21 comments for ”East Jerusalem: Israel detains 8-year-old Palestinian boy“

    
  1. [...] פשטה על בית בסילואן ועצרה ילד פלסטיני בן שמונה בשם עלי סיאם. [...]

  2. 
  3. Shame on Israel. Shame on the USA. Shame on any people who harm children in the name of greed and hatred.

  4. 
  5. When will Israel start to arrests the guys who violently arrest an eight year old? Do soldiers never refuse to follow orders?
    .
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iOGHTN8USqw&feature=player_embedded

  6. 
  7. It is an absolute disgrace to be an Israeli these days. Kind of like being South African in the 80′s or German in the 30′s. Sorry, but that’s how I feel about this.

  8. 
  9. 
  10. The brats should stop throwing rocks and be grateful for the opportunity to live in Israel.

  11. 
  12. so who’s telling the truth: JD or Haaretz? Both have so many details to prove their story is real, yet they unfortunately contradict each other… is this the meaning of pluralism and liberalism?

  13. 
  14. children what?

    forget the age, what is the gender?

    odds are it is an angry, homicidal teenager. typical.

    just because you are under 18 does not somehow give you the right to commit assault.

    i think it is poor journalism to flash buzzwords like “boy” and “children” as if children are being deliberately targeted.

    it is the palestinians who deliberately target children. see fogel murders.

  15. 
  16. “odds are it is an angry, homicidal teenager. typical.”
    Odds are you do not know what a ‘teenager’ is. A little hint: Listen closely to the end (and only) syllable of the word ‘eight’, read aloud.

  17. 
  18. and we’ve seen eight year old palestinians recite mein kampf on hamas television.

    or have you forgotten about the child suicide bombings?

    i find it hard to believe israel would bother to arrest and 8 year old boy simply because he is 8 years old.

    and who says he is 8? really? the palestinians are serial liars.

    jenin jenin anyone. nothing beats a juicy story though!

  19. 
  20. “and who says he is 8?”
    The Israeli police. Anything else to distract from the sheer idiocy of your ‘teenager’ comment?

  21. 
  22. Any people capable of bombing densely packed Gaza with the most modern weapons in the world, including white phosphorus and deliberately targeting schools, UNWRA food and medical supplies warehouse (which was also sheltering terrified civilians), homes, mosques, the electrical generating station and sewage treatment plants is certainly capable of detaining an 8 yr old boy.
    Switch on your crap detectors!

  23. 
  24. And here you are wrong, Koshihiro!

    The police version is that he is 7.
    Police in Jerusalem does not lie, perhaps, but the police statements were neither accurate nor consistent.

    They told the lawyer that they do not know where the child is. Haaretz: ” Finally, the boy was found by his mother waiting in a Israel Border Police vehicle near Silwan. He arrived at a police station after being held up in the police car for two hours, where he was investigated with his mother present on suspicion he had hurled stones. He was eventually released about four-and-a-half hours after his arrest.”

    This may enter annals of lesser abuse. Another statement: “A minor of about eight ran to his house, with officers taking both him and his mother to questioning at the minorities’ unit. The boy was released at the end of his investigation and was put in the care of social services,” the police said.

    “Minoritiess unit” in a vehicle?

    Anyway, the tyke got it easy, because Jewish State indeed reserves more special abuse for teens. This what Amira Hass writes about a boy of 15 and half who had an encounter with police in Jerusalem:

    …the medical report: a scalp hematoma, a linear skull fracture, subcutaneous swelling and hematomas on his face and chest, multiple scratches on his back, multiple signs of blows on his limbs and a tear in his liver.

    The police response to Haaretz evaded the medical findings and the following facts presented to them: The police dragged the unconscious boy on the road after he was beaten on his head. He was loaded onto a Jeep, was unloaded from it at a gas station and there, so that he would regain consciousness, he was sprayed with water and air from the tire pump. He was beaten repeatedly, he spit blood and he fainted again. He still had deep handcuff marks on his wrists 10 days after the cuffs were removed.

  25. 
  26. C’est tout à votre honneur et à celui d’Israël d’ouvrir les yeux et d’oublier votre mauvaise foi. L’histoire vous jugera .
    Avec mon profond respect aux amis israeliens qui, sous les gaz lacrymogènes, les pistolets paralysants et les violence de la police et de l’armée israéliennes continuentà dénoncer l’occupation et les methodes utilisées et qui sont indignes d’une démocratie.
    .

  27. 
  28. KOSHIRO , ABBAN AZIZ , It would be all with your honor and that of Israel, to open the eyes and to insincerely stop being . The history judge .
    With my deeper respect to my israeli friends who under of the teargas grenads, the paralysing guns and the violence of the police and the israeli army continue to denounce the occupation and the methodes unworthy of a democraty.

  29. 
  30. Le peuple palestinien (sans parler des Israéliens) attend toujours, 63 ans après les événements, des excuses des gouvernements arabes qui ont créé leur tragédie.
    Pensez-vous que des gouvernements démocratiques dans ces pays auront le courage de publier cette lettre d’excuses?

  31. 
  32. Max, even in French that sounds lame and is of topic. The issue at hand is the (violent) arrest of very young children.

  33. 
  34. 
  35. @DirectRob

    Yes, you are right. There is a difference in the two stories.

    According to Haaretz, she was not hit by a “rubber bullet” but an “anti-demonstration projectile”.

    Don’t you love harm reduction? :D

  36. 
  37. Some comments here make think ….do they have any kind of humanity ? is it possible to live with these creatures ? I am sure if the IDF arrested a 3 month old infant they would defend it , sick Zionists

  38. 
  39. And remember the Palestinians who stabbed to death kids while they slept recently

    Not to mention the thousands butchered by their own regimes

    Islam religion of peace……hahahaahahahah



Leave a comment