+972 Magazine's Stories of the Week

Directly In Your Inbox

Analysis News
Visit our Hebrew site, "Local Call" , in partnership with Just Vision.

Abducted from Sudan, tortured in Sinai: Mother and child languish in Israeli jail

After facing brutal treatment at the hands of Sinai smugglers, an Eritrean mother and her baby daughter – who did not intend to go to Israel – have found themselves victim to Israeli policy, despite not having done a thing to deserve such a fate.

By Anat Ben-Dor

There are things one can do only when no one else is looking. Detaining a baby girl a year and three months old for a period of three years, for instance. We met Ambat* yesterday in Saharonim prison – an active child, she was dressed in red and was held in her mother’s arms. We sat in the oppressive 30 degree heat for an hour, and while we interviewed her mother, little Ambat attempted to entertain herself. She hopped around gleefully, laid down on her stomach in order to peek under the caravan, scanning the floor in the hopes of finding some new form of entertainment.

The two of them have been in this prison, surrounded by fences, security towers and barbed wire for over three months. Trapped in a tent with 12 others – six women and six children. It is doubtful whether Ambat’s mother, who is only 23, knows that she and her daughter will spend the next three years in this place.

Ambat and her mother Zabib* have been jailed for “infiltration into Israel.” This past January, the law was amended to to allow placing “infiltrators” under administrative detention for a period of three years, in order to deter future “infiltrators” from entering Israel. However, Zabib never intended to go to Israel. She was born in a small village in Eritrea, where she was married. Her husband was drafted into the military, leaving Zabib in the village, where she could barely support herself through selling food. She saw her husband just once every half year. When she was six months pregnant, her husband defected to Sudan, where he lives today. After the birth of her daughter, Zabib and Ambat left Eritrea in an attempt to reunite with her husband in Sudan. Shortly after crossing the border, the two were kidnapped at gunpoint by smugglers. That is where their long and painful journey began.

Zabib and Ambat were transferred from one person to another on their way to Sinai. Sometimes, they would lay down in the trunks of vehicles, and sometimes inside boats. The elderly people that were with them during the journeys often fainted due to the trying conditions. It is still unclear how little Ambat managed to survive. In the end, they were brought to a smugglers’ camp in Sinai. There, Zabib’s legs were cuffed, while the smugglers demanded a ransom of $25,000 in exchange for her release. This is when the baby turned into her mother’s protector. While other women were raped and sexually abused, Zabib was only the victim of beatings and lashings. The smugglers often dangled Ambat out a window, threatening to throw her in front of her mother. They also slapped her when she cried. Zabib says that Ambat learned from the smugglers: she gently strokes her mother’s cheek before suddenly slapping her, in much the same way as the smuggler slapped Ambat.

They stayed at the camp for five long months. Some of the other detainees died after being tortured, or from the harsh conditions. In the end, however, after her family sold all of their belongings, Zabib and Ambat were released. After crossing the border with Israel, Ambat was brought to Soroka Hospital due to fatigue and malnourishment. She is currently in Saharonim Prison, and the future that she faces is especially frightening: this is a baby that will never taste freedom – will never take a walk in the park or along the beach. In the next few years, she will sit with her mother behind bars, victim to Israel’s policy, despite the two not having done a thing to deserve such a fate. It is doubtful that she will meet her father in Sudan, or whether she will ever be able to reunite with him. It will be interesting to see what kind of behavior she will adopt from Israeli prison.

When we said goodbye, Ambat blew us kisses. Luckily, she is too young to know what awaits her.

*All names used in this piece are fake

Anat Ben-Dor is the clinical instructor of the Tel Aviv University Refugee Rights Clinic. This piece was originally published in Laissez Passer.

Read more here on seeking asylum in Israel.

Asylum seekers can now face years in prison over false accusation
A scorching desert jail for asylum seekers, with no way out

Before you go...

A lot of work goes into creating articles like the one you just read. And while we don’t do this for the money, even our model of non-profit, independent journalism has bills to pay.

+972 Magazine is owned by our bloggers and journalists, who are driven by passion and dedication to the causes we cover. But we still need to pay for editing, photography, translation, web design and servers, legal services, and more.

As an independent journalism outlet we aren’t beholden to any outside interests. In order to safeguard that independence voice, we are proud to count you, our readers, as our most important supporters. If each of our readers becomes a supporter of our work, +972 Magazine will remain a strong, independent, and sustainable force helping drive the discourse on Israel/Palestine in the right direction.

Support independent journalism in Israel/Palestine Donate to +972 Magazine today
View article: AAA
Share article
Print article

    * Required


    1. Joel

      Kidnapped and forced to migrate to Israel? That doesn’t make a lot of sense.

      What would kidnapper/smugglers want with a screaming kid and her mother?

      Sorry. This story doesn’t pass the ‘sniff test’.

      Reply to Comment
      • Don

        Joel, if you have been following the media about this(a coverage was aired in CNN). Those kidnappers from Sudan abduct Eritreans and sell them to Bedeuns in Sinai which will torture them until they pay $20,000-$50,000 per head or extract their kidney and other body organs.

        Reply to Comment
      • gigca

        You can check more info over the internet by searching CNN Freedom Project.

        Reply to Comment
    2. I would expect a developed democratic State to have an internal review policy to release some detainees in exceptional circumstances. Maybe my expectations are too high. Still, it seems that the present outcome confroms to the group corporate logic generally employed by the Israeli State to outsiders. Strange, for corporate logic was so often employed against Jews, to horrible effect, for so many centuries.

      In the present case, though, releasing this mother and child without aid could well be worse–at least they will eat where they are, with some kind of roof. The omniscient State is most kind.

      Reply to Comment
    3. Tseggai Isaac

      There is an Abyssinian saying that can be translated to mean: If God is designing the path of your demise, He makes you make errors in your judgement.” The Israeli Government is making errors contradicting its own laws of heritage, captivity, refuge, and destitution. The “mother and child” case is an affront to Israel; it bespeaks of utter inhumanity and a desolate heart.

      Reply to Comment
      • It is the responsibility of Belief to challenge these outcomes. Change must come from within.

        Reply to Comment
    4. gail

      israel throws toddlers in jail all the time. i read it in the news over and over again, two years, three, and five years old. held in prison for years with no trial and not told when they will be released. this is nothing new.

      Reply to Comment

The stories that matter.
The missing context.
All in one weekly email.

Subscribe to +972's newsletter