18 comments for ”Palestinian ‘car protest’ in West Bank challenges road segregation“

    
  1. what about “Moslems Only” roads in Mecca?

  2. 
  3. Gill: That is a truly despicable riposte. How many Jews live in Mecca? How many Palestinians live on the West Bank? I have never heard of ‘flying checkpoints’ in Saudi Arabia preventing drivers from using certain roads. Yet you countenance this practice. Why? And, let me remind you, the Palestinians are both Christians and Muslims. How many Israeli Arabs are allowed to use these roads? Or are they only for Jews? How many Israeli Arab settlements are there in the West Bank? I am sure your ignorance is the only excuse you have for attempting to use that old ‘hasbarista’ standby, attempting to show you behavior isn’t despicable by pointing at someone else. Either ignorance or something worse.

  4. 
  5. A question for Mairav: do we know who sponsored the protest action? Were these the same people that did the Palestinian Freedom Rides in November? Was there a discernable organizational affiliation here?

  6.  
  7. Challenging the Jewish-only roads? That’s pretty interesting, because there aren’t any of those. Do you mean to use the word, “Israeli”???

  8. 
  9. Mike, lol. Jews are not allowed to enter Saudi Arabia. Not that it would excuse Jewish-only roads, which don’t exist. Israeli Arabs can go anywhere they want inside the green line and outside the green line in the West Bank, thus making them Israeli-only roads.

  10. 
  11. What sickens me is that the idiots in Washington send my tax dollars to help expand the apartied roads and settler infrastructure. I wish we had a choice here about our tax money should go to. Certainly not for wars and genocide.
    As long as AIPAC runs our government, we will continue to support current Israel regime no matter how it affects the Pals.

  12. 
  13. There have been a couple of occasions when my Palestinian Israeli friends were turned back as they tried to reach Nablus, being told, “You must know that this road isn’t for Arabs.” This doesn’t happen all or even most of the time, but there is always a chance of it, as the soldiers at the roadblocks often issue conflicting and arbitrary orders about who can and can’t pass. For the most part the rule that is applied is Israeli-only – and that’s bad enough. Having to take up to three hours over a journey that should last twenty minutes has an extremely detrimental effect on people’s quality of life. Think about what that would mean for you if you were subjected to it.

  14. 
  15. Yitzhak – I’ve travelled with Palestinian-Israelis in the West Bank. Many times they (not me) were pulled out of lines at checkpoints, and their IDs were examined for 10-20 minutes. Only then were they finally allowed to pass. Also, I’ve been in cars with Palestinian bedouins – we were (of course) refused entrance into settlements, for example, into Maale Adumim. The Palestinian bedouins east of Jerusalem, live in encampments which are regarded as totally illegal by Israel. Often their tents or shacks are demolished because of this. Meanwhile, nearby Maale Adumim is of course zoned for legal residences (but Palestinian bedouins can’t live in them). There’s a problem here – how do you think we should solve it???

  16. 
  17. Israeli-only roads are no better than Jew-only roads, but they are different. But foreign number-plates from the countries with which we have those “cold peaces” seem to be allowed on them too. In effect the only people inconvenienced by this stricture are those who live in the areas they run through who are not Jewish. Such are the twisted ways of occupation.

  18. 
  19. An effective demonstration in the spirit of Gandhi.

    To succeed, they should undertake it twice weekly until it receives widespread international attention.

    It should remain limited to the specific complaint (“Israeli/Jewish only”), and not get spread thin into other even related issues.

  20. 
  21. My hard earned American tax money goes to support these fascist policies and this is what makes me ANGRY. Peaceful resistance is key I think this protest was effective.

  22. 
  23. [...] also frequently compare Israeli soldiers to Nazis.On Tuesday, for instance, after Israeli officers blocked Palestinians from using a road reserved for settlers near the West Bank town of Jericho on Tuesday, one outraged [...]

  24. 
  25. I have seen just a little bit of humiliation in my world. I cannot imagine how it must be to make events such as this protest a statement of what one is. Generations have lived this. I have no advice as to what they should do next. My mind cannot comprehend the landscape they live. Some days, I replay the “Media Box” on +972′s front page. At its end, with the last of that young woman’s words, I sit awed: “We teach the world life every day.” I hope so. For the world’s sake.

  26. 
  27. A friend (Jewish Israeli, human rights lawyer) was driving on a West Bank road between Jerusalem and Be’er Sheva a few weeks ago, just because it’s faster, and she saw a billboard type sign for road safety–something about not talking on your cell phone when you drive, I think–that read “Everyone is Equal on the Road” and she said she nearly ran herself off the road with outrage. Everyone is NOT equal on the road.

  28. 
  29. to all who protested: thank you. Keep going.

  30. 
  31. ayla- those signs are written in hebrew and arabic- put up by a regional council that can continue to receive encouragement for acknowledging and starting to think together. we think those signs and road safety is a positive place of co-operation…

  32. 
  33. Response to ‘Gill.’

    ‘Whataboutery’; when someone has nothing original or intelligent to say.



Leave a comment