Appreciate this article? +972 depends on your support -- click here to help us keep going

Analysis News

Israel's High Court sends South Hebron Hills evictions to mediation

The High Court of Justice declines to make a ruling on the evictions of over 1,000 Palestinian villagers from what Israel calls ‘Firing Zone 918.’ Villagers’ attorneys say referral to mediation process is a sign the court wasn’t satisfied with the state’s arguments. International writers sign petition against evictions.

Palestinian residents of the South Hebron Hills, supporters and observers at the High Court of Justice for a hearing on Firing Zone 918, September 2, 2013. (Photo: Irene Nasser)

Israel’s High Court of Justice referred to mediation a petition against the eviction of dozens of West Bank Palestinian families to make room for a military training area in the West Bank on Monday, pending the State’s acquiescence to the suggestion.

The courtroom was packed with representatives of the Palestinian villagers, foreign diplomats, Israeli and international activists and journalists.

Some 1,000 Palestinians in eight villages live in what the Israeli army has declared Firing Zone 918 in the South Hebron Hills. For 14 years, the state has years sought to evict the traditionally cave-dwelling Palestinians from their homes and grazing lands inside the designated area. A number of Jewish settlements within Firing Zone 918, however, have not been served with eviction orders.

In the High Court hearing on Monday, the state argued that Firing Zone 918 is of military necessity because it reduces logistical costs of training exercises due to its proximity to a nearby army base.

Lawyers representing the villagers, however, argued that international law clearly prohibits the expulsion of residents from an occupied territory, as well as the permanent seizure of land for military use.

Fadel Hammadi and his son, Abed, hold copies of the Koran as they sit on top of a mosque that was demolished by Israeli forces in the West Bank village of al-Mufaqara, south of Hebron, on December 4, 2012. The village is located inside what the Israeli army has designated ‘Firing Zone 918′. (photo by: Oren Ziv/ Activestills.org)

Following the hearing, Attorney Sholomo Lecker said he believes the court referred the case to mediation because it did not want to make a decision, but rather to signal to the state that it should change its position.

The mediation decision indicates that the court was not satisfied with the state’s arguments or the factual background it put forth, Attorney Tamar Feldman added, saying that the decision “is a good indication that the court is at least leaning [toward disagreeing] with the state.”

The referral to mediation would not be the first attempt to resolve the issue of Firing Zone 918 out of court. In 2002, villagers and the State entered a previous round of mediation, in which it sought to relocate the Palestinian residents to a smaller, nearby area. Residents refused, however, and in 2005 the process ended without any result.

Ahead of the most recent court cases, filed by the Association for Civil Rights in Israel and Atty Sholomo Lecker on behalf of the villagers, a group of well known Israel authors signed a petition opposing the eviction of Palestinians from the South Hebron Hills.

“In a reality of ongoing occupation, of solid cynicism and meanness, each and every one of us bears the moral obligation to try and relieve the suffering, do something to bend back the occupation’s giant, cruel hand,” they wrote.

Ahead of the Monday’s hearing, 50 international authors joined their petition, calling on Israel “to halt its displacement of the Palestinian villages located in Firing Zone 918.”

The international authors included: John le Carre, Michael Chabon, Dave Eggers, Ian McEwan, Nobel laureate Herta Müller and Philip Roth.

The full list of authors and the petition text can be found below:

Related:
Israeli authors lend their names in effort to save Palestinian villages
1,500 Palestinians face expulsion to make way for IDF ‘Firing Zone 918′

For additional original analysis and breaking news, visit +972 Magazine's Facebook page or follow us on Twitter. Our newsletter features a comprehensive round-up of the week's events. Sign up here.

View article: AAA
Share article
Print article
  • COMMENTS

    1. The High Court’s shunt to mediation again reflects what I have come to think of as the War Council nature of the Israeli constitution: primary entities seek consensus alliance rather than direct confrontation to nurture a common front to the greater outside. Rather than simply decide the State is in error and enjoin any expulsion, requiring the State to submit another plan, the Court offers hope of partial fulfillment of State goals through negotiation. It sounds reasonable, but underscores the Court’s great hesitancy to assume the power of full judicial review. By shunting to negotiation no binding principle of jurisprudence is asserted. Such a stand focuses on the stability of the War Council, not the plea of petitioners. Shunting is better than denying petition, but the Court still hesitates to cross into full independence.

      Reply to Comment
    2. Jan

      Seems that Israel can’t get enough of the ethnic cleansing of the Palestinians that was begun in 1948.

      It is more than obvious that using the trick of a “closed military area and a firing zone” is to remove the Palestinians. This vile and heinous tactic is never used against Jewish settlements, all of which are illegal under international law.

      Maybe this latest bit of ethnic cleansing which has attracted the ire of some of the world’s best writers will finally tip the scales and Israel will be forced to give up its dreams of a greater Israel based on the dispossession of the people who were there on the land long before the first European Jew sailed into the waters of Palestine.

      Reply to Comment
    3. Joe

      Who exactly will do the mediating? Why would the state listen to a compromise?

      Reply to Comment

    LEAVE A COMMENT

    Name (Required)
    Mail (Required)
    Website
    Free text

© 2010 - 2014 +972 Magazine
Follow Us
Credits

+972 is an independent, blog-based web magazine. It was launched in August 2010, resulting from a merger of a number of popular English-language blogs dealing with life and politics in Israel and Palestine.

Website empowered by RSVP

Illustrations: Eran Mendel