When I got home last night from what was probably the largest demonstration in Israel since the first Lebanon war, I checked my usual websites to see how it was covered.
I also checked my usual two international papers, the New York Times and the Guardian sites. But there was nothing. Oh well, might be too early. I’ll check in the morning.
This morning, 7 hours after the demo ended, 10 hours after it began, nothing to be found on the homepages of both respectable outlets. Not a word.
Despite being a leftie, I’ve always believed that there is some truth to the claims that international media focuses on Israel and the conflict much more than on other conflicts – just as bloody, just as unjust – if not more.
So when 150,000 Israelis, a huge number even percentage-wise, protest the cost of living, as they do in Madrid and elsewhere – suddenly it’s not a story? When it comes to Israel, it’s not interesting? We’re only occupiers, right? What kind of news editors are you guys holding up there? Seriously, are you telling me this isn’t a story?
Excuse my French, but… gey koken ahfen yam.














August 1, 2011
4:49 am
Reporting in Germany has been quite extensive across the board:
Handelsblatt, the main business daily:
http://www.handelsblatt.com/politik/international/proteste-im-land-wegen-lebenshaltungskosten-/4449526.html
Tagesschau, the most watched news program:
http://www.tagesschau.de/ausland/israel1072.html
Die Zeit, one of the two main weeklies:
http://www.zeit.de/politik/ausland/2011-07/massenproteste-israel-soziale-gerechtigkeit
Die Welt, national conservative daily (“The Arab Spring Reaches Israel”):
http://www.welt.de/print/wams/wirtschaft/article13517546/Arabiens-Fruehling-erreicht-Israel.html
Süddeutsche Zeitung, national left-liberal daily from Munich:
http://www.sueddeutsche.de/politik/demonstrationen-fuer-mehr-soziale-gerechtigkeit-gegen-netanjahus-politik-1.1126453
Frankfurter Rundschau, national social democratic daily:
http://www.fr-online.de/politik/100-000-israelis-fordern-mehr-soziale-gerechtigkeit/-/1472596/8730760/-/index.html
Die Tageszeitung, green/left-liberal daily from Berlin:
http://www.taz.de/Protest-gegen-soziale-Ungleichheit-/!75400/
August 1, 2011
5:52 am
Your protests are both too much and premature. Looking over the papers online this morning I seem the protests covered in the NY Times, the Washington Post, the Independent, the Guardian, the Christian Science Monitor, and CNN among others. It isn’t front page news, but most news about Israel-Palestine isn’t front page news, particularly when something as major as the debt ceiling debacle is happening. If the protests are sustained at a high level and actually look like they are going to result in changes, I would expect even more coverage. I don’t think anyone is seriously saying this isn’t a story.
August 1, 2011
6:58 am
In my last post I mention the NY Times article but I had only seen the online version. It is actually on the front page of the print edition. You don’t get much more prominent than that.
August 1, 2011
7:53 am
Which, yet again, proves my point: If it’s on the front page of NYT, someone obviously thought it’s important. So, why wasn’t it important when it was breaking? Must be that damn auto pilot I was talking about…
August 1, 2011
8:58 am
Perhaps it wasn’t covered in detail as the story was breaking because ultimately large non-violent protests over social benefits and housing prices in Israel have very little importance in the US. Given the important political/economic decisions happening in the US this weekend related to our own social benefits it is not surprising that this topic wasn’t covered without delay. What is more interesting than the events themselves are their ongoing impact and the more detailed analysis of the events significance for Israeli politics. This is what is coming out now. Nobody is telling you this isn’t a story. Rather they are telling you that in the US it isn’t as important as it is to all of you in Israel.
US news editors definitely go into auto-pilot mode when addressing this conflict, but the idea that result of that auto-pilot is a presentation of Israelis only as occupiers completely turns around the way in which western media reflects the power balance that exists in Israel and the OPT.
August 1, 2011
9:12 am
@merlot – i agree with some of what you say, but not with most. i suggest you read the whole comment thread.
.
my point is, i understand, as a journalist, the decision making process in a paper/website. I’m not saying the NYT lead story on the site should have been a tel aviv demo. but of the hundreds of links on a homepage, during those hours of the demo, it deserved to have a mention. even to a small wire story..
.
because ignoring it just looks stupid.
August 1, 2011
9:15 am
in retrospect, i should have taken a screenshot of the pages at that time, and shown how much less important int’l/world stories were up on the guardian and nyt. again, not talking about top, lead stories. just mentions in the world/int’l sctions on homepage.
.
btw – on the int’l/world sections of both respective sites, meaning inside the site, not the homepage itself, there was no mention of the demo as it happened.
.
And as I said, now that it’s being covered just strengthens my point. apparently, if the int’l news editor doesn’t work on the weekend, things fall through and don’t get done.
August 1, 2011
12:11 pm
I have read several posts justifying the “western” mainstream media “sudden” blackout on Israel, and with all respect to the posters, their arguments are not only not convincing, but show a lack of understanding on media control. An integral part of Israel’s survival strategy as an occupier is their control of the message and the means to deliver it. Saturday’s demonstrations were the peak of a several weeks’ movement every newspaper worth its name should have been following, regardless of world events, however important. Ami’s intriguing title “So, suddenly Israel isn’t a story anymore?,” says it clearly: Israel is on the news day in and day out, and to see the “western” (read corporate) media stop reporting on Israel, on a weekend, after a 150,000 people show of force, is not coincidence. The corporate media, at least in the US. decided to downplay Israel’s social movement, since they know it comes at a very crucial juncture, when Israel has been preparing for a foreign onslaught, not a domestic challenge. I don’t believe the NYT or the WaPo care so much about giving Israel “the proper placement” in world news. Their editorial policy re: Israel is, well, “Made in Israel,” or close by. However, I find it embarrassing that the GU or the Independent from UK did not do their job, and I tend to believe the European media has been waiting for the housing/etc. movement in Israel to show some real signs of something akin to Tahrir square, have some real punch. However, I don’t see any malice in their coverage, or lack thereof, nor the obvious complicity of the US media. The US/corporate media is under total control of the Israel lobby. The news blackout on the marchers is not coincidence, or a displacement of Israel by more important news, i.e. the debt ceiling. If Hamas would have dropped a couple of dud Qasam rockets on the outskirts of Sderot, I am sure it would have made front page news on the NYT or the WaPo, even if the debt ceiling debate would have failed.
Taoist
August 1, 2011
1:55 pm
Hamas did fire more than a couple of rockets in Sderot AND in the outskirts of Sedrot AND in the Ashkelon area.
Did it make the front page?
August 1, 2011
2:11 pm
Well at least in England we have this thing called the silly season which lasts from mid/late July through to late August or early September, during which our political and media elite all disappear to holiday in Tuscany or the Dordogne.
Typically junior underlings are left to run the newspapers and TV news shows for the whole of this period and these are far too lacking in confidence and resources to show much interest in foreign political stories which do not fit easily into the preferred ideological mode of their publications.
So if its about Israel but not about bombs and rockets and assassinations and settlements they literally don’t know what to do about it – so play safe and don’t make a big deal of it at all.
So you’ve really got to up the ante and turn it into The Israeli Summer if you want the mass media here to notice it at all.
August 1, 2011
7:44 pm
SYLVIA,
The subject was Saturday’s demo, which I expected to be front page on Sunday morning. The rockets were launched today (Monday). A non-sequitor.
August 1, 2011
11:03 pm
Well, I still haven’t seen any coverage in the US MSM. Even if the NYTImes has finally seen fit to cover the story somewhere in the paper. Sometimes I think the NYTimes should alter their logo from “All The News That’s Fit to Print” to “All the news that fits, we print”.
But aside from that, the overwhelming majority of the American public DOES NOT READ THE NEW YORK TIMES either because the print is too small or some of the words are too big.
Many people do look at the Huffington Post as a news portal,so as to search for where stories are not only in the US but in other parts of the world. Most of the Huffposts stories when clicked on are from other news sources. Moreover, these referred stories are included in the center column on its home page. It was BURIED in the business section.
Yet to the vast majority, the “news” is what they get on ABC, NBC and CBS. On the evening broadcasts, two of the networks, the two with the much higher ratings, NBC and ABC after the extensive coverage of the debt ceiling circus, did a international news story. Remarkably both had foreign correspondents in Mogadishu, Somalia showing people who are starving and living in tent cities, and especially on ABC the report was treated as a “tearjerker”.
If these reports keep coming in, I see it as a preparation so that the American people will understand when the US armed forces intervene there for “humanitarian reasons”.
I’m waiting on that to see if I’m right or wrong.
August 2, 2011
4:18 am
The BBC has finally gotten around to reporting on this story. I saw it on the TV station and it is also on their website at:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-14344515
August 2, 2011
1:22 pm
Its not worth covering. As soon as it begins to rain, your tents will disappear.
August 2, 2011
6:44 pm
I ended up on this website (amazing project…congrats) because I was looking for info. Today NYTimes online: nothing. Today National Public Radio (USA): nothing. Today ANSA online (Italy): nothing. I don’t think that Israel is not a story anymore, I think that Israel’s protest is a story that nobody wants to cover or emphasize (at least in the US). Thanks for informing us. You got another reader and supporter
August 3, 2011
12:19 pm
Is it possible you think Israel is so important it should captivate our attention at all times?
August 6, 2011
5:09 pm
ok, not the opener :
http://www.spiegel.de/politik/ausland/0,1518,778798,00.html
http://www.tagesschau.de/ausland/israel1088.html
http://www.zeit.de/2011/32/Israel-Proteste
….
August 7, 2011
5:37 pm
The Corporate Media would not want to give the rest of the world any ideas……we are all in the same boat but we sit and do nothing.
Wake up people!!!!
August 7, 2011
5:42 pm
Bravo to the people of Israel. For being united and one people. We have alot to learn here in the West.