Appreciate this article? +972 depends on your support -- click here to help us keep going

Analysis News

Palestinian prisoners' rights activist detained, tortured in Israeli prison

Ayman Nasser, a researcher for the Palestinian prisoners’ rights NGO Addameer, has himself become a detainee in an Israeli prison, having been charged with several counts of membership in an illegal organization and of partaking in illegal assembly. According to Physicians for Human Rights, he has been tortured during his 39-day-long interrogation.

Nasser, 42, was arrested on October 15 in a nighttime raid by armed soldiers and attack dogs on his house in the village of Saffa in the Ramallah district. According to Physicians for Human Rights, Nasser was taken into custody after a prolonged search in his house and a brief interrogation, during which his wife and four children were held at gunpoint in a different room.

His interrogation by Shin Bet agents went on for 39 days, with sessions lasting up to 20 hours a day, all through which Nasser had his hands tied to the back of the chair and his legs tied to the legs of the chair. Nasser later reported to his lawyers that throughout this period he was held in isolation, he did not receive sufficient medical care for his pain nor for the lapses of disorientation from which he suffered. PHR has so far not been allowed to send an independent doctor to examine Nasser.

About a week ago, the military prosecution filed an indictment with fairly mild accusations against Nasser. The main charge was his alleged membership in the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP), which is considered an illegal organization by Israel. Evidence for this membership is derived from the other four charges, which state that Nasser allegedly assisted in organizing and participating in two “illegal” PFLP rallies in Ramallah, one in support of Palestinian prisoners, and the other in memory of former PFLP leader, Abu-Ali Mustafa, assassinated by Israel in 2001.

Nasser, who works as a researcher for Addameer, rejects accusations of membership in the PFLP, stating that he had no part in the Mustafa rally. He confirmed his participation in the Palestinian Prisoners’ Day rally – which was not a PFLP event but rather a national day of protest and solidarity and has been for quite some time. This year’s rally took place in the midst of a prolonged hunger strike of administrative detainees in Israeli prisons, and marked the start of a new collective hunger strike of more than 1,000 prisoners. Nasser called for all factions of Palestinian society take part in the prisoners’ day.

Ayman Nasser (courtesy of the family)

Ayman Nasser (courtesy of Addameer)

“The evidence the army has really amounts to nothing,” says Nasser’s attorney Mahmud Hassan. “They have but two main witnesses. One admits to having taken part in planning the Abu Ali Mustafa event, and only says that he consulted Ayman on his planned speech at the rally, which Ayman told him was too extreme. The second witness says he told Ayman about a planned shooting attack (on Israelis, H.M.), for which Ayman yelled at him and told him he mustn’t go through with it.

“This is all they have after a long investigation, when for weeks they got the detention warrant prolonged solely on their statement that they suspected him of armed resistance – even though there is not a shred of evidence of anything like that in the file, and the indictment we now see has no mention of it. So yes, he did participate in the Prisoners’ Day rally, but that is an official national and public event, and who better to go there than a worker from Addammeer?”

In the passing weeks, Addameer and PHR have voiced their concerns that Nasser’s arrest is an assault on human rights defenders, in blatant disregard for international treaties. The two NGOs have for the past year been leading campaigns in support of Palestinian prisoners such as Ayman Sharawni - who is now on the 153rd day of his hunger strike - in the face of multiple hunger strikes within Israeli prisons.

“Ayman is a colleague of ours,” says Amani Dayef from PHR, “perhaps it is easier to pick on an NGO in the West Bank than it is on an Israeli NGO, but it is still an attempt to hinder the struggle for prisoners’ rights. As in other cases, we see how part of the interrogation process is to isolate a detainee from all outside contact, including physicians, and even at the cost of lesser medical care. We plan to file an appeal and demand to allow an outside doctor to see him.”

Nasser’s lawyer has filed an appeal against the latest resolution by the military court to prolong his detention until the end of proceedings. The appeal will be heard on December 17.

The IDF spokesperson unit has directed all questions regarding Nasser to the Shin Bet security service (Shabak), which issued the following response: “Ayman Nasser has been arrested on suspicion of activity within the PFLP. During his interrogation his was examined several times by a physician who found his medical condition allows for further interrogation. Medical instructions given by the examining doctor were followed to the full.

“Nasser’s claims regarding torture have no grounds to stand on! His interrogation was carried in accordance with the law, and he received all the rights which he deserves.

“Following the end of his interrogation Nasser, was and charged with membership in the terrorist organization PFLP, which is an illegal organization, and with offering this organization services and partaking in its rallies. The military court has ordered his detention until the end of legal proceedings.”

Related:
Israeli forces arrest Palestinian prisoners’ rights worker in West Bank
Palestinian Prisoners’ Day: Hundreds join hunger strike
Visualizing Occupation: Palestinian Prisoners’ Day – the numbers

For additional original analysis and breaking news, visit +972 Magazine's Facebook page or follow us on Twitter. Our newsletter features a comprehensive round-up of the week's events. Sign up here.

View article: AAA
Share article
Print article
  • COMMENTS

    1. Distressing and disgusting. Furthermore, a surprising story, showing Israel’s utter disdain not only for human rights — of its many old prisoners and for this new one — but also for its international reputation.

      While Israel’s (rather crippled) right hand tries to curry favor internationally, its left hand continues with the crazy, destructive — of Israel — activities which have brought Israel into pariah status.

      I — and much of the world — believe that Israel’s left hand is its honest hand, and that its right hand — its hasbara hand — is a pure fake, and no match for its left hand.

      Reply to Comment
    2. Danny

      Israel is a police state with a secret police whose mission it is to quash any and all dissent – especially of the unarmed kind that cannot be crushed by military means. The differences between Israel and the most vile regimes in the world, including some of its Arab neighbors, are blurring by the day.

      Reply to Comment
      • Piotr Berman

        Iran seem to be making a self-conscious effort to be a bit better then Israel. Torture was outlawed shortly after Abu-Ghraib revelations, and just last week the authorities relented to demands of a hunger striker after only 47 days. They also do not kill protesters as regularly as Israel and so on.

        Not they do not crush the dissent, but they do it in the humanitarian tradition of Imam (a bit like democratic traditions of Jabotynski).

        Reply to Comment
        • The Trespasser

          Wow.

          Are you on any prescription drugs or something?

          “Human rights watchers say regime in Tehran is executing many hundreds of people, often on the flimsiest of evidence and after trials held behind closed doors

          Human rights organisations estimate that as many as 600 people were put to death in Iran last year, of which at least 488 executions were carried out for alleged drug offences. In the first half of 2011, Iran was executing at the rate of two people a day.

          This year Amnesty said the authorities have so far acknowledged the execution of at least 182 people, 35 of them hanged in public.”

          http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2012/sep/16/iran-public-executions-hangings-human-rights

          Humanitarian tradition of imam?
          Where did you learned that phrase?

          Reply to Comment
          • Piotr Berman

            The statistics of death sentences and executions are very confused in the case of Iran, the figure of 600 executions in 2011 comes from a poster, other sources give a figure around 300. Concerning drug offenses, Iran is flooded by heroin produced under American supervision.

            In any case, I did not say that Iran is better in every category, just torture and killing of protesters.

            Reply to Comment
    3. It is impossible to have 20 hour interrogation which is not torturous. The only way Shin Bet can provide credible testimony for its actions is to allow an indpendent doctor access to the prisoner every 24 hours, with full, protected rights of speech for that doctor on the prisoner’s condition.

      Because the IDF outlaws most assembly in the Bank, most any organization, irrespective of associated outlawed organization, of a rally can be considered criminal. Attaching PFLP is a sweetener. And, in the logic of blanket criminality, such association would naturally be suspected.

      Forknowledge of a planned shooting is a different matter. That Nasser should have reported the incident, if credible, seems a strong argument even under occupation. But this charge does not condone his isolation from independent medical evaluation.

      Brave reporting.

      Reply to Comment
    4. Piotr Berman

      “During his interrogation his was examined several times by a physician who found his medical condition allows for further interrogation.”

      Somehow I think that a routine chat would not be interrupted by a medical examination. To interrupt interrogation several times …

      Reply to Comment

    LEAVE A COMMENT

    Name (Required)
    Mail (Required)
    Website
    Free text

© 2010 - 2014 +972 Magazine
Follow Us
Credits

+972 is an independent, blog-based web magazine. It was launched in August 2010, resulting from a merger of a number of popular English-language blogs dealing with life and politics in Israel and Palestine.

Website empowered by RSVP

Illustrations: Eran Mendel