Appreciate this article? +972 depends on your support -- click here to help us keep going

Analysis News

Israeli police shut down, attempt to raid Palestinian school in East Jerusalem

Israel Police yesterday shut down a Palestinian school in East Jerusalem for a period of a week. The school has over 1,200 students between the ages of 12 and 18 years old. The police justified their actions to the students and teachers by voicing suspicion that stones were thrown at settlers by students from the school. +972 magazine learned from students and teachers that the school doesn’t allow students to throw stones from the school, but they cannot monitor students outside the school. It is unreasonable and unrealistic, a teacher said, “to be held responsible for individual students’ actions outside the parameters of the school.”

Palestinians gather outside the boys school in East Jerusalem to stop police from entering (Photo: Eyad Abu Sarah)

Earlier in the day, stones were thrown in the At-Tur neighborhood at settlers, and one of them was hit. The police arrived immediately to the scene and launched an attack at the school, suspecting that students were involved in the stone-throwing. Residents from the neighborhood and teachers clashed with the police and stopped them from storming the school and arresting students. According to eye witnesses, the police resorted to punishing the teachers by issuing traffic violations and parking tickets to them upon leaving the school.

+972 magazine talked with some of the parents who refused to identify themselves or their children because of fear of retaliation from the police. One of the parents described a phone call he received from his son:  ”I received a horrifying call from my son whose voice was shaking, he said he can’t leave the school and it is besieged by police. My son was terrified that he would be arrested or killed. He was begging me to get him out of school.”

Collective punishment against Palestinian communities and schools is not a new policy of the Israeli police. Throughout the First Intifada in the late 1980s, similar actions were taken to shut down universities and schools. However, this strategy never succeeded in stopping protests or stone-throwing during the First Intifada. The opposite process happened, with more people becoming active in protesting the occupation.

The police action raises another question regarding their response to stone-throwing at settlers. In an incident that I wrote about last month, a Palestinian beaten by Israeli Jews was barely given any attention by the police. The Palestinian community in Jerusalem is convinced that the Israeli police have double standards when it comes to dealing with violence. When a Palestinian throws a stone, it must be stopped at any price, but when a Jew does the same or worse, it is a minor incident that poses no danger.

This incident comes only few days after Palestinian Israelis commemorated the killing of 13 Palestinians citizens of Israel by police twelve years ago. Unfortunately, many Palestinians under Israel’s rule don’t believe that any lessons have been learned since then. Palestinians don’t believe the premise that the police is fair and doesn’t discriminate according to race or religion.

Closing the school for a week is an unjustifiable decision. First, such an action will not stop youth from throwing stones. On the contrary, they are now free with no school, homework, or activities to participate in. Throwing stones might become even more attractive to students who haven’t done so before. Additionally, attacking a school in this manner causes trauma to teenagers who may suffer from it for years to come. Such trauma could affects the decisions and actions of hundreds of young people. In conclusion, police behavior is counterproductive to their goal of putting an end to stone-throwing. Violence generates more violence and the Palestinian teenagers who encountered the police attack on their school are likely to remember this incident with bitterness and rage.

Lady Bird Johnson said that “children are likely to live up to what you believe of them.” If the police treats these children as terrorists or criminals, they could grow up as such. Schools should always be off-limits to police attacks, and collective punishment against children should never be tolerated.

Palestinian children in Jerusalem see growing number of extreme settlers moving into their neighborhood. They watch them take their land and enjoy superior rights and better infrastructure. These children are living the consequences of the occupation. They see injustice carried against their community on daily basis. Violence and collective punishment will not bring a resolution or peace.  The solution is to end the occupation, not to terrify children.

As Nelson Mandela said, “We owe our children, the most vulnerable citizens in our society, a life free of violence and fear.” This is true for Palestinian children just as it is true for Israeli children. It is unacceptable that Palestinian parents have to send their children to schools not knowing if they will come home that afternoon or spend it in an Israeli jail. It is not acceptable that a mother has to convince a child to go to school every morning because he is afraid of the police, as is the case in many families. This is not a normal life, nor does it make Israelis safer when Palestinian children live in trauma and fear.

Perhaps my vision for the future is too naive, but I keep dreaming of a society that respects all humans regardless of race or religion. If that is too much then at least we must expect that children enjoy basic human rights and not be treated as criminals. Is too much to ask that Israeli police officer see a Palestinian 12-year-old child the same way he sees a Jewish one? Mother Teresa put it best when she said, “It’s the greatest poverty to decide that a child must die so that you may live as you wish.”

Related:
Chronic uncertainty: Trauma of childhood under occupation
Testimonies by Israeli soldiers detail abuse of Palestinian children
Report by British jurists reminds of the horrors of Israeli child detention

For additional original analysis and breaking news, visit +972 Magazine's Facebook page or follow us on Twitter. Our newsletter features a comprehensive round-up of the week's events. Sign up here.

View article: AAA
Share article
Print article
  • COMMENTS

    1. I read Hitchens, but nevertheless, Theresa had a point: “It’s the greatest poverty to decide that a child must die so that you may live as Jewish.”

      Reply to Comment
    2. Danny

      Israeli collective punishment is perhaps as old as the state itself, and effectively lumps together all Palestinians – women, children and elderly people – along with the so-called “terrorists”. It makes the dehumanization of the Palestinians much easier if they are all considered terrorists (or in the case of children – potential/future terrorists) and causes even moderate Israelis to close their hearts to their neighbors’ long-standing suffering. I hope to see the day when my fellow Israelis will finally recognize the Palestinians as human beings.

      Reply to Comment
    3. “Is too much to ask that Israeli police officer see a Palestinian 12-year-old child the same way he sees a Jewish one?”–Yes, it is. Which is why you must keep asking.

      The police should not have the authority to close a school absent immediate threat. Nor should the police be allowed to target employees of that school with parking/trafffic violations IN RETALIATION FOR ANYTHING. Racial control here becomes reason of law, with no court oversight. I knew, once the Nazarene 13 were killed, the rule of law would not cross race. The State’s reaction to those deaths is a symbol for the lack of equal protection in Israel, and failure of the Declaration of Independence.

      If you did not report the present case, who would?

      Reply to Comment
    4. Jan

      How can anyone blame Palestinian kids for throwing stones or even large rocks at the colonizers who are rapidly stealing almost all of Palestine? The colonists are well armed while Palestinians are armed with only stones. The colonists have no right to be living in the West Bank and the fact that they are there is in violation of the Geneva Accords and is a war crime. It is the colonists and the government of Israel that should be brought into the Hague to face charges for the immense number of war crimes that they have accumulated over the decades. The kids who throw the stones are heroes. My heart is with them.

      Reply to Comment
    5. sh

      Even if they understand nothing about politics, kids recognize belittlement, condescension and brutal behavior by their neighbors and harassment and neglect by the authorities of the places in which they live. They can easily compare their circumstances to those of Jewish kids by running across route 1. They know they have no protection, the closing of that school is yet more proof.

      Perfect Mother Theresa quote.

      Reply to Comment
      • Working with traumatised teenagers, I find that it’s easier to help those who will throw stones or shout insults or even just stick their fingers up at the army. They’re angry and they know they have the right to be. It’s hardest with the teenagers who don’t feel anger at all, because they don’t even believe that they matter any more. So long as they’re chucking stones at jeeps I know there’s some sense of dignity and worth alive in there.

        Reply to Comment
    6. Piotr Berman

      There are reports of police inactitity when Jews are throwing stones: http://www.haaretz.com/news/national/hundreds-of-jews-hurl-rocks-at-cars-in-jerusalem.premium-1.466873

      From purely pragmatic point of view, even-handed enforcement could decrease tensions between the communities and decrease hooligan incidents. Teachers from schools where pupils engage in stone throwing and other incidents could be invited to coordinate educational steps decreasing tension between communities, and so could clergy etc. I guess that is happening in Jerusalem from a parallel universe.

      Reply to Comment
      • MS

        If the issue were “hooliganism” or amorphous “tension” then yes, maybe your plan would be appropriate. But this isn’t about rabble-rousing teenagers messing around. Israelis in East Jerusalem are settlers, that is, colonizers. These children are the indigenous population of a colonized land. Their anger is justified. They’re living under Jim Crow .

        Reply to Comment
        • Piotr Berman

          I was trying to describe what should happen in a sane country.

          Reply to Comment
    7. Eliza

      The police action in closing the school and intimidating the teachers and students is not aimed at preventing stone throwing. Of course the actions of the police will make it more likely that young Palestinians will express their justified anger by stone throwing. This actually works for Israel as it can present Palestinian children as uncontrolled rabble if not budding little terrorists. Israel fears effective peaceful resistance as much as it fears suicide bombing – something well in the middle is just what Israel wants. The other benefit from the Israeli point of view is that it reinforces regularly to the Palestinians that there is no humiliation too small that it will not impose on them. Nor is there any humiliation too large it will shrink from. It is difficult to maintain occupations unless you are able to regularly show the occupied just how powerless the occupied really are. Of course the police action is irrational if you think that Israel wants peaceful co-existence; but entirely rational if you accept that Israel has not yet given up on the notion of the transfer of as many non-Jews as possible within the realisation of Greater Israel. Just how can this be achieved without making the lives of non-Jews as miserable as possible and hope they will leave voluntarily; how can any possible forced transfer be justified except on security grounds or the desirability of the complete separation of Jews from non-Jews. I never think that Israeli actions are just irrational – there is a method in this madness.

      Reply to Comment

    LEAVE A COMMENT

    Name (Required)
    Mail (Required)
    Website
    Free text

© 2010 - 2014 +972 Magazine
Follow Us
Credits

+972 is an independent, blog-based web magazine. It was launched in August 2010, resulting from a merger of a number of popular English-language blogs dealing with life and politics in Israel and Palestine.

Website empowered by RSVP

Illustrations: Eran Mendel