Appreciate this article? +972 depends on your support -- click here to help us keep going

Analysis News

Israelis and Palestinians are pessimistic about peace, poll finds

Palestinians fear Israelis more than Israelis fear Palestinians, opinion survey finds. Both societies reject the one-state solution, but Israelis also oppose the Arab Peace Initiative.

Israeli and Palestinian flags in a peace march. 74 percent of Palestinians fear that they will be hurt by an Israeli (Activestills.org)

A poll released Tuesday reveals pessimism and mistrust among Israelis and Palestinians. Members of both societies seriously doubt the chances of meaningful negotiations taking place.

According to a survey of both societies, conducted by the Harry Truman Research Institute at the Hebrew University and the Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research, a clear majority in Palestinian society – 57 percent – believe that Israel’s long-term desire is to expand its borders from the Mediterranean Sea to the Jordan River and expel the Palestinians. 37 percent of Israelis believe that the long-term ambition of the Palestinians is to conquer the entire land and kill a major part of the Jewish population. Seventeen percent of Israelis believe that the Palestinians’ goal is to conquer the entire land.

Only 10 percent of Israelis and 27 percent of Palestinians believe that negotiations will be renewed and violence end. Thirty-four percent of Israelis and 31 percent of Palestinians believe that negotiations can be renewed but that violence will continue. Forty-four percent of Israelis think that negotiations won’t even be renewed.

Sixty-eight percent of Israelis and 69 percent of Palestinians don’t think a Palestinian state will be established in the next five years. Most Israelis support the two state solution but a majority of 51 percent also thinks that this solution is bound to fail. Fifty-eight percent of Palestinians think that the two state solutions is irrelevant.

At the same time, there is no alternative for the two-state solution that gains substantial support. Sixty-three percent of Jews oppose a single-state solution. Even a larger number among Palestinians – 69 percent – opposes the idea. The last figure is a bit surprising, suggesting that the one-state solution’s popularity within the intellectual elite has yet to take precedence over the Palestinian desire to separate from the people who have controlled their lives for so long.

Half of Israelis are worried that they or one of their relatives might be hurt by Palestinians, as opposed to 74 percent of Palestinians who are worried that they or their relatives might be hurt by Israelis, that their land will be confiscated or their house destroyed. These figures haven’t changed since the 2012 poll.

In general, one could say that while both societies are pessimistic and feel threatened by the other, Palestinians are more pessimistic — and more threatened.

One place where Palestinians and Israelis differ is with their attitude toward the Saudi plan (also known as the Arab Peace Initiative). According to this idea, Israel would withdraw from all the areas it conquered in 1967, and an independent Palestinian State will be established; and the refugee problem will be solved in a way which both parties agree to. In return, all Arab countries will recognize Israel and establish full diplomatic relations with it. In a poll conducted two years ago, both Israelis and Palestinians had the same level of support for the idea. Today, a majority of Palestinians (56 percent) support the Arab Peace Initiative (as it was defined above) while most Israelis (67 percent) oppose it. Today, only 24 percent of Israelis support the plan. Those figures might support something I have written several times in the past – that Netanyahu is constantly moving the Israeli public to the right.

The Palestinian poll included 1270 participants from the West Bank, Gaza and East Jerusalem. The Israeli poll included 601 people.

Related
Give the Palestinians a break, Kerry, and stay home
Analysis: A recipe for diplomatic collapse
 

For additional original analysis and breaking news, visit +972 Magazine's Facebook page or follow us on Twitter. Our newsletter features a comprehensive round-up of the week's events. Sign up here.

View article: AAA
Share article
Print article
  • COMMENTS

    1. XYZ

      Glad to see Israelis reject the phony “Arab Peace Plan”, realizing that (1) with the Arab world falling apart it does not really have the support of the Arab oountries who can not deliver peaceful relations with Israel, and
      (2) that a “mutually agreed solution to the Palestinian refugee problem” means that unless Israel agrees to an unrestricted return of ALL refugees then there will be no agreement because the Palestinians can not compromise on that issue, which is the core of the Palestinian struggle against Israel.

      Reply to Comment
    2. Daniel

      It seems to me that the palestinians are actually more optimistic than israelis.
      27% vs. 10% believing that negotiations will resume and violence will end is quite a difference.

      as far as I know, for them to feel more threatened is a natural result of the objective reality. though comparing two different questions is not quite the best of practices.

      another interesting point is that with
      58% that think a two-state solution is bound to fail and 61% opposing a single state solution there are at least 19% that hold both these views…
      which makes me feel the poll might have left out some interesting questions.

      Reply to Comment
    3. Philos

      Hi Noam – thank you for your article. Any chance you can link in your article to the poll?

      Reply to Comment
      • I got it in the mail, and it’s in Hebrew.

        Reply to Comment
        • Philos

          Quite a few readers here can read Hebrew. If there’s anyway you can link to it I know I’ll be pleased to have a look, and hopefully some other readers too.

          Thanks for replying to my post.

          Reply to Comment
          • what I got is an incomplete press release – the questions I have are in the text. If I can put my hands on the data I will embed it.

            Reply to Comment
    4. The Trespasser

      At this moment there can be no 2-State Solution because A – there is de-facto two Palestinian states, one of which is ruled by a hostile government; and B – because Palestinians are insisting on RoR, which is not going to be granted by Israel ever.

      Also, at this moment there can be no 1-State Solution because A – there is de-facto two Palestinian states, one of which is ruled by a hostile government; and B – because Palestinians are insisting on RoR, which is not going to be granted by Israel ever.

      A perfect stalemate – there can be no solution because there is no solution.

      Reply to Comment
    5. Joel

      In 1947, the Zionists had nothing so they agreed to whatever the world community offered them, which was than a barely viable mini-State full of Arabs and a corpus seperatum for Jerusalem.

      If the Palestinians really want peace and a State then they should steal a page from the Zionist history book and negotiate a deal.

      Larry. An imposed Palestinian State will piss Israel off same as the Arabs got pissed when the Jewish State was imposed on them. Why engender bad feelings when the opportunity to reach negotiated settlement exists?

      Reply to Comment

    LEAVE A COMMENT

    Name (Required)
    Mail (Required)
    Website
    Free text

© 2010 - 2014 +972 Magazine
Follow Us
Credits

+972 is an independent, blog-based web magazine. It was launched in August 2010, resulting from a merger of a number of popular English-language blogs dealing with life and politics in Israel and Palestine.

Website empowered by RSVP

Illustrations: Eran Mendel