5 comments for ”Hebron teachers protest measures that keep them from school“

    
  1. Ben Israel, Bosko, Richard of America,
    Please explain this away for me. This actual case. Please.

  2. 
  3. while i am fully against the occupation of the west bank and would love to see all of the settlers in the west bank expelled, this particular story does a great disservice to the anti-settler movement. there is the continued accusation that the IDF denied these palestinian children their education. it seems clear from the article that the teachers simply refused to submit to a daily walk through a metal detector. as a resident of jordan, i walk through metal detectors almost every day. if i refused to walk through a metal detector at city mall in amman, for example, i wouldn’t say that the city mall security team denied me my right to shop because i refused to submit to their security protocols. my main point here is that in a legitimate liberation movement where brave men and women have struggled (and often lost their lives) for decades against injustice, we don’t need propaganda garbage like this that is just embarrassing. protest the existence of the checkpoint, protest the existence of the settlements in hebron, but don’t equate the requirement to walk through a checkpoint to denying the right to education.

  4. 
  5. The teachers, and much of the community behind them, are protesting because a right that they have held for seven years has been revoked for no reason. They are not just mad about having now to walk through the checkpoint like everyone else (though this ruling is ridiculous, because they have been walking this route to school every morning for seven years, they are clearly not a threat); their protest is symbolic of what they perceive to be a larger attempt by the IDF to deny their rights, and specifically to crack down on the Qurduba School. If it didn’t tap into this larger vein of anger and resistance, it would not have become a rallying point for the community. It has also exploded in the community because of the intensity of the IDF’s repression of the demonstrations.
    Finally, this metal detector is not comparable to one in a shopping mall, because the latter is not a tool of a military occupation. The protest is not a petty griping about a little metal detector, it is a valid battle in a war that must be fought over the large and the small.

  6. 
  7. here’s a link of photos from the protest. look at the way the IDF is handling the children, look at their reaction. That’s all the analysis I need.
    https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.181879695224143.46823.124657287613051&type=1
    *
    When these things happen, as they do, nearly daily, links such as the one I just posted circulate around the Arab World. This one went to Egypt and back before it reached me. In countries that have already lost plenty of children to our missiles (Egypt, Lebanon…), this is what they continue to see; all they know of Israelis.
    *
    hey Israel: how CAN Palestinians fight for justice, if not by peaceful protest?

  8. 
  9. The action of the IOF is against the NATO agreement and should not be happening.
    I wonder what would be the result of settler kids treated as these kids.



Leave a comment