The only way you can think of the poem 'What must be said' as anti-Semitic is if you think of Grass as an anti-Semite. His history as well as the poem itself point in the exact opposite direction. If Gunter Grass had ever said or done anything that showed hatred of Jews or of Israel, then I, too, might take a very uncharitable view of his warning in the poem "What must be said" that this country, or even this government, is liable to nuke Iran and "annihilate the Iranian people." Like I wrote before, that's a misleading suggestion; for all the past reports about "bunker-busting" bombs and future scenarios about a regional WMD war, Israel is not…Read More... | 83 Comments
Now Interior Minister Eli Yishai has declared Grass to be persona non grata while Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman has accused the German author of being "willing to sacrifice the Jewish people on the altar of crazy anti-Semites for a second time, just to sell a few more books or gain recognition.” Yishai and Lieberman are the two most outspoken racists in the Israeli government, so if one of the ways to know a person is by his enemies, I'd say Grass is looking pretty good. And in a way, he's getting off easy; when ex-Mossad boss Meir Dagan started criticizing Netanyahu and Barak's plan to bomb Iran, his diplomatic passport was revoked and some cabinet…Read More... | 67 Comments
His poem was especially brave because he's German and because he's vulnerable over his past. If I take Gunter Grass's supposedly anti-Israel, anti-Semitic poem "What must be said" literally, I guess I could quibble with a couple of phrases. He says an Israeli attack on Iran "could erase the Iranian people." An unknowing reader might think Israel is planning to nuke Iran, which isn't the case, even though there were reports in the past about Israel considering the use of tactical nuclear weapons as "bunker-busting" bombs on the underground nuclear sites. And if we want to take a little poetic license, an Israeli attack could expand in all sorts of directions…Read More... | 57 Comments
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR WEEKLY NEWSLETTERSubmit
Reports, maps, infographics and other documents on human rights and democracy.
Children under occupation
The effects of occupation on minors.
On the challenges facing a growing population of asylum seekers and refugees in Israel.
A series of striking infographics.
- MOST READMOST COMMENTED24 HOURS|WEEK|MONTH
Streaming on +972: 'My Neighborhood', @JustVisionMedia's award-winning documentary on Sheikh Jarrah http://t.co/ujJjKgqr2B
Zionism and the Shah: On the Iranian elite's evolving perceptions of Israel http://t.co/PHUqEsd0yY
Will Europe take a leading, confrontational role on Israel/Palestine? http://t.co/HHZafKAqL3 by @nsheizaf
Stream it on +972: 'My Neighborhood', @JustVisionMedia's award-winning documentary on Sheikh Jarrah http://t.co/ujJjKgqr2B
Masses who identify with Israel's ‘social protest’ are callous to those with much more urgent complaints http://t.co/TSMqgcrWX7
New on +972: Will Europe take a leading role on Israel/Palestine? http://t.co/HHZafKAqL3 by @nsheizaf
Now streaming on +972: 'My Neighbourhood' - the human impact of settlements in Sheikh Jarrah http://t.co/ujJjKgqr2B by @JustVisionMedia