Appreciate this article? +972 depends on your support -- click here to help us keep going

Analysis News

Amidst hostile media and police violence, J14 finds new voice

Has the movement – also known as ‘the tent protest’ – abandoned its consensus-building approach, and is it ready to pursue a more confrontational agenda through more radical means?

Demonstrators march through Tel Aviv on Saturday night (photo: JC / Activestills)

It was a different J14 protest than the ones we saw last year: less organized, and more emotional and confrontational. On Saturday night, thousands of Israelis assembled at Habima Square, and then marched on to block some of Tel Aviv’s main roads: Ibn Gavirol Street, Begin Road, and even the Ayalon highway, that crosses the city from north to south. A couple of banks had their windows smashed; 89 protesters were arrested.

>> View images and footage from Saturday’s protest in Tel Aviv >>

Police later exaggerated reports of violence by protesters, perhaps in an effort to justify the unprecedented number of arrests. Unlike in previous cases, protesters detained by police weren’t let go after a few hours, but rather were held for the night. Yesterday (Sunday), the police asked the court to extend the remands of 14 protesters on charges of assault on cops and even stone-throwing. Yet despite numerous videos taken at the protest – including by the police – there was no evidence whatsoever of such assaults, and not a single law enforcement officer was hurt (not the case for the protesters). On Sunday, various clips of police officers beating protesters emerged (like this one, be sure to check out the last few seconds). Later, a judge released all the protesters.

There is no denying that something has changed in the J14 movement. Last year’s consensus-building atmosphere was gone, replaced by a surprising level of bitterness and anger. Many protesters spoke of the need to take the political battle to the streets, now that even the government’s mild promises from last year weren’t fulfilled, and especially due to the lack of Knesset opposition. Prime Minister Netanyahu now has a coalition of 94 members of Knesset behind him, leaving a fragmented 26-MK strong opposition, which doesn’t even meet the threshold for the assembling of a special debate (which requires 40 members). Netanyahu may have secured the near future by cancelling the elections he wanted to announce, but he reignited the protest against his government.

>> Click here to watch images and read on the violent arrest of protest leader Dafnie Leef last Friday which brought thousands to the street >>

Another interesting development is the change in the way the media treats the protest. Last year, proxies to the prime minister spoke of “media conspiracy” against him, due to what seemed like the mainstream media’s favorable treatment of J14. Things couldn’t be more different today. J14 was blamed for the economic slowdown Israel is experiencing, which sent the media market into a deep crisis. As a result – and perhaps, out of growing dislike of the protesters themselves – the media tone has changed to one that ranges between ignoring the protest and bashing it.

This is no conspiracy theory. I have heard in person from at least two employees of a couple of the largest media organizations in Israel that they were instructed not to promote news items about the protest, unless something “really exceptional” happens. The managing director of Channel 10 even said as much in public, when he ordered his employees not to “create a social protest.” The effect of the new guidelines was visible last Saturday – until the protesters blocked the city’s main highway and the bank windows were smashed, only Haaretz featured the report of the protest as its top story.

Furthermore, in the days following the demonstration and the arrests, the Israeli tabloids highlighted “the violence” of the protesters. In Yedioth, the reporter at the protest, Danny Spector, wrote today that the protesters “destroyed shops” – something that even the police didn’t say. Just as it happens so often in the West Bank, the papers didn’t bother to fact check claims of stone-throwing by protesters on cops. I was at the demo for several hours, mostly close to the area of confrontations, and all I saw were a couple of water bottles which were sprayed – not even thrown – towards the cops. Considering the Tel Aviv heat that night, I wouldn’t have mind being sprayed myself.

The caption to this pic, printed today in the daily Maariv, says it all (via 7th Eye).

Picture taken at J14 protest and printed in the Maariv daily. Image caption reads: "Protester confronting a policeman" (scan: 7th eye)

J14 is now the protest of the outsiders. With no backing from the media or major political parties, it is no longer the summer festival people claimed it was in the past. Some questions – like the debate on the need to discuss the other urgent political issues, and most notably the occupation – still haunt the movement. Yet there is renewed energy in the streets, at least in Tel Aviv.

The torrent of grassroots initiatives – generally launched on Facebook – that was the trademark of last year’s protest, is visible again. One emerging idea is a boycott of the “Tel Aviv White Night” – a culture festival organized by the municipality, which is due to take place on Thursday night. Tel Aviv Mayor Ron Huldai played a major part in reigniting the protest when he ordered city employees to make sure not a single tent is placed on Rothschild Boulevard. So far, several art galleries have decided not to extend their opening hours into the night as planned, and other events were canceled as well. If the initiative gains momentum, it could mark one of the rare moments in which the Tel Aviv cultural scene – the well-known “bubble” – comes close to taking a political stand against its immediate business interests. This is J14 at its best – a movement that can politicize people and institutions that normally benefit from the status quo and usually are only too happy to help preserve it.

After two large yet uninspiring demonstrations this spring, activism seems once more like a viable route for political change in Israel. Much will depend on the form the protest takes from now on, and on the response of the authorities. It will be hard to predict or even control the events, since the J14 movement is more fragmented than ever, with last year’s leaders split into at least four or five camps. It’s clear that more confrontations with the police will lead to a smaller, more radical protest and would make a larger political shift more difficult, at least in the short run. And there are events that could dominate the national agenda regardless of what protesters do or don’t – a war with Iran, for example. Yet for the first time since September 2011, the largest protest movement Israel has seen in decades seems very much alive.

For additional original analysis and breaking news, visit +972 Magazine's Facebook page or follow us on Twitter. Our newsletter features a comprehensive round-up of the week's events. Sign up here.

View article: AAA
Share article
Print article
  • COMMENTS

    1. I like Maariv’s caption: “Protester gets into confrontation with police.” Looks to me like “Policeman chokes protester.”

      Reply to Comment
    2. Piotr Berman

      I am not sure about choking, the cunning protester keeps hands in front of her neck. The tention in policeman muscles suggest that he is pushing her down.

      What is this idea of “White Nights”? Is it because Finland is a liberal Ashkenazi version of paradise, as in “we are not in Finland”? Is the idea to emulate “Venice on Baltic” on Mediterranean?

      Reply to Comment
    3. sh

      I think that despite TA Municipality’s efforts to link the name of the event to TA’s nickname The White City (because if its Bauhaus buildings recognized as a world heritage site or similar by UNESCO), White Nights was borrowed from the French expression nuits blanches, which basically means sleepless nights. The French probably did take their name for sleepless nights from their estival overdose of daylight, but they stage their annual all-night cultural crawl in the fall. The Germans and the British call their equivalent the Long Night of Museums. The French, par contre, have a summer solstice fest called la fête de la musique. Doesn’t seem to have caught on here. Long answer to say neither the name nor the event are Israeli originals but they’re not Finnish either. On the other hand we are, since yesterday, surely the only Middle Eastern country with a monument to the Russian victory over the Nazis in the shape of, to quote Putin, the white wings of the dove of peace.

      Reply to Comment
    4. sh

      I left out the word western … the only Middle Eastern western country with a monument to the (Soviet) Russian victory over the Nazis.

      Reply to Comment
    5. Richard Witty

      If Noam’s reporting is accurate, that the tenor of the J14 movement’s participants and the tenor of the reaction to the participants, is more emotional, less organized, less consensual; then the movement will be short-lived or should be.

      Other factors than the willingness to confront, or to shift to “light” violence, are the litmus tests of determination to successfully make meaningful change.

      The factors that matter are the commitment to people, not to tactical victory. The commitment to people can shift to real grassroots organizing (in neighborhoods for universal mutual aid), to real media, to real art (including artful demonstration).

      “Which side are you on?” ends up usuallly as the wrong side.

      Reply to Comment
    6. Bertie

      Protest movements everywhere are failing because they don’t really have a goal outside of street theater, and they don’t have a goal outside of street theater because there is no known serious alternative to neoliberalism.

      (OK, for the pedants, there are two alternatives to neoliberalism: 1. Have a lot of oil, or 2. The East Asian model, where 50% national savings rates are culturally possible and acceptable. Neither applies to Israel.)

      Reply to Comment

    LEAVE A COMMENT

    Name (Required)
    Mail (Required)
    Website
    Free text

© 2010 - 2014 +972 Magazine
Follow Us
Credits

+972 is an independent, blog-based web magazine. It was launched in August 2010, resulting from a merger of a number of popular English-language blogs dealing with life and politics in Israel and Palestine.

Website empowered by RSVP

Illustrations: Eran Mendel