
Voices
More Voices
Five Broken Cameras


Lisa Goldman
'5 Broken Cameras' director: There is no room for guilt - only taking responsibility
NEW YORK -- Before Guy Davidi co-directed and produced 5 Broken Cameras, he was involved in Indymedia and an experienced filmmaker. He was also associated with Anarchists Against the Wall, Israeli anti-occupation activists. This is how he came to know the West Bank village of Bil'in, home of the film's co-director, Emad Burnat. "I lived in the village for two months in 2005," he recalled, during a conversation that took place at a coffee shop in New York, where he was promoting the film ahead of the Oscars. "That was an intense time, with the [Palestinian Legislative Council] election. That…
Read More... | 21 Comments
Ami Kaufman
WATCH: IDF reservists call for charging makers of '5 Broken Cameras' with incitement
And, the Oscar for weirdest item of the day goes to... the group of soldiers who call for charging the makers of '5 Broken Cameras' with incitement! The Israeli website Mako reports that the group, known as "Consensus - Guardian of the IDF Spirit," has posted the following Youtube clip as part of a campaign against the makers of the movie (my subtitles). Mako reports: "The movie Five Broken Cameras is indeed a nominee in the category for best documentary, but it seems it should be in the category for best propoganda film. The film lacks any objectivity, and…
Read More... | 5 Comments
Mairav Zonszein
Occupation goes to the Oscars - but films carry very different messages
Both Oscar-nominated documentaries from this region are important documents of Israeli occupation and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict in their own right. But if 'The Gatekeepers' wins, it will whitewash occupation by presenting Israeli guilt in a redeeming light. If 'Five Broken Cameras' wins, it will go beyond the message that what Israel is doing is wrong and show the world exactly what wrong looks like – and just how ugly it is. The Gatekeepers and 5 Broken Cameras have already succeeded in breaking one of Israel’s biggest taboos: airing out its dirty laundry on the big screen, for the whole world to see. Now…
Read More... | 10 Comments
Mairav Zonszein
Can Palestinian non-violent resistance make it into Israel's education system?
By the time the documentary Five Broken Cameras came out in November 2011, the Palestinian village of Bil'in in the occupied West Bank had already become the symbol of Palestinian non-violent resistance to Israeli occupation, Israeli settlements and the separation wall/barrier. It had already celebrated six long years of weekly Friday demonstrations led by the residents, joined by Israeli and international activists and aggressively repressed by the IDF; it had already seen several of its residents killed after being shot by IDF soldiers during these demonstrations (among them, Bassam Abu Rahme and his sister, Jawaher Abu Rahmah); and succeeded in pressuring the government to alter…
Read More... | 19 Comments
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
Submit
Special Coverage

Last Metro to Taksim
Yuval Ben-Ami reports from Istanbul.

+972 Resources
Reports, maps, infographics and other documents on human rights and democracy.

Children under occupation
The effects of occupation on minors.

Seeking Asylum
On the challenges facing a growing population of asylum seekers and refugees in Israel.

Visualizing Occupation
A series of striking infographics.

- MOST READMOST COMMENTED24 HOURS|WEEK|MONTH
-
owic get_most_read couldnt, old cache used
-
owic get_most_read couldnt, old cache used
-
owic get_most_read couldnt, old cache used
-
owic get_most_commented cached
-
7
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
3
-
owic get_most_commented cached
-
34
-
31
-
23
-
14
-
13
-
owic get_most_commented cached
-
63
-
55
-
43
-
37
-
37
@972mag
Is a binational identity possible in Israel? http://t.co/yFmq5vBPGV
The unwitting common ground in the debate over binationalism in Israel http://t.co/qDoWMqR8fO by Jeremiah Haber
VID: Former female Israeli soldiers break their silence http://t.co/2H7V47Cj9I by @MairavZ
Israeli MK's 'sexy' pose goes viral on Facebook http://t.co/vktM2Rk4OH by @AmiKaufman
The soldiers' stories that Israel lacks the courage to hear http://t.co/rlleFPDVVq By Larry Derfner, cc @ShovrimShtika
- twitter.com/972mag
