55 comments for ”West Bank village A-Dik joins anti-occupation protests“

    
  1. According to you and the average comment on this site, everything was fair for the Jews and unfair to the Arabs. When the population was 85% Arab and they decided to launch some pogroms, apparently that was unfair to the Arabs. When the Arabs ensured that not one Jew could remain in Hebron safely, apparently that was unfair to the Arabs. When the Arabs rejected Peel and 1947, both of which violated promises made to the Jews by the world, not just the British, that was unfair to the Arabs. When the Arab population grew because the economy in Palestine was booming like no other country in the Middle East, that was unfair to the Arabs. When the Arabs helped the Nazis and sought to have them assist with anti-Jewish programs, that was unfair to the Arabs. When Jews debated whether they could or couldn’t live side by side with the Arabs as they had hoped to before all the attacks and hostility from the Arabs, that was unfair to the Arabs. When the Arabs launched a war and lost it, that was unfair to the Arabs. When the Arabs sought to expel the Jews but only succeeded in the areas they conquered while finding themselves expelled of the areas they lost, that was unfair to the Arabs. When the Arabs launch terror attacks against the Jews, it’s because they know everything is unfair for the Arabs. And when the Arabs get bombed after launching 8000 rockets at Israeli communities, that is unfair to the Arabs. When the Arabs claim peace but nobody believes them because at the same time they deny Jewish history in the Land of Israel, that is unfair to the Arabs. And it just goes on and on. The most important one, though, is that when the Israelis offer the Arabs another state, with all of Gaza and almost all of Judea and Samaria, plus eastern Jerusalem, plus reparations, plus control over Christian and Muslim holy places, plus a permanent peace, and the Arabs reject the deal and do not change their positions at all, that’s also so unfair to the Arabs.
    Hope that didn’t exceed 500 words or apparently I will be banned by Lisa Goldman. I believe that banning me will be unfair to the Arabs as well.

  2. 
  3. You don’t have arguments and are ill-informed. Sentences like “When the Arabs helped the Nazis” (as I told you you don’t have any clue about palestinians&hajj Amin) or “promises made to the Jews by the world” (the League of Nation was a colonialistic western society; study also the history of the resolution 181 and the situation of the UN at that time) show a basic preparation that I don’t have time to correct. Study and put away your egocentrism. Ignorance is not a solution.

  4. 
  5. I could provide 10 of these links without even trying hard, but I’m trying not to give these folks an excuse to ban me. Let’s start with one link to one book. Top of page 59:

    http://books.google.com/books?id=HGkthBwbNg8C&pg=PA59&lpg=PA59&dq=the+abolition+of+the+jewish+national+homeland+in+palestine+hitler+amin&source=bl&ots=5QoZ9_fsNy&sig=fuLlIMMlYceVKuqaXfdH2n-tplg&hl=en&sa=X&ei=QFM9T6uFNOWW2AWd2Zm4CA&ved=0CEAQ6AEwBQ#v=onepage&q&f=false

  6. 
  7. passerby, you really know a lot about the issue. impressive

  8. 
  9. Berl, I keep providing links and facts. I don’t know what more you want. You wrote “When the Arabs helped the Nazis” (as I told you you don’t have any clue about palestinians&hajj Amin) so I provided you with a link to an academic’s book revealing the same information I provided. Then you critize me again. It’s not my fault that this is the history and the history is disagreeable to you. It’s not my fault that many Palestinians want to distance themselves from Haj Amin but can’t. It’s not my fault that the “colonialistic western society” of the early 20th century made promises to the Jews, any more than it’s your fault that the same folks created virtually the entire modern Middle East. It’s also not my fault that 181 and 194 were rejected by the Arabs. My ego is not involved in these issues, it’s just that since I took the time to write the comments above, I wouldn’t want readers to think that just because “Berl” says that I’m ignorant, that they should ignore what I’ve written. So as long as you do, I will continue to provide information that shows that my comments contain valid information.



Leave a comment