although a fifth of the country’s population is Arab, 97.6 percent of all industrial zones in Israel are built in Jewish towns, while only 2.4 percent belong to Arab municipalities. This utter lack of equality dramatically influences Arab towns’ income from municipal taxes (“arnona”); 52 percent of all income generated from arnona taxes comes from the industrial and commercial sectors, yet only 1 percent of the overall arnona is generated from industrial zones in Arab towns.

Mahmoud A’ssi, head of the Kufr Bara local council, has been fighting for years for the establishment of a shared industrial zone with the Drom Hasharon Regional Council. He says that the various authorities have blocked this Arab-Jewish initiative and that without income generated from industrial zones he is unable to provide sufficient services to his residents such as education and employment, especially for women (75 percent of whom are unemployed). A’ssi has an active partner in the head of the Drom Hasharon Regional Council, Motti Daljo, who is fighting alongside him for the establishment of this joint Arab-Jewish industrial park. The two local leaders have long since signed an agreement outlining the shape and details of their partnership, including on the tough issues of dividing revenues between them, as well as zoning matters. In spite of this agreement, the government has done nothing to advance this unique and progressive model of regional Arab-Jewish cooperation. Thus, the two leaders are expecting an uphill battle at the regional planning committee.

Shared industrial parks have the potential to create local and regional growth engines that would allow Arab towns and Israel’s Arab citizens to achieve economic stability and provide a better future for the younger generation. Especially at a time of deep national budget cuts, the central government should do everything in its power to advance the creation of new economic platforms to increase the Arab towns’ self-generated income, help them achieve economic self-sufficiency and secure a more hopeful future for their residents.

In 2004 the government made a decision to encourage the creation or expansion of shared Arab-Jewish industrial parks. But according to the State Comptroller, in the nine years since then, the government has not advanced a clear policy or time frame for its implementation. Furthermore, a contradictory decision made by the same government creates a situation where Arab towns are not eligible for funding earmarked for planning once these towns partner with a Jewish (more affluent) town. Add to this conflicted reality the time it takes to acquire the necessary permits from the various planning authorities and the obstacles Arabs face in Israel’s bureaucracy. The result is progress so slow it is hardly noticeable. Steff Wertheimer built seven industrial parks in Israel housing more than 200 initiatives and with an export value of $1 billion. It took Wertheimer twelve years to acquire the necessary permits to build the industrial park in Nazareth.

Beyond being an economic and social injustice, this reality negates the core principle of equality. We face this distorted reality on a daily basis through our work directing Sikkuy’s “Equality Zones” project, which seeks to build Arab-Jewish municipal cooperation. This US Agency for International Development (USAID) has funded project advances values of civic equality in many fields especially economic development, equal employment opportunity (especially for Arab women) and Jewish-Arab regional cooperation. USAID views economic development of the Arab community as key to social empowerment and the shortest route to civic equality between Arabs and Jews in Israel.

The most significant reason for the high rates of unemployment among Arab women in Israel is the lack of access to work opportunities in their immediate surroundings. The lack of employment opportunities and decent public transportation in Arab towns are the main obstacles to Arab women joining the work force in Israel. Still, nearly all the industrial parks we are trying to advance are stuck for various reasons. In the present state of affairs the government must jump-start the process; it should map all the shared Arab-Jewish industrial parks that have been agreed upon between the sides, invest money and energy to advance these parks and set a time frame of three years for their implementation on the ground.

Israel’s decision makers must realize that an agreement between Jewish and Arab mayors to establish a shared industrial park is neither trivial nor something that can be taken for granted. Arab and Jewish municipal leaders who, despite the mistrust and suspicion between them, get together and reach an agreement to create a shared industrial park are not an everyday occurrence, to say the least. Put simply, if the state does not throw its weight behind these shared projects, cooperation between Arab and Jewish municipal leaders will be a thing of the past and along with it we will miss the last chance to achieve economic equality and stability for the Arab towns in Israel.

Khalil Mari and Ronen Sebag of Sikkuy: The Association for the Advancement of Civic Equality, are co-directors of the “Equality Zones” project advancing Arab-Jewish municipal cooperation on a regional scale in Israel.

Related:
Land, my land: One issue that can be resolved

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article
  • LEAVE A COMMENT

    * Required

    COMMENTS

    1. XYZ

      This is an important issue. Regarding the low level of employment in the Arab women’s sector…I was under the impression that working in a factory which involves punching a clock is not regarded very highly in the Arab sector. In Jordan, as a result of the peace agreement with Israel, an industrial zone was opened in northern Jordan where several textile factories were opened which would be allowed to sell the products in the US with reduced tariffs. I read that they could not find Jordanian workers to work there so they imported workers from China. Is that the case in Israel as well?

      Reply to Comment
      • This piece focuses on the lack of State response to local municipal joint initiatives, not the cultural economic backwardness or malfit of Arab women. Perhaps the Arab municipality is similarly lazy and that is why no progress at the State level has been forthcoming. Perhaps you can import Chinese mayors.

        Reply to Comment
        • XYZ

          Can you give me an example of another Arab country that has a successful industrial economy that can be used as a prototype for this typd of development in the Israeli Arab sector?

          Reply to Comment
          • You have requests for joint development from Jewish and Arab mayors. Approve them. Unless the government administrators are too busy comparing economic development in South Korea and Egypt. Again: you have Jewish mayors who want this. Give them a chance.

            Reply to Comment
    2. In times of budget stress zero sum attitudes predominate. Resource distribution to Arabs has always been skewed downward, and no one wants to lose out in the now to redress the past. I don’t know how significant USAID grants have been, but it sounds like the standard racial filters are foregoing that aid–perhaps because it would still involve allocating State funds against the wishes of other clamoring voices. As I’ve suggested elsewhere herein, Israeli politics works much on a “war council” consensus, and Arabs are not in that council.

      I see economic growth not the fasted route to equality but the only route. The allliances you detail between Jewish and Arab municpalities, although certain at times to involve conflict, would be a foundational Israeli way of moving away from the past towards a dynamic path of equality. Which, again, is probably why it isn’t happening at the moment.

      Reply to Comment
    3. XYZ

      Unfortunately, we hear again here the endless 972 refrain that the problems in the Arab sector are “the Israeli government’s fault”.
      Listen, there are very wealthy Israeli entrepeneurs. One example was former Kadima Knesset Member Dabah who was a friend of Ariel Sharon, Tzippi Livni and who was critical in rounding up support for Mofaz’s defeat of Livni in the last leadership race. This fellow has political clout. So do others. Why aren’t they using it to push this industrial development. OBVIOUSLY there are other factors.
      In 1953, South Korea and Egypt had the same per capita GNP. Today Korea’s is EIGHT times that of Egypt. Why? Both countries have a history of high military expeditures and poiltical tension on their borders.
      Korea is a successful industrial state, Egypt is a failed state. Please don’t use the “history of colonialist exploitation” because BOTH suffered from it.
      In fact, during World War II the British Middle East Command was headquartered in Cairo and the British poured huge amounts of money into the country into various industries there. So why weren’t the Egyptians able to build on this? (The same occurred in British Palestine, both the Jewish and Arab sectors got some of this money and the Jews used it to expand their pre-state infrastructure, the Arabs squandered it). YOU tell me what the difference between Korea and Egypt is!

      Reply to Comment
    4. XYZ

      Another factor for the fact that industrial development in the Israeli Arab sector is lagging…ask yourself this question-what do the Arab Knesset members do with their time? Do they work to encourage cooperation between the Arab sector and both the Israeli government and its financial and industrial sector, or do they spend their time cursing Israel, demanding that it disappear and engaging in general rabble rousing?
      The Israeli Arab population is ill served by its representatives in the Arab parties. Maybe if they would vote for more responsible people (without giving up legitimate demands for having their interests looked after) ecnonomic and industrial development in their areas would have been greatly accelerated. Everyone, Jews and Arabs would have benefited. Arabs should look in the mirror for the source of their problems.

      Reply to Comment
      • Again, you have Arab and Jewish mayors who want this. State officers are turning their heads. I suspect you are not accurate in your portrayal of Arab MKs. Someone who decides to compare Egypt with second and third generations Arab Israeli citizens has a simple handbook for economics.

        Reply to Comment