Appreciate this article? +972 depends on your support -- click here to help us keep going

Analysis News

Palestinian university shuts down in wake of violence, teacher strikes

Critics often say that Palestinians should concentrate on state-building rather than fighting the occupation. But the prolonged closure of a Palestinian university is a reminder that Palestine can’t get on its feet when it’s under Israel’s boot.

It’s been 10 days since I’ve seen my students at the Palestinian university in the West Bank. A week and a half ago, I was in the middle of teaching one of my afternoon classes when a number of my male students got up to leave. “Sorry, Miss Mya,” one said. “But there’s a fight outside.”

It was the latest flare-up in a long-running family feud between two clans—one from Abu Dis, the other from a neighboring village. This round included stone-throwing and gunshots. It took place right outside the university gates.

According to the Oslo Accords, Abu Dis is in Area B, which means that it is under Israeli security and Palestinian administration. This also means that there are no police in Abu Dis. Thus, in situations like this, there is no one to restore order. This is a common problem in Palestinian areas of the West Bank, including those that are part of the Jerusalem municipality but are on the Palestinian side of the wall. While I was reporting in one such area recently, locals told me that whenever there is crime, the villagers—who pay taxes to Israel and hold Jerusalem residency—have to handle it by themselves.

Abu Dis is in a similar situation. Parts of the village are, technically, inside Jerusalem’s borders; the university is right next to the separation barrier. When the Israeli army heard about the violence, they came and fired tear gas at the crowd, thinking that the fight was about the occupation. The gas wafted into the building I teach in. When the soldiers realized that the feud was internal, they left.

For students’ and faculty safety, the university was shut down. Everyone went out the gates on the opposite side of campus, away from the fighting. For security reasons, the administration decided to keep the university closed until Saturday.

When I got word of the closure, I gave up on holding office hours on Wednesday as I had planned. I was disappointed—several of my students had made appointments because they needed help with their work. With the week prematurely over, I left Abu Dis and headed back to Jerusalem. On my way out, I saw Palestinian Authority police officers standing outside the university. They can only come into Area B when they get permission from the Israelis.

Order—if one can call it that—had been restored to Abu Dis. But for how long? And what might happen next time?

***

Saturday came and the quiet held. Classes, however, were still cancelled. The faculty was on strike because they hadn’t received their salaries. The past week has seen other Palestinian schools closed by strikes, as well.

This is an ongoing problem. Teachers’ wages come from the PA; part of the PA’s money comes from taxes collected by Israel. To punish the PA for the UN bid—which has produced no meaningful change on the ground, anyways—Israel has been holding Palestinian funds since November. Israel does this from time to time to keep the PA on an even shorter leash.

While Israel’s plans to release part of the funds was widely reported by both the local and international media in late January, that won’t be enough to keep the struggling PA afloat. And here it’s mid-March and, at the university in Abu Dis, wages remain unpaid. Campus remains closed.

The PA’s financial woes suggest that there are more tough times ahead for the Palestinian economy. According to the United Nations, “the real obstacle to growth is the Israeli occupation which… has almost eliminated marketing and investment opportunities and has constricted land and natural resources available for productive activities.”

As the strike grinds on, my students flood me with emails. Are we having class? When? Do I want their papers? Their anxiety and irritation fill my inbox.

A few have written just to say hi. One who had mentioned “Shaun the Sheep” in an in-class free write sent me a photo of the cartoon character. “Remember you asked what ‘Shaun the Sheep’ was? This is it,” she said. Just now another email popped up: Do we have class tomorrow? PS) I MISS YOU SO MUCH. I want this strike to end.

Last semester, my students told me that they find these strikes extremely frustrating. The strikes usually don’t accomplish much and the kids get behind in their work. And, like most people, my students seem to like stability. It is difficult to thrive—or feel comfortable, safe, and happy—in total chaos. And in the midst of the chaos of occupation, taking classes at the university provides much-needed structure.

Going to school also gives some of my students hope and a feeling of agency—feelings the occupation deprives them of. I think feeling like you have some degree of control over your own life is a human right, as is hope.

For additional original analysis and breaking news, visit +972 Magazine's Facebook page or follow us on Twitter. Our newsletter features a comprehensive round-up of the week's events. Sign up here.

View article: AAA
Share article
Print article
  • COMMENTS

    1. The Trespasser

      So now Israel is responsible for Palestinians being bloodthirsty barbarians.

      Perfect leftist logic.

      Reply to Comment
      • sh

        “According to the Oslo Accords, Abu Dis is in Area B, which means that it is under Israeli security and Palestinian administration.”

        See Trespasser? You got it wrong. It’s the Israelis who are responsible for the “security” blood&guts and the Palestinians who are allowed to do the paperwork -which, by the sound of it, consists mostly of IOUs. But no-one is responsible for settling internal quarrels in area B.
        Whereas, despite the wealth of police operating around our way, our Jewish barbarian internal feuders regularly succeed in account-settling killings between what are called “crime families”, just as one example. Imagine how much more barbarity we’d see if we, as in Area B, had no policing of internal feuds.

        Reply to Comment
        • The Trespasser

          1 – Area B (Palestinian civil control and joint Israeli-Palestinian security control)
          http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Administrative_divisions_of_the_Oslo_Accords#Area_B

          2 – Army is not the tool to settle internal quarrels.

          3 – As you are speaking of Israeli crime families, it is worth mentioning that great most (Alperon, Abarjil, Abutbul, Dumrani) of these families (and absolute most of their soldiers) are of Arab origin. Coincidence, huh?

          “Allegedly there are 16 crime families operating in Israel, five major groups active on the national level, and 11 smaller organizations. There are reputed to be six Mizrahi Jewish crime families active and three Bedouin crime families.”

          Reply to Comment
          • Your police can not come here! We control this area!

            But you are responsible for your own crimes! We control this area if you make crime against us! Otherwise–barbarian crime not our problem!

            Kafka, most dear, racist Trespasser, was a Jew.

            Reply to Comment
          • From the piece: “According to the Oslo Accords, Abu Dis is in Area B, which means that it is under Israeli security and Palestinian administration. This also means that there are no police in Abu Dis. Thus, in situations like this, there is no one to restore order. This is a common problem in Palestinian areas of the West Bank…”

            Once again, I refer to Kafka, as he obviously doesn’t apply.

            Reply to Comment
          • The Trespasser

            But Oslo accords are not relevant anymore. Don’t you know that Oslo was officially cancelled by the PA?

            Reply to Comment
          • Leen

            You kind of lost me on your point.
            Are you saying that Jews of Arab origin are excluded from the Israeli tag or ‘not Jewish enough’ or Jews of Arab origin are more ‘barbaric’? Because the families you listed are all Jewish families.

            Reply to Comment
          • The Trespasser

            The latter. Families I’ve listed are all Jewish Arab families.

            More barbaric than European Jews? Oh, yeah.

            A question: How many of 972 staff are Mizrakhi?

            Reply to Comment
          • leen

            Eh, I guess this reaffirms my suspicions all along. Racism runs deep in Israeli society, and I am not talking about racism against Palestinians.

            Reply to Comment
          • The Trespasser

            the leftist bunch has quite strange standards of “racism”

            whenever you don’t like some facts about certain cultures, you simply dismiss them or allegedly “racist” basis.

            p.s. there is no such thing as “European race”, but some less developed individuals simply can’t grasp that.

            Reply to Comment
          • Leen

            I’m not a leftist, I’m a classic liberal.

            Culture is not solid but dynamic, remember Europeans were fond of killing, hanging, beheading, etc. Lord the medieval times has enough bloodshed stories (let’s not forget all the ‘gruesome’ stories of torture techniques and some questionable characters in history). Therefore your classification of a culture on no factual grounds is discrimination, and your classification of ethnicities/nationalities/race is racism.

            And as I said, be careful if you laud a certain culture/ethnicity/ancestory as more superior because we all know what happened last time.

            Reply to Comment
          • The Trespasser

            I’ve written you an answer, but for some strange reason it never made through.

            It seems that the most extreme of my posts are allowed, while more moderate and thoughtful are not.

            Reply to Comment
          • Leen

            And I’d be careful to laud the European ancestory as the superior race. We all know what happened last time.

            Reply to Comment
    2. Neither your students nor you, Mya, deserve this. If one continually batters hope down, what should be expected left? Yet the Wall protests have endured. Humanity refused the defintion of slave.

      Reply to Comment
    3. Joel

      Greg Pollack and Trespasser are having a dispute here, so we’ll
      blame Mya.

      Reply to Comment
    4. It is very sad, as many other incidents that occur daily.
      It is also very sad that nobody can’t freely comment without fearing to offend anybody. Dear readers, the Israel-Palestine conflict is by far the most complicated-mentionable conflict ever. Depending on the point at which you begin the narrative, the balance of things, rights and claims can look very different.
      And by the way, @TheTraspasser, your attitude is very typical and certainly doesn’t help.
      Mistakes have been made on both sides I’m afraid, take your own risponsibility in the matter. I see no saints here.

      Reply to Comment

    LEAVE A COMMENT

    Name (Required)
    Mail (Required)
    Website
    Free text

© 2010 - 2014 +972 Magazine
Follow Us
Credits

+972 is an independent, blog-based web magazine. It was launched in August 2010, resulting from a merger of a number of popular English-language blogs dealing with life and politics in Israel and Palestine.

Website empowered by RSVP

Illustrations: Eran Mendel