8 comments for ”As it happened: Gilad Schalit comes home in prisoner swap“

    
  1. Honestly, I’m happy that Gilad Shalit is free. I hope he has been treated well, I’m sure he has. And I hope they gave him some good stuff to read. You know, like Ilan Pappe, Tom Segev, Avi Shlaim, and hopefully he learnt some French …. A little Stockholm syndrome would be nice.

  2. 
  3. Once again the supposed “Extremists”, Hamas get results while the moderate Fatah flails around with no support from Israel.

    Back at the start of the second Intifada, Israel stated it had “no partner for peace”. It consistently undermined Abbas, in an effort to bolster Hamas and divide and conquer.

    This stratagem is still being played out. Hamas is the darling of the IDF. A convenient excuse to impose the harshest conditions on the Gazan population, expand the ISraeli security state, silence dissent in Israel and keep the “peace process” on track i.e. stalled

    Watch: The annexation plan continues apace, the freeing of Shalit comes just after the announcement of the completed encirclement of East Jerusalem. Mass expulsions to follow, in time.

  4. 
  5. Surely, it’s illegal, even in Israel, to openly solicit murder?

  6. 
  7. [...] Gilad Shalit, shortly after his return to Israel.According to Noa Yachot and Dimi Reider, who are live-blogging the prisoner exchange for the Israeli news blog +972, the Hebrew text at start of clip reads: “Tuesday, 18.10.11: [...]

  8. 
  9. Outside the emotions of the moment, Gilad Shalit’s release must be viewed within these core facts:

    The Gilad Shalit’s release swap was noted for its lopsidedness: Shalit, an Israeli soldier, for 1027 Palestinians! And that makes Shalit the “golden boy” of Israel. He has already been promoted to a Sargent of the Israeli army, and if he stays in the army he would certainly enjoy a quick and meteoric career to a 4 star General. He then can retire and use his fame to become Israel’s prime minister – like the late Yitzhak Rabin! Benjamin Netanyahu also rose to the prime minister position on his brother’s (Lieutenant Yonatan Netanyahu) fame who was killed during the Israeli raid on Entebbe in 1976.

    Fame no doubts brings fortunes, and lopsided fame has an imperial and permeative nature that borders on veneration and worship. Shalit has just arrived on that stage,
    and Hollywood would certainly be knocking on his door soon for a “Shalit” movie that would probably make him a mufti-millionaire! On top of that will the icing of the cake: billionaire Jewish girls vying for the Israel’s most eligible bachelor, while other nondescript bachelors will be collecting dust and eating their hearts out! Poor Shalit! He suddenly finds himself in the pantheon of fame that is equal to, or surpasses that of David Ben-Gurion. And his future ahead is probably a Midas built road that he has never dreamed of!

    What the “lopsidedness” of his deal would bring to the other side: the released Palestinian prisoners? Nothing! They would just be discarded like a truckload of trash! Nikos Retsos, retired professor

  10. 
  11. Thanks very much to Noa and Dimi for the live blog. It spared me and those like me all the maudlin verbiage and gave the essential, which is his homecoming and events surrounding it. Fantastic determination and stubbornness by his family and their supporters were a lesson to all of us not to lie down and take what governments dish out. That murderers were freed is hard for the tragically bereaved families, but sacrificing Gilad would not have brought their loved ones back, nor would it have solved the problems that caused him to be seized in the first place. Now it’s time for peacemaking. Wonder if the government will twig.

  12. 
  13. @ Wisdo , Israel since its creation made it clear that the only language that it understands is resistance and violence , thats what indigenous populations do under occupation.

  14. 
  15. SH-
    You are absolutely right, people should not sit passively and take the garbage the government dishes out. Those of us who opposed this suicidal release of terrorists, and particularly the relatives of the victims should have done everything possible to prevent this horrible deal from being carried out.



Leave a comment